← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaVATAP/338/2019allowed

M/S Saluja And Company v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2020-03-13Dr. Justice S. Muralidhar,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan8 pages

    



! "#$#%& '( )"'*

(+$, -./ %!01 %2 11 -- % $  )2 % %!' )$  $1%! %$ (&,,(3  ,, ) $ %&4

         

),(3  *  

  

 ! #$

  %"  '((# *% * +  ,

 ' -" '( .



   " /, * "* +  $

'( .

 3 )*3*+ '( (2

' # ,

     

56  "

 7" , ,

8   59

   

((

"2/

  &, 

;

'<= 

<=9 >  " 

 

  "  !     "  

   ? 

<

8, "   , "  / 

.<$

,, "

,

  

 ** ,  , "  ?

8 )**+

$ " 

3 '( (2

 "  "  @ % 02'

 

   A

< )#+



 1   '( ",  

?< <!2 B :/2"2?  "  ?

8 )*?*+ " 

#>

 

 1   '( " , ,     7"





* , " 



!A ;

<'<= 

;

# '<=

 " * 1C 



B D  '( 1    

?#<.<(<!2 ,  **  , ,  ,

*, 8*  **

B=

,

F"  1#= "  ",

!"  "    "   

& 

'<= 

",

<= 4"

   ,  ,

  ** 

*F /  2  " 2   ", .,,

?  

 "  ",

 ' -" '( . " 

&

, **

"2/

"   

", ;

# '<=  , 

  

     

  

 

(

 "    ,

",  ,

 

"  " ,   "    ,

 

((

"



"       " 





, *" * ? 

 

      



!

"

#

$ %%# & #'

 (



*+, *, - * 

' " 

 , 8



"      , 

", 6 " "  ", 

  ,      8 ? 



"

,

.

/ #  0  

12#

"

#3

  45 12#

   

#

 # 

- 6 -#

# *8  45 





   

% :1-1 ;

,

+5 #

'

    

 #'

< ;



5 





   

+  :- 4*5   < 3) % #

  

 #'

 - * --  $&

-

  -  

 #'

*  =

 ! *,,,

#G  "

 

   ?    ",

 "  ,



"!,  "

((2 E

 "  





"

 "   

$=

" B(=

#= ",   8

!$

"  ",

,"  "

"  

>

"2/



(( 5F 

 " ,  ", 7 7 8 4" 7" 8 



"!,    

  *

< 

  

 7" " ,  "  "  ,

" " 57" 



"9 

  * *

" " 4"  , ,

 *8*

" "   

 &,    *8*

*"*   8  " E

  "      8 /  ," "  *8*

*"*   ,

"  "

,



8,  

"8

"

 

 8

 * *

" "

$

E .

/ #  0  

12#

"

#3

+     

 , 8 *@

* *    

*, * *     "

C ,"" F " 8

.$( )*CF *+

E 

"

CF   '

+)+  

  7" E 

  &, "  

, 

4" 

 8, " ,   , """

 , "    

"

$'

 7",   "", 

 *@

* *  "



H>@

"", 

"   ,



,

@

"

"

     

" , 



,

     "       , 8  ",

 4" 

"

 ,

  " 

,    

", "

&   * &* ) 8+   , 8 4"  "

  2  , )0CC+

  "     ", "

&" , 8 &

 4"   &"   ,A "   , "

,    , &"  ,A  &"  4"

  "A  

 "  .<

(( , , 8,  

,  " 4"  &"  

, 

, 

 "    

A

 8   8,,  8, ,  8 8

'(( A 4" ,  & 

$# @"  &



5E " @

* H ""

"

"    " 

"      , "" "      "

 

   E    ,

, 8 

  " E

  ,

"      

"      , "  " "

    "9

B

 

   

 

,  ,  

 ** *"* E 12#

  )

+   

7"2  8  * @AA*  7"   " $) +)+

I %"  '((# )*I%*+ , "  ",

 *   8* ,   '(=   ",

 *" 7"  8* ,  

'<= 



*B   , 

    ", )E+        

" )+ 7"  4" "

 J& & &K )+

  ,L ,

 G

"*

B'



7"2     *   8* 

 & " $ +)+ $) +)+

I%  

5 "

 

   , 

   

", E '

 7"  4" "

"   

    " E # 

 " E > 

"    

 

"  " E <

7"  " " " 

?D

.

'((1  ,

 

"  " 9

1    .

/ #

+ 12#

 )

+ "

 

 

"

 

   "  "  *"

* 

:



    

, ,   

" "

$=

.

"

 



 

 , "

  " 

  "

0    # '

 (

"

#

#

*++8   +*  

 

. @ " '( > /6F $1(<

'((< ) #

'

    

 #'

+

'(

 

 "

  

" , 





   

+  :- 4* &

 , *F 

/ *   *G * *M / * 1( F

  "

 %"  '((# ) % + 1( 

*1( F 

 ,  " ", 7 7 8 4"  7"* '('

" ,   



5 " 



 *   "

    &"  "   " 

*   , 

"*

 1(

F

  "

   



E "



 *

,  " 

 / :&   " ", 

 



@

F ,   

 9 ""

 2     5G 9 5M / 9 "

1(

F

  "

 %"  '((# ",   9 '

@

      

 , **

"

  ",



  ,  

   ,  "

 ! , ?  ''



"

 &

 !  "

"    " 8     

'#      " " 



),(3 +    '( )"'*

),+ 

  8' ' )$1 9#%:+) $% !; $+ 8' ' )) 1) <- ; $+