← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1635/2016allowed

Raj Kanwar @ Raj Kumar v. Geeta Devi And ORS

2017-03-28Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul12 pages

 

     

  

   

   ! "# $%%&%!'()     

  

! "   #

 **** +"  

" ,)-./

 /

".  

"1 $"-/

 /

""   *'#" 3, ****   

&.  * 4 "

#3 " 5*6*7.

. "    -. 4"

 8,



2 3&"8# /+ 4 9

".

"/:. &"8# ;</4. " 8, .  3  8,.  3*$  09"    . " <# ") 

"! .  /=

"-"



#

.

. ".#8 /3 ,/". #3" "38"/4 3 #

//>*4 4"

 0 #"

394 < "

"3"    )? 4  @#3"/4.

" 3 . " 8"

. ""  0 ,

 9"    A. " < 6" ,   /    /  ".  #3"    "38"9

 <4"0 -  " " 

** , 8 "-" -"  5* *A/8 - "0 8,  8"@#3"

& ?2. 4 

4-. 3 . , . . ,"  $

#" "  .8

  5*  5

 /    #38 "  8 "-  " -"    5*6*7

-0 . </8 - "0 8,+4#3"9"   7 . " <".  - - 3 "   .-. / 3

3. 

  .. 3 ,

".#3"  "38"9

 <" # . "

/".#3"  "38" . "

# 3#   -" 0 #@#" 

. " /4. "  8"93 , < . ? .8 "3

. "

# 3 "@#" @#3"/4.

4

4- . 3 , 8 - "0 8, 8"/. 

4. " -" #38 "

-0 . &.

#-..  "0 "

- 0 . 

"4. /8#. "   "/. 

4, 3.   &.  @#"

*".  #3"     "38"  4  .   "

 /B" 8 4. " . #

#38 . @#"  . 3

, #"-.  #" 

" 3 '." -"

/B' A=/

A/ # ") = A*

'+2/+ )

 /4- " - "

. 

@#3"* , 4  &.  3 

.. ".#8 4, "

- . 3

. .5 4 "-7/>* "3 .8,

--" # #"

"? 3 ?0  -#3

 ?.4  ." 3 / " "

. 8

,  "  #  .#3 ,

./.  3 "    A.0 8  "0

**

0 

  &.  * 4 " "   7* "0 ".0 

@   4"    3   ?-  " 3",  8@     

38 ,/ # 



# '4  .,

4 0 " # 8,"   7 #  ".  - - 

"0-

. 0 . C#  .  -  /3    ' ,  /. ,4 "   8  ,, . 0 .  C#    4  #"

 4.  "     *'#"  2 3, &. "

" / 8 ,/ ,/

'#" 3, &. '#" 3,*"     4"   3 ?-" 3", 8@  38 ,/

#   . -"

.. "   7* "0 "4

-0 

0  . 3 

( 3 "/4#83 . # .

.  0 "

#""

4.

. 0 . C#  .  -  /3      

 4" - "

-.  "0 "*"   7 # 4.  "0 "   4 "    D"     3  '#"

3, - ,',  /. '#" 3,  8 

, . 

-0 . 48 -  0 

 "3  

#" , &. &"8# .

..  .

".#3"  "38"4. " # 

. @#" # 8,.3. 

 4. .4 # #  ".  - -  "0-

- 0 . 8,"   7*+4#3"&.

#-..  3

*A*

.. ".#8 4 "-7/>* "3 .8,

- -" # #" 4 "? 3 ?0  -/8#. 8 

, -   0 - 0 . "

" /. &"8# 

?.  3 

.

 .

 # 4 "?3. " 03  A/7>*  "3 .'.4,/. #  3 

 3 

7A/>* ) # . 

 4 " ."  #38 "/. &"8#   >"

# 0 4

 4 

4 8,  .  5 ;8  )#" 3  2 #"          

  

 !""#$%&

'!'

   "-. ,   3#   "

'.3 "/. 3 #

3    /A/>*  &  .    3 # 

/  .

&"8#  

/>* 4"

 "#3//>* 4"



# "  D   7/>* 4"

 

  

- ,/.

    ,8    .  3  4  3#  

//>* 4 0 "/4.   -4. 8 , 3? .

,3 

/. '#" 3," 8@ . .  "0 "4 .

-0 

0  .

3 

 

    .  0 .    C#    4  8 -      0   

  "3  E    

 #" ,  %D+    

,

8 "- 7>>+"

>$

#

8,. 1 -#.

",/$

9."?. <&. &"8# "

0

"

" 3.  1 -#.

",0   " 77

=7..   9%D+<. 8 # 8,. "

*7* . 3 

  #" #3"  . 3

+4#3"*"   7(. 8

"  "

"/ .  

. '#" 3,4

8,. &"8# 

.. 3 

/"   7*+4#3"4 .

-0 

0 0  &. "

" /.

