Shakuntla @ Shakuntla Devi And ORS v. Sanjeev Kumar And ORS




   
  

 

 

!"#$% &'#(!"#$% &'#)# &"*+ ,,''# &+ -*+%+ !# .)/%0#*# &"*+ +,  &+  

 



*+ &

1*"&# 2#')#& 3*&"#,,''# &+ 1* %,&#)#& 3**+,  &45
+%*# 0,#  !"#$% &   %#'   "#,,''# &+"#)0%, #,,#'#6# +&&"#7#*#&   87"*920, 3 +  ::;5"#+9 #7#*

#% &  3 #&"  3 *.  <#'    #  *#  # &  7""  &$  ,'#  

 =
  ()

*33#&+3&"#+#*&"#&  =#+*.<#'

7#+  *) 6  0&*2'  *   #   555::4  #   "+  73 !"# $% &'#)7#+,'' * 6 &"#&0&*2'"0&*2'7#+ 9 6*)  **&'3&'# +3&"*## #&# *0#'+, "27*6 63*0)''#6 #,%*1# # &&"*"%+ "# #%* #"#%*6#*"*#>" &"2*#" #*+"''*3%$#0"# # 0&*52'  #.#.  '#& #  9#* 6   54 5=4  #0  3*0 #"#%*6#*"+ +,  &7#+*) 6&"+#0&*2'#&# )*23#+&  +,  #*#+" #   & 0#

* &+&*%$  #6# +& &" 0&*2'3&"#++#*+%'&37""9&"&"**+3&"

 0&*2' 555::43''7 # +%33*0%'&,'+0,'# 6*)%+ .%*+*.<#' .%*7#+&#$ & #. *#+,&#' #&#'# 7"*"+%%09&&" .%*++%33*92"0 &"# &

48#& =7#+*6+&*#& '!&#& !##* #&#'#3*&" 33 % *!& +:

;4 =5
 ) (* 

 6 ++%"#+9 *6"&'2*&%*  3#)%*3 &"'#0# &+#+
48#& =7#+*6+&*#& '!&#&

!##*  #&#'#  3*  &"  33   % *  !& +  :

;4 =5 
  #6# +& *+,  &# "7#+"#*65+"& &" + & +,%&9&7 &",#*&+"#+7#+8 2#*+3#6#&&"&0 3# &# &"*9% #'"##++++&" 03&"#+#+

+8?4 ;5,*#

%0"0, "#+9 #++++#+% * 5 !* #+ #'%'#& + @A
0

+8?4 ;5 @A ;4*3@A#9)+%&#+ ,*+ #'B, ++3&"#+

+8?4 588::

+ 884;5 @A 0, #3&*#,,'2 0%'&,'*

+ 884D C +  = ::

@)A <++3 +*&%0

+  ;5 @)A

% *#'B, ++

+8 ;5 @)A <++3')# #33&

+  ;5 &#'0, #7#* + & ,&---./  &"'#0# &+7*3%  &&'&&&#'0,

3+ & ,&---./#' 67&" &*+&3*0&"#&33' 63&",&&

&''*#'E#& ' 6++#&+37&"&"0,%6 #7#*&"'#0# &5 #,,''# &+"#),*3**&",*+ &#,,#' ()  <#* % +'3*&"#,,''# &++&#&+&"#&&"9 3&3 3%&%*,*+,&+%6"& & "#)9 6*# &"#&39*&"3&"

#+  0 &    
0  #B  &%*  B"9&  #+  B 5=  +  8="  &"#&3# &&"#+7#+8 2#*+'
03&"#++*#'%'#&#+ +8?4 ;53*0&"#)*#63 &"*2#*+
 +3%* +"92"*73
"#)"#*'#* % +'3*&",#*&+# ,*%+&" #+3'"3#&3# &+#0&&# ,*)
&+&# ++&#9'+" &"#&&"#+"#+#+#*+%'&3&"# &  63  "#+  *6"&'2  9  6)  92  &"  *9% #'  #   &  +  &  *F%*  # &*3*  &"#&#% &
&",%'#*3#&+# *%0+&# +3&" #+&0&&" +3.%+&&"0, +"*92*#++++ $, 6 )7&".%60 &+,#++92 G9'&"!%,*0%*&

   

  

 

 

)',,#' 8?3 ?#    

      

  & !,#'<#) &&

@)'A88 3 =@ 4  :A#+% * % 0#1+ #'2"'#! 3+ @A
0

+8?4 ;5  H3%&%*,*+,&+@ +8?4A

+8?4 I8?4C

+?=4;5 @A ;4&"3@A#9)+%&#+,*+ #'

B, ++3&"#+

+?=45 + ? = + ;5 @A 0, #3&*#,,'2 60%'&,'*

+ ;5D

+  ==? @)A

% *#'B, ++

+8 @)A <++3+&#&

+8 ;5 @)A <++3&&#' +*&%0&#'''#0# &+ &4

+  ;5@ +=  ;5 #"A &#'0, #7#*

+===?;5 &#' "# 0,

+===?5 & ,&--- 4+ &- ./ " "# #0% &30, 3+ &- ./+"#''9

,#2#9'7&" #,*3&70 &"+3*0&"#&3*,&3*&3 ,23 &"+ ** " "#  #0% &  30,  +"#'' #**2 &*+&( H,*#

%03*0&"#&33' 63&"'#0,&& &''&+ *#'E#&  )73&".%60 &3 G9'&"!%,*0%*& &" #+3 !   "!

 #$        

)',,#'=8?3  0# 6 & +3+9%*+#'

3#0% &+"#''*0# % #'&* * 6'2&"#7#*+&# +03&&"#9)B& &# &",*+ &#,,#'+#''7 5

6

(7 

 

 + >"&"*+,#$ 6;*#+   +; >"&"* ,*&#9' +;