← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3071/2018dismissed

Ashok Kumar & Others v. State Of Haryana & Others

2018-02-15The Taxing Officer,Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal4 pages

        

 !"

#$% &%'()(*+ , 



       



  

  !+ - .!//  .

- .!/.0/.

1%)%*$+ !1/#2#* 3(14!1*56)3*#*&#*& !1.#7($()3(4&8'#$%) 1$3%2%$($(*%1)  #9%)3 (*&#7 3#77%*:%(*$3%21%)%*$2%$($(*()$$3%#;%*&;%*$ 67%<

"#" $3%#1=#*#>* 6*$1=7#**(*: %2#1$;%*$%'3*('#7 162"/%18('%;%*&;%*$67%)4

 1)31$4-$3%

67%)-"4#) '#11(%&6$8(&%#;%*&;%*$&#$%& ?

 3% 2%$($(*%1) #1% >15(*:  #) ))()$#*$  $);%*46*(1

$);%*  #*&  /%*(1  $);%*  (*  $3%  >*   6*$1=  7#**(*:

%2#1$;%*$3%())6%)6:3$$@%1#()%&()1%:#1&(*:21;$(*$$3%2)$ 7#**(*:))()$#*$3%2)$)#1%$3%1>()%'8%1%&@=$3%#1=#*# >* 6*$1=7#**(*: %2#1$;%*$%'3*('#7162"/%18('%67%)4

<<? 1)31$4-$3% <<?67%)-"*$3%'#&1% 7#**(*:))()$#*$4$3%1% #1%$$#7 2)$)4>3('3#1%$@% 21;$(**7=

  .%#1*%&'6*)%7 1$3%2%$($(*%1))6@;($$%&$3#$21(1$$3% (;26:*%&*$( ('#$(*4$3%A6$#21%)'1(@%& 121;$(* 1; $);#* '#$%:1=>#) B4>3%1%#) 1;$3%'#&1% 6*(1*:(*%%14$3%)#;%>#)  B$3#)@%%*#1@($1#1(7='3#*:%&$ ,B 1;$3%'#$%:1= /%*(1

$);#*#*&,B 1;$3%'#$%:1= 6*(1*:(*%%1)3(7%'#11=(*:

6$  $3% #;%*&;%*$4  $3% #'$  $3#$  $$#7 2)$)  (*  $3%  '3#**%7   /%*(1

$);#*#1% 4#)';2#1%&$  (*$3%'#$%:1= 6*(1*:(*%%1 3#)@%%*$$#77=(:*1%&$>#))6@;($$%&$3#$$3%1%#1% 2)$)(*$3%'#&1%  1#'%1C  <  2)$)  (*  $3%  '#&1%    ))()$#*$  $);#*4  >3('3  ()  # 21;$(*#72)$ 1))()$#*$ $);#*#*& ?2)$)(*$3%'#&1%

/%*(1 $);#*4>3('3()#21;$(*#72)$ 16*(1 $);#*43%*'%4 $>156$$3%2%1'%*$#:% 121;$(*$$3%2)$ 7#**(*:))()$#*$4 $$#7    #77  2)$)  (*  &(

%1%*$  '#&1%)  )367&  3#8%  @%%*  $#5%*  (*$ '*)(&%1#$(*4>3('3();6'3;1%#)';2#1%&$$3%'#&1% 6*(1 *:(*%%1$ >#)  61$3%1)6@;($$%& $3#$ * 221$6*($= 3%#1(*: >#) #

1&%&$$3%2%$($(*%1)@% 1%#;%*&(*:$3%67%)  $%13%#1(*:7%#1*%&'6*)%7 1$3%2%$($(*%1)4>%&*$ (*& #*=;%1($(*$3%)6@;())(*);#&%3%27%#)6:3$$@%1#()%&$3#$*6;@%1 2)$)(*$3%%*$(1%'3#**%7 21;$(*4$>3('3$3%/%*(1 $);%* @%7*:4)367&@%'*)(&%1%&8()D#D8()$3%*6;@%1 2)$)(*$3%'#&1%

6*(1*:(*%%1()$$#77=;()D'*'%(8%& 1$3%2612)% &%$%1;(*#$(*

2%1'%*$#:% 121;$(*$$3%2)$ 7#**(*:))()$#*$)3#)@%%* 27%#&%&4$3%1%#1%$$#7 2)$)(*$3%'#$%:1= 1#'%146$ >3('3 ,B #1%$@% &(1%'$1%'16($;%*$4>3%1%#) ,B@=>#=

21;$(* 1;%111(*$%1)E03#7#)(>($3,=%#1)%F2%1(%*'%3%*%F$ 3(:3%12)$()))()$#*$ $);#*3%'#&1%3#)< 2)$)?

