← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/30943/2018allowed

Mahabir Singh Tanwar And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2023-12-13Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil7 pages

 

   

    



  !



    

  

"

"   #   $   

 $"

%""$ &$$

$  

 !



 $"

"""""$ $ #'!

$$  

 !



$ 

 &

' (  '

&'#

) %"" &$$

$  

 !



 $"

"""""$ $  # *' #"

$ $   # '

 



 

 !"

 #

$

  %&

'

 







& 

(

) 

+ ),

 $   # '+

, '- . //    0  & /(   // 1, ( (

+, # ,

( 23 4 , 5 ,  , //,

  #&    

!"

3 !"

38 7 0

9 :  9#  (, /& ( !4 3!8  

(( $ 

  0( 5 ( /($  (( 93   , 

    " !

&  ( , (( (,&

5 ,0/

,01,($ /  9,, ,0( ; < :/ $ (  9 : 9#  (, /& ( !4 !8 ( & ( 

/(/&  " !



-   ( '& 

 =  (& /(/ // #  ( 9#  (

!4 !"

7, 4 > " ($8 & ( && /( ,  / , 7 0, &  $ /&(  (( ( (#& ,  &$   (( / ( 5 /(

!"   

!"  ,0/ (  7&

 0& ,(($ (&0( ( /

 1,    & &  / // / (( 7  ,0/ 2 !

!"

(/& ( ($& , +,&/

 8  - !

(   

    

 ,01,($ ,( : 9  @

- !

!

: (&   / # &  ,0( (&  &($  /((  $      / ,

2 !

!"

A   - !

( (( ($  ( ,& 9#   , &  (

0, / (  

& / - 2

9 : /& (

!  ((& #    

  

  !

"

#!$!

 %&'

( #$%) #   !  !

   

 #!$ !

 " !

%&  '

* +

   

         

               

  





    !

        

  " 

  

  !

  "     

"#  

 $ %

 & !

    

" 

 

      

' 

(

 



)  ) *+ ,+ ,*-.&/.0 &   

*, ,*- #1 

  

     #  

#        

  2**  ,*   

33



  

4' "  ** ,*- & !

     

#  .&   

 

4' " 

 

      

' 

(

 



)  ) *+ ,+ ,*-.&/.0 &   

*, ,*- & 0     "  ** ,*-         " 

  

" 

      ' 

(

  )  ) *+ ,+ ,*-.&/.0 &   

*, ,*-  )  ) *+ ,+ ,*-.&/ .0 &   

*, ,*-  &

  "  4

  "    " 

   "   

 



  

4' " 



 



 

' 

(

 



       

 

   

 

 

+  



 

   

 

  

& !

       " 

#

  

 

 

 

#  

               " 

  

4'   "  

& 7  

  1  " 

   4'               

   

4'

   # 

 #    )5

  #    " 

    

' 

(

 8 

  #  -  / (  - !

>



, 

' 3!

  / ( 0(

 

,( / ( (( &  , & (0($ , /(/ (( / *  ':9  ,  0,&$ , &

5 &  (,   / ( 0  &



!   

@ ,( ( ,   ,  6,8 ( (  ,/   & (

! !

 , (    /    $ 

 +,&/ ,( : 9 @

- !

!2 , ($& ,

7   -   ./0!!

   1 2!

34556(*)

7*8

 ( (     ,&  ( ( &, $  $( (&   : 9 ,   

&( 9 < &  / / &  (

&( %,&

@ ,(      (  ($ /   1,($     ,  6,8

!!

' (  & # *  ':9 ( &  (,

(,

! & ( ($ 

. & *  ':9  /(/ 

 ( &,     



0

/ ;7 :

 (5 9# 6 ,  :/ *$8

!!

6  3/8   /,  9 : '9#  && :

 - )$(  ( (5 9# 6 ,  :/8  

/ '+

/

, B 6 ,  :/8 (55 /($ 9#  &

$  &  ( ( 0,   (55 (555 ( 5.

9#  & / /   0/   & //  9 : 9# 3!8 ' , && $ &  $  / / $/  (

 &,/ (  ( (& +,&/    ,  6,8 @

- !

  (( &  , $  9,, 0(

$ ( (0($ 0 (   *9;

 1, < ( ($

  $ &  (  

$( ( / (,3&

( 

& // < :/

* 0   (( ,    (

(( 0    2C ,/   0/ , ((  ,( (D 5 ,( ( 1, / 0,   , ( ,(  0(& 9#   ,(  ,  0, /   $  $ , ($  (&/ , 0, ,$ & ,& / $ , &  ( 

 ,( 9# !?

B &($

,$   # '-

"

"  

    ) # 9   $#+   :

+) 9   

:

+)