High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4628/2013disposed of

Rani Devi v. Sarbati Devi & ORS

2017-10-12Mr. Justice Darshan Singh11 pages

Vimal Kumar 2017.11.03 11:20

! !

#$%!

&' ()*

! "# $%&!

%# #( !#

#+,&!

&' ()*

! "# )* %!'

%# #( !#

,""!

&' ()*

! "# )* %!'

%# #( !#

$!,#!

&' ()* + , % -#.%+ /0!( ! "# $%&!

%# #( !# ) -.) / 0 1% !2 %$$'

3'4!5( +!

5 ! #

%16075( +!

%% #( !# #

(

%6)#'8&5( +!

%% #( !

%) %*$7'!'

5( +!

%% #( !#

%% #( !##

0 1 9'#%( %(## ! .% #%#7 .! +# (!

( 4%( % ( &: !'

!% ++( ! / 8# 9%&. 56.%.3#'

#8 ++( !

/9/#

'#+' 7 (!'

4%(54'

&:+8 #! 5

;<'#

4%( (!$%&!

(7'&%$7'

/9/#

+' 7 #!'

4%(54'

&:'

+ 8 %+8 #! +#++.! !' '

%(.7'!

%<< 4$%!4#(#8## ((

/9/#

:# +' 7 ! !'

4%(5 4'

&: '

% + 8 % +8 #! +#++.! !' '

%#*6.8%4# (#8## (4'

'#&

%% -#.%+ /8: +' 77 !'

4%(5 4'

&: 8.! 5

;< &: 4: #!'#&

4%( (!$%&!

(7'&%$7' ++.! ( !' % (.7'!

% $%! !

( ( * 6.8% &%

+!#% !'!

5*6.8%('#4

5 8 :5 $%!5 4 : 8%% ( +.

5 4 !%

7 &: %( %8 6.%.3#'

!%!'

%4:!" 7 )'#*%8!%+:+ & %7

=< < 5*6.8%%(74!''#4

#!!7 9'

:4 ++8 (&:) 4$7'(8 #'6.8%# %!

8!%+:+ %7=</< !&.!

154'

*6.8%('#4

$%! % +'

( % 9>- / 6.%.3#'

!%< '( %(5 !

+%##7!'

&.#<#!(68(5!'

(7!%.+3& %7% 7#!%! =< )<54!'% #( !!'

%7+87!

%: '7'#

(#!%.+3!'

8!%+:+ %8& '(%#' :( 7 7 ! :* 6.8%($%! #!+!% (

(4!'

%((. %!.!

: %!4'

!%.+3+%.#'

(!'

8!( !'!'

#! 8 #' 6.8% !'

++8:7 8!%+:+ +'# ( !'

!%.+3! !#! ( ?.%:5!'

%(#+ # ('#8 #)* # 81%3#'5% #( ! " 7 '&5 #!%+!'!3 !

%!'!

+.!

%5 !'

( 4: %8 !'

#! 7 !'

(7!%.+3 #!(7!!'

#!9'

+ +8 !!'

#! ++( !?.

#!4# #!%!

( - !'# % 7%(5 - (!

.( % $ +!# 5 55 <-1/4#% 7#!

(7#!!'

%9'

#!<8%!

8 (&( *6.8%($%!4#+(.+!

(+!%# 0@1=#! 56.%.3#'

!%!'

47(: * 6.8% 4# $+ 9 +'

% ,

%8 ! (( $+' 5,'%%#= 4#

%# 7 !!'

!8 ++( !(

% (# %:

;< %8!'$%!4# :

%# ((4# 4%37 # # # % ! $'% 6%#' ,

%8 ! :.%

(+ / 5 6.%.3#'

!% = % 8!' : +8 4#

;< 9'

: 4 8%% ! :('(!#!%!

( 8 : )

(7 .%!'

%5 ! # ##%: ! 8 ! !'

( #+%! %! #9'

#8 ## 4#2

# !'

8!'

% * 6.8% ( ( ( 8!'

%<< 4 $%!( ( $%&!

(7'&%$7'% 8!'

%( !'

$%!( ((8!'

%<< 4( !'

%<< 4 *6.8%( ( + , % -#.%+ /8:08!

(A#.%

(79%.+3& %7=< )< # % #. ! ! +( !5 !'

(#.!

