← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/30649/2018allowed

Improvement Trust Sangrur v. Prem Singh Walia

2024-02-08Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj15 pages



       



!"#$%#&'('$)** 

    

     +  ,-+ * ./ .* *    



   !   



"#  

   $ 

 

   !  

%%% / .* * 0!1

&    

 '   () (* +(,- ./  )0 

 23  . 1 4  #   

   !      1  -*+5-6+7 , +(,*+, - +(,7

'1#    1    !

 

+ +5 (((6      

'   '  

! '       1       

   '   

9:

       

+7 (, +(,*  # 

(((6 '       /

   # "

 1 

&   23  .40

  

        !    

+

  !     



       ,- +(,+

  ' 

(((6 

;

#  '   

9( (((6  1 

)

  ! 1!

'       

      # 3'   <

    '   !     



   !/ =

'  ' 

5*((6 

;

# !  +((

;

#

-,((6 

;

# !  '  '   +((

;

#

    '

!

 '

   +> 

 +5(

;

#  ,- +(,+ '    

1

   '          < 

 ,> ,+ +(,, '  '  "1 =

 +, - +(,+

           

? !   

   ++& 2  

 

,9-7 !     ' #

1!  23  .40



    '  

& 

 23  .40



  # "



'

" # 1  !    

? 

   ;

 ' '     ) * +(,- 

!    

 ' '

1"    

*

&  !   

 

  1  

  

    &

+9 !

'  

  

                  

    

    

      

    

 

 



  

  

 



     !" #      

"



    



  

   

  

 "



$

?      1   ' #       

   1  6         

? !

     !     '

!

 '

 '     #  

  

 3        1  

@  

    '

     

(((6 

;

#

      

     !     

    

            1  #

  

  

1      !     #

  

        !      # ' 

&   23  .40



'1#       1     

      1   

 ' !

     

,+    

      "1

' 

,9++ "1

'  .4 A  2    

,9-)                 #



  ! !           

 ' ) +(,,

'

 '   +- > +(,,   '

 ,- +(,+

? 

  ;

  1  ! 

    #

 1 ! 





 !   B/ 5

=

"1

   !       !/

? 

# 1

  



-9,(6 

1  1   !      1  

'      '  '3 



-9,(6

 

(((6 

;

#

1  1# !/   1 =

 !      1  

1

1"     #     "1

' 

,9++     

     1   1 1 

!! ' "

     

>

2   !        

# 

+9 1   '  1  1 #   #     

 

  

 ;

  #       '    1   #

/ #

     !  ;

  

? !  ' 

" #     !          6  ' #   

 23  .40

 ' 1  1

 

/

   



        3  

      6 1   #       ;

 6   



    

   

 #   

!       '  

-,((6 

;

#

 !

 

1        

1

 



  

   



  



  



      

      



  

1

    

  1 #       1 #    

      !       

    '    

-

#    61  

C6



     1  3 !!      #

' #  

6     

1   

 ;

 1    1  C6

/



!!6'

     # !! 

  

    

'

   !       !!  '6      #

  

!

  

   

!! # A # ! 

        

6C

 !

        

(((6 

;

# '      

!    

     & 

,-7+   1 6;

    !!    '  

 #         !! 

   '

   

        

 1 1   3 1 # 

       #  

     

  !!     

1     !!



      /    '    

 !!

 '#     

 

D    

    

 

# 

1   

  /  

 1      ' '   !       

     #   #          !

          '     !

3    1

1  

   

   ' '  !!       !!  '  1     !

  #   

     !! 6  # 

  3   



              #  !

    '  !                !

1  

   1             #

 

   

!    

' 

  # 1"   

 ' 

 1       

;

 #  

 !!  

 1      

' !

# 3'       '     ' 

,(

 

 

" #

1

'

/  

   %" !&    ' 

  



 

  ()** %"!    



 

        +

 *()*          



 %"!

 

  

  



      

 



*,*))* * #

 -    

  



              

  

   







 



       





  



           

 

          .   

 

   

 

       

 

 

              +

     



 

 



     #   #   -

   

 

   

   

           

 %".(    

  

 

   

 ! 

        

    %"!/0   

      

 







 

  +            

 

  

      

      # 

  

 

      

  

 





  

   



  *1 !  # 

  

 



2     

   3  ,,  

  



 

 

  

    4 

 .

     

 



         

 2  !       

  !

          

 

         

 

 . 5)))60

  



 

     

   



  



   7 8    



 

  ,*)*&

        

  

 .5)))60 

" 9    $ ,,

 # '

'

  + 

    

    

 

 :

 -  ;

 < <  

 <  +  

    

   *&) 

= !    %" !& 

 &* 

 5) <     

 .(*))60 <       

   



 !      >  #

   

 

   (/)** 



  *,1   *(*   %" !  

