← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4695/2014dismissed

Jagraj Singh v. Pritam Singh & ANR

2015-01-08Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri6 pages

 

        

 !"!#$%    &'

()!#&* ++,,  -'"."

/)!#&* *'

 "+#0# "  

 

  

 ! 

)$ 1' ()!#&*)!0*.203

'   

"

  3!#&  '/ !#0  .#". "".,  4'  *  !3!,  .0& 5)#!'!3!"!#62

'!07 + !#!,0.#0') !#8'

09!

) !# *.

#:;

'0" %5!#"*'

< * =6'

/#    "  &.

#    /!#'"  '

"*0+  > .'

.&* '6 #0).'!#0')!#&*5"#6 #0''"

'

!# 0?

*!/2 ++' *0 *!".'

4?9 ?!#"

,,#&!#& *(.0&/#

9

"',3 ' 0(.0!

!# *!#"

''

*'!#/ ?4# ! 0* !"

*' */!#'"2 /,?2'

"*0+> .'50 .&* '64'## 8  #0).'!#0'

)!#&*5"#64'##@@ *'"+#0# ' */

'# ,&'

" */!#'"* !,0 + !#' ."

/!#'" /9 ,,904? *!3!,.0&5)#!'!3!"!#62 1.7 ' 9*! * "!,0 *!".'

3!0

  '0'0

0 ,,90 ,# *+!# (.'!"0!

!##,? 93'2 "&'

0+'/!""!# !, !#4'

* .'

3!#&  * (.'!"0!

'? * "

/ * !"

9'7!#&  "  #  #0  ,"  9#"    / ',  +.

 *."  !#  3!,,

07 '#*9! 2# /,?2 "9 > ,!

"1* > .'* 0&# *'+ 0 ?"4' *0,!3'?/!#'

).'!#0' )!#&*  ,#&  9!

*  ,,  (9,,'? #0  3 ,.

! ,"   0,!3'?).'!#0')!#&*2"** 00!0 '0!#& '"+#0# ' &0 4.

%@?

'" #09'3#.# /

#0,7  ' */",3" * "* 3+'* *29# #+'+'

?2!,,!

#0# '# #?

*!#& #0* 3#".'

!# / "". * *? .,0# 4'!#&.+ #00.

*/!#'"

+'+',? * 'A."

""/ #? !/" 0,!3'4 7 */!#'"4.

# !, '0!#&,?2

!,0 + !#.#0') !#8'

09!

*) !# *

' ."

*/!#'" +## ! 2 "0!0#

#0  9'  +' 00   B+   3!0  '0'  0

0    93'2  #   2  '"+#0#   '0  #0  !,0 

++,!

!#'"

!#& "!0 *B+ '0'0

0 9*! * "  ,,90  !#  3!9    #  4( !#  &!3#  4?  *  .#",  ' 

*'

 '2'"+#0# !,0 9'!

#"

/# '

!"!#& '!."+',!/!# '?4( !#" "+, 00

0# ,3  !# 9 '0" */!#'" #0!#

"+.++ #0"*!""!"

95* 4*!6

"+'*'9!"*" .'

*'+, 00

"!#  *0 ?*"

'#!#&2*"+# /"

 *!" '#!#&"# "+' *9!"*"*!""!"

9 ,9 ?"

!&#'0 */!#'" *!'/ *'

!

"B '/#

#  9*##  2*+' .'0 # 0+ !#00

*!#"

# *!""!"

9"*9!#&

** 0+  *!,05"# *!""!"

96 #0"*90

0+ !#9 "/ 0 ',!'* !0  0+ !#  00  9 "  / 0  7#9!#&  .,,?  9,, 

 *  9 "  #

/+ 0+ * *!,0 "*9 ,'

0?* 3!#&#/ , / , *!,0 '0!#& '"+#0# !0 0+ !#00* 4#B .

0#,?' *+.'+" 0+ !#2'

*'!

04# 9'!

#!# *"* +&! 00D9!,, #0!

04#& 9'!

#

0+ 0 *!,09.,04# 9*,*!"+'+'

?!*0!"9*!,!# "'3!  ".'

*'+, 00

',!' ," '!0

7' !4, ."

*/!#'"'9*! *  '!/!# , /+, +#0!#& *!/ * #3'+ !0/ # .#0'

) !#  *0'!/!# ' 0.'!#"+!

 ""!#&

*'0'4? * .'

#0*!"!# ''

'" 22DC #/'!

"2

3'/# "/ 0!# !#9'0#!0 +'

?''0!"/!""

,

/9 "/ 0 '/ *+, 0!#&" !"2

'

/0 *,,9!#&!""."$C

 ;* *'+ !#'!"# &.

#/!#'"'"*0+> #0).'!#0'

)!#&*E  ;* *'  + !#'  !"  # ,0  '  ."