7%(7 +8 #!& 7!4# !# 8 # '.#&(#( (4

(!4+ 8#& 7/9/# + 87 +8 #!!!'

!. 3'#++.! !' '

%#* 6.8%(/9/# + 87+8 #!!!'

!. 3'#++.! !' '

%(.7'!

%<< 4$%!4'

#!'

% !# $%! (+ 8 !!& %7/9/#

+ 87 +8 #!!!'

!. 3'# !

% +#( %7 !'

% # % +%(5 !'

9%&. ! 6.%.3#'

!% ( !# +# (!

( 4%( (!

(

(#8## ( !'

+ 8 !!# (&:

(++ !

(!'

+ 8 !! (&: % !# $%!( ( 9%&. '#++ !

(!'

+ 8 +! (&:$%&!

(7'&%$7'5% !# $%!( (&# 71% 4%(# 4#2 B %8 !'

#( .!'%! #5 ! # + % !'! +# 8%% ( (.7'!

%5 !'

+8 #! # ! & 7

! '

% % !#

5 $%&!

( 7'&% $7' % !!

% +8 #!++.! !' $%!C 9'.7'! #!7 !'

8.7 (4%(5

D#+ 8 '#&

% #!%+!

(!+8 #!++.! !' '

%# :5&.!

'# &

<#.!

% !'

# !'! ! 4# 8(!%: ! '

8 ( ( !'

7 % !!

((+# :'

! * (5 !'

: #' & 8 ( ( # % #( !# ! !'

+! ( 4'

!#8 ( (5!'

!!#!8!& # % # !'

%#! ##.

# ++ % (5 - %

% 8:#

E% ##7: (.

!!'

%# (% 8(%( %=4

%5#

%## +(##.

#++ % (5-(! (8:#

!4!'!'

4 9%&. !'! : & +.#

(( ! 8 ( '

87## !'

%#+ 8!#%# 7 % !!

##'

+8 #! 9'

% # ! $ +! !% "

'+ # +!5

%#'%!F!'

+!D54'+''#&

(#8(!%:'#!& (+ %8!:4!'!'

!% ## =(.$.++ ##+!5 9'

&%!'

%# (*6.8%4 / ##--'

%#('( %7'!!+8 #!!'

% %4(4 (8!'

%5/ ##- '

% -! # : !'

&# 4(4 !'! &%!'

%# + + 8 #

%# %# ! !'

#!!

( ( &%!'

% / ## -- '

%# 9'

&%!'

%#54'% (

!(# !!

(8%%7 '(!'

%4#.%+ # +8 (4 !(

! !

*6.8%(4. ('

+ 8 #!!'

% 8!'

%5!'

% !'

%' 7 <( ( !'

8!'

% - 4. (5 !'

5 ! ++ ! !'

7 #!

E.( 9%&. !<#.!

(' (!'

!!#! 8!& - (8## +8 %8 !'

8!'

% (.%7 +%##<

E8!!'!#'

'(!4!'

%##5!83 #(

#8!!

+!5 !'

(7 9%&. # &: !.% #7 #

< +!%(+!%:- #.!#'

(!8!& 5

!4. (8+! %!8 ! +8 #! !'

+# 4(45

+8 #! # #'% ( %7'!5 ! 4. (7

% ;%(#'% +8 #! 3 :!& 4%( 9%&. ).!

'#'( !(#

!'7'((%: #(

& !4

4!'

=(.$.++ ## +!54'

4%(F'

%D'#&

.# (!'

E! % %!:

!&:

8 (+8 #!%: ## #!'

!%"

'+ #+!#!'

.%# # &!' +!8 !#% ! (#8 9'

8.! #!

+!#!% %!:!'

!.% #!!

4%(F'

%D'#

(

($ +! =(.$.++ ##+!54'+'8 #F:

%#5 8 %

8 5 4' # !!

( ! #.++

( ! !'

% %!: !

#!!

.( % G!'#H +!D ( ++%(7 : !'

E% ## F 7 !!

#D.# (% #!$ +! +!#!(

(( %7'!# &%!'

%#% 8#.&# !!!'

8!'

%+# !' ##98.+' 8'##+!& + ((

+:!'

%##!'

%!'!'

(+# #!.( %$ +! +! # 8!!

% +!5 $ +! + % ( # !'! +!+& &%.7'!&: %: 7 % !!

( ( 9'

7# !.% 4'

! +!

( !'

