High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1437/2012disposed of

Dalwinder Singh And Another v. Ut Of Chandigarh

2015-09-22Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain5 pages

!"# $#%&'&()*#+"#,-#.

/ 0

) 12 ** 2 .#'#(") . 3&,!(/ .!.$&+*&(43!($ . 3!(*&(43!(!/$5%!"# ."3#6!($7(#.' .*#"&!/ . ##+!8*3!.,!!($ .9&'3!6*$3&/$5%!"#' .(&(#..&".:/ 3!($&4!.3 !;#'3&($!6 3&'.$#.7&66$&'+'# !-<(%3 !++#!6'-#!.&(4 '

" = />=">?/ ?

/ >> " 0/

=" =/

/ ?>" ?> /0

?"0 /0 0?"0

!($

@ '

/ = /0 =/0 / >" / >/

=!($

" =

!'"3#'!,#!.&'#<" %,,(!%A<&'&"&(

("3#!++#!6' &6#$-:"3#6!($7(#.'/"3#:!.#'##8&(4 <."3#.

#(3!(%#,#(" %,+#('!"&( ."3#!%A<&.#$6!($/73#.#!'&("3#!++#!6'

&6#$-:(&(#..&".:/3!($&4!.3/"3#+.!:#.&' ..#$<%"&("3#.#

.&# 6:/"3# !%"' "3#%!'#!.#"3!" 5&$#("& &%!"&($!"#$

=/&''<#$<($#.*#%"&( "3#2!($%A<&'&"&(%"/?>

'3."/1"3#%"1B/(&(#..&".:/3!($&4!.3'<43""!%A<&.#= 0!%.#'

6!($ &( 5&66!4# 3!(!'/ !$-!'" 0/ / 3!($&4!.3 .#3!-&6&"!"&( '6<,$7#66#.'3#'!,# 7!' 667#$-: ("& &%!"&( $!"#$0 =/&''<#$<($#.*#%"&(= "3#%"3#2!($%A<&'&"&( 66#%".

.'3."/1"3#66#%".1B/5&$#!7!.$$!"#$0 =/!''#''#$ "3#%,+#('!"&(C 0/ >/0 >DE+#.!%.#44.&#5#$!4!&('""3#!7!.$ "3#66#%"./"3#6!($7(#.' &6#$-;#%"&('73&%37#.#.# #..#$""3# 6#!.(#$%<."-#67/738##+&(4&(5&#7"3#,!"#.&!6+6!%#$(.#%.$-: "3#+!."&#'/$#"#.,&(#$"3# !&.5!6<# "3#!%A<&.#$6!($C0 />0/ 0>DE +#.!%.#3#'!&$!7!.$3!'-##(%3!66#(4#$-:"3#6!($7(#.'!'7#66!' (&(#..&".:/3!($&4!.3-# .#"3&'%<." 2#!.(#$%<('#6 ."3#6!($7(#.''<-,&""#$"3!""3#!%A<&.#$ 6!($7!'6%!"#$;<'"%6'#""3#!-!$& 5&66!4# 3!(!'!." &"&'

!-<""&(4"3#.!$6#!$&(4 .,3!($&4!.3" <66!(!.&-$!''/73#.#!'( "3#"3#.'&$#7!'"3#6!($ <(;!-*"!"#3#!.#!(<(;!-'&$#7!'

!6.#!$:$#5#6+#$5#("3#6!($6%!"#$("3#"3#.'&$# 3!($&4!.3E <66!(!.&-$!''.!$3!$-##(!%A<&.#$ .<'#!'"!(&%!6!.$#(!($ !"<.#!.86'#""3#!%A<&.#$6!($!6'/"3#.#7#.#!%A<&'&"&('#!.6&#. "7!'!',!66+."&( 6!($&("3&'!.#!/73&%37!'6# "<"3#'!6#$##$

F=B$!"#$ =/5&$#73&%3 8!(!6'!($ ,!.6!' 6!($7!'

'6$ =/

/0DE7!'("%('&$#.#$-:

"3# 6#!.(#$ %<." -#67 3# 6!($ $#!6" 7&"3 "3#.#&( 7!' 6%!"#$ ;<'" !$;&(&(4""3#!%A<&.#$6!($7&"3('+#%&!6!$5!("!4#'3#!5#.!4#'!6# %('&$#.!"&(+!&$"3#.#&(7<6$%,#<""/ //DE+#.!%.#(

!%"/"3#.#!.#5#.: #7'!6#".!('!%"&('&(3!($&4!.3%('&$#.&(4"3# .#'".&%"&(.#4!.$&(4%('".<%"&(3#6#!.(#$# #.#(%#<."3!'7.(46:

.#;#%"#$"3#!

