High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18366/2025dismissed

Surajmal And Others v. Commissioner, Rohtak Division, Rohtak And Others

2025-07-22Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger18 pages

!#$% (%)*+*&,

- .-

/01#23#4 &$5%1+

------ %$*$*&,%1+ 6%1+0+ &33*++*&,%17

&5$#8 !*9*+*&,7

&5$#8 &$5%1+

------

%+:&,(%,$+ ; < -

/ /

1%+%,$ 1- /0+5*4 /5%&1#,7 (9&)#$%

'&1 :%$*$*&,%1+-

+- :#+#,# !5#=#,7 #1>#,#-

- - /

- 1#>%1 *,+$#,$ )*9*4 =1*$ :%$*$*&, '*4%( 0,(%1 1$*)4%+ .

&,+$*$0$*&, ,(*#7 *,$%1 #4*#7 '&1 *++0#,)% # =1*$ ,#$01% )%1$*&1#1* '&1 +%$$*,?

#+*(% &1(%1 (#$%( .- -

,,%@01% 7 :#++%( &33*++*&,%17

&5$#8 !*9*+*&,7

&5$#8

+5&1$ ;!*9*+*&,#4 &33*++*&,%1;7 =5%1%A> :%$*$*&,%1+ 5#9% A%%, %9*)$%( '1&3 4#,( B0%+$*&,-

- 1*%'4>7 :%$*$*&,%1+ )4#*3 A% $%,#,$+ &, 4#,( 3%#+01*,?

C#,#4

#14#7 )&3:1*+%( C5#+1# &- 7 7 +*$0#$%( 9*44#?% /03(# C5%1#7 !*+$1*)$ 5*=#,*7 &, A#+*+ 1( )1&:

+5#1*,?

A#$#*-

&,)%(%(4>7 #'&1%+#*( 4#,( B0%+$*&, &=,%1+5*:

1%+:&,(%,$+ &-

5%1%*,-

%+:&,(%,$+ &-

5%1%*, '*4%( #, #::4*)#$*&, 0,(%1 /%)$*&,

* 0,2#A /%)01*$> <#,( %,01%+ )$7

+5&1$ ; )$;7 )4#*3*,?

1( )1&:

+5#1*,?

A#$#* '&1 )1&:+ C5#1*'

0:$&

#A*

7 =5*)5 =#+ )#4)04#$%(

+- 7.

- 5% #'&1%+#*( #::4*)#$*&, =#+ '*4%(

&13 ;<;

,,%@01% 0,(%1 )$7 =5%1%*, %2%)$3%,$ =#+ +&0?5$ &, '&44&=*,?

?1&0,(+

! !

# $

' % ( % ' '

)

* '

, - , #'&1%+#*( #::4*)#$*&, '*4%( 1%+:&,(%,$+ &-

5%1%*,7 :%$*$*&,%1+ =%1% +033&,%( $5%> +0A3*$$%( $5%*1 1%:4>-

$ ,&$*)%#A4% $5#$ )&:> 1%:4> '*4%( &, A%5#4'

:%$*$*&,%1+ ,&$ #$$#)5%( =*$5 *,+$#,$ =1*$ :%$*$*&,-

- $ $1#,+:*1%+ $5#$ 4%#1,%( ++*+$#,$ &44%)$&1 +$ 1#(%7 5*=#,*

+5&1$ ;++*+$#,$ &44%)$&1;7 9*(% &1(%1 (#$%( - -

,,%@01% 7 5#( (*1%)$%( :%$*$*&,%1+ 5%1%*, (%:&+*$ # +03

+- 7.

)4#*3%( 1%+:&,(%,$+ &-

5%1%*,4#,( &=,%1+E 5&=%9%17 =*$5&0$ *,$%1%+$7 =*$5*,

(#>+-

- 5% :%$*$*&,%1+ 5%1%*, #1% +$#$%( 5#9% :#*( +#*( #3&0,$

+- 7.

&, - - -

%%4*,?

