United India Insurance Co Ltd v. Monika & Others










 





 









  








 




 






 








 






  


  !

"#$%&

 ''((

 )' !(

$%&

'

 







  
!
  
"#

$



%


&
  
!








'

( 
  
!
  
")
  

 #





 

'



 








 









 






  


 +!

#,!

$%&

 ''((

   !

"#$%&

'

-


%


&
  
!








'

( 
  
!
  
"*    
' 
  
  
!
  
",
  

 !  "#$%&!'()'*+ &!&,"+**% !&,"+**%-(./ 

.!+*+((+'


!!

%"/0 ! " 

   '

#1

   &&+

 2( +" .+#0

($ 3 '

 +  !  4 ! .+#0

(4 *!#1&"'

!

#  &&0



!)%

   5

 "  %!+&0(  &&+

!

6 '( &   
 

    !

 #  +( #1 ! 7  8 +

&2"'

1, *! ! ! '' (!

# '#1 &(

6+ / !

&"

&"'

 .! '

 + !

(( #  !98

&2"'

1:

!9&(

: &+(+ 1  &







!
20 (  ! +

& &"'

1 *0( + " !

'' (!

# '  +(;0

0"&"'

*(( 

!;0 +%+ /(+& &'#1!6$+% ! + %!+&( .! .+#0

( !

 &"'

-$ <$

+(!0  > 

!(1+ &" 

 -$  => )0& '

(?'  =- + + + &"0 0''& @ 0( +'(+   ,' &1

$ $ ,&  +0" !*+*

 $$=>
0  (?'  

$=>  $(

0+ / 

$=> .

'

?'  

-$=> 20 (

1+   +(;0

0" &"'

#1

(*0(0/ !



-

 "'(1  A 1

 B% "

 !+  "+(1 !

 # ?

# + +

&+ ( +

&0 !A 1

2"'

+

 +

& !)'

)& B% "

C"'(1 0($  + ! 9 0( :$ !

+

'

+  "+(1 &  0 !  + 0( + (+  # 0&  + ! (+/!

D0/"

A 4#( !30'"20 "#$%"
""&#
'&%"

()
*
+,,$
+,&-

),"&.
!/0

/$1$#0
   A *0( 0 ! ''+ ! 20 !

 D#  ! &  * ' +

#($ !

+# + 0 0( + #0&  E+ ! /  +%+ / (+& &$ &0 ( *0( /0 !

!6 *  !(+  +%+ / (+& & !+F+ / !+"  +% ! (+/!

"  %!+&($ !$ ! *  &"'

 +%  +&6!

* # + /A

>2>

 20 ( !&(

$ !&

 1$*0( /0 !

/ ( 1 *  $

(!

* /(1

6

 & +

&"    -$  => ' "

! A *0( 0 ! /0 !

 &(

 "

1 # ((* ;0

 &"'

 0  & %

( !  + ! (+/!

  D0/"

A ! 30'" 20  23-
""&#
'&%"

()
*
'
-
4
,',&'
-

),"&.
! /0

/$1$#0
555 .!+ '

 #!

('



 (+#+ /'

#1 &0 ( .!& * *6+ 2

(B0

"'(1 A 1

B% "

.!&(

?

"+

6!$&&0

2(6$

3%+&)+%++ $3 '

E> '% ( 1  A*0(' !

+ !"

!50(1 *  *+ ( 1  $

=>.!

+ ( 1 + #

6 +

& +

&"'0 /(' &1+ !(+/!

D0/"

 A ! 30'" 20  21$
$
1"&'
"#,$
&6&)
&6&)$.
/ !0
5
+


 )$#
'&%"
-67
($-$)"
1
$&
+&$1)1

),"&
!!

/0 
/$1$#0
5

.! .+#0

( !

 +/!

(1 ((* + &"  0 0 ''& $ 0& '

(?' 

'''+

"0( +'(+&&+ /(1$ (  ' &1 + & (&0(

- $ -$ => G - $ -$   $

? ? H  <$ $=>@ * 0 0''& >

 <$ $=> =- * '

(?' I  & %

( ! $ &(

 !

(( # 

(

<$=>+ !(+/!

D0/"

A !30'" 20 )$#
'&%"
-67
()
*
&7
+"),$

),"&.
!8
+
 8!

 +"9)$$
(:&

),"&
*
)$#
'&%"

()

),"&.

!
+
!5 %+* #%$

(&"'

+ -$-$ => .!+#+ / !20 &

1 *+ ! /  0&

 '

  "+(1  ! &  0( .!& * 1 (

+" &&0 &   ' 

"

6! E>$  +6  *+*  &  *   *+ /  ( 1

! 

   $ => + ! "

!  0/0  8 %+* 0( 0( $*+*  !

((#

(  ( 1 '+ 1  !

/  - 1   3+ & D#  ! &  * ' +

#($ ! 

+

 '

+ 0 0(    +  # 0&  " &"'

 #1 !+ 20   .!

+

&+ ( +

&+& (&0(

$$=>  $ =>? ? 

  %+*  #%$

( &"'

 '

&(

$  0& $$=>&"  $-$ 

#1

(+0& !?

 $ -$=>  -$ <$ =>>  $-$  =>.!?&

$+ ( 1'

+$ &(

 !

(( # &% #1 +

& &"'

1 #1 +(+

'''+

 ''(+&

#

( 3  &

1*+ !/ &"' &1  !6  +% ! %!+&( +  ;0   ! # +  +%+ / (+& & ' #1 !+"$ !+ &

 + "+& &+% *! ?

"+ + !(+/!

D0/"

A !30'"20 2':'
";3
1
&$")#
'&%"
-67
($-$)".
!8/80
+%#"
85. ! %!+&( +  ;0   (( 0 ! +   (+/!

 "  %!+&(0 3&   ! J!+&(& $  ! '' (

+' &&+ /(1 
  
.
!














/ <
2(0
9)B0(

+:


















E! !' 6+ /= 

1= E! !'

1=