!% "

'+ # +! % I (!'

4!++88(!

#!.!#4!'.!& 7# + +(

5!'

&# / ##-'

%5/ ##--'

%#+. ( ##!

! + 8+8 #!(#

! %8 #+'

!J'

(!'#8 %5 (7( #!' (7((# & !&

%%.

( /87 ! !'

+% ##.

7%(7 !

% # (#.!

# & !4

(!'

% !# $%!( (5!'#&

%7.

(4!' %+ &: % $'

3'4! !'! !'

9%&. 4 ! +8 !

: 4%7 (#!7.#'7!'

+# !'#/.%!K!

(-(-#.%+ /8:

08!

( "# 1% ( !'

%#5

/ / ( #!

(

47 !'

( +## (%# =7' /.%! ('% 1%( #' =7' /.%! ! =:( %&( ( !'

6 % =7' /.%! ! >%3. 8 +# #5 8 :5, %:)!'

%"#$6*3)

%#( +(

('% 1%( #' $!!

( 9%#%! /%%! !'

% "# ): 7&'.#' !'

%#5

/@ ( ( :88!'

%#"#6 % $!!

(9%#%!/%%! !'

%#5/@ %

!!'

4 E% ## (&:!'#/.%! ): 47!'

!'%

*.(78 !#%

!!'

4 !'#/.%!5

'#&

( %

( #!+ 8 (!'%.7''

%(.7'!

%< < 4 -$.!'

%$!!

#-(() 7 !'

:&'7 4#

4 (4' !'

%%!% !'#/.%!(%!'

%-(5!3#'% 4 %

# # 7#! !'

8!%%+' #+ !: $.!'

% #+ !: !'

!%%+' #:#!

8# 4 (7% !%! !

%%!% #%!'

% -((!'# %#!& .( % :7(8#+ !%+ !'

*.(78 !# =7'/.%!#$.!'

%$!!

#% (.&:!'

9%&. 9%&. '#!##7 (:% #!( %! %8!'

4%+!+ ( !'#/.%!('#&%.#'

(#( *.(78 ! +# ('

!'!!'

!!&:

4!'% +!!'

E% ((.7'!

%<< 4# !8!& +!

!+# & ' -#.%+ /8:4#!'!% !#<< 4+. (!& #(!&

!# ( ( (5 !'

5 !'

!! !#

# ! 8!& 0 % $7 @.(7 665@!+ ('#%( %!'!.( %$ +! =(.$.++ ##+!5!'

&# +' (% ('.#&(5!'

8 5 '

%# '.#&( #' & 7 '

%# 9'

% ( 8!'

%% '

%# '.#&((5!'

5!'

:#' & !3 #

7 '

%#9'.#5!'

8!& !: !!+. (!& (.&!

( /.%!&#

(!'!!'

8:%&& : %:(! 8: ! %8 : ' !'! !'

% !#<< 4 +. ( & #!!

( ! & (

!!'

%7# (.7'!

%<< 4=4

%5!.7'!!83 (

+# 4'

# + 8!#'# #( (5!'

/.%! (9'

$7 ) +''

(# 4#2 B L- %. 6.8% 7%4 ( !'

! -#.%+ /8:(!'

%#5( +( ( !'@. :5

(

5 !'

$.% /.%! 4# ( 74!'!'

+# !' 48%(++( ! ( #.( ( !'

7 & %+'

# !'

8!!

% ## ##8 ! +!%&.! '.# ' ( %!!'

8 : ) +'#3 !'%.7'!4(

!*.(78 !#

+7#8 %++ %#%@.#!+ 6,7. :%

%% !*.(78 ! #) +' (%#=7'/.%! ! -#.%+ /8: %

3 / #+ .#

( !'

% %!

(

!'! ?.!

% !

%! +

!# (

% %%!

: ## ##7 !'

'8 83 %#M + #L EE EE EE -

35 !'

/.%! . !8!

: #.77 #!

( !'! !'

'.# ' ( %M# +!%&.! 8.#! & !3 # N '.#&(M#+!%&.!!!'

8 :-8# !!7!'#.! : !#4 %!%!+. %%+'( +!

% +.# #.% %!'!!'

% !#<< 4+. (!'

!% !

(#(

!#(!'

+ 8 !!8.#!'

(#8## (-'

% (:'

(!'!!#!..#. !'! (.7'!

