High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1905/2016allowed

Oriental Insurance Company Limited v. Suresh Garg & Others

2022-11-24Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan16 pages

!"#$%&'

'''$$

(

) *+"

''',

!"#$%&'

'''$$

(

) *+"

''',

) *+" '''$$

(

* +-.%,"/% "

''',

) *+" '''$$

(

* +-.%,"/% "

''',

!"#$%#&'('$)* ++ * ,-

+ .+.+

0 1

',23#4 #5""-6" 7"$$

7" $"8"'

'3#6)+4%-6" 7"$$

8"'

')2%(#-6" 7" $"8"'

'39 -*-.%'

::::

+.+ /+ '

4% "-

"77" '' 7 "5 7"7 "#$% 7 "5 7"7 - / 6 ""7 # '

47 % ##$7 "7 " -/ "";$ "'

' 5"1$'#'-%"+ "$ +"$ ''(; *+ /7, #*+'$ "7 (; *+-# %-)') *+7)#') *+< #"5"+ #$" ) "

-"7

""( -==5+ !08"'

"7 !0 8"'

> "7 + '' * +- .% ,"/% -3;

-)"7.%"+) %-)"7 .% "+ !"

"- 3;

< "/ "7 5 5+

> + "8"'., 77" "77+5 - 3 #)+<6"7"77+5 !"#$% "7"77+5 ' 7#$ 2 )+ - "; )+ / *+ 5 + "7

', #*+ $"7"# #$" >'

4" # $" / "+ "

" # '

$6 ""7 "77 %5" 1$'#'-"77+5 5+65% $"8"'<3 # )+ + + # /" 5 "/+ " 6"

""777 #7"#0$ ) "$"6 5++ "8"'.,3>-/ / "

+ "

% ) "$" / "/ 6 0?& " 3 3;

* ," #/ 5+ + " 8"'.,? #7"#3 "77+5 7+ ) "$"6 -

7 5+8"'.,? 5% +"+"/"+ /5 5 ++ " "+$

+ 6

+) "$"6 # "

$5" $ "7 -# %-(; *+ , #*+ 77# $ 2 $"3 # )+6"7"77+5 7 7"#$ 7# $ / /

5%,26)-+

"7 7; "#"/ 3 ?#!"/;-/"/ + "

,8"'

' 7""77 ) "

->>> 0!/ + + 3 #)+-5 6 0"

)")- '

8" "7 #$" / +6" -/"

$$$ 7 $/ # " +

" #$" '

$5 # 2"/ #7 " 5 7"7 ">-%;6"

+ "52 " -" # "+ 7 ;$ " + +6+"7) "$"6 6/ 7 "7 @" #"77 "'

' "77+5 65% $"8"'<3 #)+/ $ %+"&<A " /5 ?#7 %"6- %/) "$" # 7"# ?# 6

+ 5 7"# " " $"8"' 5 "/ 6 " 6) "$"

6 $"

$$ 5; -"/6- % #7"#A ;5 ' "+" 8"' ">-5 6/ "7 $$+"7 ) "$"6 @ %"55 #7" + ') "+ #

"7 #$" + #'

B $"8"'5 6

" #$/

# 6 "' '

;5% $"8"' "#$% / # " #$" /

"""

"7 8"'"> $"8"''."/6- "#$%

+ 7 # $" "

"/" $"

""C "#$ "7"# $"< "#$% $"8"' / "6+6 77 66+ #"7 # "" "7 $"

% / 5 5% 8"' " > ' "#$%

+" #$" "#+$/$ " ;$ " 77%2

+" $"8"'/ "7 + 57

' 6- $ 5% $"8"'/ / "7 "5"% + + "$"7 6"7 $"8"' 6' "#$% "+ #

"7 # $" '

0"7"# 8"'

"=/ #7 5%## #"7 "+% " "52 "- 7 # $" /

"/ 76" "7

$ + "7 $ - 7"

"/+

/ 7#1

#$ % % &#'

()**

& &

+ , , ()** - &#' !!

! !

+ , ( )* % ' &#

& + , ()* % ' '

A+ " "7 6 "7 - )') *++" # " 0B' ""

C##4 0B ,26) 0B> $"66 " # DC'0"DC'0 '

5 8"'">$" " #

DC',>", "

6 , $"8"'3 #)+ +" "/ # " ,B$" " # DC', DC', ' , $" 8"' $" " # DC', "

6 '8"6 / "5 7"7 8"'

"='

7 + +# - "" !

