High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4619/2014allowed

New India Assurance Company Ltd v. Poonam Rani And ORS

2023-04-10Mr. Justice B.S. Walia4 pages

2023:PHHC:049385

!"#$"%&'&#()**+ ",(-& ''./ (%" #01 (23&0&!"- 411"55 (! 6"/'.' ##( 0 (& (-#!7"/' 4*"'1#(-"(!'

#/ 0)

#(895" /*.'!&%"*:*; 5& /"'"(!)

/*<&(#- .1! =-6#% !"$#/!7" 11"55 (!*

/*: > />> /, 5=-6#% !"$#//"'1#(-"(!#*!#* #("$#//"'1#(-"(!#*?* @@@ *:*; 5& =* / 5

7 55"(>"&(!7" 11" 592!7"('./ (%" #01 (2&'!#!7" , /- #$ '* A=?=B 5 %' ' %#01"(' !&#( !# /"'1#(-"(!%5 &0 (! #'*!##( %%#.(!#$-" !7#$ /-""1C.0 /=7.'9 (-#$/"'1#(-"(! %5 &0 (!#*=$ !7"/#$/"'1#(-"(!%5 &0 (!#* (-'#(#$/"'1#(-"(! %5 &0 (!#'*+ #(!7">/#.(-!7 !!7"-/&6"/#$!7"#$$"(-&(>6"7&%5" ( 0"52 /-""1 C.0 / , ' !7" 9#//#,"/ #$ !7" #$$"(-&(> 6"7&%5" !7"/"$#/" &( !"/0' #$ !7" -"%&'&#( #$ #(895" !7" :.1/"0" #./! &( D

(-D

= !7" -"%" '"- %#.5- (#! 7 6" 9""( !/" !"- ' !7&/- 1 /!2= !7"/"$#/"= /"'1#(-"(!'B%5 &0 (!'#'*!#,"/""(!&!5"-!#%#01"(' !&#(#(52!# !7" "E!"(! #$ 5& 9&5&!2 ' '!&1.5 !"- &( !7" &('./ (%" 1#5&%2 .(-"/ !7"1"/'#( 5 %%&-"(!%#6"/&*"*'*5 %'* 3" /("-%#.('"5$#/!7" 11"55 (!7 '/"$"//"-!#!7"%#12#$

%"/!&$&% !"#$&('./ (%"=&*"*1#5&%2&''."-!#!7"#,("/#$<"7&%5"#* AG??= &(-&% !&(> '* 5 %' '!7" 5&0&! #$ "/'#( 5 %%&-"(!

#6"/.(-"/:"%!&#($#/!7"#,("/-/&6"/* + 3" /("-%#.('"5$#//"'1#(-"(!%5 &0 (!#'*!#%#(%"-"' !7 ! '1"/ E7&9&!&*"*!7"%"/!&$&% !"#$&('./ (%" 5!7#.>7 1 %H >" 1#5&%2, '&''."-2"!5& 9&5&!2#$!7"('./ (%" #01 (2.(-"/%#6"/ .(-"/:"%!&#($#/#,("/-/&6"/&''*5 %'#(52* 3" /("- %#.('"5 $#/ !7" 11"55 (! 92 /"52&(> #( 1 / >/ 17 #*#$!7"-"%&'&#(&(D

%#(!"(-' !7 !.(-"/:"%!&#(+#$!7" #!#/<"7&%5"'%!=&$!7"-/&6"/&'!7" #,("/#$!7"0#!#/6"7&%5"!7"(&(!7 !% '"!7"#,("/%#.5-(#!7&0'"5$ 9" /"%&1&"(!#$ %#01"(' !&#( ' !7" 5& 9&5&!2 !#1 2 !7" %#01"(' !&#( , '#(7&0*./!7"/92/"52&(>#(1 / >/ 17#*#$!7"-"%&'&#(&( D

=5" /("-%#.('"5%#(!"(-'!7 !&( 6&",#$!7"-"%&'&#(#$ #(895"!7":.1/"0" #./!&(

8 !7"9#//#,"/#$!7"6"7&%5",7#, '-/&6&(>!7" 6"7&%5" (- -&"- &( !7" %%&-"(! % ((#! 9" /"> /-"- ' !7&/- 1 /!2 (- ("&!7"/:"%!&#(+(#/:"%!&#(#$!7" #!#/<"7&%5"'%!,#.5- 9" 115&% 95"*"5"6 (!"E!/ %!'#$!7"-"%&'&#( /"/"1/#-.%"- '.(-"/) D

"## $#%& '

( *+(

&,)%

( , %%&

./ "#!

