High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1573/2016disposed of

Bharti Axa General Insurance Company Ltd v. Gurmeet Kaur & ORS

2025-02-10Mr. Justice Pankaj Jain5 pages

!"#

%& '

' #

' ) ** + , ,

! "

& "

! "

& "

(

! "

"% "

& " )

'% "

& "

(

% "

'% "

& "

(

% "

'% "

& "

!# +

-&.

#, %"/ !$ 0% %

*+,+-./ * 0-1++23405672380.+ 93*.:+0;;+550-.,-,<*0-8+3=;0-40-7 93*.:+*+,;3-7+-.,>-3, )6 (0-7 (39

*#% 0-7:>*672380.+ 93*.:+0;;+550-.>- )

0-7 93*.:+*+,;3-7+-.,>- 3-+93*.:+0;;+550-.,>-3, (0-7 (39

*-?<,:0=;05672380.+93* *%<,:0@*00:010-672380.+ 93**+,;3-7+-.,3.3>- )

AAAA $ 0% % %,

2 4.:>,83==3-3*7+*6>-.+-7.37>,;3,+399.:+093*+80;.>3-+7 ,>B0;;+05,0*>,>-@3<.39.:*++7>99+*+-.850>=;+.>.>3-,7+8>7+7C43.3* 88>7+-.50>=*>C<-056=*>.,0*C483==3-1<7@=+-.70.+7

3 39

>,0..:+C+:+,.39>-,<*0-8+83=;0-4 0*>,>-@3<.39;+.>.>3-3 39

3 (39

>,.:+ 8*3,,0;;+050..:+C+:+,.39.:+850>=0-.,3 39

>,0..:+ C+:+,.39>-,<*0-8+83=;0-40*>,>-@3<.39;+.>.>3-3 ) 39

3 )39

>,.:+8*3,,0;;+05;*+9+**+7C4.:+850>=0-., 3( 39

>,0..:+C+:+,.39>-,<*0-8+83=;0-40*>,>-@3<.39 ;+.>.>3-3 39

0-73 (39

>,.:+8*3,,0;;+05

:+850>=;+.>.>3-,0*>,+3<.390-<-93*.<-0.+=3.3*2+:>8<50*

088>7+-.70.+7

D:+*+>-.:*++;+*,3-,6-0=+546 0?:D>-7+* >-@:

,$3,,0 >-@:6 <?:7+2 >-@:,$3<*7>05 >-@:0-7EC05 >-@:,$30*7++;

>-@: 7>+7 :+ 850>= ;+.>.>3-, D+*+ 088+;.+7 C4 .:+ *>C<-05 :357>-@

<?:7+2 >-@:5>0C5+0-7-+@5>@+-. F:>5+@*0-.>-@83=;+-,0.>3->-850>= ;+.>.>3-3 ) 39

3- 0883<-.397+0.: 39EC05 >-@:6 *>C<-05 3C,+*2+70,<-7+*/ GBB BB BB -.:+0,,+,,=+-.4+0*

( 67+8+0,+7:070->-83=+39 ,)6 6

$-.:+-+B.0,,+,,=+-.4+0*>+

6.:+ 7+8+0,+7:070->-83=+39, 6( 6()$6:+*+D0,0- >-8*+0,+39, 6)$32+*.:+>-83=+39;*+2>3<,4+0*- .:+-+B.0,,+,,=+-.4+0*6.:+7+8+0,+7:070->-83=+39, 6 $D:>8:=+0-,.:+*+D0,7+8*+0,+>-.:+>-83=+C4 ,(6 $:<,6.:+7+8+0,+780-C+,0>7.3C+:02>-@ 0--<05 >-83=+ >- .:+ *0-@+ 39 ,6

$ 7<*>-@ .:+ 0,,+,,=+-.4+0*

H :+*>C<-050883*7>-@54@*0-.+783=;+-,0.>3-.3.:+850>=0-., 3-0883<-.397+0.:39EC05 >-@:3C,+*2>-@0,<-7+*/ "0.+39088>7+-.

$ $

@+397+8+0,+7 )4+0*, 88<;0.>3-

+59+=;534+7 50>=0-., F>9+6 ,3- 0-7 =3.:+*

*>C<-05

*3 =3<-.,

$ ;+* 0--<=

6 6

66 )$

6(6 )$

6((6 $

6(6 $ )

$ ( 6

6 6 $

3<-,+5*+;*+,+-.>-@>-,<*0-8+83=;0-4,<C=>.,.:0..:+*>C<-05 +**+7>-.0?>-@>-83=+397+8+0,+7EC05 >-@:0,,50?:D:>8:>-85<7+, >-83=+39,6 6

