Saraswati Devi v. State Of Punjab

4 IN TH HE HIGH COURT FOR THE E STATES OF PUNJAB AND HANDIGARH HARYANA AT CH
*+*,-.

./  12  +$+$* *+*,

        $$$   0



         $$$ 31 



 (

  !"# $%& '(
# (

!

' 1
0*
.
.

'

!

 
1
.


"
..5
*/ ( 1



&
.

 !

'"

'

!

' )%$


6


(
!
( ()


* 
'
7



  
' )
(

' 
(
#$%



   

* 
'
 

  0
!
$

 '

 





 0!
!'
!

'
  
!

* 
!
 
!

!


 



!"
#$%
&



& 
'"


!
()

'"


+  
 




''*
+ ( 
,*"
&
&
'-* 
&

'"


!"

"



")
)
 '
"

  "(




"
 


& 




*(
./
0


(
 

*'
! 
'
 
!

!
12
+"

"
3
$ *
!

*"
!
%
 42


(
*''

'!*
(


.
"
&

* '
8'*
( (&
"


9 
+ 
!*





*'

")
& 

(
 
()
"

  9 

)
&

 !

*"
!
%  :42 
&'
"*
!
*  
&*

"*

 
!

" )
!
% 4942
 

 
()
"

+
 
& &

 



*(


' ''*

,* *"
* 
'"





"

"*
!
%

:42
&
 "
()
)


&*

(
!'
! 


"
;
(

 * *' 

'"




!" 
"*
&


' ''*

+&
!
*'
 

!
12
+"
3 
$ *
()
&)
!

*'
&'
 '

*


"'

 




'

' ''*

 )

"* 
!
% 494 2


'"



 
*

*




!


* 
%

'

'"


'"

&

 )





!

(
 "
!"

;

'

*
&
'-*
!
%
 2




















%

74 2
 ' )
(
!
& &'
&
* * 

*!!' ')
!
!* 
6



' ''*
!

'"

)
& &

"

' 
!

" 


(&
"




&


'

"

'*
"
&!*



()
 
&!*


! *

'"

+'
'"

 
)
!
 
'
 



' ''* *

. 






"

"

 '
!
 
!
'  )
(
(!

*
!

.



*





 

  


&
8

  (!
!
"
( 
*(/'


/ 


&

 !
:
) 
+&


!



 
!

( ' 
&
" 
 


   6



( 
!
()



*



(
*
()

'*



(
!

 "

'



'
$
!'



 '"


"
.

"

"
!

"

"


(&

'  ''*

'"


&
 

&
' '

''*

,*"
&


'

*

'
!"
"
 !

12
+"
3
$ *
&

 *
 "
(*

!




()
'" 

 



)
8
" *
!
% 7 2
!
8
!
"

"
6
'
"
&



'' 


"
$
&
" 
!"

 
()
' ''* * 
, ,*"

''
&
''

*
+( 
,*"
&
&
'
 !

"
!
12
+"
3 
$ *
6
 



 
"*
!
%
2

 
'"


 

!'
"
!
 
'
"
"
*

6
 *
(&

 

!
'
 *
6
&






!




*
& 
'-*

!*
!

'"



(
*'  
 
&
'"


* 
' 
7
!

( 
$*"

"
.'

 
(
!
()

'"

 

  ''*
<  0
+ & 
,*"

./
0 
'
(
8
(!

!
!
 
( (

6
'
!


 

)
&

'
!
 
' ''*

 

  )


 (
'

*


  '  
* 


!
.(
.'
+
'* 

, *

 


-*



 
/



' 
/
 


**'
!

!

 


()
*
 !

.




* 

*

 
 *



*

)




 
 )

( 
()

"
' 
!
(

(
" 
()


*
6!


*
 


 


(


&

 *
 

(
!
()

   
$ $

*(" 
 

'*  

()

'*

!

'"



*



*




 $
!'



"
' 
!

