High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3065/2018dismissed

Rajiv Dadlani v. State Of Haryana And Others

2018-02-09Mr. Justice Amit Rawal5 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

!"# #$%&%'( ) ) ) ) *!+%, !-.!'% #"%"%'#/ 0& "!"# !/1!'!!'-"*#/& #&2'-#'"& 3( 3( 3( 3(4 53 4 53 4 53 4 53 663 663 663 663 /#&#'"( 3/.7689!/ !%':-,$!"#:!'- 3/9%"/!&!-:-,$!"#:

/"*#2#"%"%'#/ 663 : ;5< 663 : ;5< 663 : ;5< 663 : ;5< *%& 2#"%"%' %& %.#- / &##7%'= ! >/%" %' "*# '!"8/# $#/"%/!/% /?8!&*%'="*#'"%$#-!"#- %&&8#-@1/#&2'-#'"A 8'-#/#$"%'A "*#-# /%9%'!./$#-8/#:)BC /&*/"D"*# /EF *# !$"&=%,#'"9#:-8/%'="*#$8/&# "*#*#!/%'=:!/#"*!" !' !22.%$!"%' >!& 9!-# %' "*# *%# 3%'%&"#/ &%'=.# >%'-> !=!%'&" !& 9!'1!& 2#/&'&%'$.8-%'="*#2#"%"%'#/:>*>!&!"%'"*#&!%-.%&" *#/#!

"#/ "*# 2#"%"%'#/ /#$#%,#- ! '"%$# 28/2/"#- " *!,# @##' %&&8#- 8'-#/ #$"%' A "*# / ' A B !&7%'= *%9 " !22#!/ %' 2#/&'@# /#"*#$'9%$

#'$#&%'=C /&*/"D"*#4F:6!/'!. ' B " &8@9%" *%& /#&2'&# %' /#.!"%' " "*# $92.!%'" %.#- !=!%'&"*%9!'-%'/#.!"%'""*# /!8->/"*.!7*& /82##&$99%""#-@1 *%&$92!'1%'$''#$"%'>%"*"*#%'&8/!'$#!'-&!.# 9@%.#2*'#7%"& ;82'&<"%&&8@9%""#-"*!""*#2#"%"%'#/*!&&8@9%""#-*%&/#&2'&#'" %'2#/&'@8""*/8=**%&-,$!"#3/1-*1!/!&!-*#2#"%"%'#/*!&

'> /#$#%,#- "*# %928='#- '"%$# -!"#- %' >*%$* "*#/# %& ! /# #/#'$# ''!22#!/!'$#@# /#"*#:6!/'!.') !'-"*# 2#"%"%'#/*!&!=!%'@##'!&7#-"!22#!/%'2#/&'' !.'=>%"* /#$/-"%&&8@9%""#-"*!""*#2#"%"%'#/*!&=%,#'"*#/#&2'&#""*#'"%$# ' "*/8=**%&-,$!"#"%&"*8&&8@9%""#-"*!""*#2#"%"%'#/%& @#%'= 8''#$#&&!/%.1 *!/!&&#- @1 "*# ',#&"%=!"%'=

%$#/ "*# : 6!/'!.!'-"*#2/$##-%'=&%'%"%!"#-!=!%'&"*%98'-#/#$"%'A /!/#2!"#'".1#//'#8& *!,#*#!/-.#!/'#-$8'&#. /"*#2#"%"%'#/!'-!

"#/"!7%'= %'"$'&%-#/!"%'"*# !$"&!'-$%/$89&"!'$#&:!9 "*#$'&%-#/#-2%'%' "*!""*#/#%&' /$#%'"*#!/=89#'"&/!%&#-@1$8'&#. /"*#2#"%"%'#/ #$"%'A "*#//#!-!&8'-#/( GA "%$# !22#!/!'$# @# /# 2.%$#

%$#/H ;< *# 2.%$#

%$#/ &*!..: %' !.. $!&#& >*#/# "*# !//#&" ! 2#/&' %& '" /#?8%/#- 8'-#/ "*# 2/,%&%'& &8@ &#$"%';< &#$"%'A:%&&8#!'"%$# -%/#$"%'= "*# 2#/&' !=!%'&" >*9 ! /#!&'!@.# $92.!%'" *!& @##' 9!-#: / $/#-%@.# %'

/9!"%' *!& @##' /#$#%,#-: / ! /#!&'!@.# &8&2%$%' #I%&"& "*!" *# *!& $99%""#- ! $='%J!@.#

#'$#: " !22#!/ @# /# *%9/!"&8$*"*#/2.!$#!&9!1@# &2#$% %#-%'"*#'"%$#

;

< *#/# &8$* ! '"%$# %& %&&8#- " !'1 2#/&': %" &*!.. @# "*# -8"1 "*!" 2#/&'"$92.1>%"*"*#"#/9& '"%$# ;< *#/# &8$* 2#/&' $92.%#& !'- $'"%'8#& " $92.1 >%"* "*# '"%$#: *# &*!.. '" @# !//#&"#- %' /#&2#$" "*#

#'$# /# #//#- " %' "*# '"%$# 8'.#&&: //#!&'&"@#/#$/-#-:"*# 2.%$#

%$#/%& "*#2%'%'"*!"*# 8=*""@#!//#&"#- ;A< *#/#&8$*2#/&':!"!'1"%9#: !%.& "$92.1>%"*"*#"#/9& "*#'"%$# /%&8'>%..%'="%-#'"% 1*%9&#.

