← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3932/2014disposed of

Rattan Lal & ANR v. Naurang & ORS

2018-10-15Mr. Justice Satpal4 pages

      



!" #"$%&%'( )

*  !! '+ , '# '!-". //",, '!& 0".&1&  1. '2 '#!-".& "&/'#"'!&  

 

."&"'!( .34#5#6$ !" .!-" //",, '! . 78%.4%'2-5#6$ !" .."&/'#"'!9'&1. '$" :/ ';



 -%& //" , - & 8""' %,"# 8; !-" $, %: '!& &""<%'2 "'- '$":"'!   !-" $:/"'& !%' = .#"# ! !-": 8; !-" ," .'"# !. $$%#"'!, %:&.%81' ,5 .%# 8 #>.%81' ,? .&-.!6%#" = .## !"#

 ' $$1'!   #" !-   0%< & ,% & '% %'  :!. 6"-%$," $$%#"'!'

@

 -" $, %: '!&5 =- ." !-" / ."'!&   !-" #"$" &"#5 %,"#  /"!%!%'1'#".4"$!%' AA !-"!.0"-%$,"&$!&""<%'2$:/"'& !%' ' $$1'! #" !- 0%< & ,% &'%#1"!%'71.%"&."$"%6"#%' :!. 6"-%$," $$%#"'! =-%$- !< /, $" '

@

    # !"#

@

= &."2%&!"."#1'#".4"$!%'& @ 5 B '# @ !,%$" 4! !%' ,#  .%# 8 # 2 %'&! ."&/'#"'!   ! = & /," #"# !- ! !-" #"$" &"# !!-"!%:" -%&#" !-= &=.<%'2 &  %'"$-'%$ ,&&%&! '! =%!- 9& ?&  0 

%$" %& :'!-,; %'$:" = & &! !"# ! 8" &

9B"= & ;" .&,# !!-"!%:"  $$%#"'!:/"'& !%'= & !-1&/. ;"# .

 -"," .'"#.%81' ,'$'&%#". !%' $!& '#"6%#"'$" '."$.#-",#!- !!-" $$%#"'!%'C1"&!%'!</, $"#1"!!-". &- '# '"2,%2"'! #.%6%'2   

"'#%'2 6"-%$," 8; %!& #.%6". -"." %& ' #%&/1!" ."2 .#%'2!-" 86"& %# %'#%'2 !-"," .'"#.%81' ,'!-%&%&&1"5=-%$- - & !! %'"# %' ,%!;+" .'"#.%81' , 1.!-".$'$,1#"#!-"#"$" &"#!8"

;" .&,# !!-"!%:" -%&#" !- '# &&"&&"#-%&%'$:" &&)

/".:'!- "#1$!%' ) D= &"

"$!"#!= .#&!-"/".&' ,"E/"'&"& & -"= & 8 $-",. !". //,;%'2 :1,!%/,%". 5!! ,#"/"'#"'$; = & &&"&&"# !&5

9B&1: &)

9B" $-= & = .#"#!= .#&

1'". ,"E/"'&"& '#,&& "&! !"-1&5$, %: '!&="."-",#"'!%!,"# . !! ,$:/"'& !%' &5

9B ,'2=%!-%'!"."&!F@)D/". ''1:

.:!-"# !" %,%'2 $, %:/"!%!%'!%,,." ,%& !%' +" .'"# $1'&", . !-" //",, '!& &18:%!& !- ! %'$:"   !-" #"$" &"# & &&"&&"#8;!-"," .'"#.%81' ,%&'!%'#%&/1!"="6".5 %'$." &"%'%'$:"' $$1'! 1!1."/.&/"$!&&-1,#8"

.#"#F D %' 6%"=    71#2:"'!   '?8," 41/.":" 1.! %'  !%' , '&1. '$" :/ '; +!# 0& . ' ; 4"!-% '# !-".&5

@   %6%,

1,!%/,%". *%'&!" # &-1,#8" //,%"#<""/%'2%'6%"= 2" #"$" &"# :1'! = .#"# 1'#". !-" $'6"'!%' , -" #& '""#& ! 8" "'- '$"# & /". !-" 71#2:"'!   !-" '?8," 41/.":" 1.! %'  2:  "'". , '&1. '$" :/ '; +!# 0&  '1  : ,% & -1-.1  : '# !-".&5 %' %6%, //" ,  )*  

* #"$%#"# '

*  ! %& !-1& /. ;"#!- !!-%& //" ,8" ,,="# '#$:/"'& !%' = .#"#8""'- '$"# +" .'"# $1'&", . !-" '&1. '$" :/ '; - & ."