%<< 4 !3 # +% % !#<< 4 '

'.#&(M#'.# 9'

#!.!#!%. :7!!'#+# !'!!'

+ 8!#'

#!!'

%# #9'

% (.7'!

%<< 4(!'

%# + #+. (

%& .( %< #!8!

(-(#!.! .7'!

%#<< 4% !

% &.%7 $.+' +( !# % E+ !# ( &

75 : #' & %7!!

% #5 #+ !: +!# 4!' #

!#!8.!!'##+.%7 5!'.7'!(+! ##77 ! (.7'!

%<< 4

%% % !'

'8 837 9'

(.7'!

%<< 4 # !'

+%% % 8 : !%(! ! !'

7 %! E! 7 8&(8 ! #+% + % #!%: !%(! .

#(8 78 '.#&(#

8 : %+!+ # 4!' & 7+

8 :M# .&%77C + & 8 % (.&! !'!

#'. ( &

(!+8 #!!'

!' '

%#((.7'!

%<< 4$%! #.&* +! % 8( %+

(7# =4

%5 !'

#! ?.!.8 +8 #!((#!%&.!#8!!

% +#( %! 9%&. (! %!'#/.%!5!'

%#!#!+ 5#7#!!'

%7'!# $%!D# % !#9'

9%&. 4 %

#!!'

*.(78 !+# (!'

*.(78 !#4'+'8:& +!

! ?.

#! #!!'#+# % !#'%( :: (

+. !: 4'

-#.%+ /8: ( # ! (#.!

& !: &: ?.

#!7 !'

(!: % 7 0+ # (%

(7 9%.+3% -#.%+ 1 +:$+ (4 &!',

%8 ! !# ( # % 8 :

# !'

+8 # (+.8 !

( ( 4( : 34 ( !'

8. ! %;8. ! +( 8 !'( + # : & ( ! %%

!+8 #!.( %!'

! '

(# + 8 !++ .(7

% .!.% %# +!#54'

8 :8 !4##!& ! % !% !'(!'

J' 9%&. '#4%( ( 5

;<!!'

% !# $%!5!'

+ 8 !!# (&:

(#8## (

( #'

'# 7! +8 #! 4'!#

%5 4'+' 8: % ! & !%

#!: *.#!+ 9'

+ 8

!'%.7' '

% # * 6.8% '# &

(

%8'

%(.7'!

%<< 4#.

+'+ !:

# % #. ! &

(#+.##5 4' # !!7 #( 8.7 (4%((!

(

%% (&:

% (## ( 4%( .% % !# $%! # # ! #( % #' +#( %! 9'

+ 8 !!# % 8( ( ! !'

9%&. % #' +#( %!&:##7 #'4%(++%(+ 4!' 4

8.! #!4%( (!!'

% !# $%! 4 !& (#&.%# ((!'

%8%( %(!

(

##.

(&:!'# /.%!#' +!.

%!! !'

(## % 8((!'%

8!'# !'

% %! # ! %+' !'# /.%!5 +# : % 77%

( +# 9%&.

!!'##!7 5%$'

3'4! %7& '

#!!

# ! !'

)% !'! $%&!

( 7'&% $7'5 % !# $%! ( (5'

.%+' (% 4'% 4 # !!

(

% %!

8!%8 '8 # '

#:# # 1%+ ( !'

%# '!7%'

%5#($'<3

%% +!

:= .%!'

%#.&8!# !'!!'

% !# !

$%! 4 !(

! '

%+8 ('( %4#.%+ +8 54' 4(4

8:'

!4 7##5&.!4#% #(74!'( (*6.8%9'## ###.

9%&. !+#( %!'

+:!'

% 8( %+

(7#.%!'

( 5 :54 & % #!%+!

(!#

% 8( (% +!#(!'

( 4 % 8!+!

4 +87 !

%% ( &: !'

+ , % -#.%+ / 0!( 7#! !'

+ 8 % !# $%! ( (5 %( %# % ?.% ( ! & ## (5 # !'

8.7 4%(!#

'#&

# !#( (!'

+ 8 !!#% 8( % #' +#( %! # +!#%

!!% 8(9'

/8:4 '

!# #: #'!'

%7%.(# ++%(7 :5!'# #%( (! #!((#8## (&:3

7!'

##.

%% +#( %!% 8(! +( (++%(+ 4!' 4 ! !

" 2 0 3 "8