← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2427/2019allowed

Ankush Tiwari v. State Of Punjab

2021-11-15Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl19 pages

 



        

 

!"#$% & % '%! &!

()  "% *    

!

+ & % '%! &!

()  "% *  , ,

'%!

-"

& % '%! &!

()  "% *    

  

&%  %&% & ./ %"* % %-% )% 0".1.&!

() %2%( % 0"./ %%*   3*4

   

  

   !" !   

   !"# $ %  

 % !

#" **4  !

% 

5 %& % % 3*4 0 " 3*4  6"/%  0" 7 8"/%  0"   (*4 %*    "*% **4 9 "**4  %-% )%  0". 1. &!

(). **%   *  :"""" )( "**4 %44$ ;

/$  " %  3    " **4    )( 0/ )+ " 4%   !

4. " **4  % 44$  6"/%  0" 7 8"/%  0"   (*4  3*4  %*    44 " "% **4. %*/4+ 3  33  *%   %% " #

&#'('

#" %% $44 *  " % "% **4. 

4 )+ **44   !" #$%.  

4 )+ **44  !

+   ,

4 )+ **44  '%!

-" 0  " (!03   < 5

 %%   5

/ $"" 44 " !**44  $%  /       !

%  = /'%!

-"

)*+*

,,( &( ( -( &( 

,< % $"



 ;



& 4  # !

%0 %0%! 3*% 3  %  *%  +%   *+      . >.  !4  $""  !%"%!

%03*43*% 3 %3 "

% )*+*

,,( &( ( -( &( 

, % $"



 ;



& 4  # !

%0 %0%! 3*% 3  %  *%  , +%   *+      . >.  !4  $""  !%"%!

%03*43*% 3 %3 " 

,, % $"



 ;



& 4  # !

%0 %0%! 3*% 3  %  *%  < 3 "    *+     ,. >.  !4  $""

!%"%!

%03*43*% 3 % 3 "

, 

5  ;



& 4  # !

%0 %0%! 3*% 3  %  *%  , +%   *+      . >.  !4  $""  !%"%!

%03*43*% 3 %3 "  / !"#$% )*+*

,,( &( ( -( &( 

,< % $"



 ;



& 4  # !

%0 %0%! 3*% 3  %  *%  +%   *+      . >.  !4  $""  !%"%!

%03*43*% 3 %3 " 

, % $"



 ;



& 4  # !

%0 %0%! 3*% 3  %  *%  , +%   *+      . >.  !4  $""  !%"%!

%03*43*% 3 %3 " 

,, % $"



 ;



& 4  # !

%0 %0%! 3*% 3  %  *%  < 3 "    *+     ,. >.  !4  $""

!%"%!

%03*43*% 3 % 3 "

, 

5  ;



& 4  # !

%0 %0%! 3*% 3  %  *%  , +%   *+      . >.  !4  $""  !%"%!

%03*43*% 3 %3 "  /!

+ )*+*

,,( &( ( -( &( 

,< % $"



 ;



& 4  # !

%0 %0%! 3*% 3  %  *%  +%   *+      . >.  !4  $""  !%"%!

%03*43*% 3 %3 " 

, % $"



 ;



& 4  # !

%0 %0%! 3*% 3  %  *%  , +%   *+      . >.  !4  $""  !%"%!

%03*43*% 3 %3 "

)*+*

,,( &( ( -( &( 

,, % $"



 ;



& 4  # !

%0 %0%! 3*% 3  %  *%  < 3 "    *+     ,. >.  !4  $""

!%"%!

%03*43*% 3 % 3 "

, 

5  ;



& 4  # !

%0 %0%! 3*% 3  %  *%  , +%   *+      . >.  !4  $""  !%"%!

%03*43*% 3 %3 "     

  

          

     

  

                        

         

     





2%   " *%   % "  ?; )% 

,  ,



$ %0% !

%   ,,. ,. ,<. , .

5.

 " ;

 & 4  "% =;&@  &4  3*!%.

64 "%.  " 3   6"/%  0". $" " %/  (!%  " "   " *%  !**44    4   1!%* %  0"

7 A44. $" "   ) 4%  *%43  % #" %4 !% %  % 0 "  % /  " 3  "  4! " "   !

%  ,  % $" 

;& $  3 ! 0  " *%  **44    "+ $% B!  " "%0 !

%  ,  % $" 

;& ; $   *%0%*"   " %4 !% (!03  "  *% " 34 *  .

   " "% %.  &C %!004. &C %9- !004   &C

%   2" " 4%  +  "  (!%   0%!  4 % "/ 0 ) 4 $" !"

$40 %     !

