Steel Authority Of India Ltd. v. Steel Strips Infrastructures Ltd.
!"
#$%
%&'('
) *
!#+
,$-.
!"
!
*
/ 0 !
1
2
! "#
$
%
! & '
( )
( )
'
* )( )
+ ,-- "..
+ $/" ".. '
* 0 )
( )
'
)( )
+ ,-- "..
+ $/" "..
"
&
",.""..
%
1 ) 2 )
34"../
( 1 51
% (
6)2 (
7
8"9
:
" ) + $/" "..)
;
2
8 "9 $ <
* ( )
2
<
) *
+ ,-- "..
= (
>
?;
&+2& +#@@# #A# 0*B 4.......
".4".44 ,.4"...
#C $,=-" 3=,$=3 ""/4$/ ;%A 4-4..-,- /.,""//= =,""$-,.
;%A /3.....
=.33."/ -.-3."/ ;2 + 4.",44 ,-$-43 ",$/",4 ;%
0 $//$-,/"
4--,4,.
/-44=$-"
% "344 $"-"4 =4.,4 3,, 3433 4 , 3
$
( &
* D2
)22
/3/
E
*
) * + -F3/ $./3/
4)..)...F; ( )
& +
0*)
,;0)2 #
* ..3/3/ *
""."///% ( * * )
C 8 =9
+ $,3= $.$//.F
+ $-.3"3.$//.%
C8.,49 CG<
2G
+ $4",.$ .$.4//. //4/"/$ $,=-"
4 #
*
(
* D
( )
(
(
?;
+ %A+AH % % #) A( & + 2DF/"F"".4 1 )/"
"$/3,4...
"$"34"..
"-43/3..
;
"-43/3..
" 2DF/"F"4"/ 1 )/"
"$==$,...
",44=..
-334-..
;
-334-..
=
$ 2DF/"F"444 1 )/"
4=,-33"4..
4=,-33..
$,..
;
$,..
= 2DF/"F"-$, )/"
../....
.-,/=3..
$"/4"..
;
$"/4"..
4 2DF/"F"-,.
)/"
"4".....
"=34,..
$=3$..
;
$=3$..
- 2DF/"F$.. )/"
$=3,=$$ $=,=3,..
"4-$ ;
"4-$ , 2DF/"F$./ )/"
$"34....
$""4..
-$34..
;
-$34..
3 2DF/"F$$/ )/"
"/4,....
"/43...
;
...
;...
/ 2DF/"F$"3- )/"
""-/.$ "=-44/"4 ;
/-4,/= ;/-4,/= .
2DF/"F$$=$ )/"
"3....
"3.$3-..
,=..
,=..
2DF/"F$$== )/"
=-"....
=,....
=4....
=4....
" 2DF/"F$==/ )/"
"/=,=,..
."3"/"..
""-=44..
;
""-=44..
$ 2DF/"F$4.$ )/"
-"/"3=..
4"3$4/..
../"4..
../"4..
= 2DF/"F$4$- )/"
$"/....
$".34...
.4...
;
.4...
4 2DF/"F$,4$ )/"
$33"....
$,"3-3..
4$$"..
;
4$$"..
- 2DF/"F$,4= A)/"
"$-$4..
"=$--..
;
,$..
;,$..
, 2DF/"F$,4A)/"
4"44....
="3434..
/-/4..
;
/-/4-..
3 2DF/"F$,4A)/"
4==,4..
3$=$"..
;
"/"3=-.
.
;"/"3=-..
/=343$ $$$==/ = -.4$$, 4 ?
?
( ?
;%AF2DF/$.$"
$,....
;%AF2DF/F4=4 /4"..
;%AF2DF/F4=.$ .=.3=4 ;%AF2DF/F4=.$ /3/.4 ;%AF2DF/F$.. "4-$ .4 + 4-4..-,-
4
- (
4-4..-,-
* )
,
+ =,$"4.//
$3="///( $4,..3% ,,..3( /3.....
, % + 4.,.-//$
4.",44
+ /$F$=-.4.4//$ ( C %
$//$-,/"
(
?;
#5$'&67#5(
%%)8#)$ 6&-%5
%:'$%8 ;
6)$ <(= %A+A2DF/F$.$"
1F2DF/"F"" $,....
%A+A2DF/F4"=4 1F2DF/"F"$= /4"..
%A+A2DF/F.4=.$ 1F2DF/"F"$4 .=.3=4 %A+A2DF/F.4=.$ 1F2DF/"F"$, /3/.4 %A+A2DF/"F$.. 1F2DF3.
"4-$ %A+A=/"3F/$"$.$/= ;
/.,..
%A+A"=34F/4 1F2DF/$F3/= -3=..
=34,F/"
1F2DF/$F3/$ /==-"..
44-/F/"
1F2DF/$F3/$ $,=/3..
%A+A434"F/"
1F2DF/$F$- =3"...
%A+A-=4F/"
1F2DF/$F/=- $$-43..
%A+A-=4F/"
1F2DF/$F/=, 4"...
%A+A$3./F/"
1F2DF/$F"-4/ 4=-",..
%A+A$3$,F/"
1F2DF/$F",-"
-=4$..
%
%A + -=.$F/"1F2DF$F/=$ 44$..
3 (
-
% ( + =- $.$/3/
=3$,". + =, $.$/3/
3.,3. "344F;
8"=9
E / %
( * *
G# 0 G (
4"-,=.-.
".,/3/ )
( * * # C<
G2G
C
#C%
#
( ,.$//$ 4-4..-,-
/3.....)4.",44
# 8"=9 '
) *
. A ) 2
&
((
(
,
) 2
# 2
(
"/)"-),"3"5,"-"4,"$&
")..)=,.3/ 6 ",.""..)
( ( '
( )
* 4)..)...F; (
* 3/3/ 3////A
)
/3/ "
7
* #
*
) 2
(
'
)
'B ) &;$ ( """/3/ 5@C&$6 *
*
; #
(
* #
*
@(
*
3
)
*
(
)
//4 )
$
* )
*
5
6)
' )//- 3////# )
# 2
2
= '
* 0 )
5 6
*
E # ;
)
#
C (
4
)
;2
* )
* # )
/
2
",.""..
- D(
) 2 (
(
2
# 2
* 5@C &"6 $/3/
4)..)...F;
I ) *
(
*
G# 0 J
C
# 2
* ( %;)
*
#
*
) )
(
)
%;)
'
) # 2
* (
* )
(
) *
.
4)..)...F; ,
4)-4)..-,-)
(
* )
( (# (
*)
)%; 4)-4)..-,4
+ 2DF/"F.$///-
@C&/ #
( (
( # 2
:
2
( (
)
"/)"-),"3" 5,)"-)"4,"$ &
")..)=,.3/ 6
"9 3
) 2
*( (
* ' ) //3 $)3.)$..F;
)/-$)
)///
D K % (
0 2 %)$5#7
'($'77%5+
-%;' 5>( 0$8 9( 65:-#5#$?%%$ ')@-.
6)?#:"
4.
( *
$= 2 2 ( &
) /.3) (
) =
# % (
0
( ?;
L
( )
*
J /
) 2
*(
". + $/" "..)
* 2
"9
'
) 839 ",9
) (
@C&M &M4) 39
",9 ) ;
"=9 "
*
; (
"
"" D(
) 2 ( + $/" ".. * ( ( * (
2
"$ (
()
+ ,-- "..+A$/"A<".. <1
2 =
!#+ ,$-.