← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4487/2014disposed of

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Rukmani & ORS

2016-11-10Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh8 pages

 

     

 

 

 

      

  

 

   "  # $ %     & # $ %   '( "  )  # $   ! $ * +  # $ %  , 

"

) #

-#.

)   ///// 

  !



  

     0  *   

  

   & # $ %      !+  # $    "  )  # $ %  ' "  # $ %  , 

"

) #

-#.

)   /////   

  !"  #"!!   #"!! $ 

  

  

%!!

    &'  !  ((

! ) # 

* +% %,

    ! -! 

.

&' (#

   &

    "%   /#!

 0%,#



 !

 

 ! 

!  1

 +%#

 /

#! "

(%

!!,   ,

* (!

!

,

 #

 

!  



 !  !  -

'.

-(

!.

"



 # !'    !

0* 23*

! 4 %!%

 (!* 25

*  !

 #%! 

   ! (# %!

  

(' ! !  !%

  0 *7 *23  8 !

!  0**23     ( !%# ! ! 

 0*23 

 

 %

* # $ !!

!0* *23 '!! 

#!

! 9

'



 $ %     ! %&#  &' (%   !  ! ((%

#!!

'

, 1

0

'*

! !!

,  %&(

/ 5  ! :

( (!*

  !-! (!.*!

*! "  /     !  (!

!

(!

 ! 

  &!' % 

'  %&#   !  !

# '

  !  1

 0

'* !

  !   !

&$ ! '!

 ' %%

# '

 1

 0

'

 

 ! &

!  (#

!

1

)#

!

;

! ;

<"

!=# '

0% *7  !-! 0% .*!

 0%     ! &   #

*

'* %

(!

!*

'* %   $!

' '(#

8!

$% 

!(#

!

"

 0%  

#&  $!  ;"  >

( ?%$#

!!)% "#$%&'""&"(%#&)*(%&'"+,%&-./01)

*(&$+% %&0 /2"()3   4  1

* !  %  !



('

%





! 8

(%

! *

%

3&,



* &' !

$  ! ( 

!   - %&( . %

 (!

 %   ?%$#

!  ! +

1$)% !#$%)1)  %*#%&0/2"()* 5"(%#% *

' !!

!(

!

(

! &!'! '(#

 /  5  

 - %&( .

  ' ! ! @ %&(

A#

*!

!*

' !

! %$

!*! (!  %&( $! (( *

(%

(

 (, %  !

&' !

 !

*

! #!!

' ,   1

 0

'   % >

(  !  >#& ' 1$ )% ! 

%&0*(%&62$+%7$6%#"%&0%&/2"(1)"8&0$%.$"&)*(%&'"  ./0 %&0 /2"()3   9 +,%&- %)") 43 &'



$ ! !  %&(

(!  *B%!

!%93

@ ! @ %&( A%

(!*!



%$! (%

(# #&

 %&(%

( '  $!  ((   $!  ((  # ' &

#"

#!

*

(!



$% &'

!!

# *&'!(, !*

  $     '#

!  

   % ' &

(!

'

!(%

  C !

'! #%!& (( & # #&

 %&(

& %

?'#

!* "( !

  8! 

'!&

# !

 @ $!  (( A

 @ ((    $!A 

!

# #&

 %&( $! !% # #&

 %&(

#

$!*

$% *

(!

 ! '(

!*

*&

 $! 6(  $ %    !

 

*

   $! 

(( *!

*

!& "

*#

'! (( !

'# #&

 %&(

'$ % ( ( 8 !



$!! # #&

  %&(!% 

(!

(#

!! $!!%

 !

(!%

@ $!

(( A   %!

C !*!

*$ (

!! !

 !%

! !

$!!% (

(!

   %&(    !  &

 #  #%(  ! "

'

  &

 %

%  !  (

(! #

$  !

@ %&( A ! $  666 666 666 $ !%

(

!#%( !!

!%

"

( %

!

, '! 1

# #&

 %&(

2

!'

, '!(# (! !! "

( (

$!# '& !  ! "

$ !%

"   (# % '

8!  *!

*!&



#&

  %&( 

(( * 

*

 $!

'#

!

%& ("

&'! ! @ %&( A /  ! (!   !

 %  %!

 "

' &?

(!  !  )

(!A  % >

(  !  

 1$ )% !  &$/"0 &0$% &)*(%&'"+,%&-.$+$/"0:) %(:%/2$":$%&0/2"()3  ! 

#

"



! ,  1

0

'*# '& (( & #!

%#&

# #&

!  %&(*!(%!!% 

'! ((%

  ! !

,  %&(   %* !

' 6

! &!'! '(#

  %&#  &' (%  

'!

# '

1

0

'*

'(

!&

%  ! '!

 #( "

 !&

?

(!

8!(%!! (( 

 $"

( !1

0

'*

# '

 0

' % &  !

* !

* !

' # !

!(#

!"



* 

!&

!&

"

$   %!

&'*!

) %(! !  1

 0

'  8!   %

!  #'  !



 ! &

!  (#

!

 0% 

$%   !!#

#

!

&

!$"

0% %!(#

 (!

 $ ( 

 1 .&  /%

!  8    1

* !  %    

3

 "

 

 

 

 &' !   6 )% !  "#$%&'" "&"(%#

&)*(%&'"  ./0 1) ;2%)2$ ;2%(+%3 9   $:$# !9   $ ! ! &

! $"

 0%     #

 %

 (!  8  ! "

  !

     $!  #

 

!

0%  & $! )% !!! % ! !(#



!B% 

(' "

&  ! ! !

 

$ $  

'  05*23 =6D*

%( 

'



93 @>3D 5  ;3D ' 5  (  ;  C   10 7

!

  5A

      !

0* 23 

'E%'* 6(%

! 0 *23 !

<D

0523 < % 8

/(

!(  

'  !   !  ! ?%!' 0 *523%!$ 

'05* 23 E%'*   (

! #

 

  !  (   1

0

' ! "

'  !

 

 !

! =6D (%







'

35

'(

!( # !E%'

 $ !! $ 



 ; ! 0*23* (

!0* 23F

( (%#!

*!

!

 ! &

!       

' (

!(  =6D

" $$ 

'05*23

7'

 !#

! 

$!'

 6!

25

 !

#%! 



! !&

!

%!%

 (! $!?%$#

 1 .&  /%

 )% ! ;+/ ;%(#% 1"(+% %&0 /2"() 1"()*) "#2$(%&),(/(,(%/$&%&0%&/2"(3  4  $:$#  "

  ! &"

  !

  05*6G05* *723

%&  &!'! ' 6   0 *723 !

$ !

   0**23

# !

 / (  !  8 6 (!* 7 % ! 0**23 

'

35 !

6

4 0 *723 %& 0 * 723%* 

('  ( (% ! 0*5*23 H055* *7 523 05*7 *

23 6  I 0**72325 

J ;

"

 D * DC35*      ! !  #'  

+%#

 $ !

6( !1% 0

!

10



 ! 5 * !   %

!

 #' $

 

! #'%

 0%     ! & * ! !

%(!



 10     ! 5  (#  ! 0* *23  0*5 23 6    !

%(!

!  0* *23 !

 B%    

(' (#  ! 07* *523

*   !%#  0**23!! 

0*23 !

 

%

&'! 

 !



!  0*23     "

   

! &

!0*23  8 !

* !!

 ! 0 * *523

%(

0* * 23

'

("

0* * 23*

' !!

!   

$

* !

  &' !

'

!

#

!%

'*

&'!

!#   1  /239

5 . -;<% !.   C

$2

9 2  C

9 2