&"8#  D  " . '#" 3, 3 8 , ,

 .  8 ,4   # .  4 " "0 "

 . 

-  0 .  @  ,     0 " ,  

- ,/  .

&"8# /0 4"

/.

4 " "0 "

8  ,  34 "     A --" 0 -. 

"  4"

/ .  9 4 "<. . "    

" ,)-./ " # 

".  * 4 "

."-# .. &"8# .   . 4.

 0

4. 

-.  3   .4"

- ,   . @  8 , .  * 4 "4 .  "0 "

- 0 .    ,. 3 #

3 #.-. , D 0 /". ".

3  "", 

#3 0 8  .   

 0 "

#""

#  .  - - 

.   ".

"0 " 3 , 8,.3&.  .3  0 "3 

"  .  &"8#  .  .  "     7*+4  #3"  4 , 8,.3 "0 " . 4.

-0 

0

6

"  3 ,-.  "0 "/ "0- 4

**

# ?. "0-? &. &"8# ."  #  "#83 8,. " &" "(

/8#.  "

"

 8 "    0  # .

 4 D3  # "

 "

" 

"."  /. 

#3 4   D.8  8,  .  '#"  2 3,   &. "

" /  #   .

#3     D.8 /  .  3     8  "     0   3 ,/ . 

-  0 .  4  # , #"

 .  3   ""

" 8,. 

#3 ", 0 "

#

8,.

'#" 3,; 4 3 . 4"  3 . .   

. 

 /. 0 . 4#"

/

4. . "  

#" 4# 8,. '#" 3, (  "  

#" #  "3

. "

0 

.  /. #" "..  8 ,  ,. 4"

 " 4 &. " 4 8"  . "0 

,  

. #"

,( 4 "

. 0 . .?  #   -  "

. 3 

 3 ,-.  "0 "/. 0 # ,/. '#"

3,  0  8 , . -"

/  4 "

. 0 .  8 .

 8 '.   . / .   * 4 "  4     4"  .  .  "-  

"   7*+4#3"4 ?  8 -#,3 " (      .

 .  . 

-  0 .  4  # ,  #"

/  .

'#" 3, 8  ,.   . .

#"

.

  0 ",.-4.. 4 "3# .. . --   "0 " . 

. 0 .  ."- 



** "0 "4..  D"  "3  3   "0 .3 /   8  .. #"

-# ,

,8"  .&. '#"

3,.3 "8 ,   ."-   8 ...  "0 "

-0 . 4 .

-0  .

3 

     # . 

#3   .  8   "

#

 8, .

'#" 3,5 . #". ""-# ..  * 4 "   4  #   "       .  , #- "  8"

. "    8  "

# /. .?

., #- "8"

. " 0 " ,. - #  

.  4 .  3  

"0 "&.#  . 

.8

"  3 ,-.  "0 ". "0-? 4  8,., #- "8"

. "  .8  

.

@# -3  

 5 ;8  )#" 3  2 #"  "        

  (  )

* !"'+$,&  $ -&!.+   .4.  4 "

0 .  3 ,

"0 "/.  4 ".  ,..  "0 ". 0  "0- "0 " 3   "0 . 0 . 4. .8

  "0 . 3 /4.  4 "."  "0 "/. .

 ,..  "0 ". 0  . 3   , "0 ',  /.  4 "  D - .  D 

0 " ,-. - #  

4..   - #.

",  # . #   -   

..  "0- 4 

- # # . ?   . #" "

. #"

4 8  8 5 ."

""

"

. 

@# -3 4. ."  # "*

** F ' 3

" / " , . #" "# ") A=9<9<9< ? 

..  "0 "

. 0 . 0 .

4  # ,  ( # .

? /.  # . #" "6# 0   " ..     8,.  "0 "4

?   /4. . ". "  8 , . #" " . 3

C#   ".  4 "

. 0 .

 " /4. . ."  "0 "/. . ?

4. . "  .  "0 "  .    0  "0-    &. "   "  .  .     ,  .3      .

3  

"0 "'

 ." -"

  /      8    .  .  4 "  .  ?  "  8  "    3 ,-     "   4.

  C#  3    "0 . 0 .  &.

4 "  8  D - 8 , ./ .

D 

0 " ,-. - #  

"0- 4..   -#.

",8

" ."-.

 "0 

"0 "5 4 0 "/. # 4 #

8 

"  . 3 

#"

. 0 .

"  . "   "  .  #" 3,  " C#"   .

4 "

. 0 . .0 .   # ,0 "

3.   -#.

", " .  

.

4 " 

 .  0 .    . "4  0    .

 -   .  .    #    .  "0 "

, 8,.3 ?    , .  4 "

 ? "

" 

"0 " 

.

3 "" -"

-. - #  

.   .   -#.

",&.4. D   )4"  )-.;    9#"<  '

  # 

"3 4..  4 "..    

