← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1534/2016dismissed

Shri Ram General Insurance Company Limited v. Shanti Lal And ORS

2016-05-05Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan10 pages

 

       

 

  

    

    !"

"""# $

    ! """

!"  #$  %  %%

%

" &'#!'  (

   " ))) *# +, +* *-."

/      0   !  0        



   !1

 #2!!!""

!0   # !    / 0

 03!#&  1+14  54 6 / 0

5  20  

      "7789:  2  2!!    +" 

!    !'  '   !  "7";"

/  !!      "7";

0 ;"    !' 1!7 2 1 1  ! ! <!/: <

 !=0 1

+"%<::<:80 1! ' 0 = " >  !! /: =:  ! ! <!

!!   1 ?+"*:@:#:@ 1 !  

1 1 

 !   

2 0     !!"*!

    !' 2 

'0 ? !! ! "

/! '!'22  ? 0  = 

!1  

0 "  %  0!  2   !    '   *    ="      A   +";  !!

"7"; 

!     87  BB8  B;:#  %  2  1 !   %    =    = "

    2  !" 2 !! !  !

  1 1 ! '

1 ?0 +"

"  +" !8(! ' !2   ? !& 2    !! ! '' '    ! "# (

    ! 2   

10& 

 : ! ' 1 ?2  !

1' ! ! '! '

1   2 0 1 !2  ' !

1     !   

             "   / 



      ! !     !    !  1!  

 02     ! +" !8" !

  2 1

2!

:

D   

                      

    

 !" # $"  %&  '

 

( )*++  '     '  

  

  

            

 ,  ,        )*++ $   '

  

              

   

 )*+ $

 '

 

       

 '

&)*+ $

 !

 -    ' ! / 0

! !!

+"

'   !2!!

 

! :

%& '()*+,(-.

./01 -0 * "

4

5 89:

"

#!!E  B9:F@9:

B"

!

  G4 :5 ;9:

;"

   !4

 3!5 7

"

   @ "

!  789:

8"

H

9:

 $ 232435"

/

   ( 2 ! 0 

  "

'! !"

  !1  1 !

2 

 " !"



0 ! : 2 ' ! !'

1 1  ! '  1 ? ! !2

!  1 ! "9:             E       2!

      ! 02!   !     !' 0 2! ' 21  ! !" /'

+"1!

1  1 1 ! '

1  1 ? = 4 >5 2 

 ! !

 ' !  !' ,H"

>9#2  ! !   ! 12 ! !2 1 1  ! !  <!/ <

 !?

1 0 1! '

 0  !! !2     !"> !/  =  ! ! <!

!!  1 ?0 ! ' 0 +"  1 1   ?1

!

2 ! !!2 ! !

! 1 ? !! ! "*   ! !! ' ?!2 0 42 

!1  

0 ?"  / 2 

   

! ! ?!

  1 1 ! '

1  1 ?"/ 2 

 '!1   A 4,H"

B5  ! ! !4,H"

;5"   / (

  ! ' ! 0 ' ! 1 ' 0   

+""

     

   !" 

      1:

  2  ' 

0 !  0    I

1    

0

!!"

 2:

!I    # /  

  1     "/*  6/*/.$(1( (0)17'&*8*%(19-&(0)17'&*3  

-8-, 42 % 2 

1    ! !  0 '!   1 !      I ! '    I !0!     "  0



! 

? !

   !" 

 ! 

!0  '    

 0

0    0  !   0      "   /     2     0        ! 00  "/

 !!0 ! 0! 0 ! '0  !"

 #!

1 1/ 0

 

  1 1 ! '

1 1 ?0 +"  !" / ' ! ! 1 = 4 >B5 2 /' 9# <

 !=2! !2

2?

1 2 ! !0/ 0

2 2?

1     !  1 1   "9:          "   *  H !   "@9:2   2?

1@"@" ";9: 20 1 !2?

1@"""

 12 

     !

 

:1 3!   

     

  



 * 

!



:1 3! ! 1 2 0



0H!!

!  '  "

    2 1!  H0  H

'0 



 2 1

!      0!' 2  !  ' ! 

"/ ' 22 2!0 *   "

#   

  

$

 % &32 0 '

1

! :

'( . ''    ''      %  ,'%&    % 

 /. 0  ,    

 

$!'         '  &

  % 

 1 





             %        

           %    2'  

'   '  & 1

 ,

   0 ,        ''

  

&   (   #  1 0  ,    34(00''  $,'

 $ !5 6$1  ,  '  ''   

  % $!&     /  

     !'  