#??1*%9%( #?#*,+$ &1(%1 (#$%( - -

,,%@01% 7 :#++%( ++*+$#,$ &44%)$&1 )&,)%1,%(7 1%+:&,(%,$+ &-

5%1%*, :1%'%11%( #, #::%#4 A%'&1% &44%)$&17 5*=#,*

+5&1$ ;&44%)$&1;7 5&=%9%17 +#3% =#+ (*+3*++%(7 9*(% &1(%1 (#$%( - -

,,%@01% - - /$*44 #??1*%9%(7 1%+:&,(%,$+ &-

5%1%*, :1%'%11%( # 1%9*+*&, :%$*$*&, 0,(%1 /%)$*&, )$7 =5*)5 )#3% A% #44&=%( 4%#1,%( !*9*+*&,#4 &33*++*&,%17 9*(% &1(%1 (#$%( .- -

,,%@01% :%$*$*&,%1+ =%1% &1(%1%( A% %9*)$%( 5&4(*,?

$5#$ :%$*$*&,%1+ 5#( '#*4%( :#> 1%,$ 1%?04#14> =*$5&0$ #,> +0''*)*%,$ )#0+%- - , #'&1%3%,$*&,%( )*1)03+$#,)%+7 :%$*$*&,%1+ 5#9% '*4%( *,+$#,$ )*9*4 =1*$ :%$*$*&, A%'&1% $5*+ &01$7 '&1 1%4*%'

+7 ,&$*)%( 5%1%*,#A&9%-

- <%#1,%( )&0,+%4 '&1 :%$*$*&,%1+ +0A3*$$%( $5#$ :%$*$*&,%1+ 5%1%*, 5#( A%%, :#>*,?

1%,$ 1%?04#14> $5&0?5 #3&0,$ )4#*3%( 1%+:&,(%,$+ &-

=#+ #1A*$1#1> ,&$ (0%7 %9%, $5%, )4#*3%( #3&0,$

+-7.

5#+ A%%, (04> :#*( :%$*$*&,%1+ 5%1%*,7 (*1%)$%( 9*(% &1(%1 (#$%( - -

,,%@01% 7 :#++%( ++*+$#,$ &44%)$&1 )&,)%1,%(7 =5*4% %@%1)*+*,?

5*+ :&=%1+ 0,(%1 :1&9*+& /%)$*&,

* )$E $5%1%'&1%7 $5%> )#,,&$ A% %9*)$%(-

%4*#,)% :4#)%( 0:&,

"# $%&' (#,( % %)

+ *$5 #'&1%3%,$*&,%( +0A3*++*&,+7 *$ :1#>%( $5#$ *3:0?,%( &1(%1 (#$%( .- -

,,%@01% 7 :#++%( 4%#1,%( !*9*+*&,#4 &33*++*&,%17 A% +%$ #+*(%-

%#1(- -

%1% *$ =&04( A% #::&+*$% 1%'%1 /%)$*&, ** /%)$*&,

* )$

#::4*)#A4% #1>#,#7 =5*)5 1%#( 0,(%1 -.

'/ 0 ' "

' 1

3 " ' / +

++++++++++++

4- # 5 / %

' "

'/%

)1 6 "

% /

" %

' !

" %

" 8

" 5 / ' "

99: ;<3 99:

" '

"' '

)"1 6 "

" '/, -

, ,-

*9*4 E # !*9*+*&, %,)5 $5*+ &01$ 5%4( $5#$ :1&9*+& /%)$*&, * )$ 3%#,$ +#9% ?%,0*,% $%,#,$ '1&3 %9*)$*&, )#+%+ =5%1% 1%,$ 5#+ ,&$ A%%, :#*( *,#(9%1$%,$4> &1 (0% 1%#+&,+ A%>&,( 5*+ )&,$1&4 ,&$ '&1 (%,>*,?

1%,$ 4#,(4&1(- 5% 1%4%9#,$ %@$1#)$ '*,(*,?+ 1%#( 0,(%1 > ?%" ' %

& #

' %

% % %

& #

@ -5%

= ' '

)6 1 6

' '

) 6 "

" '% - :

)

A9B

9 3

" =

' ' '%

8 ( =

=" " "

C, .- &3*,?

)#+% 5#,(7 1%+:&,(%,$+ &-

5%1%*, +&0?5$ %9*)$*&, :%$*$*&,%1+ 5%1%*, '*4*,?

#, #::4*)#$*&,

&13 ;<;

,,%@01% 7 *,$%1 #4*#7 &, :4%# $5#$ :%$*$*&,%1+ 5%1%*, 5#( '#*4%( :#> 1%,$ 1%?04#14> =*$5&0$ +0''*)*%,$ )#0+%-

, #'&1%+#*( #::4*)#$*&,7 '&44&=*,?