:"*# 2.%$#

%$#/ 9!1: &8@+#$" " &8$* /-#/&!&9!1*!,#@##'2!&&#-@1! $92#"#'" 8/" %'"*%&@#*!.

:!//#&" *%9 / "*#

#'$# 9#'"%'#- %' "*# '"%$#E *# !

/#&!%- 2/,%&%' %& !' #I$#2"%' " #$"%' A "*# />*%$*%&!2!/" *!2"#/0 "*#/:%'>*%$*%"%&2/,%-#- "*!"!&"%'>*!"$'-%"%'"*#2.%$#$!'!//#&">%"*8">!//!'"&2#/ #$"%'A "*#/"*#2.%$#

%$#/:%'!..$!&#&:>*#/#"*#!//#&" ! 2#/&' %& '" /#?8%/#- 8'-#/ "*# 2/,%&%'& &8@&#$"%' ;< #$"%'A: %&&8# ! '"%$# -%/#$"%'= "*# 2#/&' !=!%'&" >*9 ! /#!&'!@.# $92.!%'"*!& @##'9!-#: / $/#-%@.# %'

/9!"%' *!& @##' /#$#%,#-: / !

A /#!&'!@.#&8&2%$%'#I%&"&"*!"*#*!&$99%""#-!$='%J!@.#

#'$#:" !22#!/@# /#*%9/!"&8$*"*#/2.!$#!&9!1@#&2#$% %#-%'"*#'"%$# #$"%'A;

< "*#/2/,%-#&"*!"%'$!&#!'"%$#%&%&&8#-"!'1 2#/&':%"&*!..@#"*#-8"1 "*!"2#/&'"$92.1>%"*"*#"#/9& '"%$##$"%'A;< "*#/ 8/"*#/2/,%-#&"*!"% &8$*2#/&' $92.%#&!'-$'"%'8#&"$92.1>%"*"*#'"%$#:*#&*!..'"@#!//#&"#-%' /#&2#$" "*#

#'$#/# #//#-"%'"*#'"%$#8'.#&&: /"*#/#!&'&"@# /#$/-#-:"*#2.%$#

%$#/%& "*#2%'%'"*!"*#/#?8%/#&"@#!//#&"#- @8"#$"%'A;A< "*#/#92>#/&"*#2.%$#K',#&"%=!"%'=

%$#/ "*!"%'$!&#&8$*!2#/&':!"!'1"%9#: !%.&"$92.1>%"*"*#"#/9& '"%$#/%&8'>%..%'="%-#'"% 1*%9&#.

/"*#28/2&# %',#&"%=!"%':"*# 2.%$#$!'!//#&""*!"2#/&' ' "*%& $!&#: "*# 2#"%"%'#/ *!- !" ' "%9# !22#!/#- %' 2#/&' @# /# "*# ',#&"%=!"%'=

%$#/K: 6!/'!. !'- *!& &#'" "*# /#&2'&# "*/8=*!'-,$!"#"*!"%&>*1'"%$#8'-#/#$"%'A "*#/ >!&%&&8#-"*%9@#$!8&#*#>!&!&7#-"!22#!/%'2#/&'!'-"*%&%&>*!" "*#.!'=8!=#*!&@##'8&#-@1"*#.#=%&.!"8/#"*!""*#'"%$#8'-#/#$"%' A "*#/%&%&&8#-"-%/#$""*#2#/&'!=!%'&">*9!/#!&'!@.# $92.!%'" *!& @##' 9!-# / $/#-%@.# %'

/9!"%' *!& @##' /#$#%,#- / ! /#!&'!@.#&8&2%$%'#I%&"&"*!"*#*!&$99%""#-!'1$='%J!@.#

#'$#" !22#!/@# /#*%9/!"&8$*"*#/2.!$#!&9!1@#&2#$% %#-%'"*#'"%$# -'"7'>!&">*1"*#2#"%"%'#/*!&@##'&*1%'=!>!1 /9!22#!/%'= @# /#"*#:6!/'!.#&2#$%!..1%'"#/9& #$"%'A "*#/ !&2#/>*%$*"*#!//#&" "*#2#/&'%&'"/#?8%/#-

*8& %' ,%#> "*# !

/#&!%- !$"& !'- $%/$89&"!'$#&: % !'1 '"%$#%&&#/,#-82'"*#2#"%"%'#/8'-#/#$"%'A "*#/"*#' *#&*8.-!22#!/@# /#"*#',#&"%=!"%'=

%$#/"+%'"*#%',#&"%=!"%' %"* "*#&# @&#/,!"%'&: "*# 2/#&#'" 2#"%"%' %& *#/#@1 -%&9%&&#- ;663 < ;663 < ;663 < ;663 < ) ) ) ) *#"*#/&2#!7%'=K/#!&'#- #&K *#"*#//#2/"!@.# #&K