*(/'
'"
.
#$%
(

:

 7 

( (

* 
'


4

4 =>
!
0


 '
 
(( 
'
5? ( 
 
*(
!



'

' ''*
./
0


'* * (*' 

!"'
!
*)
()
 
$
;!!'
&



/ 




"
 


(
" 6

 

"


#$%
  

&


?
' "
'


& 
 
()



''
&

*( 
'' "

'


**'
!

' ')


!
"


!* 
'"


()
8'
*
"*
!
")
!"
"

6
' )
!
'
"

&


 
"*
)( 
()

 


(
!!' 
!
&'
'*  
!

 

-*

+ +'


*


 


( 

(
" 

$

 
'*
!

!



' ( 
 


 
*

" '
 
'

   .
*
!

" '

'

'
 

 


  

()


.

.



* 



 

(
 

(




"
(
()
( 
 * 
 

(
!
'
*  )
!
 

()



*

!

!*
!
' ''*
<
0 

(
'

' 

*
!

!
&'
 


'" "

"

(
!!'
(& 

'"

 

' ''*
<
0 


&


''*
 

)
!

!
 
(

( 


&

 ''*
+& ,*"
 
 
(
8
(!
!
 
( *




&


)

" 
(&

 

&






"

" 
)


 ''*
./
0 
&
 

*(
!



(
8
(!
!
' ) )
( 
 

   .

"

) )
*
!

"*
!
%

:42 

"*
!













%
 2
 
*
()




'"

@ @


 "*
!
*
'-*
'"


!
()

'"

 

  


 :

$

(( 
-*

 
&

&
)
 
 *'" 



!


 

'"



 

!" 
"*
!

* 
!
"
!

"



  
!
'

!
$

( 
'


"

 $



(
  

' 


!!'
* 
'

!
$ 




!!'
* 
' 

!
$

6
&

    
!
&


'"
'

' 


!
 ? 
!

 *

*
6*

*(


  
!

*


!
!* 


5 '
)
!
 
!
' )
(  




!'

''*" !

 '* 
'
&

*


8 '

'


' )


  ?

*
!

'"

 



&*
)
 

% '
 


'
(
'
*  
 ! "#$ %
 

 

      
A=  >

47
!

'

   6





#$%
( 
 


!'
 *
'

'


" 
 "
!

*"
!
%

:4 2
()

'"


/  &



' ''*
!
 
* 
!
'*
*' 
!


"'

)
'

!
12
+"
3 
$ *
6
*
!

!


 *
( &


 

  

(
 " )
' 

*
6 



'

 &



''
!

! 
B 
(' 
!
8
(!

!
!
' )
(

%
 

&



/



( 
()

"

' 
 
(
" 
( ()

*
6
'"



  )
!
'"


* 
 ( 
$*"
.'

" 
(
$!





!! '


 





* 


''

&*

(
( (*

*!!


'- -*'
$
*'
''*"'
$ $
"
!

'  
 


'*



!

 


-*


!



!
#$ $%

:

' ''* ./
0

'

'' 






 




)






'

''*' .''  )
&*
"  
)
'""


"
!

!

'






&

 



'' 
!

6 

'  )
(
*(/'


' 
 

&*

* 
(! $ 
;!!'
&


!

!

)
!"
 )


* ) )

$
;!!'2. 
;!!'


 
 

( 

 
!*
 2*)
( 

2
!'
6
  

 
( (
*(/'


!

&
'  
=>
6



'  
&




 
(!

$ $
;!!'


& &
-*

=>




' 
 ' )
" 
)
 *'"

"


"

)

'-*
&

!' 
!

'



* 
"2
!"
'


*'
!

!'


*


)
 '

'
;!!' =>




'""
 )
" 
!!'
& 

(

 $
'
!
 
!
 )
!

(
' 
/* '  *


(
" &


' 

 '
!
''

 
!
)


  
  

'' '
&
& , (MANISHA BATRA) JUDGE +$+$*+*,


Yes/No Whet ther speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whet ther reportable