Jagtar Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab And Others
!
!#$
!"#$%
&'()*% &%(# + &
'
()))*+&, - "
()*!
*!
.++ !#$) ())*)&+&, - "
)/)
&%(# + & & ,-
% $
".
& !& 123 ) %4"
5! " )6678& &/)76)3679!&
/3:+ /3/+ /1 ;
367 && & . < )739 & 79)73)3679!& 1:3+/3/+138+:69+712&71=
.- +& !%+ - !%.
>..
!$
5!
%
" ? "-
& 76)2)3633; @! /<) 5!
> &$4- ?%.
)/ & ,
- ??
&
) , + >
, "
-$.
+"..4
, &
&
.,
& %! +>- %% " ?
) ?
, A % "
!$4%4-
> "!.
@ -
&$!
"%
!&!
5!
&.. !$
5!
%
" ??4$ 5!
"#!
- !,& & & &7=)=)3633& -
%% $ "
. !B..5 ( "
&
+ - & $ "
! & . !B..5 ( > .
& - &
& ) %! !- ?
+.
&(+ !%
& &3=)/)363/ !)C .
@ . " - ?%. %
& & /6)77)3633+# "--!
&B% ,+ ?# D ?? & & & 36)/)363/ .
>
"& & & /6)77)3633) "
+.
&(+ !% -.!& %%
, & -
, .!.4) & !
. !- !$?
--!
-
&% B--!
& $
& -. & -.?
& ""
-
, &.
&- !
."
+% !
& &
$4.
&(+ !%) $ !
. ! 4% , 123) ))> !.&
> !?4?A !- & + ?4$
4
, ""
- 4 & !& , $!
"4 ! >
-! "#!
- ) /36) 5!..4 ,"
- & +>-%
-$
&! "
?% !& ""
!& &
. *
%, > ! ""
..
&.4- ?? & "-$
, ?-$.4
& %!
"-?.%
-! > "!.
@ -
)
!% !!?$ "-
-.!&
B.S.Joshi and others , State of Haryana . /, (01,20,
"
..
&$4 ! !.. --
"30-4 .,( 5/ /, 6
(0 78 . /,9
:, & . >
, .,
-
&
.>) " + !% !Gian Singh ;
State of Punjab and another : :(01,20, "! & . >
!
& . .>
&$4 !% !"
5!
State of Haryana ;
Bhajan Lal9:(011 :
()
97 #!&?
& !& '
!
"
#
$
%&'
(
"
)*+ , #
- +
,
(
!("
( - "
-
(
(
.- -
(-
(
/
(
$
($
(-
! !"#! !!
(
. 0
1
(
.
(- *
(
2 ( 3
(
-
(
- -
-
-
.
(
(-
(
(
( -
(
-
-
(
.
# "
#
(
-
(
#
#
-
+ ,
-
#
4 %%.4 .>
&$4 !% !%.
"#!&?
& !+ %% >
,
& -
-
>
.4$!
"%
!&$4..
>&-- %
%4 $45! >
-!
#!
- + >- %?.4 $# - .
.! -!& 123)
!.+ !"& -
& 5! .4"..
> ?$&%?
&$4#!&-.% & + )6678& &/)76)3679!&
/3:+/3/+/1 ;
367 && &. < )739& &79)73)3679!&
1:3+/3/+138+:69+712&71= &
.- +&
!%+ - !%&.. !$
5!
%
" ? 5! &5!
&.
4 %
.. ?$ !& $4 ?
& &
& & &$ "
! $ >)
& ..
&)
&%(# + &
&'<% .!-A4 C AB
&'
B
C
$.
'
B