High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1555/2010disposed of

Alisher And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2016-02-08Mr. Justice Arun Monga6 pages

!! "" #!$ %!&! " ' !!"!! (""!)&*( +$,)-

.*! !!!"!!!- / ' ! +$,) $*!"! ,- 0!

!0(1$)!2!3( !4!1$)!,,!(23 !"" !1252%!& !+&#!)23 !!"$!23 !!"

!"#$% &'()( 7! ! ""2 ( $& $""!*&

328 $9)) "" ! !! * *!$, !! ! "$!"

"!$, "!"" . """ *+, -.

. """

!,,!3 +$,) !!!*& (!"":$!2( !*& $), ! ,, )) &!;<; 3$!

"!3 !"7=$!&!" > >2 * $" :!0(1$)!2!!:$*&! 4!1$)!23 ! ""$*) """

$2 "! +)*?@0>?@0<2 *

""?@0?@0/ !! $!"$( $*) !)*&. )) 3$!

>( ,( (*& !:$!2*$ (!"":$!!3! (!+$,)! !:$!"! "!3 ; 0$+*$!& 8.$!2; /2**+)$!:$ A $* @"!,2)$ 2" $ *))!( . (!"":$!" 3,!3! ,", > ,3 , "

. >(/;9 )!( ! """

*$3 )$!, 9% $*) (!"":$! !!$& :3:$! 3+$!2$ ,, +$,)!!*& 7$B :$!

2 $! !$*) ""!$& !, *,3 ! "$!" )2)$ 2

/ ! """!

%!&:, 8%,2;< ! !*! !!

;< $ 3+$! :3:$!. ( 2' $)2" ""

! "$!" ) 3, ! $!"$ * !2 $2 $*) ""!)", ))))! !",! ! )"$,+$,) & 3*$3,"( (9$ !) "$!3( !) $"!& +$,)!

(!"":$!* !:$!*!! !+&#!)2!!"$!2!$""!, * >$*) $ &!;; (@

)*!! ) ;<;( , ! &! !, &2 (!"":$! ) $ ,!$ $(*!!*&( ). "" !)?@0 ?@0/" & $ !, &2 * &" >" ! "(9 &!;

/. ( 9(,

,"!3!9 3

,,!3( "! !&!"!"!3

! A8)(* ! $ ! $! $"!& !) "" !1252%!&2$*) ' ""! !! ' !0(1$)!2!*$$*) "! "!3

> > %!&C4 $!"$ !! )2 ;;

2 """

$! ,!&??3$), & ! , $! ! :,!& & & 3 !, * ! ! ) * "!3 !, ! A 3 !!$ ! "!""! ""!*9(!! :$!*( $* ""39 +$! :3 :$! &!;; ( )$!" !) "$!$ )(

) > !:$! ! 3, $ )2, "

)!*& ' $)"!!!" ""?@0?@0/ 3*$*)*& "" "

! "$!" ) !" 3, * !$!"$. $, 2(!"":$! , " ""*,*$ )*! 2 $ +)*?@0>?@0< ! &!;

> 2;< </2;

2;;

;/ ( "

*$3," "$7! 9 *!3&2 !3"! , !!*& (!"":$!!"!$ !*(

! "#$

%&!'%&!( )'* )+ ,*- *

,*- . "

." "

$ "

. 0 . "

39) &! ,,

) 3$! >*$=$& $!

""!)$. (!=$!"!! !( (*, """

9!! ,!3 3!!!2 &A*,$ $2 )& 3(2 """

* !,

!"!"!3 ;*(;<

) > $! !) )!*& !,, *, "&) !$,)$(!)2A) 3( ) *$!* ,*$ :$!9" &( !,! !D& !! 3,*" ""$*)*& "" "

A),!)( $*) !1$)! "" ""!)$2 +$! :3 :$!"! $)D!$$*&7$B $"! $2 ! !2 , (!"":$!33 +$! :3:$!*,*!!$* !*& !,&2 )) 3$! > !*&

!). "

$!* " >33 *& 9. %!&!

!"!)!! ""$*) ! ) !3$!

; /;< ) """

!( (2

"! !*&( "! ) !) !" ! "& !! :$! " "" !). ! !2 > **!&2 !3 " "

9 " !A$ $2"

! 3! " > !( * 9 " *"

!( ( ' !)!2""" (/(''()"