% !"

%!3 .  )+ " 3. "+ $!4 "/ ! " "  " (!% *% 6"/%  0". " "+ $!4 "/ ) 0!4+  3!%%

 #" **44 . "!. "/ )  /       "    "/) 4"% )/ #" !% 0 " *  +  " *%  **4. "% *% **4  "/ ) 3/  "% *% **4 % *4 0 

%% " 3*%3 )+ $+  /  " 3*4  $" "

   " ! 55<  " ) 4 

% *4 0  %% " 3*%3 )+ $+  /

D!%  $" %*  **44   !" #$% #"  /  %*%!  !

%    !

 "  # $       

  %  !       

  

&'

(           ) (*+   +((,,-(.

  +,+ +,/ +,0 +-1 (/2 (/* $  $"  

%  !     3

4       4  "

  % 

 5  6   5 4                 

   

         

7   

7

"$ 

" 6  "  !

 !                #    0-2,-(*     5  6  5 4        

        

     6    6      6 

&'

9         

       

    5  6   

5

:  % 



 6 

%  !  

       5  6           

.

    6  

 6    

    5  6 

9 "        

  

       5  6  



       6  5  

   

 9        

#            5  6    6      

  

 5    6  

    

          

 9    

 5       

          ;



    5 

    

    



  6  

     

   < = < 

 6      5  6  9        

#            5  6   ;

    

< =

 ,     >     6 

6  6 6  6

 

  

   







 

6    "'%  3   & 3            

  

      5 6          3  !  

(/(,,-(*

"'%  '

$ #

?:

5  6 9

5 5  " ) 4   

% *4 0  %% " 3*%3 )+ $+  /  3*4  $"

%***44 !

+#"/%*%!"% !

%    !

 "  # $       

  %  !       

  

&'

(            

) (*+   +((,,-(.

  +,+ +,/ +,0 +-1 (/2 (/* $  $"  

%  !    6   3

 4   "

  5  6  6

     < = 

 "$" 6  "  !

 !          3

 4   "

  5  6    #    02,-(* ,    6 6       

       

     6    "

  % 



<

 ) ,2 ) 2  6 

!  

 6    &'

? 9         "

  % 

          



  

   6    



       6            

 6 "



% 

          

#   "

  ;

 

        < = $ #   <

< 

  

   5      

 

  6     



 6    "

 

?9    

 "

  %  6             6



 

 

   

 5     %   % :

6

  

"

  ?9    

         

 >  6   6  6

  5 

   

  

   @      

  

   6   

"'%  3   & 3            

  

      5 6          3  !  

(-(,,-(*

"'% 

,5,  " ) 4  ,

% *4 0  %% " 3*%3 )+ $+  /  3*4  $"

%*  **44  '%!

-" #"  /  %*%! "% !

%    !

 "   " # $       

 A %  !    $ #     

 

&'

(            

  ) (*+   +((,,-(.

 +,+ +,/ +,0 +-1 (/2 (/* $  $"  

% !    6   3

 4   "

  5  6  6

    < = 

 "$" 8 6   "  !

 !          3

 4   "

  5  6    #    -0-2,-(* ,    6 6       

       

     6    3

 4      

  <

 ) .1/ 8

 "  

   !  

 6    &'

? 9         3

 4   

!

  4

          

 

    

   

  6    



       6           

 6 3

 4       4            

#  

 4    ;

 

         < = $ #   <

 < 

  

   5      

 

  6       



 6   "

 

?9    

 3

 4       4

6              6



 

 

   

 5     :  % 6     

6



4  

?9    

           >  6   6  6

  5 

   

  

   @      

  

   6   

"'!



" %B$C)B) 3   & 3         

      5 6        3  !    % & "'!



" %B$C)B)   " 

)

!  



 $ #   "

# $ 5     ,( :

 ,-,-

) /-1+ !    $

 *%!4  " )/ / $!4 "$ " " 3*4  6"/%  0" 7 8"/%  0" " *44+  " $"" %/  %*)4."3%") *"!* "



3*4  "  )(  " !**44  % B! "%0 "?;%0%0 "3B!"% 44 A%  !

4 % " * % " !)3 " " 3*%3  0 !    )    " %%%  " (!03    %  2 "  " !%   

 !"

# 

$ 4  = % & '( )* + ,!*"') ) ! !" ,- &.+/ 0 + ,!*"')1     " !

% 34% %!3 . " * !

%  5 %& $  %    " ?; $" 44 !)B!  *% 0 $ B!"   / " (!03    / $    " )  3*%3 A%  !

