High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3231/2015allowed

Seema And ORS v. Raj Kumar And ORS

2016-12-22Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj9 pages

!! "

$%#

!" #$%&'

"%$ '"

($)&

& '

$() *+, - !! '

$.( () *+, - '

$+/!*+, - 0 %*+,+(*-.# ( ! ./ ,!( 1() , - , ( 2 ./ ' ,,( !( (.#!* #) 3! -

4 (.#!56- -

%# 3! -

4 56* ( + (,! ,,( 787097:9 2( , . () )( ( ;:7; ;8<:= 3!

4 --()+ (,!56 9 (

# (+!+ ( ! ( ,!( - !!

1() ,-, (*(!-, - , .()

1( - 1-.

+(/ 0 ( - >*87*777?; !!2 ./ (.#! ,!( *2 , # -!!2 &;

3(6 -

%# 3((6 )- 0</

3(((6 #!(,- =@@<7?;

3(+6 #,(-:?8 !(./ (.#! =@@<7;:>:@<6A <=8B< # # -- <=<776 3+6 # - ,/ - !/() #!( !( -:@ 3<=<77C:@6A >97777 # 3+(6 D

-, (#- 2(- :7777 3+((6 D

- - <777 3+(((6

# !C <777 /0

8 D ,# !- !! )# 2 !/ .(! ( !/2-, /2 09/

-) (.#!E# (2( (!/2) 1 ! / 9:7?; /*2 (, !2 (2+ * ( # (,-

./ (.#! .# #) , - , (-!!2() ( &; 3(6 .

+( - C# (, -

"# $ % & '( )* *

" ! ! ##+ ,!( (! (( ( (, - 2 -## 3((6 '( , (! - (,!( 90 !

(! , ( - !

- !+ --,(*, )#(, 3(((6 (.#!2 , (-:7*777?; 2(-- - !

-, (#*2 (, !2 (

3(+6 , ( 2 2 !

- -# ! C !

E# ,!! - , 1 () ( +(2 -, ,,(

1 !,( / 97:9 D ,# !- 0; , / )# (.#!1(,- -(!/2) 9:7?; / 2+ * 2 (! , #() #! (, - , * (!/(,2 #!( !(2( 0@</ ( - , 12!) ) !/ - !! 0@< / - / <9#/ (/ (.#!

#! +#, 2) -<9/ - #!(,- ) ()

#.(

(-! ,# !- !! - ) -((((, - 2 -## * )#

(!! # , ( ( ( - , ! ) , - C # ( , - , *( - %* . (

" !

// @

!/* 1 E# ( - (, -

./ (.#! !(; 2 (! () F;0

.2 2 1()( !/2-, /.#

,#!

#,/+(,( # - 2 (, ! (.#! 1(,- -(!/2) -( #.

#.(

(-! ,# !- 0 (!/2) ) !/ !! 0@< / - / ( , . -!/

# (!/2) +(!

!(/! !!<9#/ *2 (, -!!(/ (* -,( .1, 2 (-,(!/2) .# (,2

E#() (2(

(!/2) ,!( ,#! #,+(,- !/ (, .(! ( !/2-, / = +(!/2) 2 () #@777?; ( / 97:9 (.#! !/ !( - #! - ,!,#!() 2) ./

#()(,- 9:7?; /* . - (! , .#!/)#

2 1- , ( (( (,-

#@077?; () ( -( ( - 2( ( , ( C ,( ./ (.#! --, B ,(-! ,# !- !! (( ((,-

#! +.!!2 .

+( - C # ( , - ( ! $ % & ( ! .,# (!! ().- C# ( - ,( , -. ( ( !!

( (!!*(( ! ((-!2./ C# ,!( (! (( ( (, - 2 -##

!(2(, - '* 0 ( (

! /

* ( ! $ % & ( !F (!1() - , ! ) , E##-) -((((,2 -##

( (,-+(,(- + (,!,,(*2 ( !- !/2 (!(-- ()2( +(21(, - '*

( ! C# .

+(. ( 1 ( ! -!!2 &;

! ! # '* $% &%

! %%

(

#! ! !

' ! # ) ! * % !

' #! ! !

' ! ) !

! + ( ! !

( " # ,! ( !"(

((!

!"! ##

(

% ( #!

- :7 , -

#) , -H.! C# .

+( :::9 -!!2 &;

.(&% 02 /!%# 0 (%

#(# ( ! !

#!! !

'* 2 /!%# 0

## (

' #!! ) !!(

( !( ! !%#!! +

'!1

! " ( 2!( ! !

