Sukhwinder Kaur & ANR v. Ghansham & ORS
!
" ####$$ %% !" &
"" " ' !
####
!"# $%&'( #&% (# )%*'
!( ) # $&
' *+ , !
$$ %% !"# ) #!" .*+ , !
! #/# ) # ! ' *+ , !
) ###*+ , !
! #0# &+,-,)+./$ % ' !" + -% $$ % "
1 '
! - " ! " 23) !
,, !% '" 2 %* 1 24% !
! "5! 2 %67- ! - 1 !14% !
! "5! 67"2 -,% ' !8 $$ %% ! #/*- !
,% ' !"8 $$ %% !" #9 0 " -,% ' !"8 $$ %% !" #: ;* 0<#/9#9<<= 2 , "
- ! . " "--
23 ' 9>#/9#9<<= ' !
+ ,% ,, !! + 2
1
1"!
! # 8908 8/9>>4% !
! "5! -- 1+ ,% 67# 9# " ,% ' !"8 $$ %% !"
1
'
! - " ! * ! % - ,!" -! , "
2 1"$$ - "
+!3# 0# 2 % %% , '$ " ! - =*<0*<<<?8 ! ,% ' !"*, ", '$!
"- %% "(8
47 1 093
47 , '
;/<<$
' ! 47 /?0 - 47 ,!
" $
" -! 4;/<<8/=<<7A 0:<<
' ! 4+7 '$ " ! -!
$$%31'%!$%
-/B "$
1 -,% ' !" 40:<<C/9C/B7A B;9><< 4+7
% !
! ! 9;<<< 4+7 D "" -, "
!' 9;<<< 0
,+--
0
:#
, "
% - %% !" " ! ! ! " , !
,!
- 2 21 " %" ,
31 3 - '1 2" ""!
23
1:<*<<<?8$
' !# 2 % " ""
"' !%3, '
";/<<?8*," %
" # % -! - !"# #"- *' ,%
' !
2 " "" - !
* " %" % 1 $
" - =9 3
" ! 2 % " 1%3 ' ,! - /?0 ' " , '
! " $
""!
-/?:! "$
2"
+ ! " -$ @ !
!
!# 2 % " ! %% 3, '$ " ! !
,!" "
2"
+ ! " -$ @ !" # " #$%
!&
'( ) * + ,
!' & "
" ((- %" ! " % "" - % + ,! ,
1 , ' ,%
# 2 % " ! %% 3, '$ " ! ! "% "" - ,! -
!"+ - 2"
+ ! -$ @ ! , .
,
!& -
(- # ' ! - 9;*<<<?8 %% ", '$ " ! ! "% "" -, "
!'" %" %
" , %%" - '
! ! / % , " $
2"
+ ! " # / # ;#
, "
% -
! # 0 " ! ! ! 2 % " ""
, '
- ! " %3 1
"
+ "$ ,
! $ ! !! "
1 9;*<<<?8 " , !
,!
/;*<<<?8 - ' 3 - '1 2" ""#
" +1!"', -, '
"
E
! -% , '
! @
! 2! ",
! ", '
#) !%3, '
-;/<<?8! 23! 2 %- %3 1
! 3
9<<=" %" 1
" " '
! ''' 1 " $
", 2 23 ! ! !
- %3 1
"# '$ " ! %% 23 ! 2 % " ."!
" 2%
$1 + ! , @$
+ %1 !!
% + !!'
# B# '!!
%3* ,% ' !" + - % ! $ , 3 +
1, '
# + ", '
! ! " 1 -2 21 " %" +12" "" - 3 - '1#
8,% ' ! #/ %
1 "
F80 ""! !
! !! " !' ! 1 32 ,, ! " %" ! $ 31 3 , '
! @# ! 3
$% ' -2 21# " !' ! 1 3
1" , '
'"2" "" -2 21 3- '1# =# ! 2"
- 3 +
1 2" "" - 3 '1* ! 2 % " 1!%3 ""
, '
- ! " ;/<<?8$
' ! ! 1 ' " %3 1
# " $
'
"% 23$ @ ! / * ,! -/?:!"!
