← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/30737/2018allowed

Varinder Hans v. Union Of India And ORS

2019-07-31Mr. Justice Satpal,Mr. Justice Raj Mohan Singh10 pages

         !"#$##%

  

 



   

 

  !  "

#   &'

( )&*+*&,  ( )&* **   

$ %& '

#( "#  $ )"*"

 )  +,    !  $ (% " -( #  .  /

(!.1)!.'

)! 

2"# " "# 3# %# +  +" ",  (% 2*  ," +" & "    43"*5+  (##  . 674476 * "%"

 + +"%    8"* %



2" % ,

"' !  " $  1   9  "  :'!;     %        +  ##   %  #  

 +2"  '<!

:, <% ;



2"=   "#3 

>    

                

        !  "  !  #          

 $%$& / 2")   3    "%     < 



 '(  $

$$ )$$    $ $$%$$        #       $ %$!       #     *   $          $           *  % +  #      $ %$!           

  $* $ ) $$ % +  %     $$   $

 $    *   #  )    $$  %  $         $!     ) #         $$ 

%        $$%        $$%$%$ % ,-   #    .$.   $$ /"+ $$%/" $$  %0!*  1 *  $$% + $$%  +

2 

   .$    $$%* 

 % + !  #   !$$%  #  $$%         

 

  $   % #  $$%  % ) )   )$$%* $!     $

 $$     $    $%!

 )   ! $ )$$%    $!   

$ %$   !$$%$$    $$  "+ ) )    $+   $  ! $$$$$ $ %$! %$!

    $$ $$%  %+% %!    #    +%   $$% %+ %  $

+ $  $!

   +  $ %$      $&

2"# ## "# ")"

 ,+ "#?:,&)1; 8 

"* +"@# " +3A# %  3"  $7    B     )

   6  "<  B    !   ($"  ", <% %$



      7    "  3  A     *%  %    "#

#"##  %   #= "A +" +* *")  

- ,%% 2" #

"   +*     "3

 *

 3 2"#  *%" ##           %   (           

 +"# 3  +*  / /  "# 3A##*")  ,%% 4 /   2"  )   ,%%         3 +  "   

"%"  A

*+ +"%-*  "%3" %   2"-*#%*"    3  <+#"     #"+#"   !  "   )"

,+"# 3 %% 3"

%A  .@"%3) -C %3"33%A

( + "# 3%% ## % 2"  '<!

:, <% ;+ " + #)"

, + ) -C %3#  "3 +  2"# 3  ## %    / -  8  / 

) -C %"3<   *%%#   / /  + ** "#<%@#    "  #          8  "  #  <'!

   %%*%%"+    " @#   2",%%"+   " @# "# %$7B   )

 D%3""%* +  +   2",%% "3 "%#  "@% 3"""# %@#  *%*"# 3*    ## %     +

  #    2"   '<!

     2"

. ,%% "*"" +"")  ,%%"  "#  +* "#2"  '<!

:, <% ;

"3" #"=   "#  " "   !2!      "  #        "  "    2   %    + E  !    3""  3  "     = %   2" ,%% #   "  ## "  " )   ,%%" "= %    !%% " "  #2"  '<!

:, <% ;*3 

& "#",%%"" # 3%   8 "+ " "#  #"% = * " % 





5+  (##  " +* %"#  " "3#  F"%+%"*""# ##  "  #    2"   '<!

 :, <% ;    #     " % *"'!

2"3*3 @%  2" +* " + +   =   +

3 *"A"+*  7 % 3 

  +3""##  % & "

"3 @%   % 3*## ,  %"

%* 3= ## +  + %  +3"7 % %    & "  %    ##   *  "     "  ##    3    *   E  5   "         +*   3    *  

  

/  3 2"    3*%" "* %A "3 @%    3 

 7  "#  3A *% %    "#

#"##  %   #= "A +" +* *" )  ,%% 2"#  *%"##       %    (      *  "  )    ,%%  "  3    +*  3  

  "  3   4 /    (# %  3" 3

"  A

*+ +"% -* "%3" %  2"-*#%*"  3<+#" #"+#" ! ")"

 ,+"# "%@% %%A 3    ## %  #   3""-  8  /  2"F  ) -C % %#    + ** "@#  *%*"# 

2"%% # A " "*+  

3# ""#  #"%    !  %%     3    "     2"  " "# 3%   8

/ B%"* "" 

+   %#   "#"#  2" %  *% *"%3

  E 3  +* ##"  3 A

  +3#   "%@% % %A 2"@#3"

"A

"   " #  A +  %  3%% ## % 

   -  8  /  3%    8"" 3A*   +"% " 2" * " "3 A + A

""3A"'!3  #"   8

 G* ) #%,   "&*&012! *2"* 3!$453"  66  78  *  .6  "   "  3"  "  3   %#   *          #  "    # +  " =   ""* ##  "3A * % 3

* =   *"% !3*  34     $  5    )21   $$ $$!

       6/ $ 



  * * $  $       

 $   $ 5! ) $% %$ %

  $  $$!   $ $   

       0  * $     ) ) $

$$ % $ ) $        

     5  

       *          )     $  % *  +    $$ $!) !)%! $   5     !$ %%$ & 6

2"  G* ) #%,   23493#"3:313%1": +$":0: $!2*#3#$&%$"3! $ $!;<$%#";"3#%:;),,6 "   "    3"  "         #  "    =    * ""3A +   @#  3

*"" "% %  "+ "" A   =     H* , * 

 >4   ! 

 *       * * $ 

$  $ %   $%!    %$    %  6/7  6/4  ) ! % +

       #   $       $%! ,$#  $$!   $!      

  %$!  $    $ * $ %  

 %$! %+  )%    $ !       $!  +    ! $$  +   %$$

) $%      !           



      !  $+     %    $ * $   ) !8# )



$%+  %!

  )   ) $%          %    (    !%#$      !    % ! *   !8$ $%) 9     (  +    $  %  

$  

  

 /   $% 

$  

)% $ ) 66     #



  

 $$   $* $!

   

$% $   $ )  $ $!

$$$$   :    4       

   $%  $!

%$ $

  $%      $  $ %$  %

       ; )

 ; !    + 

    $%

$   

$!$$)%   & 4

( & "",  *3"3=>$$#?30" 23!93!  0%>3=4"@0!#0"3!% $":#A:/;) , 2"%



6 9          $                   +

  %    

  

* * $ )   $%$    %                             

    !!!"#$  % %&'(&)!!) $ ("$$'( <  

)     %   

  

     !           *  * $    $   !  6=4  %   %!  $ #           # 

        $  %        *   

!#  %0  %  $ %! . 8%$

  *(+ & ,   -, , .   .

  / !!0#1 < "  )    

               - - ,2,(3 !!#")$4456' !!#")$ )#   , $  $     $  $   6/ )$ 

   *  * $ )%   

    0* $    

   $  $% *  +               5  !     $$

%        . 8%$ 

           '( <     $      )  2    1     $$ $$!



      6/ $ 

   *  * $  $    

 

 $  $ 5!

) $% %$ %   $  $$!    $ $   

      0  * $               ) ) $

$$ %

$ )  $       

             5             *    ) $% *   +    $$ $!) !)   %!     $          5     !$ %%$ <

   ( + "# 

3 2"%# + - +%  "D ,  (% 2*    2"   8%  +""#   2" #   *   3" 

 =   * 

7+*&8 7 ** 8      0!A ,

+ F"")#A +7  I F""#* I