' #!! ) ! ( ! ( ! "( ! ' ! %!

+ (%

( ( ! ( #% %% #!#(! !! !

' (%

( !% (

# ' ) '!% +( !( ! ! %#

' !

2 '* 2 /!%# 0 ! ! ( ! ! "

' ! !

!3""

2!% (&4 /

05.&&

6 "

( ( ! ! !

' ) ! !

' !%# % "

' $%! 7%

+( !"( ! %#

5 ' ! ! !

( #!

$%!7%

I ::

- ,2 ! ) , -H.! C# (, -. ( ( !797=97:8 $#):<7<97:< ( , $ % & ( !

#) , - H.! C # !!2 -## ( , - !-; !/

-!!2() .

+( (, - ( ! :9 ,, - -## +( ) , , #(( - #,,

-# )

( !(- 2 (, ( ! ,#

-+- + / #.()(+!+(/+,(+(-* 1 ()(+(2 .(!(/*, ,(/,*/.( (( ( !(-* ( , $# (-( ) - (( ( (,- *2 (, H(-!( / H(2 (, 2!! !(+()1( ,-(! * *, (!/2) ( -,12!) (, (), ) *!.# , ) (!/2) +(, (-!# ()! 2, #(, ( C - (!?!.# , ) ? )( , 2( , E#(! (, ( ( (, ( .,# - () (, ( , - !(+() (, - ) , / ( - (!/ + !

(, (-! -+(,((,,( +!

(#( #-, (( E#( .$# .!

8 1 () (-!( / ( +(2* 2 (, - . (, (( -!(- !(1!/(, -# :0 , 2 .-,!(:*- -,!( 90 -,!( ;

( , ,(/ .* - - + (# #( - -(!/* 2 (, !

$# (-/ ) - (( 2 !/(,!1 - ) !! -(!/--(

!(1.1 ,,# * D ,,(* / - !, (,(/ 2 .(!!

* - -

, !,!!))(), (! * ( , *(,! ! , - -(!/, +(, ./ (!

/+!#

+(, ./ # ;2(- ,2 (, -( ) - (( ( (, - 2 -## $# (-( :8 (.#! !!2/, (2 !

- !+ --,( , )#(, ( , (! - * (,

:!, (2 ./ (.#!2 !

-, (#- 2(-- ( !

,:!, 2 !

- * !+ --,( - : !, # ! C 2 ./ (.#! <777?;( !

!2 (

( ,9<*777?; :< +(2 - / .+ ( ,#

(* , ( 2 (, ,!( (!(

-!!2 &;

3(6 -

%# 3((6 )- 0</

3(((6 #! (, - 3

./ (.#!6 =@*@<7

3(+6 <7J - 3(((6 .+ . -##

=@@<7K0B09<6A ::8>=< # # -- ::<7776 3+6 :?8 -3(+6#,

!C - ::<777;9B=<76A B@9<7 # 3+(6 #- ,/ - #!( !( - :@( !( 3B@9<7L:@6A :0B7777 # 3+((6 D

-, (#- 2(- :77777 3+(((6 D

- !+ --,( , )#(,- , (! :77777 3(C6 D

- * !+ --,( - :77777 3C6 (- -# !C 9<777

:@ E#!-/( ,#

(.+* ( ! ( ( ,, 2 - (.#! ( (-( , ( !!2 ,!( - - # $ () ( , - >*87*777?; :=*7<*777?; , # - , ( 2(!! ,

/ ( M =J # - - -(!() - ,!( (( (!!,#! !(N( 0; , /.() ( - --()+ (,!2(!! (

-,!( :*8 <( ( .1,,# /

#) -

-,!( ; !! 90*2 ( *2(!!. ( ( (!(N .1 -(C ( (!! ( / ( $ (/( * 2+ *,! .1/1 ,#

) ())-( E#( (- (- # /

!! . 1 .

() -

- (.#! ) / - # ( ( ( - - ( (() $ (/ .+ ( ,( . (

# + ,!( - #,

,# #( ,( * .1# #!!/)(+ .

() - (.#!) /+- ( ,!(

( ) - $ (/ !( :;* .() # !)# (-( ,!(

!!.(!)(

- ( ( 2( .1* !/* E# !/* !- / !/ #!. * ,+(,C - ( .

#) # := +-( -/- ,!( .- -

()-2 *, (- ?

!!. ( +(+() ,!( 23+ .

%$ '"

($)& $1 #$(" :!# , ! ;!, :#

;!,