Bodhdeep Pal And ORS v. Ut Of Chandigarh And ANR


 
 

 

 ! " " #" $% 
&"  " '!
   ! ""
  
    ! "
"  ! " (")"*"+& +",#-  ("+) ,#

" !" ("+* ,#

""! "#$%&' &(()*+  % !"  !   
&" ,*" &- " .&* $%
&" !  (
&/ $%
&"  0"1  & &/""!""/ "  "  *  "&&% !!"   
&" ,*"!" % !*." -/- #/*"#-" *!"! "& $%
&" !"&/*"+"  "   " ""*/!"

 % "        ( 
&    $% 
&"  * )#"*(
&2! 
&" 3-/   "

% #/ "* (

+"" !,35 
" 0"&3+6'37$%

&" !+ " 
&-!

  &/"" !""/ "*$%
&" !- !&8 83 833 "* 
&" %  *"!-  &/""3 "  &/""- *  "1"* !&
83833 "* 
&" +/1  "

 ""- " "*   "1"*-""!& 833 "*  $%
&" ' * + 9/ 2" 2* " .*& $%
&" ! /!&
833 "* $%
&" %  "/"&*&*
&" 


::


 

    

-  &&  &/""% -"!--#9&*

; 

! -   /<,<"4 -  -" !  ,=",!!- / 
&" ,*" & 9&*/ *-!  #&/""  ",.. ( " *- .** " (
& !&  !!  #    *" &-""/ " ""+&&  #   !  &/"" !&
833 <*    "*           $  %""" 
&"         
 ;;

   

  9&*-/."/ +& &>  *",!  9&*

 

:!/  #  =,

: /<,<"4 -  -"! % *  *"!&/ " "

+&& " "" 9&*  #  " "

"* !&  !"" "* ""&*  2-#"

"  ,*+

4

 ">*!"! !

-   /<,<"4

&!"# ""

!&833"<* "* $%
&"

 "* /"/* "& "#&!" &/"" !&8 83833<* "*  $%
&" -/& -% ""-  !"!,<"4

- & "& 
 

    

    

 *- -#9&*  

 ! -   /! "",<"4:% ""-"/"/"" $% ,*"-" "* " ""- <-*  .!#- "1"* *
1  !"*

/' 
&" ,*" !""*&

"*& &/""&"-  #       !% * /!""

 "& ,<"4; *"!"4 ,  !
!"
 

" '-..-*-).-

       

  

   

 !" #  $  
 
%# &

'

('(

)*

 **  ('   +$,- " .

  /

0 1 

.   0 1 "   ""2 ""  

 3 4 3 ,553  67  ,"

"" $  "

38 
8



2   "



9

9

"

:"" ; .  

 0 1 "





":""

27  

""

" 





 ) ""  2" "

9   2""

9

$

9 



""



9

$

9

< 

 2      * 

"

  " 7   

   " 2  &

7

1 =   



 >


 2""

?   

<



2 

 "

"

67 :3 67  2   

.   " 7  "

.  : " 2?    :  2 .    @ 



   



"

  " 7   

   " 2  &

$  7

27  ""

  7 2""

7

   ?:7      "      3:01    " &AA1 "

 % !"-"! & &/"" /&"/ "/""##  #  9&*!      !3*/  9&*

/&"4!"!! /"" "&

 3 "! / $%,*"  /!   ""!"#"-  "   

/  !3  "-"&" /  * /"-  &  *"/ * "+  /  " #/*!- 0" " 9&*   2?/+!"*"

# 

$    %&

 &'

()*+(+,-  /.!* % " -"

" /&& + 9/2"-".&$%
&"  !  /.!* : %   "#"  #"""-  ,  *## "!"  9&*       ! 9&* /* "4!"/  $%,*" ; ="  "    "     !"  /*              !     /  "    */&         "1"* !&833 "* $%
&"  "/""3 /   "$%
&" ! -  #!8 83833<* "* $%
&" */&#!" "/  **/&#  " $%
&" /&&#/ & /"&+

9/ 2"2* " ! */&"

 *!&&/"" * "1"* 833 /&! "* $%
&"  " ,*+

, &  *"! /."

 /&& & /"&+ *" #" "& $%
&"

*!/!& "833<* "*  $%
&"   % !"-  #    "/9 &

@ A """ "$%,*"   &/""2  "  #        !  #/ *!*% "1"*

!&833<* /" " ,*+

*&  " ! -  #".*  / !"#&/""% ""/& *!*&&"*"**> 

   *""1"* #/ /"   -  ! "** "+  !!$%
&"  %   "& *!& &/""  0"& "#" ""!"" !"&"!  "* 9&*      !4 B.