5 -3;

77" 5

8"' 76""7 + 8"' "-

8"'>+ $"8"'76""7 8"'"'

"77+ "

-5" #

$" / $ "#$ ""7, ' --E/ / "5" @ #$"5+ !0 8"'

"7 " ""7"7, #*+ "#$ ""7 , '> -=- E/ /"5" @ # $"5+ !08"'

>"7 " ""7"7(;

*+#""6 ' "#$ "/ // FG$#7"#"77 +"7 #$"

H"' 5 % "7 8"' " "$% "#$ "#"/ 7""52" 6 '

"#$%5"$" 5+"7 6/ "#$ " + / " + - /

E$" 5+

7/ "#$ "/"

# " +"5"

67 $$$

57" !"'

8" "7 $$

" $ 6 -/"$$$ "+ " ' '

6 " 7"$ 5 +"+ "+ "'

%;+$$$

'' 7 5% "#$%'

# "7 ; 5% " 7" $$

/ 5 6/ "7 $$+"7 #"77 ) "$"6-/"/ 7 "7 @"/ "

% $" 5 7"$$+"7 '

= $"

"7 + + , + ) "$" 6

+#/"+ %+ ,+ 5 67

# #"77 7 $ "7$ "7 $ -5 "# 5 / +"+" #"-/ ) "$"/ "#"7"# ;

"- ) "$"6 "

65 "

7 " / "77 5%57"$" + +/%'. "

"/"6C "-

5 6 " " 6" % #+ " $

+) "$"6 5 /% % $$ 5;

% "7 5 7"-5 6""/ "75 " "7 5 -# %-$$

"#$% 57 /%

5 %'45 /"+ %#

"7# 5 "$% "#$ "" '

"- " 7"

"7"#7 # "7 6 5"+"7 5%$ -5 "# #$ 8"' < 3 # )+ / " "7 5% + +6+"7"77+5 ' +- / ""7!"" , "+5% "#$ ,26) /+" / + "#5"7"77+ - #5 "++".%,"/% -3;

% #" ;$ " ""7

+ +6+"75 -"+#"75 6

"#" ,5 " $5% 8"'" / 5+65% $"8"'<3 #)+#' '

"#$ " "" "+7

$"+ 5 6" "77) "$"6'$ "77 +"

" "/5 65 $"7 /+" @ "' C# )',26 )- "#$ 0B>-/" 776DC'0B>E7

% $$" "7 "# $ './ "

C#" 5 7"7 5 ;" + "

"%# $"'8" " 5 ++ "$"6 $"#$5%/ #+6$"

%+ 5 6'

6 "$%"7$") "> !'0'!' DC'0 >- #"7,26)) " !'0'!'

DC'0 - $ DC'0 -# $""7

7 DC'0 - # $""7"77+5 DC'0 -$"

#"#$""7 , #*+ DC'0 =- "$%"708 "7, #*+

DC'0 ' + $"8"'<3 #)+$$ ,B'"+ 776DC',BE-$"" +6/ #'.

"$"6" " "$%"7

6+ DC', "$%"7$$ " DC', ' "

C#"-#/ 7 + # 7+++" /% # / + + 6"7) "$"6 '. " 5+.,?

/ /6

+/ "#+7"#3

" " 5 +""/ " ''

5 5%$"$ % % +6 +"7 2 $"

"- "#" "

" @ ";$ " + +6+"7 "77+5 5%3 #)+< $"8"'' "" % ""77/5 "$"'"

+ + - !" @" "

7 # "7 6 5"+"7 5%$ ) 7 ""56"5 "7 "2

# -7" " $"+"" $ "7 $ "7 ##" " %+ ;$ "7 "7) "$"6" "#; # ' "+" "" "/) "$"6 / 7 "7 @"' "% " 7) "$"6 -/"

65 $5%$"

7""+ ' "+" "" ++ ) "$"6 6 "7 # " $"

#7"# $ #5%5+ + +6"5 6''

$"8"'<3 #)+'7"-+# "6 5% " 7" "#$% 7""5/"% # 2 "+ %' >'

& " 7" "#$% +

-/"$ /"7 , #*+ "

" + "#$ "" ""7#""6 '

B " 7" 7 +# + / +/

6+#$"6+#6"

6 - %6 77

" ""77#"- + "7 "7"$$"

+ #"7 $$"

# +%6""52 "-7 "#$ " / " C

6 %'

7+6 "" - 7 +# 5% " 7" "#$% " "6 +'

7 % "+ "#$ "" ""7 "7+ /#""6 '5

/ $ $"$$$"$#+ % 7" "+ "#$ "'

."/6- " ""

$$"

5 %+/+' '

& " 7"$$

< !"#$%

$""5 7

"+G"7 "#"7 "/ 7$"

$ / " ++ - "

"65"5 # "72+#

## $"

%-5%$C!"#C##"7G"7#" % "# "

