← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4525/2014disposed of

National Insurance Co Ltd v. Monika & ORS

2019-01-29Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh4 pages

 



      

 

 !"#"$%&%'())  

   



  

* +( ',-." *&/&!%$" "01  %!! .

*"&"'!(

* 2%'3 4/*5#2$ !" *!1" 44".. '!

'"**"&4'#"'!&!    1"  4*"&"'!  44" .  #%*"$!&  $1 .."'6"  6 %'&!  7 *#  # !"# )84 &&"#-9!1" !*$$%#"'!& . %+&*%-/' .5 . '#1 * %'

&1*!5,!1"*%-/' .,71"*"-9$+4"'& !%'1 &-""' &&"&&"#' $$/'! #" !1:1 '; .%' +!*2"1%$/. * $$%#"'!!1 !!04. $"' << /'&".*!1"%'&/* '$"$+4 '97/.#%'*+!1 !!1" 44" .1 &-""'4*""**"#! && %.=/ '!/+$+4"'& !%' &&"&&"#-9 !1"*%-/' . 1"*%-/' .1 & 7 *#"#$+4"'& !%' &5>55 #"! %."#1"*"/'#"*(

'!1.9%'$+"!1"#"$" &"#

&5 "#/$!%'*4"*&' ."?4"'&"& @8*#

/.!%4.%"* > ;&&#"4"'#"'$9

&)55 ;&&$'&*!%/+

&55

/'"* ."?4"'&"&

&5

"#%$ ."?4"'&"&

&5

 /'&". * !1" %'&/* '$"  +4 '97/.#  *6/" !1 ! !1" $. %+ '!&#%#'! 44* $1!1" /*!7%!1$." '1 '#& '#!*%"#!$*" !" "2%#"'$"7%!1*"6 *#!"+4.9+"'!:1 '; .7%!1 $'$"*'%'71%$1 1%&-*!1"* +; . A7 &&! !"#!-" 4 *!'"* '#"? +%'"#& %#

+; .!4*2"!1 !!1"#"$" &"#7 &7*0%'6 & ' 6"*7%!1 @& :

!*&5 . '#1 * !& . *9 &54"*+'!1!%&/*!1"* *6/"# !1 !!1"*%-/' .5' #"! %."#$'&%#"* !%'!"&!%+'9 +; .

A%'$./#%'6 $!&".%$%!"#%'1%&$*&&"? +%' !%'51 #*"/&"#! $$"4!4." !1"$. %+ '!&!1 !!1"#"$" &"#7 &"+4.9"#7%!1 @& :

!*&5 . '#1 *! %&/*!1"* *6/"# !1 ! !1"*%-/' . 1 &  &&"&&"# %'$+"    #"$" &"#  !  &5  4"*  +'!1  -9  1.#%'6  !1 !  !1" #"$" &"#7 &&!/#9%'6 &!"*/&%'"&&#+%'%&!* !%'

 '#1%& *"&/.!7 &#"$. *"# !"*1%&#" !1 !%&/*!1"* *6/"#!1 !$. %+ '!& 4*#/$"#'*"$*##$/+"'!&?!B7%!1*"6 *#!#"$" &"# #%'6 *+/'C -"$1'%$ . '%2"*&%!95 . '#1 *-/!!1"*%-/' .

1 & %."#!! 0"%'!$'&%#"* !%'!1 ! &4"*#$/+"'!?>5#"! %. + *0&$ *#%'*"&4"$!!1%*#&"+"&!"*"? +%' !%'%' *$1%&&/"# 'B>5:1 '; .6!*" 44" *%' 4"*%"44.%"# 4"* !%'

"&" *$1 ?!"*' . !%&/*!1"* *6/"#!1 !!1"*"%&'#$/+"'!' *"$*#&17%'6!1 !-"*"1%&#" !1%'/6/&!55:1 '; .1 # *" 44" *"#%' 4"*!1%*#:"+"&!"* '#$." *"#!1""? +%' !%'"%!1"* -"*"* !"*1%&#" !171%$16"&!&17!1 !:1 '; .1 #'! $+4."!"# -9!1"!%+"51"4 &&"# 7 9 $$*#%'6!$/'&".5 %'$+"!1"#"$" &"#%&.% -."!-" &&"&&"#-9! 0%'6 $./"*+!1" '!%%$ !%'%&&/"# -9!1":! !"/'C -%?%'6+%'%+/+7 6" !!1"

8 *"."2 '! !%+" '# 7 6"1%61.9&0%.."# 4"*&'7 & &5B4"* +'!1'!1"*&/-+%&&%'+ #"-9 /'&".!1 !$+4"'& !%' ..7"# /'#"*$'2"'!%' .1" #&'""#&!-"*"&!*%$!"#! &B55%'!1"

.%61!C/#6+"'!& ',-."!1":/4*"+" /*!  

              

  

   

 '# 

            

 ! "# $ %&  1"*"%&'*"4*"&"'! !%''-"1 .$. %+ '!&717"*" " *.%"*-"%'6*"4*"&"'!"#-9 $/'&". '#%&4/! -.95  !1"  #"$" &"#  7 &   6* #/ !"  '#  1 #  -""' 4/*&/%'6 *+!1"/'C -"$1'%$ . '%2"*&%!95 . '#1 *"1 # 4 &&"#/*!1&"+"&!"*"? +%' !%'1".#%' *$1 &4"*#$/+"'!

?B-/!6!*" 44" *%'!1%*#&"+"&!"*%' 4"*,44.%"# 4"* !%'

"&" *$1 "?!"*' ., " '%'6!1"*"-9!1 !!1"#"$" &"#1 #'!$+4."!"#

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

 #"$" &"#5  #+%&&%-."  #"#/$!%'  *  4"*&' .  "?4"'&"&  7/.#  -"  @!1

/.!%4.%"* #4!"#-9!1"*%-/' .%&$**"$! '# %*+"# '!1%&2%"7!1"+ !!"*5.&&#"4"'#"'$9%&$ .$/. !"# !

&5>5

&)555??>E &B5><5

D ##%!%'F &>5B5 @!1 #"#/$!%'

'#"*  $'2"'!%' .  1" #&5  $+4"'& !%'  7 *#"#  -9  !1" *%-/' .  %&  +#%%"#  !  !1"  "?!"'!  !1 !  $. %+ '!&  &1 ..  -"  "'!%!."  !

&B5

&5*.&&$'&*!%/+5 &5" $1=/ .&&!"&! !" '#/'"* ."?4"'&"&5 #+%&&%-."%'!1".%61!C/#6+"'!& ',-."  !1" :/4*"+"  /*!  *".%"#  /4'  -9 $/'&".  * !1"  %'&/* '$" $+4 '9  ! .  $+4"'& !%'  %&  $ .$/. !"#  !  &5<>5

&5>5E &B5 '# ##%!%' . +/'!%& &5

&5<>5F &5>5 



   

 

 

        

  

    

       



  !

"#   $  %&' 



 

(

    

    $     ) $ 

$ 

    

      

"01  %!! .

 /#6"

)) +1 '-%+-*