#9%13%,$+ =%1% 3#(% :#1#+ .

0 = D

E "!9" E #>":7

% :

E #>":7F'

, .- 4$5&0?57 :%$*$*&,%1+ 5%1%*, 5#9% ,&$ #$$#)5%( )&:> 1%:4> '*4%( &, $5%*1 A%5#4'

%2%)$3%,$ :%$*$*&,7 5&=%9%17 *$ )&,)%(%( 4%#1,%( )&0,+%4 '&1 :%$*$*&,%1+ $5#$ :%$*$*&,%1+ (*( ,&$ (*+:0$%

#3&0,$ )4#*3%( 1%+:&,(%,$+ &-

:#1#+ .7 %@$1#)$%( #A&9%-

.- 9*(%,$4>7 ++*+$#,$ &44%)$&1 )&,)%1,%(7 9*(% &1(%1 (#$%( - -

,,%@01% 7 (*1%)$%( :%$*$*&,%1+ 5%1%*, (%:&+*$ #3&0,$

+- 7.

)4#*3%( 4#,( &=,%1+E 5&=%9%17 =*$5&0$ *,$%1%+$7 =*$5*,

(#>+7 &A+%19*,?

0,(%1 3 % ' + 2 +

' "

' 7#

> *

7 G

FF "

& " D " &2 )

&) H % !F# "

&) = E

* " = * 5

2 ) % % F#

* " % E & "

& ? ?

D '

0 = D 5

7 7# %

7E '

F " '

E #>":7F "

( "

77, .- 5% #'&1%+#*( &1(%1 (#$%( - -

,,%@01% =#+ #''*13%( #::%44#$% #0$5&1*$>-

$ $50+ #::#1%,$ '1&3 &1(%1 (#$%( - -

,,%@01% 7 :#++%( ++*+$#,$ &44%)$&1 )&,)%1,%( $5#$ :%$*$*&,%1+ 5%1%*, 5#( ,&$ :#*( (0% 1%,$ '&1 )1&:+ C5#1*'

0:$&

#A*

7 $5%1%'&1%7 $5%*1

:%$*$*&,%1+; )&,$%,$*&, $5#$ $5%> 5#( A%%, :#>*,?

1%,$ 1%?04#14> +$#,(+ '#4+*'*%(-

.- 5% +0A3*++*&, 1#*+%( &, A%5#4'

:%$*$*&,%1+ 5%1%*, $5#$ #++%++3%,$ 1%,$ 3#(% 4#,( &=,%1+ =#+ #1A*$1#1>E #4+& '&0,( A% =*$5&0$ #,> 3%1*$7 9*%= +$#,( $#8%, 4%#1,%( )&0,+%4 '&1 :%$*$*&,%1+ 5%1%*, $5#$ #3&0,$ )4#*3%( 4#,( &=,%1+ :#1#+ .

%@$1#)$%( #A&9% *-%-

+- 7.

7 =#+ ,%9%1 (*+:0$%( :%$*$*&,%1+-

+ 1%?#1(+ )&,$%,$*&, :%$*$*&,%1+ 5%1%*, $5#$ $5%> 5#( (04> :#*( #3&0,$

+- 7.

=*$5&0$ *,$%1%+$ =*$5*,

(#>+7 (*1%)$%( ++*+$#,$ &44%)$&1 )&,)%1,%(7 9*(% &1(%1 (#$%( - -

,,%@01% 7 =5*4% %@%1)*+*,?

5*+ :&=%1+ 0,(%1 :1&9*+& /%)$*&,

* )$7 +0''*)% *$ +#> $5#$ ++*+$#,$ &44%)$&1 )&,)%1,%( 5#( =1&,?4> %@%1)*+%( 5*+ :&=%1+ :%)04*#1 '#)$+ )*1)03+$#,)%+ $5*+ )#+% +#> +& '&1 1%#+&, $5#$ 4#= 1%?#1(+ %9*)$*&,

&13 ;<;

0,(%1 )$ =%44 +%$$4%( #

%,)5 $5*+ &01$ )#+% ;0/1

./ ,'#23+(E =5%1%*, &,;A4%

%,)5 $5*+ &01$ =#+ (%#4*,?

