M/S Vijay Rice And General Mills Ltd And Another v. Punjab State Civil Supplies Corporation Limited And Others
!"
#$ %$
&' ( )* * !"
+$ %$
,- . / //- / $ $$0011&!'
.
- ./ -/- /
-$
$$ 0 ! !'
"
3/ $ - / 4-/ 3/ $ - 4
!
" #$
%
&&'
( ) &&'
*+ " #
,,
-. /
!, ,,
! -2 .# -.-# ,!
" #2
) &&'
*
!
!
1
-'
1
!
'/- 1 !
3,
4 5
!,
-
% .2 ./ -. '
!
,
2&2./67 !
# .# -..2
#8 ,
, 2 .# -..2
9 #
1
%0
,
!
!
,,1
%0 ,,
:
!, 3
7
!
!
! "#
!
!
! "
! " $
$ " !
%
" &
!
' (
#
! ' (
" " &
) *
) !!
(
' %&
) * ) !!
*! (
'
!
%"
"
! " "#
"
""' (
&
# %
"
% " (
' &
! !
% !
"# " !
+
,
+
" ' #
(
-# #
(
' (
&
' (
! "
'
(
"
,
"
+ "
"
% !
"
!
!"
"
"
!
. "(% ! &
!"
! "
!!
!
" "/ -$%! $ &
!!
. "011(%
!
!
2 !!
! ! !!
#
"
!!
!
%"
! $&
" !!
!
. "(%
% "
" """ !
%
"
2 #!
3 4 "5
"
! "05
"
% "
"
!
!
"
6#%
. 6#%
! 7
!!
7 6#%
.
% "
"
! "
"" ""
!
#!
"
"
! " !
" !
"
' (
&
! !
"
!
' (
! " 2 !
!
!
! $&
!
! "
7 !
! " % !
!
" " 2
2"
! . !
"
"
.
! !
! %
" !!
".
% !
!
-
! "
!!
! #
8 " #
* #
"
!
"
" !!
".
9
!
!
#
! :
!!!
;
! % %
/
%
1
%0
%
,,1
%0 ,,
'
<
,
!
%,7
1
,
--/.
, 1 #&&& , 1 !,
!
,
% , , !
-8
% , !
#8 %1 ,
=,
3
-. ' #$67
= ) *
3 -.'$ /#67
>
% , ,
-#- '$67
1 %! % 3 ! %
%
! ?
3 (?
+
' ./8 , "# !$
$
%,
:
"
0%
%
1 1
, ,
" !!
1
, ,
%
%
% @% "1, ,
3 A
(A + B1 1 1 " %!
,
1 !!
A , ,!
1 !, % ,
" ,
!, 1
!
,
,
!
! , 4 A
!! , 1 -. 7-. - 3
!, %
0% "
"
<, ( )C"C+
2-2:
%!
1 !!
#:&:' :.
= ) * 1
!
, !
,
,
4
'$8 !
1 -$$& '
!!
$/## :&
1
!
!
&-/$ -$
!
!, 1
, #. .' -. - 3
# - -. - D .: ./ -. # 1
)C"C* !
!,
'2/# :/
1 !!
/-# /.
%
" $
&&'
1 1 ,! % 1 !9 ! %
!
9
:/&//-.67 D!
1 )C"C* , 2::.2##&67
,
%4 2&$ :2./67 ,
&
% " #2
) &&'
* % "
,
# %& &
!' " (# # !)*+,-.,/&&,0, "
!1 "& 2 # )*+*+.3&&,43 $5 &!1$"25 62) '!.
*+*7)4.&&0/3 9 ( " '!1 6 (&"
! *+*/)*.&&7,3
9 ( " '!) 2.
%0
" #2
) &&'
* % 3 ! ; '
$#
7 F4, )
3 !
!
"
"
; " <
. !
"
2 " " "
! !
" 7
"!
!!
2 "
% "* "
! !
"
"
" !
!
!
!"
!
= "
.!
. !
"
! "
"!
4* "
2
> ""
?
- -
!!
'! " >
! ! ! #
!
"" " ! "
!
%
2
"
" "
-
! " !
! %" !
" :
"" : ,.!
"
7
#
.
"
! *
"
!
! "
" @ 4"
! "
A 34 " A 3 4
A
- 34!
40 #
"
,.!
!
" .!
) 0343434 !" "
"
>
" ;
<;
< "
"
"
!" ! $.
"
"
!
" :) ""
! !
"
"
! "!
2 "
" "
-"
! !
"
2 "* 5"# 47%
"
B > "
# C 3 ! * " "
! ") 0"* # 8A " * D
3 ! 4A
* # &
2
(
! "
.
# " ;
< .
" !
"
%
" "
"
2 <
"" "# 4/) $ 3$#4") 0"11# # !
"
* "* "
!!
"
" % ! $ 3$#4
"
!!
"
!! " 44 ) &!3 !
! ;!
! " < ) 0 2 !"!
!
!
!
" "
" !
!
!
%
"
"
"
"
"
! 43 # C 3 ! *
!
" @ 4
! "
" 34! "11# A
3 4 " %*
" "
! "
"
""
" ) 343 4 " 11 # )
" ""
") 304"11# 4: )
3 ! 4* ! "
# $ 3$ #4 ) 0"11# !
!!
"
" :"
"
!!
"
" "
! "
:
" 2;!
! < ;!
<
2
"
9 !!
" !
"
'# !"" 4- &
"
+ E D 3 ! 4%
!
!
"
!
!
! "
3+ # C 3 ! 4
"
! . @ 34 "
A 34
2
A 34
! =
" "
!!
" !!
>
""
%
! "
!
" >
>
"
!
! >
3, )
3 !
! ! ) 0"11 # !
"
!
! " :
!!
"
" !
!
"
2 2"!
>
"
!
"
+ !G .
H
%, ,1
#&&& ,
1
!,
1 ,
!
./ - -.
, !
1
--/.
,
1 %4 4
1
1
, 1 1
% 1
3 B3
" #2(-+
) &&'
* , 3 !
% 1 ! ,!
% 1 3 (+ (+ B3
>
%,
, %,
% % !
, , !
-8 ,
0% =, : .- -. # 3
3 7& ,
, !
#8 , =,
0% %!
%
=,
0% 1
- H %,
,1 % )C"C*
3 =,
!
=,
1 -.
1
1 -. #
% !
3 0% =,
1 %0
% %0
" #2
%
,
! !, ,,
%0
% # H
%,
,1 1 1 %!
%
%
$. .
1 %! ();* *+ % !
-/ -$67 %! :- -.
() * + 1 %! % % !
2- 67 %!
/.
3 1 %! %
, % ! ?
3 (?
+ 1% , 1 %! % ! <
1 1 ,
)1* % 3 ! ;
"
,
"
!) 2.
>
* ,
?
$
!
! !, ,,
,
/
% ,
!
1
!
!
4 '
@, $
!
,
1
+'5 2167
/ 4-/ #
4
E! 2
- @ F-7 E! @ F-7