High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19791/2024dismissed

Mohan Lal Sharma v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-09-11Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj20 pages

!" "# MOHAN LAL SHARMA

STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS

$ %&$ '( ' ) *****

" #

$$$$$ ( ' )+, -./ % &

' # ( )*

)

+,++,-

/0'1 2 3 '1 "

( # ('1

& ' )!

1 ' #

) # "

4 + #

4 5 ) #

* ((1 ,

( 1 &#

)

" ( 7+7(

)& ( "'(

+ #(1 9 #" # " ( ) # ( ) &

4 5 '

8 (

) "

4 : -;0

(() '( 1 1 //< 1 +7 ) #

(() ! #

-2- #

" (#

4 5&

) ( " <

(()

& *

" &

;

## ( ) ! 1

= <

4 5&&

)(1'1

(() (

)

#3 &

" (

# (( )

#(& , < #

(()

4 5 & &

) "

(()

& *

) #

)

" ( &( *

( 1 (

) (

( " # #

# " (( #

( ' " )) ! )

# ( !

(

& "

( "

& '1 ## " (

( 4 #+++&# ( '#

2 3 =

) "1 # "

( = "

; (3 ) "

++++ ((

" ( #) !

(() 3 "(( )

( 1 )

'* 6

)

# ! ( ) .

1 (! "

-3- ( 1 # 6

)

% (! . " # "

!" ! " # !

$ % &#' ( )

# , - % ( ' &! # !

$ .

/'!

& 1 # 0

"2 % )

# 3 % 3'4 5

& !

% ! # & +# " "'

+# & !

! #6 ! #!!! .

" ! &' "

""! " *"

)

% & !

# #

& 86 2# , 6 2 % !! % &% # " 9 5 3 #

' *

1 ## "

" ( ;

(() "

( '

-4- +,5+++ )! & # )

" *

= "

; ( 3 ) "

& "((

(

4 5 & (

)

" (3 # " " "

## " # = "

; ( 3 ) "

) (

( "

' ' 7 % ) 2 3 '

/++,& "

4 5 *

) #

)

" ( ( 1

% 2 3

&! "

( # ('1

+,++,&

& '6" #"

(( )

( #

! (1 ) 3 # ( " *

1 ' "

" '1

" ( ;

;

(()"

& '6" # *

1 "

" & (

'1 ) 2 3 # "

" ) ( 1 *

1 "

( 3

& )

' '1 & *

1 ## " ) "

" # ("

4 5 "

(() "

( *

' %

( " #

-5-

4 5( '(#

) @

& #"

4 5

" ( # : -;0

(() '( 13 &"

(( )'1

'1&1

A++5@? #++ '1 )(8

# (1

" !

) #"

' " # "((1

&! ( &

# ( '1

&! "

2 () 6 ) (( ) 3 ( # (1 "

( ) ! " )

4 5 "

& (

)& : -;0

(() '( 1

5 "

)

) " !

)

6 " #

" ( "

/ < #

'")

( !

+,++, '1 2 3 '#

" ) #

2 # (( & (

) "

(

#("

" "

( ' '1

2 3 1 # "

( = "

; ( 3 ) "

3 #

1 '

5+++ ""

)(1 *

,,+++ & ' '1 = "

; (3 ) "

& & (

-6- '6"

& # ('1

<&(

( (()

( & ( '1

# '( = "

; ( 3 ) "

3 ""

)(1 = "

; ( 3 ) "

" ( ;

(() #

A '( 1 *

1 ## "

) & ' '1

,5++% "

( (

' # "

(

( (()

= "

; ( 3 ) "

& (( ) ("

4 5 % & ( (

'1 *

1## " "

' '1

((

( . "

8 )&

( # ) # 6 ;;

! # 7% # # # &# !% + #! 2$& * + & 2 % 2#

;=>*== ;=

(*) 5 ;=

' & .

" (# 4!& # #!% *"

3 % 2# , 8"

!6/'- 2 %

# " 3 ?

? !

' &' " ! & '

@ %

+ !

8)&

& ""

&% 3!! &% 7 ##!! # ""!

& ""' &% 8 / 2# , 6 2 % 6 *

-7-

" & &% /'! 4# # " # "!

%& # !

(# 4!& ) ' / 62 % .

" &! !

% "

'1 *

1## "

5 '

" ( '1 ("

'1 ) )

(()

!'1 = "

; (3 ) "

3 " ( # (# (( * "

( . " * ( # "

''1 ;

A " "

(

)

#( ()(

&"((#

## "

2)('

" B !

"; ( % "

( ( (()

(()

& ' #

'1 = 1= "

+?/+++ %

&! " # "((1

4 "

(() ' )

1 '1

! 1! ( 4 8 ++B5@,5++ + )

4 5

" (

" # "((1 # ( & ##"

' &

) "

(() & "(( #

! & ! 1 "

(() '1 ) 3 ( &

"( (1

-8- ( #

( '1

## " #= "

; (3 "

' # (( &#

& ! #

(" ) (

" ( &

& "

) "

(()

& (

" '1 2 3 (( ( ) ! "&"

'1 ) 3 ( 1 *

/++,& ' (! . "

) ## # # !" !

!" " @ %4"7 1)6-&+ 7 1:6* 4"% 7 16>3 &!

7 1864 " 7 1,

3 4" 7 1 A6 !"%

"" # % &% 7 #! !! 3) B #6 )!& %' /'! +# % ! ! /'!6 86 2# , C' %&%## !

" +

## ! "' " )

# " # % " D

862# , % 6 " ' !" @ % 4" 7 1 )6 "

!" !"

%& @ % !" !

&% 3 1

&% *"

6 /'! # >!6 )!& % "

3!)&

&% !!

-9- &% 7 #! !! #

""!

& ""' &% 8 / 6 2# , 2 % 6 * 1 "

3!)&

( % ;;

!# 7 #!!! # ##&#!%

"+ #! 2$&* + & 2 % 2#

>* <= ;=

! &% 2$&2# * + & 2 % (*)5 ;=

!" -&+ 7 1:

# !" # @ % " 2

@ %

& # # # !

&% ! @ % " @ % -

& &! &% "

!" 7> 6

8 / 6 2# ,

"" *"

/'! #6 3 6 * 1

@ % -

* 4"% 7 1 6

# !"

' &

# @ %"

< !" 7 >

'& *"

6 /'! #6 3 6 * 1 @ %'

@ %" !

%&'

<E6 3) B #6 )!& %

& #' !%

;= .

!" > 3 &!

7 1 8

" # #

-10- " *"

&% @ % -

@ % "6

& # " 4 " 7 1 ,6

6 "

" !

#! #

& " ! % " '

5 ) "3 4" 7 1A6 &

@ %"

&! &% *"

6 /'! #6 3 6 * 1 6 !" !"

7> 6 !

# # @ % "

< #& "

<;6 *"

* /'! "'

& !

% " ! $ "

% ! $ ! # & +# " 6 "'

+# &!

! #6 !!

#!!! 5 %' ! @ %4"7 1)

# !"

" *"

"" ! &%## /'!"'

&% !! &% !

#! !! #6

& !% <

;= &

+ #!

&% 2$&2# * + & 2 %

86 2# , 2 % 6 * 1 '

& '

" 2 % )

# 3 % 3' 4 6 56

% " ! $ "

-11- ! $ ! # & +# " 6 "'

+# & !

! #6 ! !

#! !!

* #!& /'! #

' & !"%

" % " & +# " " *"

6 #'

" "

% !

&% 862# , 62 % 6 * 1 &% # """ # .

# "!

& # # @ % ' # !

6 % 1 "# # " % " 6 &% " !" ' !

F , % "

1 ( 1

& (1#

& ( '#

!("

2 3 ( # ('1

( )

# " !"

# !% & "

% # " (4

!% @ ! 86 2# , - ""'

%&# &% "

! .

! #

% ) %

" !" &

& #

-12- !"

# % 2

) %

# ! % &%

!" &

6 & #'

&% % 6

" !" "

& ! .

# ! !" & " 6

% "

! ! !" !

%+ % % # " !" 3! %6 (

# %

8 )&

3)B #6)!& % 5 5

# # " !

! % " %&

" "'

5 !"

" '

" %"' " % .

6 6 ) %

" *"

& "

% % !

$ ! 2'6 8"

! 2# ,

% &% !

" '

7'6

" !

&% 3 * & !

6 8 / 2# , 6 %

;

" !" 6 &% #

"" !" 6 !

/'! & 1#

6 " !"

& &% !"

-13-

3 ?

6 !" 6

! ' #"& " 6 ) % '

" !"

& !'! A !6 " !" 6

8 )&

""!

63)B #6)!& 6 &% % >* <=E 6

&% 2$& 2# 6 #

" " !" 6 (*) # 2$&2# + #! " # & 2$&2# A ##

6 ) %

6 !

6 " !" &% ) & ! #% % (

2 3 "

(

# (( ))

0 % ( "

( & ' ) (1 '( ) % ("

& 1 +7 "

( &# ( 1 +++ 0 % " # ) ,

( 1 (

&( "

< &" # "((1

" ' ( ) # ! ( )

7+7 4

) ' (" '#

(1 # " ( #+++

1 (

& *

-14- ' " ("

1 +7

B"( # "

++++ '"

(

" !(1 "

(1 &

" ("

(

! &

& = "

; ( & *

( ' 1 ( 1' . 0 < &

" "

( ' # ( '1 ( -

( "

C( & #

! "

)

C( ( "

(( ) ("

4 5

" ( # : -;0

(() '( 1 A++5@? #++& & 5

' '1 (

'( " #

4 5

( 1 (

&! <# ( # 1(#

) & "

(

# (( )

0 %

3 2 " ++ & 2 "

" *

1 ) ! "B(()

) '( " ! (()

+-'0 3 2 "++( & '( "

-15- !

((1

)(1'

)

' 1

)

" ( 1

& " " '1"

(()

% #

" & (()

" ' *

'1 2 & '( " !

# "

% #

"++ . "

! " # G & # 9 " & '

! %

" & '

1#% % "

& % #

% "

! % " D

" & '

&%" 6!"" "!' D # % "6 1 #% %

" & '

D ' "

" % ""% "" 1 !

" % ""% &% " & '

" %&% %!!&

-16- &% ! " &

D G "9 % "

" G * 6 =5 *' ")6 ;==6 % !&# "' "D G #'

9! !&% "

# !

&% % &% !

" & '

! !

! D 7 ;

! "

(

) #

& ( ' '1 " #

# '( " ! < ! '(1 "

(

' ) ! " " &

) ""

' " ((1 ? %

# "

( "

(1 ' ' ) ( &

(#((&

# E(()

F "

+-'0 3 2 "++ @ ! # ' " #

(()

) (()

' %

! " ' " '1

1 +++'1 = "

; ( 3 ) "

& 1 *

) 1( 1 ( !

)""

-17- ( "

( 1

(

' '1

" ('#

) & % ("

7+7

& #

" # ("

4 5

" ( #

(() !

' '

)

( ( #+++

! )) ! ,

>( 1 (

& '

(1 &

& B 6

% *

# )

( 1&

# #

#" !

)' " '1 2

(" 1

" 1 +7& ("

& " ! ) D (

! # ) "

'1 2 &

1 ) ! " '

## # )

## #

#(&

#" / 8 1 " ''

) ( 1 "

' ' (() ) !

) ' & '1

4 5 +

G'(

# < # $

% & '( $

) *+*, - ..

/0( "

('"

(()( & &

) ( % (! # 6 ) . "

-18- E ' ! &'

" # "" # # 9 C!

' H5 3 I6 #

0 .

!"%

% !

% " & " ! % &

6 3 /'! ! %

' !"% !"%

! ' ' % %

% .

""! !"%

& # 6 ' # > ""! !

# " " "" "

" & !! ! @ 6

""! & & # : " !"% "

" & @

1# # " 6 &

& ## "

" !"' 6

""! &# +

) ( 1 # 1

4 5"

(

#(&8 1 !("

' ' " '1 "

) #1

-19-

# "

% ( # ( " (# " (#

)

& &

(

(# " '

4 5 "

)

(# %

" # ("

4 H : -;0

(() '( 1 # # (( )

" # (&

4 5 & (" % ("

( '

!'1 = "

; (3 ) "

3 &

(()( 1

(

"'1 = "

; (3 ) "

++ ) ! "

"<( # 1(# ) &

'1 2 "

( & " '1( "

4 5 "

) C(

! " &

)

( 1"

(( )

B("

4 5 #

" ( : -;0

(() !

)

""# ((1 ) ("

' # ( #

4 5 <#

( &(( &

.( #'

" #(& +,

>'(

1 2

) *+/, 3 .. /0* % (! . "

-20- ;

+ % ! #

' # > % ! &'' 6 # ! !" ' &

1"! 6

# 6

6 '% " &

6 # " #6 %

2 % # 6 ! '#

&# 6 %#

% 1

! 6

2 "

& !& # ""

# ! ! .!

' " 16

!%6 6

3 # & !" 6

J .

## # 6

6 !

& !" &% 6

## # ! !

% #

%6 "

% ! ##

!" % 9 + % !

! 4****5# ! (

& &

" " # "

,( ' )/ ' $

+" "#

A )B

IB4 A

'( IB4