0?   /!#'"E  @ ;* *'  + !#  !"  #  /

4,  !#  +'"# '/E

,! @ # ".++'

 *!" "2 4"!0"B /!#!#& *!/", ";

,"B /!#0.'

#0!

)!#&* ";

/(!

 )!#&* ";@59'#&,?#./4'0 "; !#69*'

"# * *'

#02'"+#0# B /!#0*!/", ;

 *  7  !""."   #0    & *'  4!#& ' ## 0  #0  # 

!#    3!0#   ,0  4?  *  + !"

0 !00 / *,0!#&

,,# "&.

# */!#'"'"*0+ > #0).'!#0')!#&* "". *9 "# # 0? "".@9 "0 !00!# 3.' "*,0!#&

!#9 "# /

4,!# *+'"# '/ '0!#&,?2 .'

3!0(.0&/#

0!"/!""0 !## 2 +'"# ,  '#0  .#",  '  *   ".4/!

0 

4!#&

*' */!#'"* 03'?'!&*  , !/ 0?

#09 "# *!'&.

# F '#0 .#", .'

*'  ".4/!

0 

*   9 "  * 3!#&  ".#0  !# # !

7&'.#0 #0* .,0+'3!04

'.

.' */!#'"   '* '!#&, '#0 .#",' 290#

!#0 #?/'!

, 8 *+B.'

!# $%&'()%*%*+)',-.%//%  01 0)+)/1 #0!" .""!#& *!"".',

!#&  ."

0?/!#' *!,0 0*,0 ".#0'$C <

'/  *  43  !

 ,,9" 

#  '0'   ."

0?/!#' *!,0'#!

*'.#0' *+'3!"!#"

 *  .

#"  #0  ;

'0"  2  %  '  !#0.

1!#'!

? #0.

#"*!+ !"'A.!'0 4 / 04? *.'

!#& *!# '"

#09, '

*/!#' 4+ /.# !/+'

#  !"#

 

''!&*  *!

*'+

9.,0'A.!'

0(.0!

!#  9*!,  0 !0!#&  *!'  # ,/# ."

0?  *  0"!'    *  *!,0  .+,0  9!

* 

!, 4!,!

?     #0. !3  #0  ++'+'!

#3!'#/# '+'+'.+4'!#&!#& & *'9!

*

4!,!

? #0/ #" * # '#0+

' * *!,0 '"/ *',3 

'"

3  4

7# !# .# 4? * .'

9*!, 0 !0!#& *!"". ."

/!#';*

/."

4  /+* "!G0  !" 

 9*!,  ,,   *'  

'"  .#0.4 0,? ',3 2  !

 !"  *  0"!'2  !# '"

9, ' */!#'9*! *!" * '. !

#0., !/

#"!0'

 /."

 &.!0  *  0 '/!#

!# 'A.!'0 4/ 04? *.'

= % * #

!#3!0# ,04? !"

*,0

+.++ ** #0"*!""!"

9 0+ 0*'"##*'0"!' +, "*'* 0# #,?

0+

(!#0')!#&*5"#*!""!"

964.

00!"!#*'!

4 *  /!#'" '"*0+  > .'  #0  ).'!#0'  )!#&*   '0!#&   

0+ !#  002 

(!#0'  )!#&*  * 0  4 /  *!"  0+ 0  "#  9   #0  *  9.,0 !#*'!

 *!"  # !'  +'+'

?  * 

# ,.00

!

9.,0# 4"

 # '."

0? */!#'"

*'9.,04 4!&'!"7 *!',!3"

** #0"

*!" 0+ 0"#

(!#0')!#&* "' '004?

*.&* "* 0# 4# +'3 *!'+ ! ., ".' !# /4.

*/!#'"9',!3!#&9!

* 9'4!#&4'.&* .+4? */

+'"# */!#''"*0+> .'

  ""

.0?!#&!# *"

'0 #0/!#').'!#0')!#&*9 ,""

.0?!#& !# *" *, *!"

"".! !# +'3

9'

7!#&&0 ' */ #09' ,"+'3!0!#& */ ,, "!  !,!

!",!>+!#&!#3!9 *

#0 !' ./"

# "

"2  *   *,0 

*   9 "  #  # ,0    4

"&.

#/!#'"'"*0+> #0).'!#0')!#&*

"". *9 "# # 0?  #3!9 4329*# *, '#0 .#",'

"# 4# 0!"+, *!#0!#&"' '004? .'

''!30

#

!#3!0# +'0. 0#' '029!#0 #  (."

!!

  !# ''  !#  *  (.0&/#    *   0



 #3!9 43 *!#0!#&"' '004? .'

2#&'.#0!"/ 0.

'0 , '!#& &.

# */!#'" ,"!#* #0!#&3' /!#'" *!/  '0!#&,?2 *!/+.&#0(.0&/#

 ""04? !".+*,0 * ,4!#&03!0 #?

/'!

!"*'4?0!"/!""0 0 

1 2$ %-3%(&4"   0 ! 1 &4"

2$