← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2805/2015dismissed

Reliance General Insurance Company Ltd v. Asha And ORS

2018-12-19Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill16 pages



!"

 #! $

"% 

$ "

 

&'() $*+

$+,- .

     

  

 

     $

 

&'()    

  

 

   $

 

&'()    

  



   $

 

&'()    

 







   "(.

/0 ("1!1

1

 

    ! " # $  % ! " & '&

&(   ( ! "  )*#+,-)./0 /. /1")/'0 "  02+,-)./2")/'0$ 33333 1

00

 4 ( 5   "+,-)./0")/'0 +, )./2")/'0 +,-)./1")/'0+,-)./.")/'0    "

 67/*/2)/') 6 ).'')/'8 

 

 4  7#"  9 9$ 

&(  !    "             &  75    "    6                7  !      6    ).'')/'8 +  6 " % '22"

  "   74-/*")/')     9     

       7     

9  5   ""% #  

(

"+,-)./2")/'0

4-/)")/')  9   7  

9  75  "(  !   !#  

( "+,-)./0"

)/'0 4-/8")/')  9  7  

9  75  "(  !  !#  

( "+,-)./1"

)/'0 4-/'")/')  9  7  

9  75  "(  !   !#  

( "+,-)./."

)/'0+  7"! " 5: "

+,- )./0")/'0

"" 6  % # $6 ";   6

% 4 6 "

 !!5/*/2)/')% 56 6"& 6   6 55"

   5 5 ;&<<&

&4&'<)1



  "% # $6

5 6 ;6 5=

 %54 % !  5 

7 5 5 ;&82& &<8)/6 5 # $ 6         

76  7   >   ! " "

   

 

5 7 "

766 5 75

 55 6  

 " %   ; 6"    ! (     6 7 ! ;     5:"( 

 6  4 "

 6  "

 (55

;  > ( 6 "

     "  + -'0</*/2)/')  % ).* **1 **.

*/8&  6 5       ?

7   55" '& 7     !  "    ""5  

7          

7  6   7 55 6  4  6  

  55 75"!   6   

& 

" 10 ///@&6 6    4-/)")/')  "(  !   ! 

"8' ///@&6 6   4 -/8")/')  "(  !

! ' '0 ///@&6 6   4-/8"

)/')  "(  ! !        6  ** 21 ///@&       



4-/*")/')  ""% 

! 55 ! "

  ! "

 & 

 -  

 5             ?

   "

   6             :         "

 6   ""%         "    & 

   !   5



 5 ?

6 

  55"

 ! """5

7  ?

 7/*/2)/')   ! "   66 5575    !5    ! 

75 

7"

54 "  6   66 5 " 55  "

   ""

 

! !5  !  5   !6 6%   " 

  "

=&8& #$""   ! "  "

 5   7"

7         "     

    "    6

   "                    5   "

  554 "   

   "  

   " # $"4 " 5- 6+*7

-86,+ 9:;

09*+  &) ""

&<7) 2  "



  % 6 "%"; 6 75

% 6; 4 "  6 "

  ;   

  

      >  "

>  ! A   )//2% ?

6  !66@ 6 6  !

  4 "      

  5  "

 "  

   6 

  !"   "     "   ! "

!  !   " 5"5" 

   "    "  

"    "

      

        "      6            65    

& ( " 

!    "   !

   6 

     !           7     /*/2)/')!!5""5

7  !%  + -'0</*/2)/')#A:&)$ 6 5   "



 #  " &% $



  /*/2)/') 6 55""

 ! !556    " 5"

 6"6  % 6  5  6 56 6" 



 6

"65 6 =  %54

% !% 5  

7 5 5 ;& 82& &<8)/6 5 6   -5  

76

 4   ""   !  ;  

7"

4

7 6 6  7 : 5

 6 7"%   4     !  (  46 7 ! ; 

 &6 "

 (55

;  >6 "

   

>+ -)0</*/2)/')  % ).* **1 **. */8&

6  5   56 "

5  !  '1'')/')6 "5        "  



7?

6

 7  6 7"

  "    "" 

 ""6  66 555

7"

 "  5 "&   55 "

    "  "     "

    5?

7   55" ! """5

7 4 "      5!



  6

7?

6  755

 6 7"4

 &" 6  "    ?

  7" ! "

# $55 "  55      %        6,=* 1  *=+6 5- 6+*7

-86,+ 9:;

09*+

*=+6- &) ""

&<7)    

!  !"

  " "  55 "! 5"

     57   

 5 " 555?

 6  !  "(



"       ""5

76  755  6 7"   

 67 !66  5

      

 6     :            !5

! 6 755  

 "  

76

7"     !    " 7     :   ! "

76  

 "  "  

75  



7     !

7   

!-

! !

  &     #=&8$   "    

55    

7?

6 5 7

 "  

6 66



 

74 " ! 6 5 " 55 5?

4 "    5  ?

 

   55" ! """5

7 4     6!                   "    "  !        ;   

  

     > ">  ! A   )//2# "

"

 ; 



  $   "

 " 6    ;9%      "+7,+ ++67

-86,+ 9:;

09*+ 5- 1=-= 1=69 6- &3) ""

&<7)      !   !        "     & 5!  ; 



 

    !  6   

6 7     " ( 5  " ;9 %      * 7

-86,+ 9:;

09*+ 5- #6;

1+*= 6-  &3) ""&<7) 

 (>9 ++67

-86,+ 9:;

09*+ 5- 8 "9 ?