1!"# !-" 86"& %# .21:"'!&=-%,"&18:%!!%'2!- !!-"%:/12'"# = .#- &8""' / &&"#$.."$!,; '#'2.1'# . ';"'- '$":"'!%&: #"1!

  - 6" -" .# ," .'"# $1'&", . !-" / .!%"& '# - 6" 2'" !-.12-!-"."$.#=%!-!-"%. 8," &&%&! '$" !%&'!%'#%&/1!"!- !#"$" &"##%"##1"!%'71.%"&."$"%6"#%' :!.6"-%$," $$%#"'!=-%$-!</, $"'

@

#1"!!-". &- '# '"2,%2"'!#.%6%'2 !-"

"'#%'26"-%$,"8;."&/'#"'! '$:" #"$" &"#%&'!%'#%&/1!"'6%"= !-"21%#",%'"&, %##='8;!-"'?8," 41/.":" 1.! %'  !%' , '&1. '$" :/ '; +!# 0& . ' ; 4"!-% '# !-".&5

@   %6%,

5  D %'$." &" %' %'$:" - & ! 8"

.#"#' $$1'! 1!1."/.&/"$!& "#1$!%' ) D!= .#&/".&' , "E/"'&"& - & .%2-!,; 8""' "

"$!"# & !-" #"$" &"# = & 1': ..%"# 1,!%/,%". *%'&!" # - &!8" //,%"#<""/%'2%'6%"=!-" 2" #"$" &"# ' 6%"= 71#2:"'!   !-" '?8," 41/.":" 1.! %'  2:  "'". , '&1. '$" :/ '; +!# 0&  '1  : ,% & -1-.1  : '# !-".&5%'%6%,//" , )*

*#"$%#"#'

*5&

" $-- &!8"

.#"#!= .#& %,% ,$'&.!%1:-"$, %: '!& .""'!%!,"# !& )5

9B " $- .,&& "&! !" '# 1'". ,"E/"'&"&%'&!" #  & )5

9B" $- ,." #;

.#"#!= .#& 1'". ,"E/"'&"& '#,&& "&! !" //",, '!&B$, %: '!& ."5!-1&5 "'!%!,"#!$:/"'& !%'5 =-%$- %&."B=.<"# &1'#".(B  

    

'$:" )

/: %"5A

9B/". ''1:

! ,%'$:" !". ##%!%' ! !-". !"  D' $$1'!

1!1."/.&/"$!&

5

A

E D H*5

 '$:" !".#"#1$!%' ) D ' $$1'! /".&' , "E/"'&"& *5

I

*5

 H

 ! ,#"/"'#"'$; !". //,;%'2 :1,!%/,%". * 

 *H@5)A5

 ) +&& "&! !"

)5

A +&& 1'". ,

)5

@ +&& $'&.!%1:!/ ."'!&F &

9B" $- *

  *5AA5

-" :1'! $:/"'& !%' ,." #; = .#"#!!-" //",, '!&5 '""#,"&&!& ;5&- ,,&! '##"#1$!"# .:!-" :1'!$ ,$1, !"# & 86" //",, '!&&- ,,8""'!%!,"#!%'!"."&! !!-". !" @)D/". ''1:'!-" "'- '$"# :1'! .:!-"# !" %,%'2 !-"/"!%!%'!%,,." ,%J !%' //.!%':"'!   :1'!   $:/"'& !%' :'2&! $, %: '!& &- ,,8"%'!-"& :". !% & %E"#8;!-"," .'"#.%81' , %."$!%'& .%81' , %' ."&/"$! ! : ''".   #%&81.&":"'!   $:/"'& !%' :1'! ! !-"$, %: '!&&- ,,"'1." K%!-!-" 86"& %#:#% %$ !%'%'!-" = .## !"#

5 /."&"'! //" ,%&#%&/&"# 



   $!8". )5

* &-= . K-"!-".&/" <%'29." &'"#(B"&9 K-"!-".."/.! 8,"(B"&9