=*$5 # =1*$ :%$*$*&, #?#*,+$ #, &1(%1 :#++%(

*,#,)*#4 &33*++*&,%1 5&4(*,?

$5#$ &1(%1 %2%)$3%,$ )&04( ,&$ A% :#++%(

=*$5&0$ #''&1(*,?

'1%+5 &::&1$0,*$> $%,#,$+ 3#8% :#>3%,$ #11%#1+ 1%,$7 %,$*1% 1%,$ (%3#,(%( 4#,(4&1( =#+ ,&$ (0% $5&0?5 #11%#1+ 1%,$ '&1 +&3% 5#19%+$+ =%1% :#>#A4%- 5% 4%?#4*$> &1(%1 :#++%(

*,#,)*#4 &33*++*&,%1 =#+ )5#44%,?%(7 *,$%1#4*#7 &, '&44&=*,?

?1&0,( +

1I0I

' & #

! "' "

' "

)" E% "

% %

% /

'/'

' +

' '

% ' ' '

% / .- &,;A4%

%,)5 $5*+ &01$ 0/1

, )#+%

+0:1#7 5%4( 0,(%1 : '%

"E 1I0I '

)"336 " '

' "

)"33 6 "'

" " E%

'"+

' '

3 %

H & I

' +

' = % '

)"336

'/ "

& "

&& * I

" "

)"336 " /

' 1I0I

+ 9 3 % '%

% ')"

1' " :

+ 1

% =

C, .-.

$ )&+$ 1%:%$*$*&,7*, ,-

1%,$ 4#,(4&1(- - , $5*+ )#+%7 :%$*$*&,%1+ 5%1%*, 5#( ,&$ (*+:0$%( #3&0,$

+-7.

)4#*3%( 4#,( &=,%1+

1%+:&,(%,$+ &-

5%1%*, ,%*$5%1 #,> %9*(%,)% 5#+ A%%, :4#)%( &, 1%)&1( :%$*$*&,%1+ 5%1%*, +5&= $5#$ $5%> 5#( A%%, 1%?04#14> :#>*,?

1%,$-

#$5%17 ++*+$#,$ &44%)$&1 )&,)%1,%( 5#( ,&$ 1%$01,%( #,> '*,(*,?

$5#$ :%$*$*&,%1+ 5%1%*, =%1% :1%9%,$%( '1&3 :#>*,?

(0% 1%,$ '&1 #,> 20+$*'*#A4% 1%#+&,-

01$5%13&1%7 %9%, *'

++*+$#,$ &44%)$&1 )&,)%1,%( =#+ %@%1)*+% 5*+ :&=%1+ 0,(%1 :1&9*+& /%)$*&,

* )$

#((%( )$ '&1 /$#$% #1>#,# >%#1 7 $5#$ %9%,$0#4*$>7 $%,#,$+ =%1% 1%B0*1%( :#> #11%#1+ #4&,?=*$5 *,$%1%+$ A% )#4)04#$%( ++*+$#,$ &44%)$&1 )&,)%1,%( #$ 1#$% F :%1 #,,03 &, +0)5 #11%#1+ $&?%$5%1 =*$5 )&+$+ #::4*)#$*&,-

&$ &,4> $5#$7 )#4)04#$%( #3&0,$ =#+ A% :#*( %*$5%1 &, '*1+$ 5%#1*,?

&1 =*$5*,

(#>+ '1&3 (#$% +0)5 5%#1*,?E +& #9&*( %9*)$*&,-

01$5%13&1%7 ++*+$#,$ &44%)$&1 )&,)%1,%( 5#( :#++%( '*,#4 &1(%1 &, - -

,,%@01% # 9%1> )#+0#4 '#+5*&, #+8*,?

:%$*$*&,%1+ 5%1%*, (%:&+*$ # +03

+- 7.

)4#*3%( 4#,( &=,%1+ $5#$ $&& =*$5&0$ *,$%1%+$ $5#$ #4+& A% :#*(

=*$5*,

(#>+-

5% +#*( (*1%)$*&, *++0%( ++*+$#,$ &44%)$&1 )&,)%1,%(7 9*(% &1(%1 (#$%( - -

,,%@01% 7 *$+%4'

)&,$1#1> :1&9*+& /%)$*&,

* )$-

1(%1 (#$%( - -

,,%@01% 7 :#++%( ++*+$#,$ &44%)$&1 =#+ =1&,?4> 0:5%4( 4%#1,%( &44%)$&17 5*=#,*7 5&=%9%17 &, # 1%9*+*&, :%$*$*&, A%*,?