4 % " * % " 4 %4 !* " 4 (!03   

   " : E)4 !*%3 !%  ;

 

'2%2+ 3 44" 3 +,5#6 ,-

4  7 %8,4 3 9 +' :) *"

! !" ,-  *; &' ")*1   

 3%   " *%+ " " *% * )44$ A%  !

4 % " 3*4  " !)3 " " 3*%3  0 !    )    " )  %   $"!  + % . !

!  4!    *%!%   $!4 "4*  )% 0 0 ! *   "%3 + )$ " 34  " 3*4    " **44 :*%+""*% **4)44$ #"!%""%4% !

4%"*% #" : E)4 !*%3 !%  ;

   %8,4 3 + +' )  !*% " !  4 " *$%  " :0" !% !

%  5 %& 4 0 $" "% ! #" %4/  *%   (!03 %*%!"% )4$  ,  

      

    + )  ,--- $  "     :

  :$ 

    

      

         $   " ?   9   ) (      

5      6    6   

   

       ) , 



5    6   

        6     

 

"  ,*/ +,+  +,0   6 +/    $   (20- ?    D $E9  "  +   $ 



 ?"    "   9  (*2* F   G    7  !

  :  ?9       "  ,*/ +,+  +,0   6 +/ $ 6  >     

" +,0

  6 +/ $

>>> >>> >>> (,  < 

  

       

                        6          

   ;

   

  >      6 "  /2,  $       

   < 

           ;

    

 

  

       

    

  

               5 6

 G  

#         #   (+    

      

   '



6      '

 

     

      

                           < 

         



   #  "

       6   6   #   6  >     6

        6  

  

5       < 

  >      6   5  6     

        6  

   

   6 

     

   

            

     

  

>   > '



6

"  /2,  $ 6

  



    #                   6

  < 

 

   #      

    6 "  /2,  $    





#  6           

     #  C       6  

    

    

   

   >   



    

  )  " A C   "   $ #   7 > )

?"

9 >>> >>> >>> (* H              " +,-  $ 6   

  ;

   

 6       D

 E 6   

6

5  >



6 #   < 

"  /2,  $

   

  (/,           5 

    

  "  +,-  $ )  6

       6  6  

   >        >  ;

   

    & ?9 ) 

       

    I ?9

% " 

   #

   I ?9 3  

 

 

 6      I A ?9          

 



   

  

    

 *%!4  " )/ (!03  $!4 "$ "  " ) "4 " " D% % %+ *$%  (  !*  :0" !% !

%  5 %&.  )  /  )+  " 3   )!

   , %& ; " !%"% ) )%/ " %3 4 *% 0 /4/  " !    ) 

!44 %%*/  "  " %4 " 4%+ )  4!   **4   3 0   /  " "  0 ! *!

"3    " 4 %3  4/% 0 (! #"!.  0 $"! +

0. " "  $"% 3*%3  %! * / . " :0" !% !0"  D% !"

%

$"

%!.

*

/$ " %!3  !%%!

 0"    %  2 "  " !%   % & '( )* ) 

. " 44$   !

% 34% %!3  #" %4/ *% "(!03 %*%!"% )4$

=$

     "  /2, $  

;

    ) ,,.   ,/-2,--. ?>

 $'(9 "  +,+ +,/ /., .-0 (/2  (/* $? ;

  " +-2  ++0 $9    $  "   " 

) 6    % ') 6      

   -0-,,-(.?>

 $'/9  

;





 

   #      



     ,.-*,-(+        "  !

 "  @   " ) 

 6    '   6      >>>J>>>''>>> K    

         #  



    ,.-*,-(+        "  !

 "  @   " )    

    

   -0-,,-(. ?>

 $'/9    6    

  

    



 >>>''>>>''>>>  

      .0" 2+8* + +,!*"'

"').) ! !" ,-  '; + + +,!*"'

<5  '2%2+ 3 

      



               6           

  "  

      

  < 

      6

"  /2,  $  ;

    

        

    #    

 

&'

(.       5  6

" +,-  $  6        <

 



      6

"  /2,    $



       

 

   

   #  (0     

 >      " !

 6     6

"  /2,    $



    ;

  



 

    6        5                    

 6     =' ':2+ ') .3 "!> : ! !" ,-

  *;

&' ")* +'

#  '2%2+ 3 6



#

 65



         6   

   ?  9     

"  /*2   $      

(2  =        6   

      

  >

 ;

     

 5  6                    #      L       

 6

       

   6L     5   6

  (/,      "  < 

      6 5     (/,               

      < 

 6  5

  6 

(1    

  #

 >     < 

"  /2,   $



   6 6        6



    #   6   6 

      6

;

  

        

    6   

"  +,-    $



        6  

  6  >              

>     5     6    # 

    

  (2 >>> >>> (* >>> >>> ,- >>> >>> ,(              6         

.