.#'!&$'!6#$##$+&(&(4"3!"((#7<6$-<:'<%3!%'"6: 6!($(6: .!4.&%<6"<.!6+<.+'#'( !%"/"3#!.#!7!'-#&(4<'#$ %,,#.%&!6+<.+'#'&("3#'#('#"3!",!.-6#!($ <.(&"<.#,!.8#"'3!$ !6.#!$:%,#<+&("3#!.#!/"3<43"3#'".<%"<.#'7#.#"#,+.!.:!($"3# +#('+!%#'7#.#<'#$ .'".!4# ,!.-6#3#4#(<&(#(#'' "3#'!6# $##$%!(("-#$&'+<"#$ ."3#.#!'("3!";<'"!

"#. $!:'/!("3#.'!6# $##$ B$!"#$ = .6!($,#!'<.&(4 8!(!6'!($ ED

,!.6!'7!'.#4&'"#.#$

/>?/0DE!"!( !5#.!4#+.&%# / 0// DE+#.!%.#3#.#!.#"3#.'!6#$##$'!6' +.$<%#$(.#%.$ ."3#'<-'#A<#("+#.&$&("3#'!,#!.#!'37&(4 '&,&6!.+.&%#' "3#6!($/3#(%#/"+&(#"3!""3#'!6#$##$ B7!'

("!4#(<&(#'!6#".!('!%"&(&'""!66:,&'%(%#&5#$3#'<-,&''&(&' "3!""3#!.#!$#!6"7&"3&("3#'!6#$##$'-#&(4A<&"#6!.4#/(%<"&'.#A<&.#$ "-#!++6&#$ 0 ( "3# "3#. 3!($/ 6#!.(#$ %<('#6 . (&( #..&".:/ 3!($&4!.3'<-,&""#$"3!"("& &%!"&(<($#.*#%"&( "3#%"&("3# +.#'#("%!'#7!'&''<#$( =*<.5#: .!%A<&'&"&( 6!($&(!(:

!.#!'"!."'+.&.&("&,#3#'!6#$##$ B7!'4".#4&'"#.#$-:"3# .#'&$#("' "3#!.#!/73'#6!($!6',!:3!5#-##(!%A<&.#$/(6:";!%8 <+"3#+.&%#'!($%.#!"##5&$#(%#3&'7!'(""3#4#(<&(#".!('!%"&(3# "3#.'!6#$##$'-#&(4+'"("& &%!"&(<($#.*#%"&( "3#%"7#.#("

.#6#5!(" 5#( "3#.7&'#/ "3# '!6# ".!('!%"&( #("#.#$ &(" ! "#. "3# !%A<&'&"&( 6!($7<6$!67!:'-#8##+&(4&(5&#7"3#$#5#6+,#(" !%"&5&":&("3#!.#!'"!."&(47&"3!%A<&'&"&( 6!($/3#(%#/"3#+.&%#',!:

3!5#4(#<+(:'!6#".!('!%"&(.$#5#6+,#("&((#&43-<.&(4*"!"#&' (".#6#5!("!'$&

#.#("*"!"#'3!5#"3#&.7(!$5!("!4#'.$&'!$5!("!4#' # <."3#.'<-,&""#$"3!""3#.#3!$-##("3#.!%A<&'&"&( "3#6!($&("3# !.#!/ 73#.# ("& &%!"&( <($#. *#%"&( "3# %" 7!' &''<#$ (

>>>!($"3&'<."&( 0 >G*3H!(7!6;&"*&(43 <;.!6!($!("3#.5(&(#..&".:/3!($&4!.3/$#%&$#$( ? 0/ 3!$ <+3#6$ "3# !7!.$ "3# 6#!.(#$ # #.#(%# <." !''#''&(4 "3# %,+#('!"&(C /0 / DE+#.!%.#5#(& &(%.#!'# ."3#"&,#E4!+&( "7!%A<&'&"&('&'4.!("#$/"3#!7!.$ "3#66#%".7!',<%3,.#!($ "3#.#7!'(%!'#,!$#<" .#(3!(%#,#(" %,+#('!"&( = #!.$6#!.(#$%<('#6 ."3#+!."&#'!($+#.<'#$"3#.#6#5!("

.# #..#$.#%.$

' &' #5&$#(" .,"3# '&"# +6!( F 0B ( .#%.$/ "3# !%A<&.#$6!($&'6%!"#$(3!($&4!.3E <66!(!.&-$!''.!$/((#'&$# 73&%3"3#!%A<&.#$6!($&''&"<!"#$/73#.#!'("3#"3#.'&$#&'"3#6!($ !%A<&.#$ .$#5#6+,#("!'"!(&%!6!.$#(!($!"<.#!.8((#'&$#

"3# !%A<&.#$ 6!($ !-<"' "3# -<($!.: <(;!- *"!"# .<($ "3# !%A<&.#$6!($7!'"3#!-!$& 5&66!4#' 3!(!'!($*!.!(4+<.6'#""3!"

