Amar Nath Sharma v. Commissioner And ANR

  

        

!"#$#%&'&()*

+!,!"-.-!,+!

//#00!("  1#,'2'

++&''&(#,3  +/04##'  +/#('!"&( %"3  &,%0#  5!,(!0  !($ !("-#,  #'/($#("'

)  67  . 5 7.  ,#'#(")8 ,9#'-,,!3$:%!"#3 ,"-#!//#00!("
 ;-#"-#,"-# #/,"#,'0%!0(#<'/!/#,+!4=#!00<#$"'## "-#>2$9+#("?

 =#,##,,#$""-# #/,"#,,("  ;-#"-#,"-#>2$9+#("'-20$=#,#/,"#$&("-#$&9#'"? 88 88 7. 3

7 +/04#,-!'&0#$"-&'!//#!0!9!&('""-#,$#,$!"#$ 

3/!''#$=4"-# ++&''&(#,3+/04##' +/#('!"&( %"3  &,%0#  5!,(!0  &(  '-,"  6"-#  ++&''&(#,6 3  :&$#  <-&%-  "-# !//#00!("  <!'  ,$#,#$  "  /!4 %+/#('!"&(  "  "-#  "2(#    ' @@3* 8<&"-&("#,#'"3!+2("&(9" '3

83%!0%20!"#$AB /#,!((2+,+"-#$!"#&0&(9"-#%0!&+/#"&"&("&00"-#/!''&(9 "-#,$#,-#""!0'2+!<!,$#$&' '
3

3C 8 ,&#  !%"'    "-#  %!'#  !,#  "-!"  %0!&+!(" &(>2,#$

,#'/($#("-#,#&( <!'<,D&(9!'!!'(&("-#-2'# ,#'/($#(" !//#00!("-#,#&( 2,&(9"-#%('",2%"&(<,D3"-#

88 &(>2,#$ %0!&+!("  ,#E2#'"#$  "-#  #+/04#,  "  /,:&$#  -&+  =!+= '"#/'3=2""-#'#<#,#("/,:&$#$ ;-&0#$&(9"-#%('",2%"&( <,D3"-#&(>2,#$ %0!&+!("#00$<(!($,#%#&:#$+20"&/0#&(>2,&#'( -&'=!%D=(#!($-#&'("-#=#$

#'/($#(" !//#00!("-#,#&( &(-&',#/04$&$("$#(4 "-#!%""-!"-#-!$#+/04#$"-#%0!&+!("

&(>2,#$3=2"'"!"#$"-!"

($#+!($=!+='"#/'<!'#:#,+!$#,+-&+"<!''"!"#$ "-!""-#&(>2,#$ %0!&+!("<!'#(9!9#$,,#+:!0"-,##<$#( =!""#(',+"-#,!""-#,!"# ' 8/#,$!4 7#!,(#$%2('#0,"-#!//#00!("-!'!,92#$"-!""-# $&'!=&0&"4%#,"&&%!"#/,$2%#$=4"-#%0!&+!(" &(>2,#$<!'("%!00#$ =4"-# ++&''&(#,-#,#,#3&"%!(("=#=#0&#:#$-#&(>2,4 +#("&(#$&("-#$&'!=&0&"4%#,"&&%!"#&'("/#,+!(#("$&'!=&0&"4   /#,2'!0    "-#  &($&(9'  '-<'  "-!"  "-#  $&'!=&0&"4 %#,"&&%!"#<!'&''2#$=4"-#!,$%",'5!0/!(! -!<0!

:#,(+#("#$&%!0 00#9#!($'/&"!035!,(!03!($"-#$%",'

-!$,#%,$#$"-#$&'!=&0&"4B-#,#&'("-&(9"$&'/2"#"-# !%"',#%,$#$&("-#'!&$%#,"&&%!"##,#"-# ++&''&(#,3"-# /-"%/&#'    +#$&%!0  =&00'  <#,#  !0'  /,$2%#$3  <-&%-  <#,# =>#%"#$"=4"-#!//0&%!(""-!'=##(2,"-#,!,92#$"-!""-#!9# "-#%0!&+!("

&(>2,#$<!'<,(904"!D#("=#*4#!,'3<-#,#!'&( "-#$&'!=&0&"4%#,"&&%!"#3&"&'+#("&(#$!'*C4#!,' "#,9&(9"-,29-"-#,$#,3$("&($!(4&00#9!0&"4 ,&(&,+&"4&("-#'!+#-#!9#*4#!,'<!'"!D#(!'/#,"-#

88 +#$&%!0  ,#/,"'   -#  &(>2,43    %2,'#3  <!'  "-#,#   -# %0!&+!("

&(>2,#$<!'#+/04#$!'!!'(=4"-#,#'/($#("!($&" <!',-&+"/,:&$#(#%#''!,4'2//,"&(9+!"#,&!0,%!,,4&(92" "-#,#/!&,'-#,#,#3!%",
@*
C<!',&9-"04!//0&#$=4"-#

++&''&(#,"9,!(""-#%+/#('!"&(-#,#&'(&00#9!0&"4, &(&,+&"4 &(  "-# &+/29(#$  ,$#, $!"#$ 

3  /!''#$  =4 "-#

++&''&(#,

('#E2#("043"-#/,#'#("!//#!0&'$&'+&''#$ 

7.     *

'>D'