High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3174/2015dismissed

New India Assurance Co. Ltd v. Devender And ORS

2015-07-09Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Garg5 pages

!"# $#%&'&() #*($&!''+,!(%#-.!(/0&-&"#$ ..#11!(" 2#,'+' #2#($#,!($"3#,' #'.($#("' 456078 93#"3#,#.,"#,' 0%!1#*'.!.#,'-!/:#!11*#$" '##"3#;+$<-#("=

:#,# #,,#$""3##.,"#,',("= 93#"3#,"3#;+$<-#("'3+1$:#,#.,"#$&("3#&<#'"= ,#'#("4,777&$3+>$2%!"# ,"3#!..#11!(" ,&#("!1('+,!(%#-.!(/0"$3!'%3!11#(<#$"3#*!,$ $!"#$ .!''#$:/73,&!<$##.7&(<3>",%%&$#("1!&-' ,&:+(!1>7(&.!"2&$#*3&%3!(!-+(" ' > ?> @5!1(<*&"3&("#,#'"

A B '"$!*!,$#$""3#%1!&-!("'(!%1!&-.#"&"&( &1#$+($#, 7#%"&( CC "3#",D#3&%1#%"> )??(!%%+(" &(;+,&#',#%#&2#$ :/#2#($#,%1!&-!("

3# !%"'>!'.+" ,"3:/"3#%1!&-!(">&'"3!"( ? .#"&"&(#,*!'%-&(<"3&'3+'#&(2&11!<#!,373!3;!(.+,! "#,<&2&(<

$@"& &(""3#*& # 3&':,"3#,&(&2&1'.&"!1>7(#.!"!($3&' !"3#, !-!,'!$*!'%-&(< ,-7!:E&!($&!

"#,.+,%3!'&(<2#<#"!:1#'!($

"3#.#"&"&(#,!($3&' !"3#,-#"( 7#%", ,!$!($*3#("3#/*#,# "!1F&(<"#!%3"3#,*3&1#'"!($&(<("3##G",#-#1# "'&$# "3#,!$>&( "3#-#!("&-#>!!,-!F#!"! ($&%!%!, :#!,&(<,#<&'",!"&(5 @@) )3&""3#.#"&"&(#,$+#"*3&%33# #11$*(("3#,!$ 3#,#!

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

!"!2#,/-$#,!"#'.##$!($(%,,#%"'&$# "3#,!$!($&"3!'

%-#$+,&(<&(2#'"&<!"&("3!"%!,:#!,&(<,#<&'",!"&(5 05C?

*!'&(212#$&("3#!%%&$#("!($*!'"3#,# ,#"!F#(&(".''#''&(:/"3# .1&%#!($1!"#,(,#1#!'#$('+.#,$!,&"&"'*(#,7-"!;8+-!,& !$!( #(/&(< "3#, !2#,-#("'> !('*#,&(< ,#'.($#(" .,!/#$ , $&'-&''!1 "3#%1!&-.#"&"&(

#'.($#(" !..#!,#$ !($ &1#$ '#.!,!"# *,&""#( '"!"#-#("!($,!&'#$.,#1&-&(!,/:;#%"&(',#<!,$&(<-!&("!&(!:&1&"/>%!+'# !%"&(#"%(-#,&"'&"&'!11#<#$"3!"%!,:#!,&(<,#<&'",!"&(5 @@) )*!'("&(212#$&("3#!%%&$#("!($"3#(+-:#, "3&'%!,

*!'*,(<1/("#$$*(!($"3!"$+,&(<&(2#'"&<!"&( C$!"#$

? >&"*!' +($"3!"%!, :#!,&(<,#<&'",!"&( 5 05C?

*!' &(212#$ &( "3# !%%&$#(" !($ "3# '!-# *!' "3#,# ,# "!F#( &(" .''#''&(:/"3#.1&%#!($1!"#,(,#1#!'#$('+.#,$!,&"&"'*(#,7-" !;8+-!,&!$!(#(/&(<"3#,!2#,-#("'>!('*#,&(<,#'.($#(".,!/#$

, $&'-&''!1 "3# %1!&- .#"&"&( ( "3# '&-&1!, 1&(#' ,#-!&(&(< ,#'.($#("' &1#$"3#&,'#.!,!"#*,&""#('"!"#-#("'!($.,!/#$ ,$&'-&''!1 "3#%1!&-.#"&"&( ,- "3# .1#!$&(<' "3# .!,"&#'> 11*&(< &''+#' *#,#

,!-#$45 93#"3#,"3#&(;+,&#'".#"&"&(#,#2#($#,'( !- !,'!$!,#"3#,#'+1" !%%&$#("*3&%3"F.1!%#(

? $+#",!'3!($(#<1&<#("$,&2&(< !"! ($&%!:#!,&(<,#<&'",!"&(@) ),!"!($&%! :#!,&(<,#<&'",!"&(5 05C?

