← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4783/2017dismissed

Union Of India v. Bhagwan Dass Garg & Others

2017-09-06Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Arun Monga7 pages

 

     

 !"#$

%!&'()*+,#-."#$

!/%0120)&%30+!/%.40

 5'1'

0%24%%''%260'

'*/'



  !" #$%&'"#()$  '&&!*#$+,"

  !" #$%&'" '&!*#$+,"

'( 8 %29)20:%./&%.

) %1'!0*

77777  '&!*#

0*0%';/0491'/&!0'1 1/&'""-<""

!0'1!/%.';2'2=%'/! 0  /  /%/  $

"#$-  >?1  = @  *%''/  ,3  0  % /+'%,1%.0%/2%0&0>!'0AB@.40,3. 40*%3%42   $ $"<<"#$"!/,3'*/ $= 0%24%%''%2.0%'''1//&0%01%!/%

*'!0*/$

"##%/$

"##, 2/  !  &'/%  !  '*/   $  !  !11  1*2%/%< *+

"

!!%&'!0&%'%0%'*/ $'%/& &1!/%&+)&'>)@!$C C%&0 $CC".04%'

*+/%'1/+'%%/>@%/$CCD4%'2%/

1&%)&%/ 0%!.03%"###.'*/

 4%'*+/%')/+'%%/>)@ 120'*/.

0''&&/+%/32/1'%/2?&*!0*/ "##"=# "##.40'*/ $4%'4;21/'*/  "=0%%)%&0%2%+:+/.0,&%+2,!=!1&%   4  !

 13.  "#$"  %/  ,!  &'/2  0+ !  0  '%+.  0 *'&3/0,4,&0+%; %20% */ 1/&%1/!'*/

.,4,&0+%;

2%/24%'24*% '!0*/$

"##

4%'%'2,4,&0+%;2%/2!0*/"$

"## "##C,30'1&&''!'*/

401%**&%!+/ %/%! '1&'

$"

"

"#$"%/$ "

"#$".'*/ $'1,+/0 *'%'?*''20'2%&%////%/$ "#$".0 '%+49&/ '120!+%1/ 20!+%& E1%  0'    !+  13  $C$    &+,.  "##

 5/  ++  /%/

"#$".0!+%!0*/$CCD=C-&+,."## 4%'

'1**/.40&0'04/0%?&*!03%"##$=#"%/"##"=# .0  '  ! '*/  $ +%/  F53 /G  F 1'%/2G %/ /120'43%'.0' '4F/G  '*/ "=):.

'%/! &!320%21%3&++/42!0  ).%2%//0'%+02,3&324'!0*/ !+$

"##C C "##C>/ 3@%/$# "##C $

"#$# >*/'0&++.0%23$ 4;2/%3'@.%2%'40&0 $'1,+/*'%/%/"D $# "#$"

8 %29)20:%.%/) %1'!  !/%'1,+/0%+'!0%+'+/0 2%

 **&%*%/):%///E10&++'!0 +    0 ' %%/3% ?'2 +&0%'+  0 +.40&0+'&/2! '

 %/22,30

*2 !!&'4/,30 42 !!&%/&%'!%3 /''%'!%&!0+*3&&/.0+*30%'%**13 *'%2%'02%/2+'!  8'/%/$

"##C%/

"#$#

  4%'  ?  &//  0%  0  &+*  %103.  %! &20&++'!0 *2%/ 42 !!&'%2 '0 '2%/240&0*'%'0%/,!/,3 $./&//0'%+%&&/%&40%4 '*0 '40*%221/'<'1&'!+!/%.0 4%'*'!&++1&%2,4,&0+%;2%/2 03 *'4%'!&++1&%2%/''.,1;*240   8'/%/$

"##C%/$

"#$#.0&'!0%  '0%/,&3/'*/ $,!&'/20+!  -

:%/  &1'  %'  %21/  0%  0    0%/  !%/   %**&%0%0 '!0*/$

"##%/$

"## "#

"##0%/%%/3,&'//,30/*%+40/&/2 0*'%!'*/ $.40&0/0%',1*0/,30 ,1% 0%'//&20/*%+20 %!+/ '/'****&/10%/,!4/%/0 &++'!0 *2%/ 42 !!&'4,%/ 0 +%;'4!1/,91'!/ %''0%,2,30 !22,!!/1,'*/

 4%'%''1,+/0%00%/,'/0%0  %/  +  !  /%  ''1/  %+//  '1&'  40  2%/   '"##C%/"#$#*1'1%&!091/2+!0*?1 /%/$"

"##//15'1' !/%%/0'.

**%

- $!"##"

4%'/&/0%0&+*&! %&0 41/,&3/%!!&'%!0&+*!0 %/0*'&,//%!?/!'1&0&+*4%' $'121'! %&0  3%  0'  '1&'  4   , %**/    '*&  !  

