Subhash Chander And ANR. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

 



    
 

 

 

    

  !"   #$    

% 

 &'(  )*&  
+ &



   !"#$

%&  !"#$"

&'

()&*+"# #$* ",- (%."#$"

'/  ,$+-. .&'
& &&-1$-"

(&!"&&'.& ' +
&2& & '  
&.&-&$&$ 1$-3"  4-2- &2'"&-!&% &1$- &5%% 6



72&



5

"+'5'  8- $"%  *% 6

 9/

72&

 5

:"+'5'  $-&%% "2& ;+  "'&
#$5%&5'$ & $' 5.& '& ($% &(" -

  +48 
&&1$-"2&28+&  .&-!;+ &+& & &$'-2& 9<'+5 ='+&&1$-'( +



6#8+/7"&+ &>8+$
+ "''$ '' 
&&1$-'2&.&"'& '  2-?++!&1$-"?++!&.&52 +)&''$ -&*$5 ,-=5  &  &  *$5  ''$  &  ''   #  '  & 
 #$5  %&5  6#8+  97  ''      .&    & 1$-"+52    ' 5&%% 



 +'  5'     8  -    $      +  ''5,2$" &+5'&;+  "& 2 +&' 5  +- &' & ;+  "     $  -  %+&  ' 5 2    +)    & '' &+@+55+" & ''85 - +2!+"  & '''+ +' 55 5' ;+ -" ' ''$-&1$-*
55%5  -" %% .&2    ' 5&% *

 9/

+'5'  $- $&%%  .&2 +)&'' 2 &+@ +55  +"  &    ''85 -  +  2!  +"    &  5    &  '''  +  +  ' 55  

/ 5'   ;+ -    '     ''$  - &  1$-  *
55 #5 -"($% &("48 
&& $ &1$-"22&%%  



2&

 5   9"
'  

6#8+ :7 &% @% 
55 &1$-,2 & 2&% *%  

 9/

2&



5

"
' /

6#8+7 % @% 
55 &1$- .&      2        ($  % &  ( '++&

+-&5
/

:A#

  -&*$5 ,- & 

25 

&  5 &'' "&$4&$&  2&&$& &%&&!  ?++!&1$-"?++!&"+ '' 

&&-1$-"(&!.&$4&$& &  +       5  2  2      5' -   1$ +&)+  &5%2&$& 5' - ?++!&1$-2  &8& 5' - &&-1$-"(&! .&    &  +  5 +"    5-      &  & '   
:

/ &
+2& &-  
/:/

  '''- 

  &5   -    

:" & 
+    &  &- 2  5 '-2&($% &(&+&

&5 +& 2&5 5,2$"''& &+ &&-2 $& "&+&8&5 &  8 &'-&%% % * % "'2&($% &(.& &   '  =25"&1$-"'! &+ & ( "&&*$5 ,-2B &5 &&& + 5 &'
:

/ .&'+-%-&*$5", &>+ '5"*$5 ,-"  &25&

&%+&.&"&&&   ($% &(&5' 5-&1$-2 2&+&''$  &*$5"&+ &25-, &2$&&'' "A#

"  -& *$5 ,- &+-($% & ("
/ :"&55

 -,&& 5 &'&  ;+ - &-&&;+  &-

/& "&-+ !+&  5',

+&&&'&$&;+;+  & &5&+ ( &
+3
+

 5 &
#$5%&55 .&  '     &  '     '    & 25 &&5 +'2+  ''  %'
&.&-&($ % &(&  5 &5'+ &
#$5%&5&+ && +&;+  &   .&-    &  &  2      &    5+ 5'+  -+&;+  $ &  &  '-  

   !" +  &'"2+  &"5 "&1$-55& '+'&5"&%+& 5+5$ ( & 25-& + &'  &1$- #+ +3"

:6#8+ 7

  ()&  *+"    #  #$  * " ,-"  2+     &  &     + &  -  &  '  2 8($% &(" -+
&& $ &1$-" 5  &*$5C'' , 2+ &2$&&  5 2  &  & ;+
&2+ + +'&8&;+.& +5' -'+35 -&*$5&
&?++!&1$-2 '2&.&&( +&5

'- && -1$-"(&!"  !&-

"2

: ''$-&*$5"&;+ 5  2  -+
&# &5"2& ($ % &  ("  
&    &&  -  1$-" &  - & .&& &% ;+ -+ .&5    -5 & 5'+ - +5;+&;+   '+&&%% &% *%  .

&;+  2+  - &   -+&  5=&&"2&&'&    -;+& ;++'5'  &;+  & $"& &&-& ;+&;+  &  &5= &-2+   5 +&  &-&;+&;+  .&5&  + &5&5%5  -"& 2& ''( &@3
+"'  ''$-&1$-*
55"'' %'
&  .

& ' "


A+(= --$+ +& $ %'
&'2&.&&&-    -' & "5-& 
 #$5%&5.& "&52&&2 5  & '   -'' &8 -

%' 
&  =      &  %D    &  &  1$-  *
55' ''$-( &3
+ 


&&&'  ''&"'+& ''  3  &  $   -"  & 
+      )+ 2&$ &*$5-%% '-%  *% '-&' &-'+&;+  &

$='+&&'C   - 5% % - B3

 5% *%  - B3"

:.& "& -&  +& '-       &  '    ;+ -  +     &  +& &'' B& #+&  2+)+ - +&5   "&-2+   & +&'- :<'+5 .&2' - 2.&'     8    &  '  %  %   2&  

  5

"+'&5'  8-$"%  *% 2&

 5

:"2&&-5'  $- &  %  %   .&      &     &         & '  2&&" "8'+ - -$" &5& 5& '   '- & .&&  /+ &  

  2&&'! @'!