' ', '
! "$
" " - !" " , '
# ) ,%
%" !!% ! " ! - / % , ! " % "" - % + -- ,! ,
1 , % $
!!% ! , '$ " ! - "'% ' ! ! "% "" - ,! # '$ " ! ! - "9;*<<<?8! "% "" -, "
!'" %" ! / % ,# " $
2"
+ ! " - $ @ ! " # / ) * + / *,% ' !"
%" !!% ! ;<G ! , '
!
,!"* "093
" - # ># ,, ! !" , "
! $% , 9>#/9#9<<=# "$! % 0<#/9#9<<=#% ' !" + "! !
! ! 9<<<?8
"$ ! !
! ! # 2 % " ! %% 3 " ! - '
, % " " - !!
!#-!
,, !* " - "! 2 1! ! +% "$! %* 1 2 '
" 2 1! ! * 1 ! 1 ! +% "$! %* 1 2*
",,'2 ! . " 0<#/9#9<<=# F% ! 1! $ ! !- ' $% , ! !
$% , *,% ' !" + %" "--
" !
! ! # 1* + "2 1!
1 '
, % " 2!
$1 + ! - ,! ! !
' '!!
"$! % -
3" " "-!
' "$! % ! !
"$! %* %'$ "' ' ! - 9<*<<<?8 " ! " , '$ " ! - '
, % "* !
! ! , "
" - !!
!# H# + - '3 2 + ","" * ' ! - , '$ " ! 2% ! ,% ' !""
"- %% "(8
47 1 - 1 !14 7 093
47 , '
;/<<$
' !4 " 23! 2 %7 47 /?:! -47 ,!
"$
" -! ;/<<8/9=;A0>9;
' ! 4+7 ;<G -47! 2 !
,!" 0>9;I/H/0A ;=0> 4+7 '$ " ! -!
'%!$%
-/B" $$% 4;=0>C/9C/B7A //</BHB 4+7 D "" -, "
!' /<<<<< 4+7 D "" -% + ,! ,
1 , ' ,%
/<<<<< 4+7 D "" - ,! -
/<<<<< 4@7 '$ " ! - -
% 9;<<< 9<<<< 4@7 '$ " ! - '
, % "* ! ! , " !!
! , "
,+--
/<# " "
E % - '3 2 + ","" * ! % " ,, $!
# -! 2 %"' - , '$ " ! %% ! ,% ' !" " ' =*<0*<<<?8 ! /:*:B*=<<?8# ' ! - " ! %%,
3!
"!J=#;G$
'- '! !
--%1 -,% '$ !! !%% ,! %
%K ! #
! #02 1"
-- 1+ ,% %% $ "!! "
-,% ' !"8 $$ %% !"! 2 ,, !" $ 3 ! " '
1 ' -!"# "
- ,% ' !8 $$ %% ! # 0* " ' * %% 2 $ "!
" '
! %K 2 "-@ $ "!!%%!
!! "' .
!3#!"*
*' ,%
! !! 2 ' 3! ,'
1 1 ' "
E
!! !'
- $ "! -! ' ! " %% !2
" ! 2 1!
"
'! 2 %! 1 !! $ 3'
! -! ' ! $ "!
" '
-!
!
-" !! 1' .
!3# 2 +
,! " 2
"" ! " + ,% ' ! - ' 3 ""'
! , "
!
,! "* ! 2 " %%3 1+ ! 2 1 !
- 2 % ! 1 ! ! $ 3'
! -!
!! 1 ! 1 - ' .
!3# % ' ! # /8
* 2 1 ' !
! % -' ,% ' !" %%2 !!% ! 1 !!
"! ! "
' " $ "!
!2 * ' !%3*E
%3* %-3
%3 % 2 ""* "$
, + ! '
! " -"2 1!$# "
%
" ""
!9<*<<<?8# +2+
/
&% (# )%*' . $%)# F
"$ 1?
" "? F
! 2% "?