Cholamandalam Ms General Insurance Company Limited v. Suman Devi And ORS









 


 







 



 
  

 
 


  




 

 
    ! ""

 # $%&$$ ! "  $' ($( ! "  !!!!!!
"


 



 
  

 
 







 

 
    ! ""

 # $%&$$ ! "  $' ($( ! "  !!!!!!
#







 


 
$ 



 

 

 # $%&$$ ! ""

 $' ($( ! "     ! " !!!!!!
%
 

  




 


 
$ 



 

 
 # $%&$$ ! ""

 $' ($( ! "     ! " !!!!!!
!"

 #$%&' "()*(+,!'"'-# ,++& "'-# ,++&.) )(

(" 


 

  *++ *+,

!-.& -( -/ 



"0'(1 (- )(0& #(/((2)(0& 2/0'-"(0 / ( .     3'"   3& 4&- (  - !(& (5"

 




 

    

 ! 0 (  0'  1 - - 3 %  6& 1-"' 7 (   0

  21-"'2( ( (0( ('"'-"(/

8&&- -"(0')(0& 
  *++ 

  0 (  0' &( 9!(  ( 0  (-5(.- -"((. 3&4&-
  *+, 

  0 (  0' 3&- 9!(  ( 0  (- - -"(&  3'" 






   (& -"'  (  (& --0(&-"'( (0 "' -"(3'" 3&(/!

(.( (5 &" 9

 0(. :;<+ <,=*  

. 

(. !(   .&(&".6( &.&!( (8&(( . (   (& " (' (& & 3(

*     (   =,,(22!(5  ($&' .&(&".(.!( )&0( (  (  0 .&   " !(  ( 
6;    .  9(  0&'(. ( .  ( (   &

(( ( '''!"&/(.-(  - (.!(&--5<%:0 ((

(.!( &0-((-0'& ( !(0&0' (-'&. / ! -  

(. !(  ( "&&   
6; .(/(" (6(( ((.&3'" /

-"

'   -'     ( ( (

(&   0 (!   /&  "&/(.-( - (. --5( "

 -( ('/& (5.!( 0 &0((> ) &0-((-0'& (&--5 %:!0 0( "&" "(0(

 (  (- "&/((.((' 0&("(   "(.   (-    '   &""  ((.    )(0&  .(. "

    (& -"'    / .&(& ". (  

(. !(   6 ( .&  ( &'(  8&(-    -( ' ( "08&(- ( 0 (
6; 
& .&    (  

(. !(  .(.  15( 9(   "&"   "(.  .  0 "& -15(9(6( &.&-   (- !  & !(  "! !'    . ((!( (&

(($( (- / !

(. (  !(   . /(  . "& 0' -

-15(9( ?(.&(8&( 
6;



+



 / .(   ( 3( 3 15( 9( & 3( *=

<61.((! 

(.!(  - 3- '</(&6
6; ( 0 "( (

' !  3&  3'"   3-0(  . /( 3-  .  15( 9(  "&(. (   

 (    ( 5 "

  ( /' 05  ( !(

. 3- & 
6; ""(/(0@(( !(0&. (""

(( -"(1&  1-"' ( "(&'-( .(0   ((( @-(( 3-((0 (!((-' (-"((0( (')5(.(((& '/(-' 3- )(0& (. '."

 (&-"' /.&(&".(

(.!( )( "   (& -"' ( "

'    (- ""

((   ('"( ("

/.&(&".(

(.!(  ) (-!"&0(

-5% :6    ( "  ) 0(

   (  (-   "&  .1& (&-"'-'0(.(- (- &("( (- "&(-(  0(

  /!  (& -"'   @-(  "(! ( (" ( ' (-  (- . ((  

(.!(  / "& -  (" 



)- !' . -

(.!( 0"!(&

(($(-' 3-3(-(  ' 3'" /-"

' -' (&

(( $ "

   (- 3'"  3& "& (  - ' /(. -(  -   (.

- 15( 9( /( / 0(. ( (  

(. !(  )( 1& ( 
 !

 
"#"$%


&
'#
%%($

+ )(&%
*+,
-"


.
/0
(1"#

"2%(3
%&# %


 !     ( /&  0  & !'   $&(   (&'(/(&/""' -)1&&"/'

&( 0//(!   (./0&.0'(&' /(!/<"(./((&'  &&  ' (-(!( !(.0(! ! ((6 (! 

(.!( ( ""(/(0@'3'" 3&(!(  (8&( "&" "(.(./(/0 "&15(9(6(!(/ - 6 (' -& (

. ('( ((. )(0&   0    0 .&(& ". !

(. (  !(  ( 8&(


 !!

 
) )(0&    (-      ;  ,A< " -    B && ""  &  / "   (!(. @"      ""

(  -& ("

( *-"&  "'& ;, + *+A< 6(( -& ;

A< "( 0'  ;

A< &  @"  ;,

A<  &  ! 