&//!0*/"##=#C4%/'

0.21/'%''1/  0 *%+' %/  ) '  40 2%/  &0%2'   *&/1  %/+'%+%'.%;'+!'1&0'1&'*&%0 +*+2!!&'<!!&'

0%*'.,&%1'!0%%'.04%'

/%3!%+'43%'&320&'!0 '!+ "##=#C  4%/'    '*/      ''  0%'  ,  &%1'/   $0'%&&1%'00%/%**13*' %2%'02%/20' '

  4%'  !10  %21/  0%  0  4%'    /  !  ''12 /&0*20%!+/ '%'0  4%'0%2!1*4'&'/0&%'+' )!%%' !0 */$

"##'&&/.00%/,'/0% $//%/00*'&,/*/</%!'1,+2 0''!=%**%'%0 *2 !!&  2%/2 !0*/

"##CC "##C.'*/ $'1,+/0'%+"

"#$#.

  .2%!0/%!$D0!**'&,/!'1,+''!'!= %**%'% 0 *2 !!&&//0'+%;' $

"#$#%/0  +%/1=4/,&%1'0 42 !!&0%/%%/3

- / $ "#$#  0' &%,&'//,&+*

%3'1,+20'!=%**%'%4%'0*%!'*/ %/0* 0%'!%/%**&%0!%&0%40 &'/2  0  &%'  !  %  +*3  !  *+.  0  *%+%

+++&%+%;'4%''''+'*%%3,3%/*2 1!+'%/%/'.3%/'&;'%/+'%/.01'.12/ 01! E1%'02!0+*12//

  0%  0%/  0  %/  &1'  !  0  *  %/ %**%'/0*%*,;%/%!0*0%0'+%/ !&0'1,+'''!0%/&1'!0*%/0 4*/'',/'+''/ $#

0  ,1%.  %!  %**&%2  0  +%%    &/. &&1//  0%   '  !  0  */  #$ #$ "##    $ # "##  %/ #$ #

# "##+%3,2/!&'/%!%**&%= $!!111*2%/%<*+ 4.0/&''

!0+*103/%/$ #D "#$"%/$

"#$"9&20 *'%!0%**&%E1%0 '!0*/"$ # "## # "##C%/#$ #

"##C#C "##C4%'1*0/ $$  0     %/  0  +  !  /%  0%/  ''1/  0 %+//'1&'2%/2 '"##C."#$#4!0% /&//&1/1 + +./ &%''1*%.404%'0/0% '01/,&3/%&0!!&%! 0&+*!0  %/  0  *'&,/  /%  4%'  $' 121'  !  %&0  3%   '1&'4,%**/'*&! '&//!0*/ "##=#C4%/'

0&0%20'4 *'%20+%;'

0 &//    0   '  !  0  */  #$ #$ "##    $ # "##  %/ #$ #

# "## '2%/'0 )!0*/#$ #$ "##  $ # "##.'%+%!&/0%0 !+!0*/!+

"##4%''1,+/,30%**&%='*/ $ #

"## 0'+!%3/%0'*  4%' 4/%/0%'!/2'.0%'%',?*%/%/. 0!.0%'203,%/%'&+*

'2%/'*%! !0*/$

"##.

0 !+4%' '1,+/,30%**&%  - "##C *2 !!&&//+%;'"C - "##C%/0 42 !!&&// 0'+%;'!0'*/20400 !0*/"$

"##  $

"##C2%/20+,  40%'0 !0*/ "$

"##    $

"##C  4%'  '1,+/    "##C  %/  0  *2 !!& &//  0'  +%;'    $

"##C  %/  0  42  !!& &//+%;'400/%

"##C 0,1%0%/&&1//0% 0 !0*/#$ #

# "##.0%**&%0%/%2/ ,%'0*%!)0

%4%='*/

0%/&/0% 01200'*/=):0%/,%/0&++'!0 *2 %/ 42 !!&%'%%%,.,10%/2%/,!!/1,0 %**&%,&%1'!%2%'%'&/0,!%/01'. ! 0  */  #$ #

"##    "# # "##  4%'  %'  /&/    ,  2/

4.  0  +%;'  !  0  */  "$ # "##    $ # "##C  %/ #$ #

"##C#C "##C41*0/

  '1'  %2%'  40  2%/    23  0%  , /%2%''*/ $%/.0!.0!/2'!0! 220 '!0*/!+$

"##%/$

"##

 "#

"##%/0,!'!&/0+*12//&%,'%/ ,191'!/.1%'%,*' 0%**&%='*/ 0%'    &0'    +*12  0  !/2  40  2%/    %;2   &'/% '!0*/"$

"##C%/$

"##C "##C.,14!1%,,'%'.4/!/%3%' /!!400!/2'//,30 01*0/20'%+.

04*'/'+''/

>#()$  '&&!1  2 '&!1 #$+,"

 #$+,"

% 3 0* 64 /7 7 7 /3 68 9: 6/

;

( /:

7 7  65

( /: