Surinder Pal Singh v. Vijaya Bank And Others


  
 

  !"#"$% & '






          
(%)*(+
+ , )*(+
+ (*  

 

  !

 "  #"#$

% 


 !

 "#& '  +-./"0("

12 (          )      *)     !

!

 !

*)     ( *"! #$+, #) !

#

  


-

   . 

* / 0*    1 2  " " 3  34)  "  !* !

*)#&  !!

 & %  &55, *)  "
6,555557 8 !

! 0"
&+555557 "0#$   

*  ) 0

 !" *  (

!!) *9 !

 # "0  !!2#  4

  

!)

*        *0 *" 
:55+5557 "!

"   ,'&5$5%   



! !"
  #&&$"&55;" * *)!

  !

"

!! # 

!  %"

! 

  )    ""!      "     <*  !  (*

%% .



2  "" 3 <( %%34)   "0  $&'&5$52 = $4

!!* % " *!0  "0  *)) 

* **    00 ! !

)  *0  0" ! "" * 0 (  "  )  *) * **  *) ) * "*""     0"
$5

!*) "0  "<)

  ) 

!"!

 ,6&5$52 = '4) =!* #$  "

!!

 ( ) !

 * *)*" <*! 

(*

2< (4#)<

*) " !

 

#$;&"&5$5)  ""0 0

*  0"   0"0 0 ( < ( 

 *)       <( %%  .



 "            .9  ! ++&5$52 = >4 *)  0"
>'5,$>;7 2 00!  &:6&55;     
!  $'2&4  "    
!?

  

3 !!"@ !

  A"!0 "
!% ! &55&  2  "  "     3  
@ A
%  !34 * ) "

0  "*" <( %%.



(  0) ! * *  3#1 !!3 !!

 )  *""  *!  *!" *

!!

 
!?

  " * *)) 0 &,;&5$52 = ;4(  ) 

"

!!

!"0 ' (  &,;&5$52 = ;4) !

 * ) " .- #$,5+>"&5$5* *)* 0) 0* <!

" . &>;&5$$ 2 = $$4*

 *) 0*) "

 

( 

" * *)) 0  $;&&5$'2 = $&4 !!"

 ) ) ) < (! 

( )  * . .- #>>$;"&5$'2 = $'4 0 ) 0  < () !!  "! "



 " .9  < (! 

 

)



 $56&5$+2 = $+4%)  *) 

0 0

)   *    0 * 0( " 0")     !

   *     *)    .-  #$;>+>  "  &5$+    $>5;&5$+2 = $>4) )  " *! *)"    !*" < (( < (!      "   *     *)       

       

& $>$5&5$+2 = $,4) ) !

 * *).- #  &:>$+  "  &5$+   <     !  "     )   !00!

 $$:&5$+*#$  

*) 
6$:,'5;>>) ) )  ) 

  ) 0 *0" !

!

 !!

  $>$5&5$+2 = $,4 * < ()    0 ) 0 !

 < ((  " #$   !

!

           !      0   
$:$'5>&7 ( *)  0 !

0) "  "
$55+5>$7 ") 
>5+6$;7 

 *   *)

 ) *   
';;>6&7 (  "  " ! !0
$+:>,$,7 ( < ( &6'&5$:! *)  0 0 0"
655

!) "

"

 *   0 %  0"
655

!

* * *) 6 %  ) ! !

  

 !

             $56&5$+  2 =  $+4  ) * 

" *))

)* < ( 0" 0

 *0 ( 



 " !

"  + 

! #$ 

!

   &6'&5$: * < ( .- #$6>5>"&5$:( ) *0*   0 $$:&5$:

> %)" "

! 0 

 * * *    &6'&5$: * < ( !

0"

#$  * "* *) )  

*0 : /))" 0  = 0 !

 0 , 1 ! " !  *" *)! !

 

"

 

 * !! 

!"!

 

 *(  " < ( $56&5$+) "

) ) * *  ; B !  ! " *)! <*!(*

%%.



2<( %%4 )   9 !

  )   )  *)   0 !!

)!  !

 !!!" )

" !

 
@ A
% ! %!

 

"  *  !00  *          !   
!  $6264  "  
@ A
% ! 0!



) *

"*   9  !

* $5 "= 0 0" 0 *   ) *  !
!$'2,4"
@ A
% ! 

C$'2,4 -      0  "    "   !  !      )

 !  !

  

  =  !  * 0         ! !  0*"  "* "

!"* ! ! 9  "0* !  " "*) " 

 0

" ! 

24 ! 

* "*)  "   0

* !!D  24 !

  * * ! !" "*) "   0

" *" "!

0  * !    "     

 *     *  !

!  !  "   "  *  )   "    

 0

"!

! E $$ 

" * 0 0  "*   )  *)  00  "0 0 !!* "0! ) !"

 "" ! % !

 *) 

00  

!
!$'2&4" 
@ A
% !2 = >4++&5$5  

 <() ?" 

 

" !A 

#$ 



!"!

"



) *!" <(%"

! <(0 *)  0!

0*#$   "* !"
!$'2,424" 
@ A
% ! !! )   *   "0  !  "   )     !0   "     

   !%0 *00* "   !0 ) *) 

)  !

0"

#$ )  " !* ! "         +6  "      0       !

  " ( 0."

/ 4"!

1#*"4" . $./ 0#5#$"$ $."

$./ 0#26

&7& +

3

20

! $& B !  *   "

 " *)  *   

"0!

*=!

!!0  $' %)" *  $56&5$+2 =

$+4!

*"

 )  !!

 )0)  ! 6+ ,7 6+ (*7     -8-# &2

    9$   / / 0+9 :"$8; #$ .

# / / 0 90 <1

#