(;

A<  (&-0/-5(.  -"(;= *+A<"'0 /(( +B "&- - "(((

 ((

*    (- /&  &.   )(0&  

/(((- &&""@  B0& -(8&(0 B/ 

' . ) -"(/ & !(  < 5 -( (. $&.- :20 3&"-1&

4%2

"2%(
.
45#(
6#72

"2%(3
 
89

8#:#$9


.#*$
;1(

"2%(
.
;#2(%


"2%(3
 89

8#:#$9
<  "(.  (& -"'  &0-(   "    0( ( (    3&   / 0     =*=      /   '   ( !-0

   -((0 -& ("

(((&-/& 0 +("

 * ))(0& (- 0( -((-&-/.!( 0 &5(

/5 !(- ) (  (     /  

 '   .     -((0  ( ( (- && "" /&  0  B(. '"(&0'& (&-"'  0((( ( (&"0' (-/& "! /- '(- &C (&- -((0 -& ("

(/& 0 +6(-   "'-;= = +,A<D;,  , +A<;  ,A<@ @

+E;

*

,A< B/ &&""<;  +A<  /" @"F C !(     -&   ;

A<

 (&-/(/ ; 

A<(   !

, 

( .&( (  ;

A<  ! 

(   ; 

A< "(  0'  &  @"  ; 

A<     ( / 6 !(/    0!    -"( ( ; ,= +,A<   ((  -"( ( ; ,+

A< ; ,= +,A< < ;= *+A<  /( 

 ' (      *B " &-

- "(((

 ((@" "(  ' + ' "'0 @ &(! '/(/ @"-&  !

(

/( !& (      ) -&

(.       /(/ 

 0 "((
(@9"(;(" "( '


 !=

 
))(0& (- ; * , A< " -    B  ( / && ""  &

A " @"""

(-& ("

( ,-"&  "'& ;+ ,= =+A<6(( -& ;

A<  "(    0'  ;

A< & @" ;,

A<& !

(;

A<

   (&-  0 / -5(.   -"(  ;* * =+A<"'0 /(( +B"&- -  "(((

 ((  (-/& &.-"( / & !(    - (  (. 

= $&.-  ( &" ( 4%2

"2%(
&% &"  .#*$
;1(

"2%(
&%&" "(.(&-"' '  .&?< G(3(.@-(0' (-"! ' 3'" "((@-(( &

 '  "( '-

0.(!( /( 6(.&/(!-( (. ( (/(

%$#&%
%%($
)(&%

-"


.
622#
62(*3
 !89
 8#:#$9
!<  -& -((0   /(      ( (0   0 & -  -"(  0  /( .    3'"   (- ("

' &0-(& "'-"(. ' 0"((/(  &-@&< < "&&

(( "!  -   ?<  ( ( .  0 5 ( ((  '(. $&  0  -"(    (- 
& .&   )(0&   (. ' (. (

 0&. (  @-((   G( 3(. ?<  ( 0   ' &-' !(  3- 3&- 9!( ( .(.  '    &0 ) (-"&@&<  &

((0 ("

  (-/(/ / ( -( ' "(   0(   0( "'  /   

/  (-  9 

/  ) -' &((  ( 8&    /(/  "( -( ' "(   "-( 

3'"  ( (  (  (  (  (0&0    ..!0'-( ('!(   1-"'  (      ' &  ""

(0   -"

'   -'   -( ' ( "( &

 "'    --0 -  '&-0 -A') !'    -' &(( ! ( "( "'0   /(/ &  3'"  +



( &

((  $   -   G( 3(. ?<   /(/     

 0 (   &

  '   "(   '   -6!'-(.

/(-'" 2

-( ' ( "(  '   "(&  "(       -"

' - "(&  ' (  (&-     3'"  ( ( (0&0 ..!0'-( ('!(C(&-  )(0& (. '(.- G(3(.?< ((. ( (&-"'0(  )  ( ( !-0

 &   "'   '   ; * , A< "

&  B   -  ; * + A<)5(.((((-@-" -@(   ((  ' ; +

A<  @0  (- /&  0 ;

* + A<     B  @ (0( (' -  ;

* +A<  &(. A " @"@ (0( (' & (- !( 0   "'-; =

A< ""

'(. -& ("

(  ,     "' -  ; + A< ; =

A<@ ,

C !(     -&   ;

A<

 (&-/(/ ; 

A<(   !  

(    .&(   (   ; 

A< "( 0' & @"; 

A<  (/ 6 !(/    0!    -"( -  ;, + A<   (( -"( ( ;,

A< ;, + A<<;* * =+A< /(

'( *B " &- -     "(( (

  (( @"   "(    '   +  '  "'0  @ &(! '  (     0"((
(@9"(;("(

'(. -$('6&
9;

0"'0 - -(.@" (  6 /
3














;
/-9
H9%& (I













 
?"5(.A

'A ?"0 

'A