High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2537/2015allowed

Bangarpet Gundappa And ANR v. Vimlesh Kumar And ORS

2024-05-07Mrs. Justice Archana Puri11 pages

"#$ %& $'()(%* "+ ,

-. /0 /

! % &' ! !

( )))) , 0 * +

,-,../,0 $(

!! * 1$ +$( + '! !!

!! +!

2 ! &//3./,, 4 " !

$ !

( !

! !! 5

6 708.0//9' :7/;

" !

< + 1 $( " + $ #

" " !

$( !

( ! $ 6 " 7/;

5 !

'! " 1 "! $ ! "

+ '

1 &//3./,, 2 !

> + $!2

= $ $

,.,7 ?( @',/ ! $ $(

< +

" ! > ( ! #

A @',/ ! $( +

$ % ?'77'/B,0 +! + + ( 2

$( ! +

+ ( ""! +

( 2

! " !

"" ! $!2 ( " ! + 6 (

2 + " 2 # ?

? $ "" ! ?'77'/B,0 @ ! ! ! !! 2 !

+ 2 "" ! $( % ,' =@ + !! 5 1 ! + "

$( @ ( % , .

"" ! $ 2 ( $#! + ! " ! (

!! !

" % , ( ( "

" ! A2+ % &' ! ( + $ 2 ( $#!

"! " !! ( "

" ! $ "! " !! ! 6 >'0 2 + "" 6>09 ?

! + ! " '!

" =@ ! = "

(

+ $ 6 >'7 $

+ $ 6 4 !

(

! ! + $( ?

+ ! !

( " ! !( 6. ! ! $"

" % & * ! $

$!2

+ 2 " ! ! $ 2 + 2 ! 2 ! 2 $

$ ! 2 $

! !

! !! 2 ! !!

" !

( ! % ,'

" 7/ 7/ @ +

( ! !

+ "

! "

+ $( $ ( $ ? A !

( $ 80-7/9' +! + 2

,/,-0//9' " 2 $

" ,33&B9' + !

6 $( >'& $ ? A ! '6 "

" ./83;

" ( 6 + + 2

&,-,.&9' " 2

" 7/;

" ( + + 2

,./--3B-& " 2

6 " 7/;

" 6 $

!( " ! + 2 B/0-880 + ( " C,8D !

+ + 2

,/88-3-,. "

" .7///9' + + + "

6 " 7////9'

" " ""! @ !

+ + 2

,/-B03-,. =

+ 2

6 " 7/;

" !

( !

'! +

708.&-7B +! +

"" 708.0//9' ! $ " ! $

(

( " " !

( ! " @ $ !! 2 ! ,.,7 1

+ 2

+( +

2 ( ! + 2 " ! "

$ ( ! !!

! $ !

$ ! " !

( ! 1 $ $+ $

( "

" 7/ 7/

$ ( " ! !

$ + @',/ ! " !! $ ! !2 (

" $!2 ""! ( 2 ( + !! + !

=@ 2 #

" !!

" ! $

"! " @',/ !2

" $!2 ( $ $

( 2 " "! !"! ! " '! $

( $

! ! $ C D + 2

@ 2 "! ( "

! ! " % , . 1 ! !

( ! 2 $( % , + 2 ! 1 + !( !

" ,/- ,&8 " *

! +! $

! $( + @ ,7 "

,-8- ( " ! 2 ( 5 2 ! ! +(

2( ! $

" " 2 ! $( ( $

2 2 2 ! ! ! $ 2 5 $( $ !! 2 ! +( + ! "

= $

1 ! ! !

! $ 2 $( % , + 2

"( " 2 " !

C D 2 @ !!

"( !

" *

" ! " % , + 2

% , + $ +

6 + ( ! $ 2 $ + ! +( " + $ 6 % ! " ! 2 + ( $ !

( ! ! +! ( !

$ $ + > $( ! ( ! +! !

