High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2332/2023allowed

Rafiq Khan v. State Of Haryana And Another

2024-04-22Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel11 pages

!"# $% &#'()($* ++

,-

+ -

!"# $ #%

& '( ) ***** -.

+

+

-

( # - ./& +01 21 '2'+ #

" - " 120/$ 45$5 6!'%!% " $ " ,- !

% +737 8) &/,.- '

"

./ "

! "

-

%9(

! " #

$ % &' #'

(

!)*'

$( +,+-+ $

' ' !$.

/ / +*+-+ +,01+/ 2

' (

3 4 '

/

' (

$

' 3 )

5

+,+-+

" ! 55 ,- % &' !3' ! # 6,--171689

# #"- $((4:336('2'' 9 9 # 9 +'

'2'' :

)(

(

( ! 7,

+,+-+

,+7&*$ $&

$

; $$ <

1<=<2= $

&

<

$ =

=

(

& '

$

)

>

$ /

)3

3 /

/ 3

'2

'

*$

&

<

$ = 5

3

33

'$

9

- #& $ ( (':63('2''- $"9 9 # 9 2+ '2'6 : //

7+6+/

'

& 2

3 // $

(

$ #

? 5( 5% ' /

$$

/

$

( ( $

$ //

)3

3 /

// ( 5

3

39

# #"--

-

+2 '2'6 ;

"

#"

" 20 '2'+ ;

" " #"

- # # ./ ;

" " #"

- # < ) ) " 9 !8(+% "-) ) ) 9 !%9 "

")

;

" " #"

)

"

" /-

" #"

# # =

" 9

# ) ," #"- ;

" " ) ( & '

# #" -

"

- # () -

# #"- ) ;

" " #"

) ) ) !9 <) " 9 " # " % ) "

" , # #

" " ," " " ) & ' )

) /"

) "

9

- # #"- ")< , #" #"

9 "

#" - ) - , " #" # "

"

#"-

) -

9 ) " :

467 $ $) "

+7:6 " (

<= ( & & $

'

@ <= '/

$$$ '

$ $$ $

/ $

<1=$

*18'/ ' 3

'$ / /

A = ' /

' #( 3

( ' /

$

0 2

( & & $

$

( ( /

3

$$$ 3

; 2 ' ' & $

3 ( / 3 / $ $ (2 $ //$

$

($/ / (2 <= ( & & $

'

'/

3

& /

' 60' $ $) "

+7:6 " ( :

2

3 / 2

' &

''

3$

($ & 3 (

4 ( $

/($

2 3 ; /

9 $ ;9

/ / ) !% "

9 !% / >"#) !" #$%&'()*+ ,- & =- "

$" " ( BBBBBBBBBC

$ (//$

'/

(2(

$

/ $$

3

'

' 3

$ / 3

$

(

2 /

2

(

( 2 33

// 2

/ 9 !% / >"#) .

/ 0 ! *

*

1$ 2 !3 44-+ , 3 =- "

$" " ( :8 BBBBBBBBBB

$

(

$ $(

.

// 3

// 2

$

( $ 33

.

2 3

(

$

3

$ (

3

3

2

.

//

$

3

(

3 ( $

$

2 3 ( ' $

/

$ & $ / ((

/

) 2 // (

'

'

( / ;& $ '9

! 9% )" "

# #"- - " / "-- 9 " >" "

- " " ) -" ?

9 ) 9 $ " ) ""

'+ " $ "

-

-

# " - -9 , $ $

+7:6 " "99

) ") - ( ( @ - " " )" # # " ) )# #

9" )) # "A #

- # ,

9 " #

# - # " ) ! # %"#- D (9 #- $""#

"

!% +

"$ $ " - ) - 9 "

-

" # !%

# #"- 5 " - 9 $" #

9 ) " -

# 9 / 9$""# 99 -

- #"

9 " # "

# , - 60'$ $ - #)# - - - # # "

#"-

' =- "

$" !"

% > -

- -$" ) #

) ) >"#) =- "

$" .

/ 0 !"

% D ( - $" . #"-

"

"

4

) 6 "

< 9 ) "

#" -

!% # ( " "

#"

) "- # ")

" / "-- "

" -

(

/ " > 99 - 9 " # "

# " # !% " 9"-

!% /# 9" # " " - - - <" 1 & # " - - " # >" ) # 9 9" " - "- # ") . " <- ) "

, # # 9 " "

" >" 9 - >" $" 9 )" >" "

+2

#"

- " 9 #

# / "

#"-

!% ) - 9B

"

"# - > #" ) - // " "

#"-

!%) - 9

9) 99 )

) ( "

9 ) ) /// . "

#" -

!% "

-

" 9 "- # ") 9 # ) "

- # 9" " , )

# "

- !% "# - -

!% 9" "-

"

# ")

0 / & <" #" -- 9 9 9" " "- # ")

9 " "

") #" # -" " " D ( "

- >" 9) $" # 9 " "

#"-

!% / $" # "

#"-

!% # "

" - # # " " - # "

!% / 9 " $" #"

" " " "

!%"#- - )

! % ++ &9 $"

"

+'

# ) ./#

! % )) # <" " "

" ) ,

" 20 '2'+B

" +6 '2'4 - " " ) 2' 23)

"

- ./ - # & :7 2+ '2+3 # &/, .- " 606 600( /$ 9

" # " #")

9 " - C"#

.- >"#) '4 '2+7 ./ , " D # # !% ) ) -

# D ) >" 24 '2'4 9 -

1 # # ./ "

"9 '2 " 9 5" " 9 9 ) ) ) -

<) 8(+ 8('

9

"< -

# "

- "- " - # "

/ -

" 21 9 -

<) B +' 9 ) #- <) / - -

- # # 9

9 +6 -

! %# #"- 9) 99 23 +'

'2''

) #" A

-

" 467$ $ 9 " ! %"# ) +4( " $ " ,- !

% +737 ,

" - " # #

)

9 99 " #" , # #"- -9

9) 99 21 2+ '2'6 ,

" # " -"2+ 26) 99 -9

) # ") "" , # #

"" # --(

- #9

" # " ") " ) 9

- # " -(

#

"

9 " &#") -

- " ) " 9

") -"-

( " & # #- -

-"# 9

- # ) >" #9 ) # "

+4

# 9 ")

"

" 9 ") +1 / 9 -

9

- #"- " #-" - ; $CE" # 9

) - ) - $CE" #

) -" - 9 # ( !%

)(" - # !%

)

9

") " # !% ,

- ) - !%

))

9 - !%

9 $" !%

# ")- / # #5 5 # ( ")- 9"

) $"/ # !% ,

) +0 / - 9 ) - ) - $CE" # - "

9 # " "

) - - ) -

+:

5 # +3 & # - - "

) +7 )

-

#) "

-

''

'2'4 4' 8

# @ 8

- @