    ?      '' 6

  ) ,9    

     6

   6     

 

 6

  G

               6

     #     ) '

    

 6

    

     #  6   



#  

 "     

     5   6

"  /2,    $



   

          

 

 

                 5    #

  5 6

 #

    

 ,,  ;

  

   

'  6  6        # 

   (0-+,--*         )  /,.'(  ,---      !

  :   <

 

   -2-2,-((

  6    '

  ) , ?"

 %9 6   #  ;

  

   



        

  ) ,   ;

         ' 

         

          ' 



  (0-+,--* 6

    



            

< 

"       8*"3 2+8* "').) ! !" ,- &.+/ 0

5<  '2%2+ 3 # 6 

    6    "  +,0 $  6   





    

6

      

 

  

     

 6  

  #  3 * + "').) ! !" ,-  '; + 

6    '2%2+ 3 #<# + **,!

2+8* "').) ! !" ,- &.+/ 0 66   '2%2+ 3 <6  6  

   

 "  +,0 $       6         6            6         

 >>>J>>>''>>> 

 

) ,,.   ,/-2,--.

?>

 $'(9 "  +,+ +,/ /., .-0 (/2  (/* $? ;

  "  +-2  ++0 $9    $  "   "  ) 6   % ') 6      ;

 



  

 ;

      ;

      

   -0-,,-(.

?>

$'/9 #





,.---'     6  $ #  "  7  "   

    ;

   #      



      ,.-*,-(+       "  !

 "  @   " ) 

  #





#"!% (!03   , *  ,

   4  7.3""4 2+8* :) 2/ ; .% ' + +,!*"'1 " "4  !

%  =          .)* 3; =":2  )) + :) ,,4(2)*,'"

*,'"

   '2%2+ 3 6#  = %, '  &' 0*. :)  ;"

0 3 3 

 6 

  

 #

   < 

     "  /-( $ 6

      

   #  6           

          

 

   

  ;

  6

       

   

    

6         

     >  6

        6    " (/1

)   

         6  = %, '  &' 0*.

:)  ;"

0 3 3 

  6 6

  ;



   

  ;

    6    6    6  



 6  

    #    (*-(,-(1       "  !

 "

 :

5 "   6         

6 

   ;

        6  #   

 (.M   ;

 

  

    6  = %, '  &' 0*.

) > )" ).4'   "  7  "   

    6 

 6   

;

 )

;



 6

4   " )/  (!03  $ 4 *4 !* " (!03   " : E)4 !*%3 !%  = %, '  &' 0*.

)  ).4'    "!.  *% 4 4$. " !% " " *$%    " (!03    / 0  " * %  " )   /4 3*%3#"3*%3 "*% 0 !  /4 -* 0  /$ " 4$ 4 $ " )/  (!03 .

3% . " (!03   " : E)4 !*%3 !%   %8,4 3 9 +'

)  !*%. " %4/  *%3% %  %  4 $ "

!

 (!03 . $!4 )  % )+ " !% ?%4+. " !%%  $"" " ) /4/  " *%  *  ) 0%F  *!%4+ *% 4 > %3 4   *%/ !%  4+. "  (!% $"" "/ ) ! %   0%!  4     **%  D") 

43   3 4 *%/+ % 33      !"  %!

!%. " B!4  !" 4   $!4 /%% *!)4  % #"%4+.  /$  "  (!%   "  .  $!4 ) 33%4 " " * % "/ )  / )+ "  4   6!0 ?!%"4+.

" 3*%3  $"!  + % % 3*!4  " )  %  $44 04+   /4!

%4+ ?"4+. " !%%   *4  " +%

 "%  " 0  "$ "  + !

$%    "   *4 % " 3 D"4+. " **44  % %   " 3>( 0 % $"% " 3*4  6"/%  0" 7 8"/%  0" %   "!. " 3*%3 $!4 )% 0 *   "%3 + 3 0 " *% / "4+. " )(  3 %  " %3 4 (! +3 $!4 %3 !

  *   "  3)4 43  )$ " *%   >% %!4 B!4"* % #"!. * 0  /$ " )/     %!3 . " *%  "% **4 % 44$   " (!03    /  < 5

 $44  " %% $% 0      5

%   "**44 %B!   " 3 **4 % .

 %%  %B!%  ) *  " *  0 344 ! **4 .   +.   " 3 % * /0123 +4(56()"    % 

C""%*  0>%  8>9 C""%%*%)4 8>9