8,. "0 " ? / ? 8,. #"

   '#" 3,13 ! "#)4")-.9A<)22=

*=*

""

" 0 "  /. . #"

4 8   #   /   # .  "

#3 /  .  #"

3,  8 

".  G (.  . ". / " # 

""   * '#" 3,."-# . "0 "

- 0 . 4 .

-0  /. '#" 3,

 8 .

"  8 . #"

. 33 0 

.  "3E  

#" ,&.  .

8,.  "0 "4

? . 3 

'4.  #,

.  * 4 " 0 " ,.  

"0 "8

"  --- .   "0    1 " # 

"  .  "     *'#"

3, .  "

""

   . @# -3      

  /) 9#"< #83..  "0 "4

-0  /. '#" 3,  8 .

8 5 . #". ""-# ..  * 4 "   "0 ,8   #

 @# -3 '.  /.  4 ".  , :.3 ; 3  

"0 "/8#.   . /.

 * 4 "  .       :.3 ;  .  3  

 .

"0 "/". " ". 3 /., #- "8"

. ". 0 " .

- #   

 .  "0-     &. "

" /  .   * 4 "

 ? 8  

.  @# -3 5 .  "-# ..

, #- "8"

. "

.  * 4 "4.

0 " 3  

.  "0 "  .     8   D3   &.#/  8   

    

  /  ) 9#"<     8  D 

   .

 * 4 "5 . #". " 

"  . @# -3 

** .  2 #"  "    01 2      0  

 !"'3$,&  14  5     !.+    (5   )

* 42

 !"',$,&  $ -&+,. "

""- 01 2/)9#"</. . "-# .4. .  "0 "

-0 . . "

#

.

# 8, -  &" "#.

",/ .#"/

# 8 "3  "   # . 4.,.  

"4,  . 8 "

#

4. . "0 ".    /  . "

" /  .  "

0 ",  "-.  .  "-. ,  8   -0     .

'#" 3, '.0 . "

 " # 

". "  42/)9#"<  4.# 4. " .

"0-    .

 8, .  "0 " 4

?   . 3 

 "0 "4 . ". "  

$#4.

4. "  .  "-  "0-   4# / ". "  

$#"- 34. " 4- "  4  &. "

" /. #8 C#  "  4  3  $#"-   4     0    .  ?   " "

 0    ) ".  4"

""

01 2/)9#"</ . 3    8 .  # "  "

#3 

.

 .   . /.  4 ".? 8  8  " 

?-. 

"0 "."

#-.., #- "8"

. "

4.

4 3"0 ,4  # ..   

 ,"  

#8.    

**   " -"

  @# -3         

  /)9#"< " /

#84.  4 "

.

0 . ."   "0 "/ .   " C#"

? 4. . ".  "0 "

  0  " H/

".#"

 /. .

 ,:.3 ; 3  

"0 "6#. "  

 /4. .  * 4 ".?

., #- "8"

. "/4.

  -. ,3 "  # / ?.   .

3  

"0 "/    # .

. , #- "8"

. "/4.

 0-. 3  3 ,/ "# 

 .  4 "  I.3 I  &. "

" /  .  4  I.3 I  .    8  ""  4 "   

0 "/.2 #"/4.   - 4.3 "   6) 752 01 0

89 ',3+ !"", ) ''

", !"',/ ..

. 4 ".

?

 .   4# ".

8  .4- # /. " 4 #". "" C#" 3 

".3

 ?. - #  

.   4..   -#.

", &. " 0"

. @# -3 "  # "* F&.  # 

 D  "  

 8 ,  

 3   # "  )   A=  "    ,    

4 ". 8 -# ,

8"  .

 "3

, '

4 ".

?

 .   4 ". 8  .4- # /. " 4

#". "  " C#" 3  

"  .3     ?  .

- #   

 .    4.  .   - #.

",(.  . ". /. 8 . #" "

4.

. # "? # . D "

 4. #  .  , ",3 8

" . 

 3? 

** # .0 "    . ,"   # . - #  /" C#"

 # . #"

3? 0 "  "." . 

"3 8 # .  ?  ."  "&. D "

   8 

   ,  ".  8 ,"   ". 

&.. 8   

4. 



. )#" 3 #" 

   (  )

* $!"'+&'"

!'. &.  8 ,      .  4 "  4/  . "

" / ""

# 8 8   &. "-.

0 ","

0

 8  

-.

     .  8 ,  .  8   ,    .

#" "G '0 4

8 0 /.2 #"  ..  * 4 "

.?   8  "  ?.  4.  --- .  "0 "  &. "

" /  .   * 4 "     8  .

 8  

- ,/. 4"

 8,. &"8#       " -"

 8 , 

 .   * 4 "    "   &.

'#"  2 3,    .

 8    ,  .  /    * 4 ".? " C#"

" . 3 

 ---.

"0 " "0 . 0 . 0 . 

   8,.  * 4 "      #



   @ 0 . . " ?->"  H J >

. . ""

"8 H J >