%& /

&# # &#% %

0& -& #.

% -

.&&#!

, &# &1 %#

)% .%#% &# ./

!.&# %& %.&!

%-& .!

, % & $#%& '

(

2# ) % .%#%

% &%# .) ,

&# !

%& .

3 %%#%& ,%#!

%& &1

$#%& '

( *+(

(% &1! 1

&## -% # &#%

% .%#% % &%#

. & $#%& '

( *+(

3 & / 4- 0& (&

%.&!

5.#

$ && */ 6#

$ -& %& &1

-% &# &%# 1 #

0& %# &# $#%& '

( &% $#%& ''

, ,

? %"-,&!7!7" $#/"0"(!&#("--"%&'&#(=5" /("-%#.('"5$#/ /"'1#(-"(!%5 &0 (!#'*!#/"5&"'.1#( -"%&'&#(#$ ##/-&( !" "(%7 #$ !7&'

#./! &( D

8=8(6 4%

%& '

= !# %#(!"(- !7 ! &( %#01/"7"('&6" 1#5&%2 ,7"/" --&!&#( 5 1 20"(! , ' 0 -" $#/ -/&6"/ (- ,7"/" !7" 1"/'#( 5 %%&-"(!#$!7"#,("/, '%#6"/"-.(-"/!7"1#5&%2=!7"9#//#,"/$/#0 !7" #,("/ ,#.5- 5'# 9" %#6"/"- (- ,#.5- !7"/"$#/" 9" "(!&!5"- !# %#01"(' !&#( !# !7" "E!"(! !7" &('./ (%" %#01 (2 &' 5& 95" .(-"/ !7" 1#5&%2*"5"6 (!"E!/ %!#$!7"-"%&'&#(&(

&'/"1/#-.%"- '.(-"/) 5& %& )% &# 1

# ,%%-

3)% #%#!

9%&:, $.

%# 4&1.. &%#

;&# 0&

0&& %

%.&!

&%# , %.&# &

#%#!

# #!

& &%#

&## %.&#%& #)% ,%%- )%.

% &%# &## )%

9%-

<%!

%- %.& %!

#%& !.&# . )%

%! %& &# %

)%%- ,%%- )%.

3 "#&# &%# .&#%&

3)% %.&!

&&%#

, .# #& .%&#

3)% )& &1

3,& # 1 )).

3" /("-%#.('"5$#/!7" 11"55 (!%#(%"-"'!7 !7"-#"'(#! #11#'" !7" %5 &0 #$ /"'1#(-"(!%5 &0 (! #'* !# $#/ "/'#( 5 %%&-"(! #6"/ .(-"/ :"%!&#( #$ !7" %"/!&$&% !" #$ &('./ (%" $#/ #,("/-/&6"/!#!7""E!"(!#$'*5 %'* A (6&",#$!7"1#'&!&#((#!"- 9#6"=!7" 11" 5&'%- * , /-&'.% ) (- ' > &('!'*A=?=B , /-"-92!7"5" /("- /&9.( 5= /"'1#(-"(!%5 &0 (! #'* !# /" 7"5- "(!&!5"- !# %#01"(' !&#(#$'*5 %'#(52&(!"/0'#$ E7&9&!&*"*%"/!&$&% !"#$ &('./ (%"/"'!/&%!&(>%5 &0.(-"/%#6"/.(-"/:"%!&#($#/#,("/ -/&6"/!#'*5 %'#(52*

**+ > ?&@

# /&1A %&

BA4%

# %#,

BA4%