← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5309/2013dismissed

(O&M)_ Union Of India v. Anil Deswal

2017-01-24Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan3 pages

   

       

"#$ %$&'(')*   )') )%'"

++$,,")# (!

-$.(/( )',$(0", $(+)%$)# (!

 *

12  3

423

.$($)#*5 .'#')4/6".7%8&"#$7 .#9$"++$,,")# .36$(9 /+#"7%8&"#$7 ..$(+)%$)#  :9$#9$.#9$$+.#$.( ,&",)$0(+"+$.6";<$",,0$%# ($$#9$=/%>6$)#?

 <$.$ $..$%##9$$+.#$..)#  :9$#9$.#9$=/%>6$)#(9/,%<$.$+.#$%')#9$%'>$(#? 55 55 423 

2!

$".% 9'(  '(  ")  "++$",  ',$%  <; #9$ )')    )%'"  ">"')(#  #9$ =/%>6$)#  %"#$%  @ 7  +"(($%  <;  #9$  "',0";   ,"'6(  .'</)",7

9")%'>".9$)&97 9")%'>".9 ')(9.#1#9$.'</)",1!78'%$09'&9) "&&/)# "6+/#"#') <#9#9$,$>("<8$A)$$7"&6+$)("#') ( 7750"("0".%$%#.$(+)%$)#"++,'&")#",)>0'#9('6+,$')#$.$(# B@C+$."))/6 .6%"#$ #9'(&,"'6"++,'&"#')'$  #',,#9$ %"#$ #9'(.%$.'$@  (  +$.  #9$  &"($    #9$  "++,'&")#7  9$  0"(  0.A')>  "(  " .%/&#')  ")">$.  ')  #9$  +.'8"#$  &6+");  "#  6<","  ")##   )

 7#9$"++,'&")#+/.&9"($%"#."')#'&A$#$D")'+"##6<","

")## .(5 ")%<".%$%30"."= D+.$((#."') :9$)#9$#."') .$"&9$%6<"," ")##79$&"6$)$".#9$>"#$ #9$#."')")%+/#9'(<">)

)$('%$9$#."')#A"=$.A7"(".$(/,# 09'&99$ $,,%0) .6#9$ #."') '(<#9#9$,$>(0$.$<"%,;&./(9$%")%#9$.')=/.'$(0$.$(/

$.$% <;9'6 $0"(/,#'6"#$,;.$68$%#.#'( (+'#",7 9",'709$.$9'( <#9#9$,$>("<8$#9$A)$$0$.$"6+/#"#$% '(#'&A$#0"(,(#')#9$("'% ')&'%$)# 9$.'</)",.$&.%$%#9$ ')%')>#9"##9$#'&A$#0"(,(#')#9$ ')&'%$)##0"(",( /)%#9"##9$.$0"(",)>=/.)$; .6")'+"## 6<"," ")##")%)#'&A$#,$((#."8$,,$.0"( /)%9$.$ .$7#9$(#.;

,(( #'&A$#0"(<$,'$8$%")%"&6+$)("#')0"("0".%$% 9$  ,$".)$%  &/)($,  .  #9$  "++$,,")#  9"(  ".>/$%  #9"#  #9$ +"(($)>$.  &/,%  )#  +.%/&$  #9$  #'&A$#  $  ",(  &/,%  )#  &..$&#,; .$6$6<$.#9$)"6$ #9$#."')")%#9$30"."= D+.$((9"%+"(($%$".,'$.

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

#9$.'</)",')#9'(.$>".%".$"

'.6$% 3 "."()#.$6$6<$.')> #9$&..$&#)"6$ #9$#."')'( &)&$.)$%7'#'()##9$&"($ #9$."',0";(#9"##9$"++,'&")#0"()#./) 8$.<;#9$#."')9$"++,'&")#0"(./)8$.<;#9$#."')<$,)>')>#

55 #9$."',0";(:9$)<#9#9$,$>( #9$"++,'&")#"<8$A)$$0$.$<"%,;

&./(9$%")%#9$.$0"(9$"8;<,$$%')>")%9$0"(.$68$%#9(+'#", 09$.$9'(<#9#9$,$>(0$.$"6+/#"#$%"<8$A)$$7#9$"++,'&")#6/(#<$ /)%$.  >.$"#  +9;('&",  +"')  ")%  6$)#",  (#.$((7  "

$&#')>  9'(  6$6.; 9$.$ .$7$8$)'

#9$#."'))"6$'(6$)#')$%0.)>,;<;#9$"++,'&")#7'# 9".%,;6"##$.( 9/(7#9$.$'()',,$>",'#;.') '.6'#;')#9$'6+/>)$% =/%>6$)# $)&$7#9$+.$($)#"++$",'(%'(6'(($%

423 !



  (=A( :9$#9$.(+$"A')>.$"()$% * $( :9$#9$.$+.#"<,$ * $(