=8=868 "9

*=+6-<7 ::+7 





 6->

8*

10# &<7) 2 

 +,+

     6 

" ** 21 ///@&

   ""% % "

               "  #A:&'$   )) .//@&  "

 5:   )) 0//@&+    "

*/B!

""    "'8  "'@*  

 

"'0 ///@& ")0 ///@& 6  ""

  : 

"  

"0/ ///@&  "

"   '7" !"""

      "( 5";9%   5   

9  #%  $  "

 

"' 2/ ///@&" 

"  # 

  "$  6    ""

% +,-)./2")/'0  

&6 7

& ' 4"  )) .//@& )    "  5:

)) 0//@& ) > "'@*   "

: )) 0//@@#)) 0//3'@*C10//@&$ A'0 /// '0 ///@&'0///D80//@&$ '< 0//@& * 4"  ""

  

"*/B 8  " 5  "'8 '< 0//@&:'):'8*) 12 ///@& 0 %

   8/ ///@& 2 +  :

'0 ///@& 1 

"  '0 ///@&



8/ ///@& . +   8 "   ./ ///@& <      )*  " E 8/ ///@&

*7 9:+-*  23    "  &  @

&(



" *) 8/ ///@&  ! ;  



  >" "% # $ 6 /./)'<2.;6 !   )/)24 "  

"

*) 8/ ///@& !       4

 

") )2 ///@&  ""%   +,-)./2")/'0  !   "10B  "

"

"5" F-

   "   

     " " 5 

+,-)./2")/'0    ":  >  "4   "

"

    

 &  

""       (   6          "

5          ?

  5    )0B



      "#A:&*$ & 

 !    

"" 5 "

       "  )0B  =&*&>  % 7 %5 > %    % 7   !    "   "       "

/*/2)/')/)/1)/')>  5

 "   5:  !    7&A   6 5 (55

;  > 6   " /*/2)/')  

 & 5*0

6 

6"4  ?

7/*/2)/')% !   

&6"      ?

  6    "      65  4  +,-**<0")/'0

" 

6" 1 ///@&   67         )/''         "           

    

"  1 ///        &     

?

    

!6"( 5";9%   1;+ 1B +*, < $<- 7 (>+6 !*+



-86,+ 9:; 3 &) ""

&<7) 

 "

 " 

'/B 

4 "  

"

 1///:'/@'// 1//@&  =  "" 5        "  8/B       "    "

""

   G#1//C

2

#1// D 8/B$HC <./@&  '' 12/@&  5" ( @6 *0

"  "   "'2   "( 5";9 %    19* 167 5+69

*=+65- $+7=

6-:

6* 6:

6*  6 

&2) "" &<7) 

" 5 

 ' .. '2/@&G'' 12/D '2H &  "

 

"0/ ///@&"  

"" 5   

"'/ ///@& "    5    "   

        

")0 ///@&" 

"   6  &  " (  !  

&6 7

&  

  ' 

" 5

' .. '2/@& ) 

"" 5

0/ /// * 

"

0 /// 8 % '/ /// 0  5

'/ /// 6

*7 2@&       6       4      @ 

    "

 "

  6 7 !  

"10B   "

""5"

 F

3

     "#A:&8$ & 

""  .B "  &6

"" 5 "



5   76& "

 "" 



6  ! 5 6    5

 " # 7&>$ 6  69   6 ! 

6  "

   



9 4 " '2 ///@&6    "   6! 

"

)0 ///@&" 

"" 5# "'0 ///@&$ 6 

"

)0 ///@& "

"

5    

""    "'/ ///@&"  5  4

&  

"12 ///@&  "(  ! !      "10B  "

""5" F -

   "  

 

 

     "#A:&0$ &

""    :"80B    " A:&0     

""   "

  965  "  "     

 @ "

 6 "

6

5  



"66  "I46( 6 J<)6 #" "$  "  9&   "

/*/2)/')'0/2)/');6 '0

"



"   ! &

! "

 66 ! " 

" "4

"&



0/ ///@&    & 

?



!6"( 5";9%     

          

! ""  ! #$%

5    !6    !      "

 "&

 )/B4 " 

" 0/ ///:)/@'// '/ ///@&   =  "" 5        "  8/B       "          "  

 "  "

            G#'/ ///@& & #'/ /// D 8/B$H  '8 ///@      5  "   ( @&  6  '0  

         "      "    "'.   "( 5" ;9  %        19* 167 5+69

*=+6- 5- $+7=

6-:

6* 6:

6*  6 

&2) "" &<7)  

   

 '()  & "

 

" 0/ ///@&"



"" 5   

" )0 ///@&" 

"  0/ ///@&" 

"

5  0///@& 6  "



   5 '/ ///@&0///@&6    "  5     

")0 ///@&" 

"   6  & " (  ! 

&6 7

& %  - ; "   ' 

" 5

) 0) ///@& ) 

"" 5 0/ ///@& * 

"

5 

0/ ///@& 8 

"

)0 ///@& 0    5

0///@& 2 %  5

'/ ///@& 6

*7 2    6 4 &

  "

 "  6 7 !    "10B    "

""5" F  ?

 +,- )./0 )./1)./.")/'0   

6 

 +,-)./2")/'0    6 

&(  "      &

&(

  +,-)./2")/'0 +,- )./0 )./1)./.")/'0    " E0 1

00F  

8>+ -G= = 75@   K @- =   K @-