&' &68,!(1'6(:3!($&4!.3&"'#6 &'!',!66%&":3!5&(4!""!6!.#!

!-<" 'A<!.# 8&6,#"#.' !;. +!." &" 3!' -##( +6!((#$ !($ $#5#6+#$ 3# 6!($ &( <"'8&."' 7!' -#&(4 !%A<&.#$ . +6!((#$ $#5#6+,#("("3#%!'#&(3!($/"3#6!($7(#.'3!$+.$<%#$(.#%.$ '!6#$##$ F=B/73&%37!'.#4&'"#.#$( =/5&$#73&%3 8!(!6'!($ ,!.6!' 6!($7!''6$

/0DE!"!(!5#.!4#+.&%# / //DE+#.!%.#"&''3!.#&(!

;&("83#7!",#!'<.&(4 =8!(!6'E?E ,!.6!'!." "3&'&'!-<""&(4"3# !%A<&.#$ 6!($7&"3 ('+#%&!6!$5!("!4#!''<%3<."3#..#6&!(%#7!' +6!%#$<+('!6#$##$ B$!"#$ =/5&$#73&%3 8!(!6'!($

ED ,!.6!'7!''6$

/>?/0DE!"!( !5#.!4#+.&%# / 0// DE+#.!%.#3#6!($+#."!&(&(4"3#.#"7!' !6'6%!"#$%6'#""3#!%A<&.#$6!($!'"3#-<($!.&#' .#5#(<##'"!"#'

5&66!4#' 3!(!'!($*!.!(4+<.!.#!$;&(&(43#'<-,&''&(7!' !''#''&(4"3#%,+#('!"&(("3#-!'&'"3#.# ? (,:+&(&(/'!6#$##$ F=B%!(-#.#6&#$<+( ."3# +<.+'# !''#'',#(" %,+#('!"&( ."3#!%A<&.#$6!($ ."3#.#!'( "3!""3#'!,#&'("!',!66'!6#".!('!%"&(!($ <."3#."3#6!($+#."!&(&(4 "3#.#"&'!$;&(&(4""3#!%A<&.#$6!($3#%("#("&(.!&'#$-:6#!.(#$ %<('#6 .(&(#..&".:"3!"&"7!'4".#4&'"#.#$;<'"7&"3!5&#7" ;!%8<++.&%#'"%.#!"##5&$#(%# .%6!&,&(4#(3!(%#$%,+#('!"&(&'

,#.#6:"-#("&%#$!($.#;#%"#$8##+&(4&(5&#7"3#'<-'#A<#("'!6#$##$

F>B$!"#$00 /5&$#73&%3 8!(!6'!($ ,!.6!' 6!($7!'

'6$ .""!6'!6#%('&$#.!"&( ?/ 0/DE!"!(!5#.!4#+.&%#

///DE+#.!%.#/3#(%#/"3#4#(<&(#(#'' '!6#$##$ F=B%!(("

-#$<-"#$3#.#;#%"&("3#.# -:"3#%<."-#67+&(&(4"3!"((# 7&66-<:!4.&%<6"<.!66!($!"!(#F.-&"!(".!"#&',#.#6:&,!4&(!".:3#.# 7#.#6" !%"&5&"&#'&("3&'!.#!7&"3"3#'3& "&(4 ,!.-6#/ <.(&"<.#!($ 8!-!.&,!.8#"' .,"3#.+!."' "3#%&":!

"#.&"7!'$#5#6+#$7#5#./ '"&66/&(,:+&(&(/ .!''#''&(4 !&.5!6<# "3#!%A<&.#$6!($/!%<"

I$#'#.5#'"-#!++6&#$("3#'!6#%('&$#.!"&('37(&('!6#$##$

F=B "#..#$<%&(4!'<, / /DE"3#.# .,/"3#5!6<# "3# !%A<&.#$6!($7<6$%,#<"">/?/DE+#.!%.#3#6!($7(#.'!.# 3#6$#("&"6#$"%,+#('!"&(C>/?/DE+#.!%.#3#:'3!66!6'-# #("&"6#$"!66'"!"<".:-#(# &"'!5!&6!-6#""3#,<($#."3#%" > . "3# .#!'(' ,#("&(#$ !-5#/"3#!++#!6' &6#$ -:"3# 6!($7(#.'!.#!667#$/73#.#!'"3#!++#!6' &6#$-:"3#(&(#..&".:

!.#$&',&''#$

!;#'3&($!6B <$4# *#+"#,-#.

/ 0 ,8

# #."#+."#.B