← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3233/2015allowed

Israil v. Ushman And ORS

2023-08-18Mrs. Justice Amarjot Bhatti7 pages

  

       

 

 !

"

     

##$$%& '(  !



 

#& "# $%&'( #) *)+( #"*+ &++ & )*(&+,-%&.&/%##$$%& )%$+0(%+,-%& .#&%

)1/ (#&%,-%& .#&"(%- 0#%2 33333 #"*+ &++, * /%##$$%&4-$%+0%&5%+$/%.+$&/#&%##%$ %1%+&  +0#(1  %6%  %&  7  8  #%  92  $%  )& --+&  $%+0  +9(%$,  )6%&  +  6/+-/  /  /%  9  1%& -0#%&+.  ,:!," 4 6+&/+&& %&&/ %&. !8;# %(0.0&/%&.+&+&(&+.&/-$%+0#&+&+&+$$%$+<%&+. &/%6%%0(&6+&/&/#%2&0+.2%/%-&/%0(&. -0#%&+  %6%  92  $%  )&  --+&  $%+0  +9(%$, )6%& /.%-&.&/-%%&/%&%+$/%.+$-$%+0#&+&+ (  =-&+  ::  .  &/  )&  '/+-$  -&,  7>>  .  1%&  . -0#%&+&&/&(. 8 , , 4&%?+1&/&%&/%&%&&/&+0 .%--+&/6%: 2%$+1&/9(+.-%#+$/+

/%0&+/+0&/$2+-0% " , 4 &/.%&.($%2.

" ",/%$16+&/ %**(6%1+1.0=/%/ /?/%&%% 0&-2-$ >8"

!6%++1&/0&-2-$%%& %9(&

)&/2%-/&(-?0%?&(/%%%+&/0%&+0 &/..+1&(-? 88 8" +92#&+%%/ %1$+1&0%-%0.0&/+.%$%/+&%1%+&/+ 0&-2-$92-0+1&/61+.&/%%$16+&//+ -0#%+ %**(.$$&/%%-++*(+/1+&%&+ (09.&/&(-?6%&692((.+&+%$$2,&/26&%? &% 0&/#+&%$9(&(&&/++(-+&+&/26 &%?&)&#+&%$,%+%9%0%+%0+&&+&/%+ /#+&%$  .0  " "  &  8 ", 

 &  :  ,

:

"& 7

"% >

"& 7

"%/6%&+$$ (&%&0& /%%$%2#&0&/%  8, , 4/+ &%&0& 1%+1 &/+  %--+&    8 %&   " 6% 1+&(=-&+ !7,""!. %&$+-=&%&+(/%% &/+%--+&,/(..0($&+#$+*(++-$(+1.%-&((.. %$&%--(&.+*(+(..92/+0+&/%--+&+&%9$ &&%%6%$?+#&$26+&/(&&//$#.%&&%&(.. #0%&+%9+$+&2&&/@&&.7 ;(..#%+,%12,0&%$ &+(..$.9(+&+#%2&/%&/0%29%6% -0#%&+. 8 , , 4%$16+&/+&&A>;#%(0 .0  &/  %&  .  %--+&  &+$$  %$+<%&+  .  &/  %0(&  .0  &/ #&,6/%$+%9$&#%2*+&$2%%$$26+&/-& /-$%+0#&+&+6%-&&92&/(%- 0#%2 %$   /  6+&&  &%&0&  6%  .+$  &%?+1  %$  #$+0+%2

" 9*-&++-$(+1&/9*-&+&/%&#&6%&/$+1% %$+++1$+-%&/%+/+-$6%9+1+++$%&+. =-&+::.&/)&'/+-$-&%6$$%%1%+&&/&0% -+&+.&/+(%-#$+-2/-$%+0#&+&+6%%$-&& 0+&2+1%$$&/.%-&/1+&%&+. %B(%&(0.

-0#%&+-$%+092&/-$%+0%&6%%$+ /(%-

0#%2++&$+%9+$+&2%*+&%%$%$16+&/#& % &6%#%2&/%&&/-$%+0#&+&+.+$%1%+&&/(%-

0#%20%2?+$29+0+6+&/-& 0  &/  #$%+1  .  &/  #%&+,  .$$6+1  +(  6 .%092&/+9(%$ !

  

              

          

      !

       

 "

  "

 #       $%&'((')'( #*

  "   $+ ,  -

 $  " ! .        

    - !  . 

 

 . + ,     $ .

  

 "



 

  "

 "

 

   

 



+ ,&'  &   :

    &  #  &/  -$%+0  #&+&+,  &/  -$%+0%&  %+$ @%0+((.%C, %**(%C ,=%*D(0%%C",

%/($ /%+$%%C %//+0$.&##+&&/6+&9@% C8 !

&9(&&/+-.&/-$%+0%&,&/#& "(%-  -0#%2  /%  &  $  %2  +-  #+&  %%+$+1

##&(+&+%($&+0%&$2,+-.#&"6%-$+ %& 

> .&/%+1&/%1(0&%%-92$%-($. 9&/&/#%&+,&/-$%+0#&+&+.+$92&/-$%+0%&%+$6%%$$6 92  #%+1  +0#(1  %6%  %&  7  8  +  6/+-/  &/ -0#%&+6%%6%&&/&(.  ,:!," 4%&%+$ &/+92/$+1&/$+%9+$+&2.%$$&/#&%*+&%%$ %$16+&/+&&A!8;#%(0.0&/%&.+&+&(&+.&/ #&+&+&+$$%$+<%&+.6%%0(&$+1%11+.&/+6%, &/#&%##%$/%9#.92%##$$%&4-$%+0%&5%+$   /%  /%  &/  %1(0&  .  $%  -($  .  &/ %##$$%&4-$%+0%&%6$$%$%-($.#&5(%-

