← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/30763/2018allowed

Rakesh Kumar v. Post Graduate Institute Of Medical Education And Research And ANR

2026-04-22Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi,Mr. Justice Deepak Manchanda8 pages

 

  !

       

   



  !"#$!% 

 & '&( #) * % )" +#)+)%)" , "+ - "% )+  "#" $  )$"

.

/   "#$ % % %% #$ %  &  & & 0 #1&02 /3 2 &1. & & '4& #1&02 /3 2 &&.

/  5555 % %%' ()* + 1.& . 21166 7 10.(7 / &/& //    

8(& 9 ./ :; &.

/   9 &6 /0 &3 )&:( 62 % )  1 /7&1 1& & & &&/    <1 )&:( 6=:;>1121:  &3& /&/:;1. &.& &  1/ &7(6&?  1;& 21 : 4    (   //160 >11&21. &>66:7 3& /( /& 16/ #101& && &&/ <1#= &1>  #101& && &&/ <1#= & ( 7&3 >66 &17& .  /  ( & 1 . & (:0 1 1 / 7 & &// :; 1 )&:( 6 1  1 &3  1 . & >& &7(6&?/ 1;& 2>11 &1/2#1/6&/;:

/2 />( /& .& 21 2160 1. &  ( 1 &3 & /&/ .& &   1 &7(6&?  1 &3   :

/&/ ( /& #  /    0.( 1 . &; :  

 : 7& /2  && / &&; 16/.& .6 6>  &  / :..&/ &/@(/ 1( &/ 1&

 )1 . & > ..  /   69+' . 

 AA $&3>&&0 /   AA2>11 > 166 7/ //(& 71 6 .& / 7 / /(2

A AA 21. &>& / &3

+ B( 2AA21. &>0&4/: & 0/(; & >1121> 66 >/ @  :41&32 /1&3 1 . &>&7 &0 /   AAA /1/&0  > 166 7/:;1. &:;& 7& & : &1-: (& (& '/ >&/ // 

2 1 &0   1 &3  1 . &>16/ ::/ /1. &>/&/ :& / &3>1:   (; &3:(>1 (:  :49 >7 )1& &2 1 . & > & /   &3 A   / (606;2    2 1 &3 >& 6  &7(6&?/

)1D( >11&  &1&3 1. &> &7(6&?/>>11&21. &>66:7 3& /:;1# &1 # )1. &..& 1/1)&:( 6 &17& : ( /& 1#2>1160>/ /:;1)&:( 6 17& ( /1  1 # > 0/ ..6:6 >

  2  / 1 &3  1 . &>&&7(6&?/  (7( 21

:16/ 6/ : /&/ ( /& #2 >11 @(/70  //    ./ :; 1 )&:( 6( /&166 7/ 1.& ..6

/ ( &1. &&7(1.&16/

.& .6 6>6/:;13 E 1 1 (&  

      

    1: 16/13  1&3  0.6 ;2>1 > &3

 2>&&7(6&?/ &//21:  : /&/ /&1# &.(&.  7& . >66:..6:6 /1/@(/70 16&/;: (.16/(. 1$ =:6#(.&0  (& + / /1& &210.(7 / &/&./:;1)&:( 6 &&; 16/.& .6 6>6/:;13 E 1 1  (&  (.& /  ( & &.

/    (:0 1 1 / @(/70      (.& 

 : 0/ ..6:6    / &(0  .& 210>./4. 7 3>1 .(6& &(6 7 3& 7 1 0.6 ; > &4 7 ( /& #  ( @:  &/ 7   >11 &(62 &3 & /&/ :;   0.6 ; .& &   &7(6&?     : &/  1 D(6 ; 7 &3 & .(&.   0.( 71. 2>11:  /0:6( /&1  &636#&3(62>11&(6&..6:6 1.&  /1& &21//

&  7 1&716;: ..&/:;1 )&:( 6>16/6 71&6  1. & 131&/16& / ( &1.& /137  1& (711& &/>11&:6   )1 D(  >11 &  >11&2   1   / &(0  1.&  /4. 7 3>1&(67 3& 7 1 &3    &6 36 #&3 (62 1 :   /0:6   (.& :73  1. & & F   & 66&;   : 3 0 / D( 2 1 (&1& D( >11 &  >11&2 1 &3 & /&/ :; 1 . & .& &  