:/&"'$,&2#,'=

&''+#( &'.,2#$>"*3!"!-+(" %-.#('!"&( "3#.#"&"&(#,&'#("&"1#$"!($ ,-*3-= 93#"3#,,#'.($#(" *!'("31$&(<2!1&$$,&2&(< 1&%#(%#!""3#"&-# !%%&$#("!($"3#

#($&(< 2#3&%1#3!$2&1!"#$"3#"#,-'!($%($&"&(' "3# &('+,!(%#.1&%/>& '>&"'#

#%"=5

#1&# C 3#,&:+(!1>!

"#,!''#''&(<"3#"#'"&-(/ "3#*&"(#''#'

!%%#."#$"3#%1!&-.#"&"&(2&$#*!,$$!"#$ >!'!

,#'!&$

##1&(< $&''!"&'

&#$ *&"3 "3# !:2# '!&$ *!,$ $!"#$ >"3#('+,!(%#-.!(/3!'$&,#%"#$"3#.,#'#("!..#!1 ? 3!2# 3#!,$ 1#!,(#$ %+('#1 , "3# !..#11!("@('+,!(%# -.!(/!($3!2#<(#"3,+<3"3#,#%,$' "3#%!'#

) 0#!,(#$ %+('#1 , #* ($&! ''+,!(%# -.!(/ 3!'

'+:-&""#$"3!""3#,&:+(!13!'%--&""#$<,!2##,,,&(31$&(<"3!"!"! ($&%!%!, :#!,&(<,#<&'",!"&(5@@) )&'1&!:1#".!/"3# !-+(" %-.#('!"&("&''+:-&""#$"3!"&(2#'"&<!"&(*!'$(#:/"3# .1&%# !($ %!, :#!,&(< ,#<&'",!"&( 5 0@C?

*!' "!F#( &(" .''#''&(2#(!(;8+-!,$,&2#,3!''"!"#$"3!"3#*!'$,&2&(<%!, :#!,&(< ,#<&'",!"&( 5 0@C?

7> "3# &('+,#, %!, :#!,&(< ,#<&'",!"&(5@@) )%+1$(":#3#1$1&!:1#".!/"3#!-+("

%-.#('!"&( 3!2#%!,# +11/%('&$#,#$"3#'!&$'+:-&''&(:+"$(" &($ !(/ ,%#&("3!"'+:-&''&( ( "3&' %!'# &( ,$#, " '!"&'

/ "3# +,"> "3# ,#%,$ *!'

'+--(#$!($"3##2&$#(%#*!'.#,+'#$

,-"3#.#,+'!1 "3#,#%,$>&"&',#2#!1#$ "3!",&<&(!1 2#,'&(<&2#(:/"3#%-.1!&(!("&("3#&'"3!"!%%&$#("3!'"!F#(.1!%# $+#",!'3!($(#<1&<#("$,&2&(< %!, :#!,&(< ,#<&'",!"&(5 @@) ) 3#!+"3, "3#!'*#11!'&(;+,#$.#,'(> *3'# .,#'#(%#%!((":#$+:"#$3!2#!1'%!"#<,&%!11/'"!"#$"3!"!%%&$#("3!' "!F#(.1!%#:/,!'3!($(#<1&<#("$,&2&(< %!,:#!,&(<,#<&'",!"&( 5@@) ) 7>-#,# !%""3!"%!, :#!,&(<,#<&'",!"&(5 0@C?

3!':##("!F#(&(".''#''&(>&'("!<,+($"3#1$"3!" !%%&$#("3!'"!F#(.1!%#*&"3%!,:#!,&(<,#<&'",!"&(5 0@C?

+('#1 ,"3#!..#11!("%+1$(".&("+"!'&(<1##2&$#(%##G%#.""3# '"!"#-#(" 773/!-7+($#,95 >*33!''&-.1/'"!"#$"3!"%!, :#!,&(<,#<&'",!"&(5 0@C?

*!'"!F#(&(".''#''&( !-

!,'3!$%-.1!&(!("*3&1#!..#!,&(<!'953!'%!"#<,&%!11/'"!"#$"3!" &(;+,#$ #2#($#, '+

#,#$ &(;+,/ :/ ,!'3 !($ (#<1&<#(" $,&2&(< %!, :#!,&(<,#<&'",!"&(5@@) ):/,#'.($#(" 7&-&1!,1/ #2#($#,&(;+,#$%1!&-!(" 95C 3!'!1''"!"#$,#<!,$&(<,!'3!($ (#<1&<#(" !%" ,#'.($#(" 7> &( "3#'# %&,%+-'"!(%#'> "3# !,<+-#("' !$2!(%#$ :/ "3# %+('#1 , "3# !..#11!(" "3!" &('+,!(%# %-.!(/ %!,:#!,&(<,#<&'",!"&(5 0@C?

'3+1$:#3#1$ 1&!:1#>%!((":#!%%#."#$ "3#,.&("3!':##(+,<#$:# ,#-#$+,&(<"3#%+,'#

!,<+-#("'

('#H+#("1/>"3#!..#!1&'*&"3+"!(/-#,&"!($"3#'!-# '"!($'$&'-&''#$&(1&-&(# %./ "3&';+$<-#(":#'#("""3#",&!1+," ,'",&%"

%-.1&!(%#