 

   '

 

          !  

     



   

   



 

           

  

  

 

 

  #  %".        & 



 

  :

  - < >

 %" . 



    

      >  #

    *5) <   

 

* 

  

   >  #

    5) <    





     

 



1

 

/



 ?     





  *(* %" !

 

  





  7 )))60  <    







    

    

 

          +         

       



   *,*) )*   

 %"!1 

  

   

  

                

@  55)*&0%" !5    ;  #  ;  .

 <   

 A<   B +   A    

  1(  */* )*&   55)*&     

  



 

  :

  -  <   

2

  

 

    

 

   1(

   #  ; .

 <  !

   @  

  #  

   >2  <

 #  ;  .

#    @  *&*)*/

  %" .*)      

  @   ;

 #  9   55*& .   @  55*&     %" .*)

>   *)   

*, 9 !

 **5/  )*&  

 +   B <  4     

     

    

   

   2

    -

#  ;  .

#        -  **0 *, C *1(6)*, 

 1*(*,       *&**/ D< E *) +           



 %"!

 *(*)* "  

         2 

  

     

     

    

    

  %"!/   

        

  

 %"!/    

         

 !    *(*)* 

    %" .(    %".(  





 "  

   

  

 *(*)*     

   

 

      

    



  "      



  *,1   *(*         

7 )))60  <    + 

  

       !  





 

 

  

   

      

    < #     

            

  !"#" "$ ""! !

%

  

 

     

        

          

    A      

 

 

 

  

 

        

       %" .( !  "  

  



 

D7)))60  <        

   *1,1  *(* D



E   

/   5) <  ** %" .     

 

 

  

 > <

   

 

  > <

  %"  ? +   <    

 

/   5)     +           



 



    *,1  ()* +

  

  A>  #

  



   *,*))*

  %"  :



 < 

     *,1   *(*      

  

 

   

 >  > <





    *,*)*

  %"  :



 <  9 

          

 

  

 

   5) <    !





 

  *(* ! 

  

"   *(*))* '   "      

 *,*))*

 > <

 + 



 

  



 ? 

 

  4 

 

 

       

  

 

   

 

 

  

  ! 

  

 >

    !    

 

<  





        +    



   

D7)))60  <          



   *(* 

        +  



  



  

 > <

   "  !

*(*))*

 



           

      

   

     

    

      4             

        #



 <      )**0* %".&     1))&  >2  4  ; 

 G



 

 0 A    "

  

 +       

     

      +        

"     

     ;  #  

 

          

6   

    

  A * 9    4 

   

  

     



    4   !     



 

 

        





   

  

 



 #

 * 



 %" !



A

      !

  >2  

+  !  *  >2  

 +  D

 



 

E .  *(1   

 

         

    A !



 

 2

    



  #

 *   



  2

             

     

 



  

  



     

 !  %"!& 

  

 ()** 

   

  



 ,  :

 )**  

   (/)** 



   *(*  

            



 %" .5  >2         *)8       "      





  

 

  .(*))60    . (*)60 ! 

      "

. )))60 

   



                

        #



 <      )**0*   +   

 

  

      

  

   *1 9         





 







     



   

    



     

  

> <

         

      9    $ ,+

  

 1 " # '

#  

+9

2 

 

 

  "

   '  

        

     2     "

  #  ! '      "

    1 !'

   ;

  1    

 !  

     '  

  

   &   # '

 1 3

     1"  #

,)





 !    1! ?E1 / & .*.0')'4!(!+50"67/(*8!0)!"!9!$5('):

$!0;<      .  

' '

 ! 



   

             

  

 

   

  .51

  

 

 

      



$ ,*

   

   1    

1 1   ! 1  !               1     # 1      1   #     '  1  

@  

 !     1

=

B/ 5 '     ,(:



1 ! # # #  

       ' !  #    # 

 

1

    ' '



&

,+       1        

1"    "1

' 

,9++ 

 !  

& ;

 #

   

6  

/  '

 "1

' 

,9++ '    # /  1 3 !     

,5

  

 '   6  

   

 &   # '

 1        ,(:

'       

-9,(6  

(((6

 !      1 #    

 ! " # '

 23  .40



!! !        & 

!!              

    #

D            1 

 

          

   #

 



     !   

 

 # ' 

&      3      

#  

" # '

!!   

#  

1 

1



 '   

 #

'

" # '   ) * +(,- ./  )0 

 23 

2 .40



  # ' 

&

 23  .40





 / .* 

     **  3#  

36  F 6<    1 F 6<