0#%2/+%##%$+.+$1%+1&/B(%&(0.-0#%&+ %6%92&/$%)&--+& $%+0+9(%$,)6%& + 6%%& 7  8&+#+&(&&/%&&/%##$$%&0%++ &//#+&%$.0 " "& :  .0&+0&&+06% #%&  (#  .(  &+0   /  $1  &%&0&  -+  92  &/ %##$$%&4-$%+0%&/%&9-+/$%)&--+&

$%+0+9(%$,)6%& /%-+&//#+&%$-/%1# -%@8&@!"&&/&(.  , !, >84(.+1(

 , !," 4$2 /&/9+$$@>"&@"/%&9 -+  92  &/ $%  )&  --+&  $%+0  +9(%$,  )6%& 6+&/(&%2% &+.(&/#+&(&&/%&//%91%& 0%1%0(&.  , 4.#%+%(..+1%%&/(0.

 , 4  .  $  .  9%+-  %0+&+     -0#%&+  /%  9 %6%.#-+%$+&,@#+&(.%&&%&,&%#&%&+ /

8 %##$$%&6%+19(+.-%#+$/+%%+1 " , 4# 0&/E.+-0(..92&/%##$$%&4-$%+0%&/%&9 -+  /.,  -++1  &/  %.%+  .%-&,  &/ %##$$%&4-$%+0%&+&+&$&&//%-%0(&.-0#%&+% &/%6%%& 7  8#%92 $%)&--+& $%+0 +9(%$,)6%&0%2?+$290+.+%--+1$2

  &/  &/  /%,  $%  -($  .  &/  (%-

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

 , !, >84(.+1(  , !," 4.&/#(#.1%&+1 -0#%&+&&/%##$$%&4-$%+0%&%/%+1&/9+$$1%+1 #(-/%.0+-+&-@>"&@"%&/-$%+0%&+&

: @%0+6.&//#&#&/%+9+$$/%-+&/ 9+$$@>"&@"@-#&9+$$@>:%@>!,%$$&/9+$$% #&%++1&&/(%&+6/&/%##$$%&0%+(&%&0& .0&+0&&+0/%+9+$$%.&+-&,%+%9%%6$$% .&0+#+&%$ =0.&/9+$$%#&%++1&#(-/%. 0+-+.0+..&#/%0%-2/#&-%&9+1&/%&.0 &/  #+  " "  &  :   &/  %##$$%&4-$%+0%&  -+ &%&0&%6%%0+&&+&//#+&%$%.&&/+-/%1 .0&//#+&%$,&/%##$$%&4-$%+0%&0(&/%B(+0+-+ .0  &+0  &  &+0  /.,  -++1  &/  (%&+  .  0+-%$ &%&0&,&/9+$$@>"&@"@-#&@>:%@>!

% -+6/+-/%&&/&(.  ,!84(.+1(  ,!8 4 &-%&9+1&/%&&/ $%)&--+& $%+0+9(%$, )6%& /% 1%& $2   , 4  .  #%+  % (..+1  6/+-/  + &6%$6+,-++1&/#+.&%&0&.6/+-// 0%+%0+&&+&//#+&%$-0#%&+/%91%&. #-+%$+&,@#+&(%&&%&%&%#&%&+ =+0+$%$2, -0#%&+/%91%&.&/$.+-0/++-& +-&&%9$+/&/+-0.%##$$%&4-$%+0%&&&/&(.

" , 4#0&/92+1&/9(+.-%#%%$$192/+0 /.,926%2.1(6?/+0&/$2+-0+%(0%

>, 4#0&/%/0%+(&%&0&.%$1(%&+ %+&6($&/%9#+9$./+0&-&+(/+9(+ %&$%&.%#+..+0&//.,/+.(&/&+&$&&/ -0#%&+&&/&(.  , 4G > 4@8H1%+1$.

+-0/+&/+1-&/6&/%&&/%##$$%&4-$%+0%&

! (..  %2  #0%&  +%9+$+&2  ++1  &/  .%-&,  &/ %##$$%&4-$%+0%&+&+&$&-+-0#%&+(&/%.%+ /%%(    ( 

!- .

!/ -  0  + 1

)+-%$@#+&(  , !," I ,!8 J ,>>, 8 4  , !,"

%+%(..+1 8 ,  , E.9%+-%0+&+  ,  , =#-+%$+& 8, @#+&(.%&&%&  , %#&%&+ 8, E  .  +-0  A

>, 4#0&/. 8 0&/

, +-

!- , , , 3,

++1  &/  %.%+  &%+$  &/  -$%+0%&  +  %$%2 1%&-0#%&+.  ,:!," 4+.%$%2#+&+&+$+%9$& 9  %*(&  +  &/  %.%+  %0(&  %  &/  /%-  %0(&  . -0#%&+-0(&&9 , ,!8 46/+-/&/-$%+0%&+&+&$ &-+.0&/#&6/%$+%9$&#%2&/+%0(&*+&$2 %  %$$2  %  #  &/  &0  .  6%  %&  7  8   / %##$$%&4-$%+0%&+&+&$&-+&/%.%+/%-%0(& 6+&/+&&A!;#%(0.0&/%&..+$+1.%##%$&+$$ %$+<%&+.&/%0(&--+1$2,&/#&%##%$+%--#&% &/%6%#%92&/$%)&--+& $%+0+9(%$,)6%& &%0+.+ /-#2.--+.0&/+9(%$9&9%-?& &/--B(%& > >

"

4#"*+ &++5   /"

*67( C/&/#%?+14%

4 C/&/#&%9$

4