 ""  ((



2  7

    "7

 6"



%

  D "

 7""

&. /

 
 000  1  0

  2,

 

3(04% .(-- 3," % .

&" B'"#  

 ,31

:B

:


"  0"&3+ 6'37 ;

$% 
&"  %@@ + 
6+
7

:B

"- / 6-7 BCC

)" ;C &    "" 



7

:      "2 2"     "

 "

  *  2"     "

  * 



EE 3

7"" 6"

  

2 > " +#2>-



  " 7

     7 #2> 

1 ""  

  ((

 "28 32.  500 



     



 %  66     #0 +6"

- 3
 #  2 > "
-

1 

  """

"7 6"

A""
 + (8- 

1 

" 7 





 D  +=" D -

"

:"" ; .  

 0 1 "





":""

1  27   2

7    :D8 7  7 " 

):

:

8 + -8(:

  

'

) ( 
%# &

 **    

 ""         0 1 +  !01
!-   7    "" 

"

 "" 

2 7 





 D 

"

:"" ;

 

1   2 7    D       3 #  

G  #  ""2     8

1 

"   # 

1 

 # 



""

? 

#  67  >  # "

 .  7 

+##8 5- " 

:

:)*8

## :)C )  C H

))C > 

::)C8

##8:)(C  (

H"

)) > 

:

:)*8 ##::



 H

)))   

 >  # "

 

""





  7 



9

9 D 

# 

 2 

  :



9

9 D    =7" D 

;

": 

 +0 1- 2   # 

""

"

 ""



 72

    (  '

%# 

C)  '

 

!" #   
 "" 

 

  )8 2

""

 "  B1 

""

7 

  :


"

D  "



9

9

3 #  ."

 

"

 3  2    3    =   2"  

 



 3

%   D   

 

  D 

<< << << <<  

   I" 3
 % # 

(CC   " '

/    % 

 

(   

" 72 2 ? 7  3 .

7 "

 

 2  

  =" D 

3 .

1 ""

""

7 2"  3 2" 7 2""

2    

    2 

 

 

     7  7  
 D  2  ." C
  



 3:01  " 

<< << << <<  2"  " 7  2



 

  2 "

5 2 7   

  "  D   "

+  

2  2?"- 2   "

 2 7

 "

  "

  " 2

 "   "

 

*@ .""

 = 2 "

 3  

*@ .""

 = "

 2" 

"

    3

1 "  D   ""

    ?      2   7 

 ""

%  

   2  2



   

  "  7"" " 2 D  



<< << << << 1

 ="

2 

 

"

 D    

 2   2 7       7

 

  #   2"  



" "

9

"

3 

 2"    #   2" " 2? "

  3 #   7

    3 7 



   

 3

1  2 ""

7

<< << << << 1 2"  7 3 = " ""

 3   2

      " 3 27  

  7"    2 3  2    "

    3 :

 

"  

   3

% 72 



 2

   7  

.

  2  


    "":

"

    "

 2" D  

   

 2 2





1  " " 



    # H!

 + - 3 " 7    ?     "

2   3   "



.

 7 2 7 "    7  

  2  

   "    

% 2"  " " -      

 

    

 D 

  D 

"  7

% 7      

   "   " 

  2""

 

"  "?

?

2 2 

"7  ""

"  2 "7

 2 "   
 ""

27  !   "

    "

 

 2?  2" ?2  "

-  2 7

     3 2" 

" 



  3 :

1    2""



;  ""

  2 7   "      3 2"  " 



&"

 .""

 ?

&AA1

""

?    "

  

? 



% 

    7 

 3 # !"#&!" " "* !""+  , &  ! /" !" -- /.!! " "* & /"&+ .*$%
&"  "!&833<*

"* $%
&" # &    

 ! "  ""/"/"" % # "& 

*
&"  "/9 "

*! "*/&& & /"&+- " * & /"&+"/9 *!

"*  $%
&" %   $%,*"   !" " -!"//      ,*""/

"! "* + 9/ 2"- !"#! !*.& ".!&#-  "  "- "D# &  ,*" /& .!!"!"!.!&#- -/ & !"!  "*9&*   

 % *!&!" -  # !! "+!!*$%
&"

-#"

" ,*+



!"*

-  #!8
&" .* $%
&"

<!& *$%
&"  *!    %     

    "         *    $%
&"

           "  #&       /  ">      9&*      !%   # "/""<  *!&""


1 -   !" !"&"!    *!&&/""6,<"4;7 /"/"" 1 ## ,"  
 3% !"   !"&"!  #> B 27 



""

" 





 ) ""  2" "

9   2""

9

$

9 



""



9

$

9

  "&

1 

 % -"!- $%,*"" *.* (

+"
&"&  
  3"  !4      #*5 +

 


   %-(%-'-6'()7*- -.8