'*4%( 4#,( &=,%1+7 4%#1,%( !*9*+*&,#4 &33*++*&,%1 5#+ +%$ #+*(% &1(%1+ (#$%( - - - -

,,%@01% ,,%@01% 7 1%+:%)$*9%4>7 :#++%( ++*+$#,$ &44%)$&1 =%44 4%#1,%( &44%)$&1 #44&=%( %2%)$3%,$ :%$*$*&,7 '*4%( 4#,( &=,%1+

1%+:&,(%,$+ &-

5%1%*,7 5&4(*,?

0,(%1 3 %

3 " 3 % + '

' ' "3

7E '

#77? " '%

& #

5 / '& .

9B " 9B

" %

' " '

77!

')" 7

'&' %

(

) %

)" 1 6 "H

' =" "'

, -

+ 1%?#1(+ 20(?3%,$+ 1%'%11%( 4%#1,%( )&0,+%4 '&1 :%$*$*&,%1+7 *$ ,&$*)%#A4% $5#$

7 '#)$+ $5#$ )#+% =%1% %@$1#)$%( :#1# 20(?3%,$7 =5*)5 1%#(+ $50+ !

' %

% '

% & ' "

= '

. 77F /

.>777F

)3 6 "

77"

' H

A.>777F & '

E '

!"/

- '$%1 )&,+*(%1*,?

3#$$%17 !*9*+*&, %,)5 $5*+ )&01$ &A+%19%( $5#$ $5%1% =#+ # (*+:0$% 1%?#1(*,?

1#$% 1%,$ $5&+% )*1)03+$#,)%+7 5%4( 0,(%1 7 " '%%

' ?

" '

) 3 6

' '

)A9B

'%" " I

A.77F "

" '

'/ &

' +)

E /* %1

)

"5 / '"97 !

&)) 93

' "

A.77F

' I

.>"777F

" "

" ' %

)" && % % & "779 5.E 7!" +

& #

)

+ "

C, - 50+7 =*$5 #44 503*4*$>7 20(?3%,$ )#+%

(*+$*,?0*+5#A4% &, '#)$+ =&04( ,&$ #::4> '#)$+ $5*+ )#+%- -

01$5%17 20(?3%,$ )#+% !

"# $%&' (E =#+ :#++%( =5*4% )&,+*(%1*,?

20(?3%,$ :#++%( 4%#1,%( +*,?4% 20(?% $5*+ )&01$ *

"% +(

&E #4$5&0?5 +#*( 20(?3%,$ *

4 /$ 5#( #41%#(> A%%, +%$ #+*(% <%$$%1+ #$%,$ ::%#4

< #1*+*,?

&0$ +#*( )#+% % %)

+7 &A+%19*,?

0,(%1

'%%

& #

)

' "+ '

" % %

' %

' 8 3

" % " % '

+ /

) 6

( = /

' %

"' % " "

' ) 6 )

)

8 !&'

8 " "

8 "'

% = '

% J%

" = "

' %J%

) '

% % "

' " %

% # '

' % "

8 '

/ ' %

% % =

% =

" "

' '

( ) 6 % ' "

%' %

" %'

' )"'"

= "

> %

% =% % " &'

' " % '' =%

% "= / "'=

: =%

= %

= % '' "

' C, - & &$5%1 :&*,$ 5#+ A%%, 1#*+%(- -

, 9*%= #A&9% #'$%1 )&,+*(%1*,?

$&$#4*$> )*1)03+$#,)%+7 '*,( ,& )&3:%44*,?

1%#+&, *,$%1'%1% *3:0?,%( &1(%1-

%+04$#,$4>7 *,+$#,$ )*9*4 =1*$ :%$*$*&, '#*4+ +#3% #))&1(*,?4> (*+3*++%(-

- %,(*,?

#::4*)#$*&,

+7 *'

#,>7 +5#44 #4+& +$#,( )4&+%(-

- .-

+28+*3#,* 5%$5%1 +:%#8*,?1%#+&,%(

"%+

& 5%$5%1 1%:&1$#A4% "%+