5"/ 7$"

$ - " +5""7

#/5 "/% "7+' ='

7# ""' "7 , # *+-5 5% "

% H+6 " + + $"

"; "#"7 , #*+- +>% "5, ' -=E$#" +"7 "#C 7 5%57"'7 " 5 #""7 "# E># 5 "555 "

5"$E>"/ $ $')6 2+# 65 +'

""7 , #*+/

+, '>-E$#"5% %+""/";/ + % 2 " ;"7" "" #%6 +' 5 6+

"#"7 , #*+7"# "5""5

, '-> E$#"/"+ % #""7G"/ 7$"

$ "7G $

2 $"

" +"72+#

"'7"5% "+/"+-#" % "#"7 /";""

, ' - > I>'

# "7""7"%

& '

(

% )"

## $"/#5"7$7# %##5 ">- ""/ 7C$ "5; E> 'A"+ $ % "7 "# " " , '>->E

= $ #"- $ % "# "", '>->C J, '- -E'

> >'

5 # $ "7 -/ ;$+ 6/+"7 , # *+ 5$"$ % '

$$ %+ "#$ "$%5 "# "", '- -C J - -E'

? "6" - 5 / , ' -E"/ $"""75"%-7

"7 , #*+'5 7/ #"7 , '--E" "/ "

"7 7/ #""7, '-E " "/ "

"7 "6 77 "'."/6- + $"

"+ 5 7

@2+#5%$C!"''*+,

# -

. !"

## $")))-// "5 6#""7, '-E "5/"6% #7"7 " "#6/"7 2+#

"-/ $"6 / /";+" "#$ " $%5 "6" -# %- "

"7 - "

"7 " "#7 C$ -#""7, '--, '-E , '-E- $ 6 % "

5/' 5 7 #" "

5 "$ +5 6%% A"+ "#$ " "#

" "

5 , -==- - -III I '5

/"+ %/ "#$ ""7, ' --E' # "

, -==-E'77 "# "", ' -=-> E'

> '

A (; *+ 57""5>=% "7+ #"7 '5 +"7 "#C7 5%#57" ; "#"5 =-=E$#" 7"#5

$$""+- # , '- >=E"/ 5" $, ' "/ $ $' 5"$"$ %5% 5 'B 7C+ "# $ "/ " "75

" ""76"

7 " 65;"

" "'

" "7 / + , '>-E$#"5% %+" 52"5/ 2 " ;"7 6 5"+"7 5% ' "#"7 (;

*+/ ; , '-> =E' >>'

5 +7

"+G"7 #" "/ 7$"

$ /# "7 /75"6 " ++"7 (; *+- "

5G" %'

A"+ #" % "# "7 "# " "

, ' - -> =I>'

7 ""7E>"/ 7C$ # "7 ""7"%

& '

(

"$ %"7 "# ""

, '=E -$#"- $ % "# ""

, '=C J, ' - -=E'

5 # $ "7-/ ;$+ 6/+"7 (; *+ 5$"$ % 'A"+ "#$ " $%5 "# " " , ' - -= C J

> -- E'

> ? "6" - 5 / , ' -E"/ $"""75"%-7

"7 (; *+'5 7/ #"7 , '--E" "/ "

"7 7/ #""7, '-E " "/ "

"7 "6 77 "' >'

."/6- 6/ "7 2+# 5% $C !" ''

+#* !"'&'(

8,# !,#

$-#""7, '-E "5/"6%

# 7" 7 " "# 6/ "7 2+#

" - / $"6 / /";+" "#$ "$%5 "6" -# %- "

"7 - "

"7 " "# 7 C$ - #" "7 , '-- , '-E , '-E- $ 6 % "

5/' 5 7 #"

5 "$ +5 6%% 'A"+ "#$ " "#

" "

5 , '>>- =- > -- III I '5

/"+ %/ "#$ ""7, '> -=- E' # "

, '>>- =- E'77 "# "", '>->-E'

>='

# "" ++$$""# "+ /

# #'

B #"7 " -

7 "5 7"7 !"#$%

"/$ %/ "

' '

7#""7 "#$ " %5$5%

"#$%-

5 " "677 #" 7"# $ /5%/%"77 +C "$$ " 57" "" !

# 5 -3;

6/"7

"5"6- 5 "

% " "" #""7 "#$ " 5 5" '

!" @ %- 7 " 5 7"7$$

/ "

) 7 " 5 7"7 !"#$%$ %

"/ 7 " 5 7 "7 $$

- #

$$ " - 7 %- $"

"7 "+ %'

'' +.+ 42 01#"1#22#!($)#34(5#!6')7 * #(4$ 01#"1#22#5$2"!89# * #(4$