← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5414/2017dismissed

Union Of India And Others v. Central Administrative Tribunal And Others

2017-03-28Ms. Justice Navita Singh,Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma3 pages



      

 !"# $

%!&' ()%&*"+,"# $

 ! -%% -*' 

 '

'.'

 %-/ '%0.

%,*% -1%* &*% -*'



'2 '



   

     

' ()

% ,-- %3& %!

 ! -%4* ) 3.

5./%3*%/%,-&%,!*2 '

 6 



    7 %8

 ! -%% -*& %! - % &3&'

*%%-&*% 1*--%- # "# 92%''-0:* % -/ '%  0.

%,  *% -1%*   &*,  4*0:  *  2 6 %.*'*%0 -&-&%1;*2%6'2 ' * <'=-&%1:<% -1% */*& %! % &%0 !' % /0.

-/%

 ?"@ *%*%-% --- %3& %! -%

'.22!*'42 % -1 *.1**&-'

?A@ *!%&'%'/1'.%*%*2%6'2 'B - *2%/ %')%;- #"

#"

C$9% -"# "

C++,'2&:

3.0'>. :,*:4/%-%'%6)%% -* %'%'4  !

# # CCC% -# # "##",'2&:

 '2  "*%'-!/ '& %%  1*%1!'.2%

.%  "+ #"

"#  1%-''!

*!%&*%*2%6'2 '4 1%1-%'%'% -4 2!/ 1'=--.',*:4 1% -*26'-'&%%'4%'

  

   1% -'=-/2:'4= 1 6 &,/:% -%:,4  !

# # C+ *1% &! &%''!: 1*/%''=-4='4%'

* %'-0:'/- &%:2%&-%'0!*0.

%    CD D"###4*&*4%'%4-  # # "## !4 1% % -&'  !  *  .4%*%   &*  ! * 0.

%  *  -&'  !  * 0.

%4%'.2*-0:*B.'-& %1*.!%//.5%'*/

*'%--*%'%-/-:%% -! %:

 :,*'/%:

2%&-/2:'%'4%'*2%6'2 '42%&- * '=-1%-'% -1% -*& %0 !'

?@ *2%6'2 '4%1% '.0B&--'&/ %

4* %!&/2 !+:%'<'&*:4- -* E2%:6 '&%  %-/''0    <'=-  &%1:<,  !  4*&*  *:  2' -  

#C #"

"# "% -"

# "# "

*2' % '4. --4 %1% ' 4*&**:%1% %22%&*-*0.

%% -* 4%'-'2'-!

---%-"A #C "# A4*%-& *%.*'%=% ! %-&'  */% *%!*/2.1 --4%'2%''-

"

# "# B& 1*&%/

?

@ *2%6'2 '%1% %22%&*-*0.

%0:4%:

!  #9#D## ""D"##4*&*4%'%4-0:*0. %-- -%-

"# % -*--%-"

# "# 4%''6%'- -&

4%'''.-6& '-*&%/ *1*!*%-&' !

*51*. )% '*/-F%-% -*''.'

 !

 -%% -*' 4*- &%''.4%'-&--4*.2*- 1* -!0:*0.

%

?9@ *  2 6%.*'  *4  B&-  *  &%/  ! 2%6'2 ',*'/'% 1*%*0 !! )% '*/-

  

  F%-<'B.-1/ 7'.2%84%'%-/''0 :*'/2:'4*4 2%:*%&%'% - 2%6'2 '

' *'0%&=-2*% *0.

%*%'-*-.

-&*% 1.2*-*&%/!2%6 '2 '

?$@

/ * %%  ! *  ',   /%: 0 '  *%  * >.' %'4** *2%6'2 '% -0 &%1;-%''=-4=''% -''-0:*0.

% *!' .

-!1% % -*'%-B.-1/ 4%'-.:.2*-0:51* .  % -  *%'  %% -  ! %:

 *  2%6'2 '  *% 1  0

&%1;- %' '=-  4='  %B.'!%0: -    /% %  '.&* &%1;% %'.0'>. '%1'%',/'4* *' &*% 1

*&&./'% &'

?+@   .  & '--  4,   &  *  '%.'  !  *  2%6 '2 '%' '=- 4=' ' .

%''%%0,*:%  - * '.0'>.   & %  0 !'  %'  4  *  0 !  !  '.0'>.  '  2%:4%'- -*2%6'2 '%'*:4 2%:

)% '*/-F%-<'&%'7'.2%8 *0.

% '.&*&&./'% &'

*%'1*:*-*2%6'2 ' -'=2%: !*:

4 2%:*!'.

-!'

?C@

*%' '%!6'%-,4- ! -% :/ *'

&%' ? #@ '/''-   ! "

   #  )%&*"+,"# $ !  "

  #