← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4606/2014dismissed

Jagbiri And Anrs v. Union Of India

2017-01-12Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan4 pages

   

       

 !"#"$%&%'()  *+%,% '# '!-", .."// '! & 0",&1&

'%''#% "&.'#"'! &

 (  23   4 5 34  ,"&"'!(6

&41'%!  7+% ,8#9$ !"8,8

, /: ,4%'*-8#9$ !"8,!-" .."// '!&

,5 ,7%'#",4%'*-8#9$ !"8,,"&.'#"'!  ;-"!-",!-"".,!",&/$ /'"<&. .",7 =+" //<"#! &""!-">1#*7"'!?

+","",,"#!!-"".,!",,'! ;-"!-",!-">1#*7"'!&-1/#+",".,!"#%'!-"#%*"&!? 66 66 34 

3 -%&%& ' .." / * %'&!!-">1#*7"'!# !"#8. &&"# +=!-" %/< = / %7&,%+1' /8 - '#%* ,-"'$-8 - '#%* ,-8 %'&-,!

2!-",%+1' /29%#"<-%$-!-"$/ %7 ../%$ !%'!-" ../%$ '!&6 .."// '!& < &#%&7%&&"#

'8'"4 !+%,&'41:-+%,< &&! !"#!+" $7%'*,7"<"/-%! / +-* ,-'

!, %'"%&&! !"#!- 9"

.1,$- &"# >1,'"=!%$:"!1"!-" 9=,1&-%'!-"!, %'8-"< &&! '#%'* '!-"," ,&%#"!-"#,!-"/$ /!, %'41##"'/=8#1"!-" 9=>",:8 !-"#"$" &"#"//#<',7!-",1''%'*!, %'+"!<""' ,%# + # '#"<  ,%# + #, %/< =&! !%'& '##%"#-"!%$:"!%&&! !"#!- 9"+""'/&! %'!-" $$%#"'! '!-","./=8!-", %/< =&- &! :"'!-"./" !- !!-"#"$" &"# < &'! + '%#". &&"'*","< &'!!, 9"//%'*%'!-"!, %''!-"# =

66 %'$%#"'$"""9"' %/"#!7"'!%'!-"!%$:"!'17+",,!, %''17+", %'<-%$--"< &!, 9"//%'* ,7!-"./" #%'*&8//<%'*%&&1"&<",", 7"#(6  ;-"!-",!-"#"$" &"#< & +' %#". &&"'*", !!-"!%7" %'$%#"'!? ;-"!-",!-"%'$%#"'!%&$9","#<%!-%' 7+%!&"$!%'@ $

," #<%!-&"$!%'6!-" %/< =&$!? ;-"!-",!-" ../%$ '! &%& ,"!-"&/"#"."'# '!& !-"

#"$" &"#%'!-%&$ &"?

 "/%" -",%+1' /$ 7"!!-"$'$/1&%'!- !!-"#"$" &"#< &'! +' %#". &&"'*", '#$'&"A1"'!/=!-"$/ %7 ../%$ !%'< &#%&7%&&"# - 9"-" ,#!-"/" ,'"#$1'&"/&,!-". ,!%"& '#- 9" /& $ ,"1//=*'"!-,1*-!-"%/" &<"// &!-","$,#!-",%+1' / %,&! //8%!%&,"A1%,"#!+""B 7%'"#<-"!-",!-"#"$" &"# < &$,&&%'*!-", %/< =/%'","//,7!-"!, %'?,!-%&.1,.&"8!-" .."// '!&- 9"'! "B 7%'"# '="="<%!'"&&8<- & <!-"#"$" &"# !, 9"//%'*%'!-"& %#!, %', //%'*,7!-"& %#!, %' -"./ $" %'$%#"'!%&""/ 7/=9",-",","8!-%& 1,!%&! //+ $:1.'!-"

.&!7,!"7,".,!!&""!-"' !1,"%'>1,%"&!*1"&&1!<-"!-",%!%& $ &" //,7!-"!, %',!-"#"$" &"#< &$,&&%'*!-", %/< =/%'" '# < &-%!+=  !, %''!-".&!7,!"7,".,!8//<%'*%'>1,%"&<"," 1'#(6 1&$/"&8'"& '#%'!& '>1,=8#%&" &",#",7%!= , $!1,",#%&/$ !%'  4(@DE3   ;



0  3 3  

6@6

  3   4 

0    3     3    8             44   

33  4  4      4 

 3

 4  FDE3  ;

 0   3 ;

 3D 4 

 3 3  4

3    6  4 4

    

33  4 4    0

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

// '!&- & ,*1"#!- !#1"! //,7!-"!, %'8!-"!%$:"!7%*-! - 9"/&!,!-%&.1,.&"8'"- &! //+ $:'!-"$'#%!%'!-" +#= '#!-",,"$9",=""$!"#,7!-".",&'#"$" &"#-"%'A1"&! ,".,!#"&'!&-<!- !!-"$/!-"&!-"#"$" &"#<","!,',&7" ,!%$/"&<","/&!#1"! //,7!-"!, %'-","$9",=7"7 BH &-<&!- !<-"'!-".",&' /&" ,$-!-"#"$" &"#< &$'#1$!"#8'" .-!$.=!-"#,%9%'*/%$"'$"8'".

66 <","<,%!!"' '# $1,,"'$='!"&F<",","$9","#,7!-".$:"! !-"#"$" &"#!-"&". .",&$1/#+","$9","#,7!-".$:"!!-" #"$" &"#8$",! %'/=!-"!%$:"!$1/# /&+"!-","-",","8!-"./" !-" .."// '!&!- !!-"!%$:"!< &/&!#1"! $$%#"'!$ ''!+" $$".!"#%' !-"&" $!& '#$%,$17&! '$"& '9%"<!-" +9"8!-%& 1,!%& *,""#<%!-!-"%'#%'* ,"$,#"#+=!-",%+1' /!- !!-"#"$" &"#< &'! +' %#". &&"'*",

'&"A1"'!/=8!-", %/< =&%&'!,"&.'&%+/"!. =!-"$7."'& !%'!!-" ../%$ '!&6 .."// '!& '&"A1"'!/=8#'!%'# '=7",%!%'!-".,"&"'! .." / '#!-"& 7"%&#%&7%&&"#

34   

) &>:& ;-"!-",&." :%'* ," &'"# ( "& ;-"!-",".,! +/"

( "&