← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4855/2013allowed

Nhpc Limited v. M/S Patel Engineering Ltd Etc

2015-09-10Mr. Justice Arun Monga11 pages

ARCHANA ARORA 2015.09.23 17:40 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document

   !

!"#$ %$&'(')*+$,#$-.$/ #0

 1'-'#$%  ,,$22")# 3$/(4(

"#$2)5')$$/')51#%")%#0$/(  $(,)%$)#( * 6 1 +71 

 

 

 

 





 

! 



 " #

$ 

%" & '

( #    &

)

!

%"  # 

%& -'#"8"2   ( 

    

*%

 % 

 )+

#   

 ,,- . 

 /

/0 "%%

%" 



1 2% 3#  + '5) $#    

 )4

 "

 

 

% # 

 #"   '

'55)  6 .(60  % 1 !* 7% 



$ 8* 

*

 $ 9 (

   9 :   

$* )'

!

.4 ;

)) !0 ( 6$ 1"

9   

888

 ! 7%  8 $  #$ 

  



(

  $* $ ''<-55555= > ?

@ ')5555=    $ # "  $ 4A " "



 $

'< '55)   '5 

   

 .0

%  

"" $* $ )5  "

 

 $ $  ''

  "  $* $ " 

9  #"   $   B"  3 

 , - '55) $    %% "

  C  .

C0 

 $ $     9/#

" 

  #$ "      " $  #

7 #   " "  % "

 

 " "

'+5'5555= 

%  

%  *

"" #*

" A5A5-5<+= $ "   $*  $*  

$   # " $% 

%

*

2

*



.2 0





 * 

$*

"

 

%

'+

'55+

'A '55+

''

'55+  "

+ '

'55< ', '

'55< "  "   "  $  ') '

 $  '<

 "

"%   %  

$  "#  "  % ; "  $/    

 

%   "

  " " $ #

9  #"  $  # "



="%

( #  %    "   $   "  % 9/ "   % "% 4+-55555= % $  'E  "

"

 "



 $

7  #   ;

 $% " "

9  #"



1 2%    *  % "

    %   "%   "

  "   % F 

$ "

 )4



9  #"   %  

# "%           



 

% #  #"   

%  

   GG %

"%   

$  "

 )4



(  # $ %      $ 

%" 

"

9  #" $% % *    "

% $*    "%  %  # $ "% *% $  )-  $

 $ 3  $  +  $  !*

9  #"    " $ 

   #  "

 " "

   "

"# $    ""% $*   " $ % " 

*% $    " 

# $ $ *  $    % % "="% % $   

(  "%   #    "

 

  %  

 

 

    #*

8 $ #    )- )-

)- 

++

+  H)- 3IJB

2B?JB   

             

              



    

        

 

          

  



       

           

            

  



!

"# $% &  $     

 '   

(   



)         

*    

*

+ 

 )

  



+     

)

 

$* 

$  +         

  

  % , 

 #

 -

     .   /000     



' 



 1  

   2 

#&3%4( 4&253#46

!

         

              

 

 

       7) +           9  "/ 

                   

      



    

  !

#                           .    77   .  

 



            2 

#&3%4(4&253#46

 1(34%94(:

"#

  '      

 9 '   

    9 '    ,     1

      9 '    7/

             '  

   

 

         .       3. ( '                          

   4 

#

  

  

 '       

  

      

          



  



   

   

      '       

           7!  ),   5

  2

+

3.   ( '        

      

; ) +

       

 '

) 



  +     

      



     





    

  

  )

      

                 

    

        

:

      

 

   



)+    

       

    

    

          

  .    

   

                   

 



< )+3

 '  )

   '+      .  

     !

7 

)+%  /000 



# -

 

        

     

    3. ( '

   



 

 7= '

     





 4  





  4 

#

'

         

                                  3.  ( ' 





    

 7>

'

   4   

    # 

   

    

4 

 

   

           

     4   

      

         

   

7#   

 9 '

     4   

   

       

   

   

   7   

  

    3. ( '    

          9 '             

    4      

 "/  

    

    

                      



   3.  ( '  

   .              '                   

    



    7

 

   

    3. ( '

      9 '        1

       ,       

          3.  ( '                    

 4    

4   

   





 



?      9 '

      3. ( '

, 5

 2

    

    

 4 

#

       ?  

  

/  6

  

   

     ?         

;

  "    3. ( '

   *  

  

    "      4        





    '

            9 ' 

     3. ( '.

 

          

 

              

 

'

   9 '   

    



  

 @

I   % "

      #%  #   "  "

 %  %     "  

    #   % $   "  



# 

 +  



   

# #  

( "

K3  K   

 )- '

$   

"" 

# 

% * 

$ ; 

""

B   +    $ 

*  $* ; *  " 

# " %       $  ; *    

""

9$ "  %  

 " # #  "   %  *  

 )4



  $ "

  

$  * ;  # $ $ %  

 )4

(

$  $     %     %% 

$ # ""% 

     % % 

 GG "

"

 A 

          

     '   BC&&         

   ' 

' 

 # 

 '

                 



       ! B 

   .    #        

          .      .

      

  # 



  .   '  



   '    

         

   

  

   

 

    '   

 

       



     1 

 

   

 

         

    



      ? 

 

 

1 @

I %% % " %    #  #" # 

 " $ %  "   $

( " $     "

L% $ "    + '5



1 2% 3#   

( "  " #*

$ =# % 

(



1 2% 3# 

  

8   #% # 

 ) '

'5'

  #*  %

"#

 %  

   #



1 2% 3#

8  ;



1 2% 3# 

  $ # " # "

  $

$ ; # # $   " "

     

%  

 

71

! +$,#$-.$/ #0 

"/&0")"