   .   %&.%  

$

&  '  



 %  

 ' 7&  ,  '

&. '    % 8

 .% ,  1 0 '

&  ,  

 '' %

    '    

  .

,   

.%     

  

    &   % 

 $' (  &, ''   / 

  

,  2' '  &

 &       %         1  

%

&    &   %&  , ,



' ,.%     '  

                              ,.%    ' 

          % 

 ''

      1 '  



  1  ,     2 %       &   ,.%  &  ' 

   &  '       '

%   %&          /,     &     

  '   '



 !1' , ''   /  



      

  ,



  %  %  !' &  

!' 1 ,    %     ,  

,            

   .%              &   

 

''       !     $  '     , 

, '    & 

   !-  .     

.%   0  /

 

 & 



''   *   ,

 %&' 

 &   '

 ' ,    %    %   %& '

%

  9!' - /   !   !   !   0  ;   

! 1

1       >B !  ! 

             ! !     "9:  H

'   H0  "

 1 H1  1!

1!!     2!

             !

      I    2

  2!

    !02!   !2 ! 1< * 

/*7:(#*+(*' */:&(  ' 2  0 ' 

 

(;'*7(0)17'&*<* (;9-&(0)17'&*  2% '*7.( 6/.(&-  (0)17'&*<*()(07(0(0)(017'&    2%    / 0 ' 

   /*7:( 4

52  1 1<  2

:

8  ,      :4$5(00 9!34$5 (0040534$5$(00405"9;      '



,  ,  

 %   <:4$5(00!

34$5 (00405 =34$5$(00405"=34 5(004>(5 ;   &   '  %2'     

       '        

     

 

 

 ' '  %

      '   .

,    /  

'' '      8'

' %  '   %

    ?%    0  @ 

 1 

 

'' '  8-

1!  ! C!  !

0 !

 !   0* 2 ?

1       1    !        2!

     0 1 !" / .

!1< * 

   /00($(,(-0(0)(017'& 8*<-:-06/.(&%7(&.((0) 17'&*3

%44! !! "" ! !!"8"; %

J  52!    

:!

2 10 ' 

!    (;'*7 (0)17'&* */:&( !

#

  ' '   , < <% ( :4$5(00!

34$5 (00405=34$5$(00 405"=34 5(004>(5 ;,  @ 8

     

  ' & '   ,    %  & ,%  

!A    

    '  ' '.

B 34(00'9,'

"5 6"  (,    0   (    C   :(   C

 1 0  ,459(00 3 45$(00405=9345$(004059345 (004>(59=;  &  

 ''

  

   '     (  D

:(  D C.0,459(00345 (00405==345(00405;    /

'' %    ' &   '   2 

,      

 

' $A  &E    



1   , 

 ' &  '  2 

, ,     %  & ,%   

!A 

     

         '  ' '    &      % 

'

&  2, &#    % $A     

 '

 ! & - .   %





$& ,!AB

 - /   ' 

     1   4    1-1,')  = ',-(0+'  '0'&(,  0*/&(0+'  .:(0>  $1)  8*  %(>'&( 67(10(0)17'&*K! !! B"B";   1-1,') =(1-0(,0*/&(0+'.:(0>$-.-1')8* /*7:(%-0?77(/7(0(0) 17'&*K! !! "B" !   221-1,')= &-'01(, 0*/&(0+'.:(0>$-.-1')8*%@(&0('8-(0)17'&*A ! !!

"7" !!!    2!

    2! !2  :!2?

1

:1

!

 "/  '%  

 !1

  !!

'0 !



!0* "# !

  10   /*7:(#* 4

5" # ' 2? (;'*7#*+(*' */:&(  0 2!0 * J0#H  /00($(,(-0#*+(*' */:&(   0



 ' 

!

 % 1

2 '0 !



!      /*7:(#*    4

5     ' 2     / 0

  

 ! 2 2 1E!!    2!

    !1 1

    !

1" +2 1        I   2

H !0.

!1 < *     '*7.(  6/.(&-  8  ()(0  7(03    2  %     2   ! %(&,(<'&.(#*+(*' */:&( 2 

!! ! 2 !     1 ' $J  4

5 0 !"



 !   !    1! !"

/   2  !" 1   & !1  /00($(,(-0J 

5*  ! ' 2   

0 !2  1! ! 1 ! ! !" + 2  !" #!



!" /    !      "9:             1   0 !/ 0

 2!!

    "

  

  %%  1 

   GIANENDER KUMAR 2016.05.06 15:09 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document