Sumindro & ORS v. Sushil Kapila




    
    

    !" #

 $  "% &" ''  ("$ " $&')' &" *  !" #$ % %
$
%
$$ +" 

"% &" #% " "(,-.&#%

   ""   "/''#%

""  $
%
$$ & +" '&! '!-&'   "    1"!-&'"

" 2' 3"!$ '# *$ 4"&" "" ""&53"!$ '5 &

 4&),'' ,%)$ "%1" 6 

 7"  "- ",$ &"&& '' 8'  "  !"&" & '

"    &"(&'9 4 

$ &  4&),'' ,%)$ "

#  "%&' 1&&9'



#$$ "& "%

4%&' 1 "!" "4" +7;6;;6 !-"  3&#4

-"&  1!" '- 2& $"

  '  2''4     <'#  7$ 4'  7& #  3&'

+& 9'"- 


8;"  & ."

'  " 4&%  ""#  "$   '$&  4&),'' ,%)$ "

 1&& 9 '



$"&  

"%

4%&' 1 "!" 4"4"

+7;6;;6 !-"  ."

'1&' & &!
#

$  $ 4 $   


8;  "  

$  1"      =#  1"    $  



#6

8;1& "&" :6>"

$  " &

' &'  '' $'"' &1"6 > "  1

" $$""6 >$

1

&1!&'"$''" 1' &! &4 &"  & ''-#$ 

6#

8;11" "'=  44"% &?$ $  #'  &%

'&' ."

$ $! & 

   =  &  !  1" 4'- $      &4&"  "  &  1&   '!'  "%"#  $''"  &  ! ""'-  '     &  !  1"  "  & =    $""    '

"   &    " 



   

  1&  & $' '-$$ !& ,$"  4"  $ "&  %  '&&! 1"@#&$#"-& 

1"&'  !  ."

$ "&  - $! &&     =&!'$'    "

  & "  1" $$""@ $"&"$!  &&=  $"" & '"  &% ! "%

" 1&'1#&$4&  &&"    
"&'# ""''

1& &$' '- $$ !& ,$"@$! &&  &!

"4&'-#&$# $4 1" 6 

!$&' @&%&" '"

 $ '   1''  '"

$ "& - &%4 &"$4&& "" 3&"      $  &    4&  ),'  '  ,% )$ "'&' $ ,$""%!-&   "%&'  #1&&9'



$&"&  "%

4%&'
 &'"

' & $&  '-@'  &&#4

-"'&  #& &77 4" " & /%"

'2''4 <'# "" A$ #

<1  '-"2& $"

'2''4 <'#7$ 4'

7& #3&'+& 9@ $"&" " ""&& 1 " '"- 


8;"  &3&'  &%$'- =  +B'9 4'# 4"<*2& $"

'2''4 <'#7$ 4'7&  '"-" C=+ & 1''''  '"C=+1""%!-& ."

'1&'  4  &  '"-    &      ! 


8;  "   &  
#

"

$ &'&$  


$ &! $1"  =#&" "#&

$''"- !
#

8;#

;

3& "%"-$4&!

" !- &'"

 $ '  " & -  $ '- 1"    &  ,$4   &  < 5!'  $"   2$"    '()*'+
*,-.'*/012'*3$)1)(0450.,-, .'*'3%0(6)'*4(60.,7

)5)+ @ ''-!"%&" &5  5   $'  '&=
$$"""!& $  " 4!#' &,$4  @ &"#  ''-!"%$ "

;

&4#1 $ '--&  "& "  $'' 8 $''"     "

#   &    !     &  !      !'&  !-  &  '4'

"" %  &
$$"" "! &$  &" 4! D  E   $'  '& &=E 3&" "#&"  " &"4$  "!-'"

 $ "& -@ &#!- &'"

 3"!$ '# &$ $&'   
#

8; " 

$  @ "'%      -"#   $ 
#F

8;1  =   "  = =G >1'%!' "   " 
#F

8;
6#

8;  3&" "#  &      =  '%!'   
F#

8;     


8;!-&'"

'  "$ 4$ 

F#

$ 1"  ="$"

#

$' 1
#

8;@ %1 &4$'  &< 5!' $"  2$"  & .'*'3%0(6) $"# " $$" "&" 6 >
#:#

8;

"#&1

-"'&   #1&&9 &
6##

$ @ %1 &4$' '1 !-&< 5!'

$" 2$"  




 

 

  
  





 

   *2*  2%'  ::#  6 > $ & ! ""'-

 & 1!&'"# &"!-" " 4 &!
6 6

8;6

;

6 6

 @&! &'!-&< 5!' $" 2$" 










 !
"

#$



 && $''"'&$'! 1&" " &4 &  &"  3& # &#1 '- -"' $ ""&   #&" "# $''" :   ! ' '- 4    $''"    :#   -    &  '     
# #6

8;
6 6

=:3&'  "' '
6#

8;& " "'=   
6#

 ' @

"  &,$4  &< 5!' $" 2$" '81'0*0.'+
*,-.'*/012'*3$)1)(0450.,-,'*- '1+)',6-6.- '1'*4 (60.9   )5)+ 

     

& 2$"   ' %6.) '10*0.'+
*,-.'*/0 12'*3$)1)(0450.,-,0'*(:'-.'*4(60.,&'' 

"  &" '


8; '

'' "$  2'  "#&$# '' 

# #6

8;
'
$ "

;

.  -
6 6

=:
# #6

8;

. '' "$


8;

. 
6#

8;
$ "'= 
6#

8;

('+
# #6

8;

3& $ '"-1"&'' #

'-#&'' $ " & $ '$'!% '' " ' "&" :6>"

$ 

 $  " & ' & ''"'H "  $   4'   &''! & " =!-&'"

'"  3"!$ ' " 

" !$"   $  &'  &'' $" B&  &  !%     &   $

  #" '  $),')++

 !" #

-480 "  B&&"9 48" 

I8 B&&"""!'

I8