Surinder Singh And Another v. State Of Haryana
"
#"
$% &
'
&
& ( )) * -.) -)/ 12 -)/ +++3322 4+
- (
5
+++3 *
6%7 + $"- !
#7
!"# $ % &'
() * + ,
---
#7
$+
. 0
1
'
/2 1
31
. /$ $2 $$/ 1 61 / 24 1
61
1 4 2
,
1 1, '
'
'
61 7
#
-+
1) ( 7 ()9 3
9: '
%;%$$$9#
!$$$9# * 1 8
/!$$$$9# :)
71
#
! "
# $ + 1
1 #'8
"
5 1
1
1'
+ 1 1'
71
, !$< 1
31 4 $ $// => ?
+ 1'
1 !$<
1 ;
%&'
( 1 1'
71
1
* (
1 1'
) =>
@9/
@92
')
!
%
71
1'
1 => ?
31 , )
: * (
1 ) ,
1
3,
* (
3, 1 )
* ( > => "
,
1
61 %2% !
6 ,
/$
1 # Sr. No. Exhibit Village Area/Price Date of sale Deed Rate per acre 1.
Ex.P1 Shahpur 16K-6M/ 10,18,750 10.06.1992 Rs. 5 lacs 2.
Ex.P2 Shahpur 2K-1M/4,50,000 27.05.1998 Rs. 18 lacs 3.
Ex.P3 Shahpur 19 Marlas/ 2,50,000 03.06.1998 Rs.20 lacs 4.
Ex.P4 Shahpur 17 Marlas/3,00,000 25.05.1998 Rs.27 lacs 5.
Ex.P5 Shahpur 1K-6M/ 2,00,000 26.02.2001 Rs.12 lacs 6.
Ex.P6 Shahpur 13 Marlas/ 1,01,000 30.08.2000 Rs.12 lacs On other hand, the sale instances produced by the respondents are as below:- Sr.
No.
Exhibit Village Area/Price Date of sale Deed Rate per acre 1.
Ex.RK/1 Shahpur 15K-4M/4,75,000 07.06.1999 Rs.2.5 lacs 2.
Ex.RK/2 Shahpur 6K-4M/ 1,44,000 18.06.1999 Rs.2.5 lacs 3.
Ex.RK/3 Shahpur 19K-10M/60,000 05.07.1999 Rs.2.5 lacs 4.
Ex.RK/4 Shahpur 4K-OM/ 1,24,000 29.07.1999 Rs.2.5 lacs 5.
Ex.RK/5 Shahpur 4K-0M/1,37,500 23.06.2000 Rs.2.75 lacs 6.
Ex.RK/6 Shahpur 28K-4M- chahi 4k-OM-Barani 7K-15M-Gair Mumkin 19.07.2000 Rs.2.5 lacs Rs.2.00 lacs Rs.1.35 lacs 7.
Ex.RK/7 Shahpur 5K-6M/ 1,66,000 25.10.1999 Rs.2.5 lacs 8.
Ex.RK/8 Shahpur 10K/3,75,000 25.07.2001 Rs.3 lacs 9.
Ex.RK/9 Shahpur 11K-18M/4,46,250 28.12.2001 Rs.3 lacs 10.
Ex.RK/10 Shahpur 15K-14M/7,50,000 09.01.2002
; // A
=>
@9/
@9/$
1
1
)
1 )
1 => "
,
11
71
,
8
, ' )
,
/4 + 1
1 /!
761,
1
/"
1
,
#7
$"& 89 B
:
B : -+
+ !
+ 3322 3
C A:D=
A:*+ :D
:.(+=
((= .
+ B:
@ A:*+ ((= .
+ B:
+ EA:D=
A:*+ ((= .
+ B: .: D=&A ((= .
+ B:
E.*A:D=
A:*+ :D .
((= .
+ B: "
:
( :EA( A:*+ :D :
((= .
+ B: ;
;
E:* A:*+ ((= .
+ B:
, ,
@C50A:D=
A:*+ ((= .
+ B: < BD&A:D=
A:*+ :D .
((= .
+ B: /$
5+A:D=
A:*+ :D .
((= .
+ B: //
5EA:D=
@C
:D .
((= .
+ B: *C E:( A:*+ :D :
((= .
+ B: ; <:
:&(=E A:*+ :D .
((= .
+ B: /4 ;
:EA( A:*+ :D .
((= .
+ B: /!
,< :
E :A5 A:*+ ((= .
+ B: /"
< ;
+ :=@ A:*+ .
((= .
+ B: /;
< : ;
( 5.7+:
A:*+ :D :
((= .
+ B: << ,
D+C
A:7= D=7==D (+ .C*+ +A ((= .
+ B: /2 : ,
C =+ 7+:D D=7==D
(+ .C*+ :D .(+= ((= .
+ B:
#7
$"& 89 B
:
B :