&7(6&?  &3 1   : &/  D(6 ; 7 &3 & 1 .(&.   0.( 7.  & 2>111: 0/1 : &17& :   (.& !. 7 3>1

1&(67 3& 71.&  &636#&3(6 / 1/&(60(. & /& : &1$ =:6#(.&0 (&

+ / 36 ..6 

9C

 C26/ !"#$%&  & 

 '& ()  & 2/// A

C2 >1& 21$ =:6#(.&0 (& + /16/13 1 &(6 &3& /&/.& & &7(6&? 0(:4    ( &1 7&  . &; :   .& (6   1  &6 36 #&3   (62 A   2 3  1  &(6 &3 & /&/ :;  0.6 ;  3&/ ( /& / &(6 >11 7 3&  1 &3  1 . & :4    (   &10D(6 ; 7 &3 & 7&  . &; : 2 1 &3 & /&/ :; 1 . && 7 & 01;&AA >&/6610>&&7(6&?/ 

 : 86(//      / ; 1 :  60/ :; 1 . & $ 2

: &(/11&(67 3& 71&3D(/ .&  1&(6>111# ( @:1 &0/ & > 0.6 ; /: 1 1 &(60 130 /2 / /&(613: 0/1: &17& &6  : /&/ /&1#2>1 >& &3  :(>&&7(6&?/ 1& &  )1 &63  .&7&.1  1 @(/70   ! "#$%& (.&&.& /(/1&( /& 

 

       



  

    



   !

"  # $ % &     

   ' (       



      (               

 (       (   !) $%      ' (     "   *    

     (    + $ %  

       ' (   (    "

$%  ( 

 

(  

      (   (  

 

 $,% -      )

 $ % 

((      .

  /   ( & /   

(( 

    (   

   ' (  

    

 (      (

      $0% ((    .

 /     )

$,%   ' (    

 

               ( 

 

    (      1 2 - 

 

         3

4 $ % " 

  

 ,$%    



  

 (    

    



    

-   

 



(  





  

    

 5   



 





      ' ( 6  "   *   (      (   

  

 

       ( 

 

  "   3

 4  $ % 

 

 !

         (     

  

!) $%-  

 ((     ( ( 

 



   $ 



7   

  

% 

 

       

 ,880 



( (   

(  $% &          (      

$% 

    

  

       (  

 

    (  (  

 



 $% -   

     (

  

(    $% -( (     

    

(

  (

    (

        (  



1

9

     

    

   



  3

4  $ %        

6 

  ,8 : (                   ( (  

        

  3

 4  $ %

        ;

 ((     (  (  



  

 

 



   (     

 

     (   

  

1   >2  .& 1 @(/70       (.&2  ; 0.6 ; >1  >   &3     :( 1G1& &3 >& &7(6&?/1& &1: 16/ 6/ :7 3& /( /&1# )1&63 .&7&.1 1/@(/70 &.& /(/1&( /& *(            (    

     

        ( 922

 

7

    

           .





   8 ,88< -    )   4   "    3  $&

 ) % 

         = ' ( 3   8 ,88< 

    

       - ( ( (  &

),(   =  " 3 

   (    >    088:,882 $&

 ) 0%-  



    '* 3 



      

  

         =  '3 8 8 ,88< 

      

 

&

              

       

           

  088:,882$&

)0%    "    3  

  

  

 



8 8 ,88<  

 

7     ?

        

     ( 

  

 

((    H

/  ( & &.

/    1  :  :6   /.(1/6/.& .6 6> /1& : 3 C !. 7   3> 1  6;  1 &(0  2 1 @(/70 ./:;1)&:( 6.&3& 16/.& .6 6>2 10

:( / / &/ 76;/ )1&.

/   /&/    /& 1 60  1 . & & 1 7& . ( /&1#:; ( 71&3& /&/:;10 .& & &7(6&? D(6 ; 7&3 & 0.( 71. &; :  )1/: >66:73 10>1 1 17

(.&

( 21. & 7 3&3 >

)1>&. 66 >/ 1 &/&0

66  (..6 . / 72  ;26 /. /  % %%

    &  

 +

  

  

 11&#.4 7G / I 11&. &:6