B2)$)#1%$

 @% &(1%'$1%'16($;%*$4>3%1%#)B@=>#= 21;$(*

1;1#'%1)#*&%111(*$%1)>($3,=%#1)%F2%1(%*'%%F$21;$(*#7 2)$ 1;))()$#*$ $);#*()6*(1 $);#* >($3#$$#7'#&1% )$1%*:$3 G , B2)$)$3%1% #1%$@% &(1%'$ 1%'16($;%*$#*&, B@=>#= 21;$(* 1;))()$#*$ $);#*>($3?

=%#1)%F2%1(%*'%3%*%F$21;$(*#72)$()/%*(1 $);#*4>3('3() $@% (77%&62 B@=>#= 21;$(* 1;6*(1 $);#*3%$$#7 '#&1%)$1%*:$3() ?3()()*%'3#**%7>3('37%#&)$$3% %%&%1'#&1% 1 21;$(*$$3%2)$ 7#**(*:))()$#*$ *  $3%  $3%1  )(&%  ()  $3%  '#&1%    6*(1  *:(*%%1  >($3  # )#*'$(*%&)$1%*:$3  $@% &(1%'$1%'16($;%*$3% *%F$21;$(*#72)$() 7#**(*:))()$#*$>($3)#*'$(*%&)$1%*:$3

 1(1$$3%#;%*&;%*$4$3% <<?67%)218(&%&$3#$ B $3%2)$) )3#77@% 21;$(* 1;/%*(1 $);#*#*& B

1;6*(1*:(*%%1*$3%#;%*&;%*$'#11(%&6$(*$3%=%#1

4 1#$(*#7()#$(*3#)@%%*;#&%)%%(*:$3%*6;@%1 2)$)(*$3% %%&%1 '#&1%)$3%2)($(*%F()$)$&#=4$$#72)$)(*$> %%&%1'#&1%) 1 21;$(*$$3%2)$ 7#**(*:))()$#*$#1% , ?/%*(1 $);#* #*&  6*(1*:(*%%1"3%A6$#%#17(%1218(&%& 121;$(*$$3% 2)$ 7#**(*:))()$#*$>#)$$#77=&()2121$(*#$%$$3%*6;@%1

2)$)(*$3% %%&%1'#&1%4>3('33#)@%%*1#$(*#7()%&218(&(*: 1 ,B A6$# 1/%*(1 $);#*#*&,B 16*(1*:(*%%1*$3#$#)>%774 $3%1%()# 61$3%1&(8()(*#;*:)$$3%&%:1%%37&%1)#*&&(27;#37&%1) 3%#1:6;%*$ $3#$ $$#72)$)(* $3%'3#**%7  21;$(* >3('37%#&)$$3%2)$ /%*(1 $);#*)367&@%$#5%*$:%$3%1 1$3% 2612)% '*)(&%1(*:$3%A6$# 1 61$3%121;$(*();()D'*'%(8%&#)

G $3%*6;@%1 2)$)(*$3% %%&%1'#&1%3#8%$@%'*)(&%1%&77$3%2)$) (*7>%1'#&1%)#1%;%#*$$@%'*)(&%1%&*7= 1$3%2612)% *%F$ 3(:3%12)$ );%*%3#)@%%*)%7%'$%&#)1#'%1#*&1%#'3%)$$3%)$#:% /%*(1 $);#*4# $%1)%18(*:$3%&%2#1$;%*$ 11%A6()($%*6;@%1

=%#1)43%#71%#&=:$21;$(* 61$(;%)4>3%1%#)6*(1*:(*%%1)#1% $3%&(1%'$1%'16($)4 1>3;7#**(*:))()$#*$()$3% (1)$21;$(* 0%%2(*:(*8(%>$3%*6;@%1 2)$)(*$3% %%&%1'#&1%4(%4 /%*(1 $);#*#*&6*(1*:(*%%1>($31% %1%*'%$21;$(*$$3% 2)$ 7#**(*:))()$#*$4>%&*$ (*&$3#$$3%1%()#*=(77%:#7($=(*$3% A6$#21%)'1(@%&3%(;26:*%&#;%*&;%*$'#**$@%)#(&$@%@#&* $3#$#''6*$ 1$3%1%#)*);%*$(*%&#@8%4$3%>1($2%$($(*()&();())%& #9%)3 (*&#7"

6&:% *(70)3%$#12#7"

6&:%

, 

;5 3%$3%1)2%#5(*:E1%#)*%&+

%)E 3%$3%11%21$#@7%+

%)E