$9*3=3.:+*,3<*8+, +,<C=>.,.:0.>-83=+.0B ;040C5+05,33<@:..3:02+C++-7+7<8.+7

683<-,+593*.:+850>=0-.,,<C=>.,.:0.-3.:>-@:0, C++-;0>73-0883<-.3953,,3983-,3*.><= :+,0>70=3<-.-++7,.3C+ @*0-.+7>-.+*=,39*0.>33950D50>773D-C4 <;*+=+3<*.>-.:+80,+39

# #$ -.:+83-,>7+*+73;>->3-39.:>,3<*.6>-83=+.0B*+.<*-93*.:+ 0,,+,,=+-.4+0*

:0,C++-;*32+73-*+83*70,BF$-83=+.0B *+.<*-93*.:+4+0*

:0,C++-;*32+73-*+83*70,BF$ :+ ,0=+,:3D,.3.05>-83=+39.:+7+8+0,+793*0,,+,,=+-.4+0*

0, , 6 "0.+39088>7+-.>,

*>C<-05:0,*>@:.54>@-3*+7 >-83=+.0B*+.<*-93*.:+0,,+,,=+-.4+0*

BF$"D:>8:,:3D, @*3,,.3.05>-83=+0,, 6

$0,.:+,0=+D0,9>5+73-

09.+* .:+7+0.:39.:+7+8+0,+7 -.:+,+8>*8<=,.0-8+,6*>C<-053<@:..3:02+ 0,,+,,+7.:+>-83=+39.:+7+8+0,+70,;+*50,.>-83=+.0B*+.<*->+93*.:+ 0,,+,,=+-.4+0*

>+, 6 $-83=+.0B;040C5+:0,*>@:.54 C++-7+7<8.+7"+7<8.>3-39$ :0,C++-D*3-@540;;5>+7:+,0=+,:3<57 C+ $ <.<*+ ;*3,;+8., -++7 .3 C+ 0D0*7+7 I J >-,.+07 39 J <5.>;5>+*39(:0,C++-*>@:.540;;5>+7-0883<-.3953,,3983-,3*.><=6+08: 39.:+850>=0-.,>,+-.>.5+793*,)6

$ 3*53,,39+,.0.+0-79<-+*05 +B;+-,+,05,36.:+850>=0-.,0*++-.>.5+793*,)6

$<-7+*+08:39.:+ :+07,

) F>.: .:+ 093*+,0>7 =37>9>80.>3-6 .:+ 0;;+05, ;*+9+**+7 C4 .:+ 850>=0-.,0,D+550,.:+>-,<*0-8+83=;0-40*+7>,;3,+7399 ( -850>=;+.>.>3-3 39

6*+50.>-@.37+0.:39 <?:7+2

>-@:,$3 0*0=1>. >-@:6>-83=+39.:+7+8+0,+7:0,C++-;*32+7.3C+ ,6 6

$ ..:+.>=+397+0.:6:+D0,0C3<.)4+0*,390@+ <.<*+ ;*3,;+8.,39

J-++7.3C+@*0-.+7>-.+*=,39*0.>33950D50>773D->-

" "+7<8.>3-39$:0,C++-*>@:.540;;5>+7 <5.>;5>+*39 :0,C++-*>@:.54@*0-.+708:39.:+850>=0-.,>,+-.>.5+793* ,)6

$3-0883<-.3953,,3983-,3*.><=,)6

$<-7+*+08:39.:+ :+07,3953,,39+,.0.+0-79<-+*05+B;+-,+,>,0D0*7+737>9>+70883*7>-@54 - .:+ 0;;+05 0*>,>-@3<.39 850>=;+.>.>3-3 39

6 7+8+0,+7EC05 >-@:>,,.0.+7.3C+>-;*>20.+13C >,>-83=+:0,C++- ;*32+73-*+83*7.3C+, 6

$;+*=3-.: J9<.<*+;*3,;+8.,-++7.3C+ 0D0*7+7>-,.+0739 J"+7<8.>3-39$:0,C++-*>@:.540;;5>+7+D0,

4+0*,390@+ <5.>;5>+*39:0,C++-*>@:.540;;5>+7 08:39.:+ 850>=0-., >, +-.>.5+7 93* ,)6

$ 3- 0883<-. 39 53,, 39 83-,3*.><= ,)6

$<-7+*+08::+073953,,39+,.0.+0-79<-+*05+B;+-,+, F>.:.:+093*+,0>7=37>9>80.>3-6.:+0;;+05,0*+7>,;3,+7399 ;:3.383;439.:>,3*7+*C+;508+73-.:+9>5+,393.:+*83--+8.+7 80,+,

>-8+.:+=0>-80,+:0,C++-7+8>7+76;+-7>-@=>,8+550-+3<, 0;;5>80.>3-6>90-46,:05505,3,.0-7,7>,;3,+7399

$ 0% % , , %"'

">-+,:

F:+.:+*,;+0?>-@$*+0,3-+7/ !+, F:+.:+*+;3*.0C5+/ 3