← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1692/2016dismissed

United India Insurance Co Ltd v. Malti Tiwari And ORS

2019-05-21Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill8 pages



  !" #

"  

  $%"%&''( 

 

    

   

   

         

  !"

 

  

()*!+ , , +,++ # $  %

""

 &'  (   )*+ ,-./(/0,-1  ( 2)*+ 3303(/0,-1  4 5  &'  ( )*+ 3303(/0,-1  (  , /)*+ ,-./(/0,-1 !   , /)*+ 3303( /0,-1   '  /306/0,7  #  85

&'  ( 6)*+ ,-./(/0,-1 99999 +,++-  

"

 (*+ ,-./(/0,-  *+ 3303(/0,- :    (      0-0,/0,-&

:  

    &:  )(

;  ;1 *+    ,-./  (  /0,-& 

 :  (  :      < 

 

"" =  (   :  &:   *+    3303 ( /0,-&

 :  (  :     

& 8" (   :   

(    ' 

*

8( ' &( :">

( *+ ,-./( /0,-    '     ! ,--(         )(

  ; ;1&   #   & 

'"  "

 %

& "

  /-0?/0,6&  : ,000 & 8 < '#

 "'

 (  

 '#

 &  8 



                  #    & 

 :    '#

  ""

 

  : ,020 & 

 

 8    &@ %  &:   &

8  : "  "     % <27<<0727&   '  :      !"

, 

 ""  ( :  

"  :  (   

 (&(  "

( 

8 ' 

A 

.

(  

" :&  #  

(@ %  &:   &: #   

 @ %  :   * 2,? /-0?/0,6& !  /7.& 206<#&# ! :   & "   "    ,<  !"

&   

    : B><!   '"  (./-?C<   (,,&000C<:" (%

   

= 

      

   ""   '"  (     (("  '   :

,<  !"



" ("(         

(,3&?6&/.-C<&  (( ,3&?6&200C< 

(  ( < &

   $< ,   /0&/-?)./-?C<D ,,&000C<1 /

 ,C2  2 

.

6 

  

(   ,&00&000C< 3 * >       /3&000C< $ /  -01-

2) ""

' ( &   ': (

&:   <

 &   : & :

""=  ( & 8"

   (  (  (        (    <

   

'    

:

:37

:     (#A</<5 " !"

& 

 8"    8    %  

 &  

     "

&  <       "(3?



  & 

 ':

   8"

 (  : /0&/-?C<    '    "(3?

 ( & (  

 ' :



"   ':  ./-?C<   ( 

"   ((  :" ': &7600C<%  (   (   



    (: 

 :     ( :

   (   

(   :'    

: 

(    

  ":

"   ( %   ""   /0:

((    " 

( 20&000C<     ( &         8"   

 

 %

 (

: '    (  :   (#A<3<4  5

!"

  '     "(3?

&:

'( 

:

& :

    "

'   ( &  &     (

:  32

  (

 

 (#A<,<   ( &  " :37 

  (

 ' & 



'      "

 

    (: 

<   :      :   '   (     '"

( 

     "

"    ' 



8 /-0?/0,6 

  "" '"( (("

8: " " % <27<< 0727:  ,<  !"

  (  "(   &  :37

   <     

32

  (

  

& B>#<2& 

:  ' &   :3.



( "  (

 :6?

 060,/002  (   : >  :   (#A<,& '  ' 

  >  "(  B' &    >< & " 

  ((  "

:  : ( &  

"



  ":37

  (

 :

(  <   &B>#</  (     (         &        :  ( 

     '"  ( ./-?C<:" ><    ,,&000C<(   %

& "



: :

%;:!



3$$ $5%678+  %9

 $5%6-   .  ,

1       

      

:  (   >(   

& (   '   :   (   

          

  ( 7600C<     :"

' (  

:

(    (./-?C< 

 "  

: : %;:!

 

 %/% %:%// $5%6 ; 5$6 ,$ $% 6 <6$ 6<6 $'  $5%6-

01  '7'/ == (  :" ' :   

 :( : ( 

 :

' (    :  ( :((  ' :: 

 (

  

'(  '   

       <  :  (   :  (      200,/0,?

 

+:   66<(/0,3*+ /?3/(/0,6  " *+ ,0//?(/0,6& ( '    &    :  (   "

(20&000C<  :"  8(  ( "  '  >  ' "

 (#A<3 ((  8,0:

((    "  8(  ( " ( & (  

:

/0&/-?C<       :37

  (

=

&  

            (  ,0E   

  (  (



: (( 8"' :

'  ( %;: !



 $' /36 &% 4< 9+'4'$%76  9,%$5'

$5%6-  = ,

0

(,C2 

 :   (.   

 :    ,&00&000C<

:  :   



 (      /3&000C< 

 :        ( > :  ,0&000C<( 

(  %' &  

(,3&000C<

( ( >  

(    ,  

( 60&000C<  

    /  

(60&000C<( 

(      ( "( %;:!



  >4 %%6 / 36 &% 4< 9+'4'$%; 3

4?

53563

4 $5%6-  01  '7'/-...    ,602/0,.( 

*+ /,,0(/0,-& *,56'

%%6 /36 &% 4< 9+'4'$%;!% $8 36 $5%6;&     

   

(  (

&

< 8 $< ,   (  /0&/-?C< /0/-?C<)/0/-?C<F/0/7C<1 //&/.3C< /    (  ((

   ( ,0E //&/.3C))//&/.39,C2G762/C<1 @,6&?-2C< 2

(,C2 

(

  >

6    ( " (.

,6&?-2C<>,/>.,-&03&/06C< 3 * >

,3&000C< - 

(   ,3&000C< 60&000C< 7 



   , 60&000C< ? 

(  

    / $ / 4<% $'@  =- - 12)



 &        : 

  

(     :'   

  :                    (

  (73E   (   (("(      H      (   :

      :   

    A   :'   (           (

&*+ 3303(/0,-  ( *+ ,--/( /0,-  

 A+,++B



   3>%

8   8"C  $ I     : $ I