! 5 !2( 6! "

( ! " ! +( + +! $"

" + $ $ +(

""!

( @ "! " !

$( 2 6 ( !

" !

@ ! !!

2 ! 1 " ! !

$ $

+ !! 2 ! $ + 1 !! 2 ! +( 1

" '

" ! $

$ !

( $ ! +( +( ! "

$ 2

2 ! @ !!

! !

! $ !!

+ ! !

! !:

< +! + ( ! $ $

( !

6 ! ! ( !

( > "! " "+ !

( $ $ !2( "!

$ 2 1

( ( !

( ! !

( + + "

+ 2

! ! +

2 ! * "

"! ( ! $ !

+ !

( !

+ '" ! @ !!

! " !

$( + $ !

( ! "

" 7/; $( @ $!2 !

'! (

! #

+ 2

1 ! "

" " "

" "

+ $(

$ ? A $ 6 >'& +

$ " !

$ + 2 ? 67

+ ( !"! +! 6& (

80-7/9' $2'

+ " $

! $( 1$ % ,7 " + * $ !

+ 2

$ ,/,-0//9' = " " !

6 !

$ 2 A +

$ $ " ! '6 " >'& +

,33&B9' + + !

6 " ./83;

" ( + + 6 6 + &,-,.&9' " 2

" !

+ + 2

,./--3B8& ?

" 6 1

>'& ! '6

6 " ,33&B9' + + !

6 $ !

+ 6

" @

!"## "

! $ !

6 $ 6 $ " !! !

,8////9' + 6 " = !

$!2 " ,8////'

7/////9' !

6 ($ + ,/; +! 6 &.///9' = "

$!2 " 7/////'8///// 6 ($ + ./; B////9' 1 ! $!2 " 8/////9' $ 6 ($ + &/; ! !

+ 2

+ ,/,-0//9' "

8/////9'

+ 2

$ .,-0//9'

6 ($ E &/; !

$ B78./9' 1 6 ($ !

$ )0 , ,12 " 2

" 6

+ 2

!( !

$ ,/,-0//',738./F8B,78/9'

" C"

!D $ 7/; $ +

$ .- ( + 2 $ "

,/,.,-8, "

! !"! !

(

$ 6 0/; +! 6 " &00B&.9' 1 !

+ 2

$ 8B,78/G&00B&.F,./B.,.9' ( + *

/3#0/"45"

6$43"

7)0 $58( 4"*)9%4# %49%4"#(%* "*:

"*40,

(7(5!

" C 6D

$ 7/; 1 2

!( !

$ ,./B.,.'B/&,/BFB/&,/B9' * %

$ $ C

D " ! " !( + 2

$ B/&,/B6,3F)0 ,,,12 "

$ '! A + + 2 !

.7///9'

6D 7////9' + + + C "

""! D ?

+ +

! "

$( *

" C " !

D C " D

6D !

+ 5 $ 6 0////9' ,7///9' ,7///9' ! ( ?

+ + ! ! " ,/; " ( ( " #

$ )01,2, )0 1, 2 )0 1, 2 ! ( ?

+ &'( ) #* #

+ +" , & + C " !

D ( !

+ 9! ( 5 CD C

D C" !

* /3#0/"45"

6$43"

7)0 $58( 4"*)9%4# %49%4"#(%* "*:

"*40,

(7(5!

$ '! +

" 080//9' ! "

C " !

D * !

($ '

! !!

.%)) %& :$9$*:$*'+ )0 ,,,12 .%)) %& '%*)%4#(;3 )0 ,12 .%)) %& $)#"#$ )0 1, 2 ;*$4"5 $<9$*)$) )0 1, 2 %#"5 )0 , ,1, 2 ! ! "

+ $( 1$ !

$ )0 , ,1, ,1,=)0 , ,2 4 !

" !

)0 , ,2 '! $ " B; " " " " H " !

" !

1 $( ( $ # " @ + " "

+ "+ ,

> 29

$) > $ $)2 %