High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5253/2013disposed of

Punjab State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd. (Punsup), And ANR. v. M/S Arora Rice And General Mills & ORS

2023-05-31Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan8 pages

# $% "&'()(*+,+-,'$&./

$ 01$

2 32

32 / #4&5% " # $% !

"&&'(! ) )* !

(! ),-,)*..

! !

+ $/! 0 #

! ,-,

2 !

(! ) )*

3 1(-* 4 #

1! + "&&&20555#

! . ,-,

! ! +!

+! #

. 1 "/"0055/,-, 1 "0 5/ $%$2.1 6"07 # 1

! !

,-,!

. ! 1 !1 &( *(

1 + .

. 4 !

,-,8 $ 9"/:05"& !1 . 1 ;

" # $

%" $

&"#

(# / -% 1 + -.

+ .

! + 05"$ ! . : ! ,-, 1 .

+! !1 !

# ! +! ! ! +! &( *(

) < )* ' !

% = !

. ! 1 > &00!

) # *+ ,- #( . ! (((

,-((" /

,-0 ". " ,- " # .

1$&1 2.340

5/# # . 6 7"

,"-.+ "6 89 9 9, 9- ( . . #

1$&1 "( .(

,"-# #( # ( " 1$&1 #( # " 4

7 . " ". # 1$&1 # : # ,;".-< )' ## # # . $<03040<$& . &

="# # # # 9

#( 7 .

# . 1$&1 7 . . # #( 2. ="

0 /

# # . 6 " " . > (( ? 1$&1 , > ((? 1$&1 -

,- #". 9 " : # ,;".- < )'

. 7 .

# # (

"# #@

,-> # ". , - . . # :

1$&1 7 . . # . ( " " 3 .

2 .="

0 # # # 0 " . 5/ . 5'/ 7

##2. ="#

0 # # . 6 "7 . 9 .

> ((? 1$&1

222222 ( . # ( ( (#

",2 .#

2." -

> ((? 1$&1 . .# . #

#. 1$&1 #

1$&1 2" . #

(

# " ( " (( . > ((? 1$&1

# " .

& # ( .

" .# . #,- #

( # . # 2. # # #,- # # " " #

# .# 9 " #

& A : B . "

( *

.!+ !%0 ! ..

.?(

* :7 .

* + ,-, ! !

< +@ 3! !! +!

.1 6 0"7? (

* +2 .

.!+1 +! ?( * +

! !

& A< 1 1 ! .

.4 ! ,-, !

, &( *

! ! ! ! . 1 + ,-, +! B +!

.1 60"73

+!! + 11 &(

* + 60"7 ! !

+ ! ! $57! B "5

00!

! . < + ! 1 +

! "" @ . ! & 00 !

< ! . "0 @ !

! + B +!

! !

! 0555 055" # ,-,

! !

3 ! + +

3 1 ! ! !

. ! + 1,-, ! +

! ! !

- +1 . ! + &( * "$ # 1 +! ! ! ! + + < C "/

* 1 ! + .

! +! 9 &( * ,-, +! !

. 1 ,

* + ,-, !

! + 1 ": 3! .

4 D.

& 1 . >(

1 ! +! !

+ !

"' 3

+ !

+! &(

* + .

.4 !,-, # .

! + ! !

* #

4 D.

. <

B + . . $/! # 11

. 1 +

E! .

6 $/! ! 1 1 "> # 1 "&

1 .

(* !+ ! 32

" ,'$&./ "F E . - 0F