High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5079/2013disposed of

Hanso Devi & ORS v. Gurtej Singh & ORS

2018-08-28Mr. Justice Satpal4 pages

!"# $#%&'&() * * * +,"!('#-&!($".#/' 00#11!("' 2#/'3' 3/"#4+&(5.!1&!'#4!!($!(".#/ #'0($#("'

/#'#(") /3(&'.63,!/!/57$-%!"# /".#!00#11!("' / +3-&/ #8!(7 $-%!"# / /#'0($#(" 9('3/!(%# ,0!(:

.&' !00#!1 .!' ;##( &1#$ ;: ".# %1!&,!("' '##<&(5 #(.!(%#,#(" ".# %,0#('!"&( !8!/$#$ " ".#, ;: "/ %%&$#(" 1!&,' /&;3(!17 !"#.!;!$ =/&;3(!1> / './" -&$# !8!/$ $!"#$ (!%%3(" $#!". /#,63,!/!1&!' /#,.!($&(!,"/ -#.&%1#!%%&$#("( .#%1!&,!("'78.!/#".#8&$8!($%.&1$/#( ".#$#%#!'#$7

&1#$ ! 0#"&"&( 3($#/ +#%"&( ?? ".# "/ 2#.&%1#' %" '##<&(5 %,0#('!"&((!%%3(" ".#$#!". /#,63,!/!1&!' /#,.!($&(! ,"/ -#.&%1# !%%&$#(" 8.&%. "< 01!%# ( * $!"#$ 8!'/#5&'"#/#$!5!&('"/#'0($#("!" 1&%#+"!"&(+!$!/7 .!(!"8!'!-#//#$".!" /#,63,!/8!'@ :#!/'1$!"".#"&,# .&' $#!".#%#!'#$8!'!,!'(;:0/ #''&(7#!/(&(5!;3"'7 9A"

7 9A 0#/ ,(". 1!&,!("' 8#/# 311: $#0#($#(" 30( ".# $#%#!'#$ ,0#('!"&(8!'".3'0/!:#$ /

.#1#!/(#$/&;3(!1(%('&$#/!"&( ".# !%"'!($#-&$#(%# (/#%/$.#1$".!"".#!%%&$#("&(B3#'"&("<01!%#$3#"".#/!'.!($ (#51&5#("$/&-&(5

#($&(5-#.&%1#;:/#'0($#(".#/#&'($&'03"# /#5!/$&(5".#!;-#'!&$ &($&(5 ".#1#!/(#$/&;3(!1(".&'&''3#78.&%. .!' !""!&(#$ &(!1&": C#!/(#$ /&;3(!1 3/".#/ !%%#0"#$ ".# !5# ".# $#%#!'#$" ;#@ :#!/'!"".#"&,# .&'$#!".' (%1#!/!($ %5#(" #-&$#(%# '.8&(5 ".# #D!%" #!/(&(5 ".# $#%#!'#$ 8!' /".%,&(57 ".# 1#!/(#$ /&;3(!1 %('&$#/&(5 ".# #03": ,,&''&(#/ /!"#' / ".# ,&(&,3,8!5#' !,!'(7!''#''#$.&'&(%,#!'' @* 9A0#/,(". #$3%"&( 9@". 8!' #

#%"#$ "8!/$' ".# 0#/'(!1 #D0#('#' "#/ !001:&(5!,31"&01&#/ 7""!1$#0#($#(%:8!'!''#''#$!"' 7 7* 9A (".#/'3, ' 7 9A8!'!8!/$#$ /".#1'' %('/"&3,!($1-# !($ !

#%"&( '3, ' 7 9A 8!' !1' !8!/$#$ "8!/$' 3(#/!1 #D0#('#'!($1!'"/&"#'!($"/!('0/"!"&(.3'7%1!&,!("'8#/#.#1$#("&"1#$

/""!1%,0#('!"&( ' 77* 9A!1(58&".&("#/#'"E F0#/!((3,

/, ".# $!"# &1&(5 %1!&, 0#"&"&( "&11 /#!1&'!"&( #'0($#(" ('3/!(%#,0!(:8!'.#1$1&!;1#"0!:".#!,3(" %,0#('!"&(" ".#%1!&,!("' C#!/(#$ %3('#1 / ".# !00#11!("' !/53#' ".!" %,0#('!"&( !8!/$#$"".#!00#11!("'(##$'";##(.!(%#$&(%/#!'#(!%%3("

3"3/# 0/'0#%"' .!' ;##( !

/$#$ #$3%"&( 9@". .!' 8/(51: ;##( #

#%"#$ "8!/$' 0#/'(!1 #D0#('#' (%,# !' !''#''#$ &' .8#-#/ (" $&'03"#$ " &' ".3' 0/!:#$ ".!" ".&' !00#!1 ;# !118#$ !($ %,0#('!"&( !8!/$#$;##(.!(%#$

C#!/(#$ %3('#1 / ".# ('3/!(%# ,0!(: .!' /# 3"#$ ".# !;-# '!&$ !/53,#("' 8.&1# '3;,&""&(5 ".!" ".# &,035(#$ !8!/$ .!' %//#%"1:;##(0!''#$!($(5/3($ /!(:#(.!(%#,#("&',!$#3" .!-# .#!/$ 1#!/(#$ %3('#1 / ".# 0!/"&#' !($ .!-# 5(# "./35.".#/#%/$8&".".#&/!;1#!''&'"!(%# 5# ".# $#%#!'#$ &# @ :#!/' &' (" &( $&'03"# (%,# !''#''#$ !" ' @* 9A &' !1' (" &( $&'03"# /&,!/: !/53,#(" /!&'#$ ;: 1#!/(#$%3('#1 /".#!00#11!("'&'".!"&(-&#8 ".#53&$#1&(#'1!&$$8( ;: ".# (>;1# +30/#,# 3/" &(

!"# $ % & # ' $ '

()*+ ,-. ,/. *))07 @ F &(%/#!'# &( &(%,#.!'";#!

/$#$(!%%3(" 3"3/#0/'0#%"'#$3%"&( 9@". "8!/$' 0#/'(!1 #D0#('#' .!' /&5."1: ;##( #

#%"#$ 31"&01&#/ .!' /&5."1: ;##( !001&#$ 1!&,!("' !/# #("&"1#$ " '7 9A #!%. / 1'' #'"!"#!($ 3(#/!1#D0#('#'&('"#!$ ' 7 9A"8!/$' 3(#/!1#D0#('#' !($ 1!'" /&"#'7 ;#'&$#' '@ 7 9A &('"#!$ ' 7 9A " ".# %1!&,!(" 8&$8 /1'' %('/"&3, 00#11!("'A%1!&,!("'!/#7".3'7 #("&"1#$"%,0#('!"&(7 8.&%. &'/#A8/<#$!'3($#/)A

(%,#

@* 0, &#7*

? 9A0#/!((3,

"!1&(%,#!

"#/!$$&"&(!" ".#/!"# @ F(!%%3("

3"3/#0/'0#%"' *

? G @*

? D@ F H7 7??@9A (%,#!

"#/$#$3%"&( 9@". (!%%3(" 0#/'(!1 #D0#('#' 7 7??@I@?7 7??@99@". H @ @*9A @ "!1$#0#($#(%:!

"#/!001:&(5 !,31"&01&#/ @ @*1H@77

9A C'' #'"!"# 7 9A

@ ? C'' %('/"&3,"8& # @ 7 9A

C'' 3(#/!1 7 9A $ @7*7

9A .#!,3(" %,0#('!"&(!1/#!$:!8!/$#$"".#!00#11!("'7 (##$1#''"'!:7'.!11'"!($$#$3%"#$ /,".#!,3("%!1%31!"#$!'!;-# 00#11!("''.!11;# #("&"1#$"&("#/#'"!"".#/!"# F0#/ !((3,(".# #(.!(%#$!,3(" /,".#$!"# &1&(5 ".#0#"&"&("&11/#!1&J!"&( 00/"&(,#(" !,3(" %,0#('!"&( !,(5'" %1!&,!("' '.!11;#&(".#'!,#/!"&!' &D#$;:".#1#!/(#$/&;3(!1&/#%"&(' ".# /&;3(!1 &( /#'0#%" " ,!((#/ $&';3/'#,#(" %,0#('!"&( !,3(" " ".#%1!&,!("''.!11#(3/# K&".".#!;-#'!&$,$& &%!"&(&(".#!8!/$$!"#$ 7 0/#'#("!00#!1&'$&'0'#$ ,

. 2

(4()*4 '.8!/ 5' '

" 637 $89 7 5' '

" : 89 7